╌>

Missing Benghazi Email Shows Administration Lied, WSJ 4/30/2004

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  21 comments

Missing Benghazi Email Shows Administration Lied, WSJ 4/30/2004

Review & Outlook

The Missing Benghazi Email

New evidence thatWhite Housetold Susan Rice and Hillary Clinton to blame the video.

Most of the media refuses to cover what happened in Benghazi in 2012, and Congressional Republicans have been less than skillful in their probes. But the story isn't going away despite the best efforts of the Obama Administration and the Hillary for President campaign.

The latest revelation comes from White House emails in the days after the September 11, 2012 terrorist strike on the U.S. mission in Libya's second largest city. These emails weren't included last year in what the Administration claimed was a complete set of documents about its handling of the attack and its aftermath. They were released Tuesday after the conservative watchdog group Judicial Watch filed a Freedom of Information Act request. We can see why the Administration tried to keep them under wraps.

A September 14, 2012 email from Ben Rhodes, the deputy national security adviser for strategic communications, sets out the Administration's view of the cause of the Benghazi attacks. He wrote it to prepare U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. and current national security adviser Susan Rice for her appearances on the Sunday news shows two days later. As Mr. Rhodes wrote, the Administration wanted her "to underscore that these protests are rooted in an Internet video, and not a broader failure of policy."

In fact the attack on the diplomatic compound and CIA annex was a planned and well-coordinated assault by Islamist groups with ties to al Qaeda that killed Ambassador Christopher Stevens and three other Americans. Within hours, State and CIA officials at the Embassy EMYB 0.00% Embassy Bancorp Inc. U.S.: OTC $ 8.00 0.00 0.00% April 28, 2014 1:27 pm Volume (Delayed 15m) : 1,672 P/E Ratio 10.67 Market Cap $58.86 Million Dividend Yield 0.63% Rev. per Employee $383,282 More quote details and news in Tripoli, Libya's president and video footage made that clear. Yet the Administration settled on deceptive spin and stuck to it for over a week.

Jay Carney , the White House spokesman, on Sept. 14 blamed the attack on a spontaneous protest against an obscure anti-Muslim video posted on YouTube. Two days later, Ms. Rice returned repeatedly to the video in her appearances on the Sunday shows, saying on Fox News that "what sparked the recent violence was the airing on the Internet of a very hateful, very offensive video that has offended many people around the world."

Former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton AFP/Getty Images

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton also pushed the video fiction, telling the public on Sept. 14 at Andrews Air Force base as the remains of the four dead were returned that, "We have seen rage and violence directed at American Embassies over an awful Internet video that we had nothing to do with."

The White House also found a scapegoat in the intelligence community, blaming the CIA for drawing up the faulty "talking points" used by Administration officials. Last May it released drafts of emails from the CIA, with input from State and the White House, that spontaneous protests had "evolved into a direct assault." Yet those talking points never mentioned a video, and earlier this month former acting CIA Director Mike Morell said he didn't understand why Ms. Rice had mentioned it.

Mr. Rhodes's email provides the answer. The message directive came directly from the White House and was followed to the word. Mr. Rhodes alluded to the video in five spots in his email. On Wednesday, Mr. Carney still insisted Ms. Rice had "relied on points about the Benghazi attack that were produced by the CIA." He must think the press corps is stupid.

The Rhodes email shows a White House political operative trying to protect his boss two months before Election Day. Mr. Obama's campaign said al Qaeda was on the run and it was time for "nation-building at home." The terror attack on Americans in Benghazi didn't fit this story. It did, however, expose the "broader failure of policy" (to use Mr. Rhodes's phrase) in North Africa in the wake of the Arab political upheavals in 2011.

After the election, the Administration was slow to cooperate with congressional investigations. The "talking points" emails were released last May only after parts were leaked to the press. The Rhodes email was subpoenaed last August, but the White House blocked release until it seemed obvious it would lose its attempts to keep them secret.

All of this bears directly on Mrs. Clinton's qualifications to be President. Her State Department overlooked repeated warnings about a growing militant threat in Benghazi, denying requests for improved security. And the father of a CIA contractor told media outlets that Mrs. Clinton tried to comfort him by promising that the maker of the YouTube video would be "prosecuted and arrested," though the video had nothing to do with his son's death.

The several congressional investigations into Benghazi have been undermined by turf battles and shoddy work. We long ago advised that a select committee could focus the effort and bring overdue clarity to a shameful episode in American history. It still could.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The White House also found a scapegoat in the intelligence community, blaming the CIA for drawing up the faulty "talking points" used by Administration officials. Last May it released drafts of emails from the CIA, with input from State and the White House, that spontaneous protests had "evolved into a direct assault." Yet those talking points never mentioned a video, and earlier this month former acting CIA Director Mike Morell said he didn't understand why Ms. Rice had mentioned it.

John either did not read the seed or is up to his old spinning tricks by dismissing a ruse that successfully and deceptively won Obama a second term with press cooperation.

That is no dead issue as it borders on an impeachable offense.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago
  • 0
    Share

Republicans charged Tuesday that an email in which a White House official advises former U.N. Ambassador Susan Rice to link the 2012 Benghazi attack to an anti-Muslim video confirms the linkage was fabricated to help President Barack Obama's re-election.

"This email is a smoking gun," Sen. Lindsey Graham told Newsmax. "It shows political operatives in the White House working to create a political narrative at odds with the facts.

"Their goal was not to tell the truth about what actually happened," Graham said Tuesday. "They did not want to provide the best information available.

"Instead, we were provided the most beneficial political story for President Obama."

New Hampshire Sen. Kelly Ayotte told "On the Record With Greta Van Susteren" on Fox News Channel: "We always said, 'Where did the video reference come from?' Now we know it came from the White House" and not the intelligence community.

Both Graham and Ayotte are members of the Senate Armed Services Committee. They have been among the many Republicans who have called for an independent investigation of the attacks on Sept. 11, 2012, that killed Ambassador Chris Stevens and three other Americans, including two former Navy SEALS.

Oklahoma Sen. Jim Inhofe, the panel's ranking GOP member, told Newsmax: "This was a cover-up, and these e-mails only continue to confirm my belief."

"The emails show that in the days after the attack in Benghazi, Libya, the White House was more focused on protecting President Obama than informing Americans about the terrorist attack that left Ambassador Chris Stevens and three other Americans dead."



Read Latest Breaking News from Newsmax.com ...
Urgent: Should Obamacare Be Repealed? Vote Here Now!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

and thus that the comment that "these protests are rooted in an internet video" was not about Benghazi specifically.

And what other incident has happened that relates to "an internet video" in that time period?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Yes, I was kidding. Muslims were rioting everywhere at that time and early media reports and news articles were saying the guy who made it was Jewish.

Though that was not the case at all, they were not as elaborate in their coverage when the truth came out.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Blame It On the Video Was a Fraud for the Cairo Rioting, Too

With all the attention the Obama administrations lies about the Benghazi terrorist attack are, at long last getting,an aspect of the scandal remains under-examined: the assumption that the anti-Islamic video so tirelessly touted by President Obama and his minions as the provocation causing the Benghazi violence did, in fact, cause the rioting at the U.S. embassy in Cairo hours earlier on September 11, 2012.

This conventional wisdom is wrong. There is a kernel of truth to it, which is more than you can say about the videos connection to Benghazi, but no more than that.

As we have covered here before (see, e.g., here ), the release and return to Egypt of the Blind Sheik, Omar Abdel Rahman (whom I prosecuted in the Nineties), has been a cause clbre in Egypt for many years. On September 10, 2012, the day before rioting at the U.S. embassy in Cairo, an Egyptian weekly, El Fagr , reported that several jihadist organizations, including the Blind Sheiks group (Gamaat al-Islamia , or the Islamic Group) and al-Qaeda emir Ayman al-Zawahiris group (Egyptian Islamic Jihad), were threatening to burn the American embassy in Cairo to the ground. The promised action against the embassy was an effort to extort the release of Abdel Rahman and other jihadists jailed by the United States.

We know this thanks to the invaluable Raymond Ibrahim who makes it his business to scour the Arabic press, where Islamic supremacists are actually covered. Ray published a post on it in the PJ Tatler . The post echoes my observation , from back in July, that the Blind Sheiks son, Abdallah Abdel Rahman, was threatening to raid the U.S. embassy in Cairo and hold our people hostage to coerce his fathers release.

More significantly, as an alert Bryan Preston notices at PJ Media , Rays post the day before the Cairo rioting and Benghazi Massacre dovetails with StephenHayess latest excellent report on Benghazi. In discussing the CIAs first roundof talking points later substantially erased under pressure from the State Department and the White HouseSteve points out the Agencys assertion that on 10 September we warned of social media reports calling for a demonstration in front of the [Cairo] Embassy and that jihadists were threatening to break into the Embassy.

Note that neither the Egyptian press report outlined by Ibrahim, nor the CIA report outlined by Hayes, made any mention of the video. The fear was threatened violence from al-Qaeda affiliated jihadists .

So how did the anti-Islamic video makes its way into the story?It increasingly appears that the Obama administration did more to publicize and the video and make it relevant than anyone else did.

As I said above, there is a kernel of truth to the claim that the video factored into the Cairo rioting. On September 9, two days before, the Grand Mufti publicly denounced the actions undertaken by some extremist Copts who made a film offensive to the Prophet. This denunciation led some of the Cairo hooligans to inveigh against the video.

It was, however, only one item in a broad list of grievances Islamic supremacists lodged against the United States. Many of the rioters focused on demanding the release of the Blind Sheikh and other jihadists. More to the point, many of them expressed their support for al Qaeda. They gleefully chanted , Obama, Obama, there are still a million Osamas! They tore down the Stars-and-Stripes from our flagpole, replacing it with al Qaedas notorious black jihad banner.

The claim that the Cairo rioting was over the video traces from the fact that the State Department specifically, the U.S. embassy in Cairo put out nauseating statements in the hours before the rioting started, deriding the continuing efforts by misguided individuals to hurt the religious feelings of Muslims, and indignantly condemning religious incitement.

Then, in the days after both the Cairo rioting and the massacre in Benghazi, President Obama, Secretary of State Clinton, Ambassador Susan Rice, White House spokesman Jay Carney, and other administration figures repeatedly cited the video as the catalyst. The Obama-friendly press, naturally, ran with this spin: the video caused the rioting at the embassy in Cairo, which seamlessly spilled over into neighboring Libya, where a similar protest spontaneously erupted into deadly violence.

As we know, that is not what happened.

Obamas re-election campaign was premised on the claims that he had decimated al Qaeda, that the war on terror was thus nearing an end, and that his Middle East policy of aiding Islamic supremacists in places like Egypt and Libya was stabilizing the region and fostering the birth of real democracy. The campaign could not afford powerful demonstrations that al Qaeda was anything but in its death throes; that terrorists were still targeting American facilities and killing American officials; and that, under Obamas policies, Egypt and much of Libya were now controlled by rabidly anti-American Islamic supremacists.

The video fraud enabled the administration and Obamas reelection campaign to stay on offense aggressively pummeling the strawman of Islamophobia rather than in the defensive crouch required to explain, or try to explain, the Obama administrations performance in Egypt, Libya, and the broader Middle East. It worked: The Romney campaign was cowed and accountability for the Benghazi massacre would have to wait many months.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

John is trying to make this issue about J. Karl.

It is not about Karl.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
The email perfectly encapsulate the Obama presidency. Blame a fictional thing for the administration's failures (a protest) and focus on creating the IMAGE of a presidents leadership rather than, you know ,the president actually leading.Government by image and manipulation rather than accomplishment ought to be the administrations slogan.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
That's such a crock of shit. You should be embarrassed to so faithfully parrot these lies."This email deals directly with the administrations response to the Benghazi attack, and should have been produced long ago in response to requests by Congressional committees. Today reporter Jon Karl of ABC asked Carney why the Rhodes email is only now being made public. Carney squirmed painfully, and claimed that the email wasnt produced because it isnt about Benghazi, but rather about conditions in the Arab world generally:Carneys answer is ridiculous. Of course the email bears more broadly on conditions across the Middle East, but it relates most specifically to Benghazi. Why was Susan Rice appearing on every Sunday morning talk show? Because four Americans were killed in Benghazi. Why was the administrations top political team gathering to prepare her for those appearances? Because four Americans were killed in Benghazi. Why does the email begin with the stated goal of conveying that the Obama administration is doing everything it can to protect its people abroad? Because four Americans were killed in Benghazi. Why is the group talking about bringing people who harm Americans to justice? The only place where Americans were harmed was Benghazi. Obviously, the email relates to Benghazi. And equally obviously, its reference to underscor[ing] that these protests are rooted in an internet video, and not a broader failure of policy was intended to deflect blame for the deaths of four Americans in Benghazi.Shortly before Rhodes sent his email, Dag Vega circulated promos from the Sunday news shows indicating what would be discussed. These topics were the ones for which Rice needed to be prepared by the political team. This one is ABCs, a screen shot from Vegas email:Which was it, a planned attack by terrorists, or a protest over an internet video? The administrations top political team, including David Plouffe and Dan Pfeiffernot to mention Jay Carney himself!gathered in order to prepare Rice to lie in response to that question."
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I thought the Benghazi story was simply about lying and a cover up but perhaps it's nothing more than incompetence. As near as I can tell, both Obama and Biden were on a conference call with Netanyahu when Benghazi blew up. The big story at the time (apart from an Obama/Netanyahu rift) was the attack on the Cairo embassy fueled, in part, by the offensive U-Tube video. When Benghazi blew up, the President of Libya attributed it to a terrorist attack and so did people in our intelligence community. The video cameras at the compound pretty much verify the same thing. For instance, John Brennan (CIA Director), James Clapper (Director of Intelligence), and Leon Panetta (Secretary of Defense) all thought it was a terrorist attack. Some who were closely involved in the Benghazi affair said they were surprised when Susan Rice connected the U-Tube video to Benghazi.Now, a year and a half later, it's finally revealed that the directive came from Ben Rhodes, then Communications Director (and brother to David Rhodes, President of CBS news). But unless he's lost his mind, Ben Rhodes would not have acted independently. If Obama/Biden was unavailable to act, then it was somebody who was either deliberately attributing Benghazi to the U-Tube video to shield Obama for the political campaign (i.e. spin the attack as a spontaneous reaction to the U-Tube video rather than a terrorist attack whichundermines Obama's claim that he has the terrorists on the run) or the decision was left to somebody toostupid to understand that theEgyptiannarrative doesn't fit Benghazi or appreciate why it matters. Either alternative undermines confidence in the White House.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The fact is that, from the Rhodes email to Candy Crowley's contradiction of Romney during the debate, Obama's minions were engaged in a cover-up to preserve the illusion that he had defeated al Qaeda and deserved reelection thereby.

Unfortunately, with Russell's support, the cover-up succeeded.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

A letter sent Monday night to the House and Senate foreign affairs committees from Sens. Lindsey Graham (R-SC), Kelly Ayotte (R-NH) and John McCain (R-AZ) asks both committees to compel the Obama administration to explain who briefed Rice for her talk show appearances, and whether anyone from the State Department or White House was involved. How could former Ambassador to the United Nations Susan Rice, during the five Sunday talk shows on September 16, 2012, claim that the attacks on our compounds were caused by a hateful video when Mr. Morell testified that the CIA never mentioned the video as a causal factor, the letter inquired.

Graham characterizes the latest emails as a smoking gun , indicating White House efforts to shape the story of the Benghazi attacks and to put a political stance on a disaster six weeks before an election.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The left invented incompetence and it is visible in every program they foist on us.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

For the third time:

Blame It On the Video Was a Fraud for the Cairo Rioting, Too

Click this link and read about you're aiding and abetting one scam after another.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

So if the White didn't really know whether it was a terrorist attack or a protest, why is Rhodes steering things toward the protest version and then telling Rice to "underscore that these protests are rooted in an Internet vieod, and not broader failure or policy"? Does the White House see any distinction between campaigning and performing the duties of a public office?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

I was waiting for that jwc - thanks.

BUSH - it's all BUSH's fault. 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

I am enjoying them but, like all Ponzi schemes, they will be bankrupt by the time my grandkids become eligible; if not my kids.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
This email was turned over in response to an FOIA request for Benghazi related documents but you now argue it has nothing to do with benghazi.

Why did the amdinstration release it response to this request for Benghazi related documents but not when congress requested Benghazi related documents?
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Looks like no one can square that circle from the administration, a select committee will be formed.If only the administration had been honest from the beginning.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You keep repeating lies even after you have been shown the truth again and again. Typical leftist!

Here it is yet once more:

The White House also found a scapegoat in the intelligence community, blaming the CIA for drawing up the faulty "talking points" used by Administration officials. Last May it released drafts of emails from the CIA, with input from State and the White House, that spontaneous protests had "evolved into a direct assault." Yet those talking points never mentioned a video, and earlier this month former acting CIA Director Mike Morell said he didn't understand why Ms. Rice had mentioned it.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Since Obama continues and expands the worst Bush policies, that would make him the new king of incompetence then right?

 
 

Who is online

Snuffy


97 visitors