╌>

Another Phony Budget Debate

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dean-moriarty  •  12 years ago  •  7 comments

Another Phony Budget Debate

Link

us-debt.jpg

Anyone watching last weeks debate over the Republican budget resolution would have experienced dj vu , as the debate bore a depressing similarity to those of previous years. Once again, the Republicans claimed their budget would cut spending in a responsible manner, while Democratic opponents claimed the plans spending cuts would shred the safety net and leave vital programs unfunded. Of course, neither claim is true.

The budget does not cut spending at all, and in fact actually increases spending by $1.5 trillion over ten years. The Republicans are using the old DC trick of spending less than originally planned and calling that reduced spending increase a $5.1 trillion cut in spending. Only in DC could a budget that increases spending by 3.5 percent per year instead of by 5.2 percent per year be attacked as a slash-and-burn plan.

The budget also relies on "dynamic scoring. This trick is where the budget numbers account for increased government revenue generated by economic growth the budget will supposedly unleash. The claims are dubious at best. Of course, reducing government spending will lead to economic growth. But real growth requires real cuts, not this budgets phony cuts.

As important as reducing spending and balancing the budget is, focusing solely on budget numbers ignores the root of the problem. The real problem is that too many in Washington and the nation as a whole refuse to consider any serious reductions in the welfare-warfare state.

I have always maintained that the logical place to start reducing spending is the trillions wasted on our interventionist foreign policy. Unfortunately, there are still too many in Congress who claim to be fiscal hawks when it comes to welfare spending, but turn into Keynesian doves when it comes to spending on the military-industrial complex.

These members cling to the mistaken belief that the government can balance it budget, keep taxes low, and even have a growing economy, while spending trillions of dollars policing the world, and propping up some governments and changing others overtly or covertly. Thus, President Obama is attacked as soft on defense because he only wants to spend $5.9 trillion over ten years on the military. In contrast, the Republican budget spends $6.2 trillion over the next decade. That is almost a trillion more than the budgets total so-called spending cuts.

If there are too many fiscal conservatives who refuse to abandon the warfare state, there are too many liberals who act as if any reduction in welfare or entitlement spending leaves children starving. I agree it is unrealistic to simply end programs that people are currently dependent on. However, isnt it inhumane to not take steps to unwind the welfare system before government overspending causes a bigger financial crisis and drags millions more into poverty?

Far from abandoning those in need of help, returning the responsibility for caring for the needy to private charities, churches, and local communities will improve the welfare system. At the very least, young people should have the freedom to choose to pay a lower tax rate in exchange for promising to never participate in a government welfare or entitlement program.

Last weeks budget debate showed how little difference there lies between the parties when it comes to preserving the warfare-welfare state. One side may prefer more warfare while the other prefers more welfare, but neither side actually wants to significantly reduce the size and scope of government. Until Congress stops trying to run the world, run the economy, and run our lives, there will never be a real debate about cutting spending and limiting government.

By Ron Paul


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

owever, isnt it inhumane to not take steps to unwind the welfare system before government overspending causes a bigger financial crisis and drags millions more into poverty?

Keynes, of course, had no children and his Bloomsbury ideals dictated that everything focus on today, "because in the long run, we are all dead." His whole economic system is based upon making things as easy as possible in the short run and not caring about what happens in the future, because that's someone else's problem.

"For most of human history, functioning societies honored the long run: Its why millions of people have children, build houses, plant gardens, start businesses, make wills, put up beautiful churches in ordinary villages, fight and if necessary die for king and country Its why extraordinary men create great works of art or did in the Europe of old. A nation, a society, a community is a compact between past, present and future, in which the citizens, in Tom Wolfes words, conceive of themselves, however unconsciously, as part of a great biological stream

Thanks to the mainstream acceptance of Keynes radical ideology that's no longer the case. Our offspring will pay for our fiscal excesses.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Article 5, 38 states, 3/4 of the states. Take the power of Washington. Take the money out of Washington politics, put term limits in place and give the power back to the people.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Most people don't even know what I'm talking about.

Have you ever seen a nuttier person? I mean, really. Well, if she is telling the truth, then isn't it more important than ever to do something about it?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And the voters make the difference. Keep re-electing the same people over and over and over and then wonder why nothing ever gets done.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Unfortunately 1stwarrior that's what we would like to think, but it is untrue in several ways. If the Republicans have it, it sucks and when the Democrats have it, it still sucks. The only way to change anything is to take the power away from the government and that can be done now, but how much longer is the real question.

You talk about the Indian problems on that article. Both parties have been in control. What got done about it?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

"there are no more cuts to make" Just shows you how screwed up that woman really is, sadly there are many the agree with her

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

The true problem here is that NEITHER the Dems or Repubs are really cutting anything. It is all smoke and mirrors.

The budget does not cut spending at all, and in fact actually increases spending by $1.5 trillion over ten years. The Republicans are using the old DC trick of spending less than originally planned and calling that reduced spendingincreasea $5.1 trillioncutin spending. Only in DC could a budget that increases spending by 3.5 percent per year instead of by 5.2 percent per year be attacked as a slash-and-burn plan.

The bottom line here is that sooner or later somebody is going to have to pay the piper.

 
 

Who is online



94 visitors