╌>

Free Speech Be Damned HERE -- Justice Thomas Was Right -- Citizens United and the defenestration of Brendan Eich. -- WSJ Best of the Web 4/4/2004

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  1 comments

Free Speech Be Damned HERE -- Justice Thomas Was Right -- Citizens United and the defenestration of Brendan Eich. -- WSJ Best of the Web 4/4/2004
April 4,2014

Brendan Eich was struck by OkCupid's arrow, but that doesn't mean he's in love.

BN-CF716_botwt0_E_20140404122531.jpg

Brendan Eich Corbis

As the Daily Caller's Chuck Ross noted the other day, OkCupid, a dating website, urged its users to boycott Mozilla's Firefox browser on the ground that "Mozilla's new CEO, Brendan Eich, is an opponent of equal rights for gay couples." Eich's offense was to donate $1,000 in 2008 to the campaign of California's Proposition 8, a state constitutional ban on same-sex marriage that has since been nullified by federal courts. There has been no claim that Eich, an executive of Mozilla Corp. since its founding in 2005, discriminated against gay employees.

Ross had some fun with the hypocrisy of two of OkCupid's co-founders, Sam Yagan and Christian Rudder. He searched the federal campaign-contribution database and found that Yagan gave to two candidates who opposed same-sex marriage: $500 to then-Rep. Chris Cannon of Utah, a Republican, in 2004; and $500 to then-Sen. Barack Obama's 2008 presidential campaign. Rudder donated $1,000 to Obama's re-election effort, but that contribution came in September 2012, a few months after the president reversed his position.

Unlike Obama, Eich has not renounced his opposition to same-sex marriage. Also unlike Obama, he is now out of a job. As The Wall Street Journal reports:

In a blog post Thursday, Mozilla's executive chairwoman, Mitchell Baker, apologized for Mr. Eich's appointment, writing, "We have employees with a wide diversity of views. Our culture of openness extends to encouraging staff and community to share their beliefs and opinions in public. ... But this time we failed to listen, to engage, and to be guided by our community."
In a statement provided by Mozilla, Mr. Eich said: "I have decided to resign as CEO effective today, and leave Mozilla. Our mission is bigger than any one of us, and under the present circumstances, I cannot be an effective leader. I will be taking time before I decide what to do next."

In addition to OkCupid's boycott, the Journal reports, "Credo Mobile, a wireless company that bills itself as progressive, gathered more than 50,000 signatures calling for [Eich] to resign."

It's reasonable to surmise that Eich's departure was a defenestration rather than a voluntary resignation. The Journal notes that "some Mozilla employees took to Twitter to call for his resignation." Denouncing one's boss on social media is normally an imprudent move, to say the least, but it seems that in this case the dissenting employees had the support of the board.

So here we have at least three corporations ganging up on an individual and depriving him of his livelihood solely on account of his personal political views. For the past few years, since the Supreme Court's decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission , we've been hearing incessantly from liberals and Democrats outraged at the notion that corporations have the right to free speech.

This would seem an excellent opportunity for a principled and imaginative leftist to advance that argument in a way that might appeal across ideological lines. OkCupid's boycott call--"We would ... prefer that our users not use Mozilla software," the site informed users who did--was straight-up corporate speech. So was Credo Mobile's organizing of a petition against Eich (though no one would deny that the individuals who signed it were engaged in an act of personal expression).

And while Mozilla's refusal to support its CEO was in part a matter of business exigencies, in her blog post Baker frames it in terms of the corporation's values and opinions: "Mozilla believes both in equality and freedom of speech. Equality is necessary for meaningful speech. And you need free speech to fight for equality."

This column does not agree with our notional principled and imaginative leftist. Our view is that the corporations involved were acting within their rights under the First Amendment. They exercised those rights in a nasty and illiberal way, but free speech protects disagreeable views as well as agreeable ones. There is nothing the government properly could have done to prevent this regrettable outcome.

Actually, there is one thing. Eich's support for Proposition 8 became public knowledge because of a California law requiring disclosure of personal information--name, address, occupation and employer's name--of anybody who gives $100 or more to a campaign for or against a ballot initiative. The secretary of state's office is required to post this information online, and, as HotAir.com's " AllahPundit " notes, the Los Angeles Times made it available on its site as an easily searchable database.

Which brings us back to Citizens United. It is known as a 5-4 decision, and most of it was, but one part of Justice Anthony Kennedy's opinion--upholding a provision requiring disclosure of political contributions--was for an 8-1 majority, with Justice Clarence Thomas dissenting alone.

Thomas's argument rested heavily on the facts of the Proposition 8 campaign, and it's worth quoting at length (we're omitting legal citations and shortening and adding links to news-media ones):

Some opponents of Proposition 8 compiled this information and created Web sites with maps showing the locations of homes or businesses of Proposition 8 supporters. Many supporters (or their customers) suffered property damage, or threats of physical violence or death, as a result. They cited these incidents in a complaint they filed after the 2008 election, seeking to invalidate California's mandatory disclosure laws. Supporters recounted being told: "Consider yourself lucky. If I had a gun I would have gunned you down along with each and every other supporter," or, "we have plans for you and your friends." Proposition 8 opponents also allegedly harassed the measure's supporters by defacing or damaging their property. Two religious organizations supporting Proposition 8 reportedly received through the mail envelopes containing a white powdery substance.
Those accounts are consistent with media reports describing Proposition 8-related retaliation. The director of the nonprofit California Musical Theater gave $1,000 to support the initiative; he was forced to resign after artists complained to his employer. The director of the Los Angeles Film Festival was forced to resign after giving $1,500 because opponents threatened to boycott and picket the next festival. [ John Lott and Bradley Smith , The Wall Street Journal] And a woman who had managed her popular, family-owned restaurant for 26 years was forced to resign after she gave $100, because "throngs of [angry] protesters" repeatedly arrived at the restaurant and "shout[ed] 'shame on you' at customers." [ Steve Lopez , Los Angeles Times]. The police even had to "arriv[e] in riot gear one night to quell the angry mob" at the restaurant. Ibid. Some supporters of Proposition 8 engaged in similar tactics; one real estate businessman in San Diego who had donated to a group opposing Proposition 8 "received a letter from the Prop. 8 Executive Committee threatening to publish his company's name if he didn't also donate to the 'Yes on 8' campaign."
The success of such intimidation tactics has apparently spawned a cottage industry that uses forcibly disclosed donor information to pre-empt citizens' exercise of their First Amendment rights. Before the 2008 Presidential election, a "newly formed nonprofit group ... plann[ed] to confront donors to conservative groups, hoping to create a chilling effect that will dry up contributions." Its leader, "who described his effort as 'going for the jugular,'" detailed the group's plan to send a "warning letter ... alerting donors who might be considering giving to right-wing groups to a variety of potential dangers, including legal trouble, public exposure and watchdog groups digging through their lives." [ New York Times news story]
These instances of retaliation sufficiently demonstrate why this Court should invalidate mandatory disclosure and reporting requirements. But amici [friends of the court] present evidence of yet another reason to do so--the threat of retaliation from elected officials. As amici's submissions make clear, this threat extends far beyond a single ballot proposition in California. For example, a candidate challenging an incumbent state attorney general [in West Virginia] reported that some members of the State's business community feared donating to his campaign because they did not want to cross the incumbent; in his words, "'I go to so many people and hear the same thing: "I sure hope you beat [the incumbent], but I can't afford to have my name on your records. He might come after me next."'" [ Kim Strassel , The Wall Street Journal]

Thomas's conclusion (quoting an earlier opinion of his own): "I cannot endorse a view of the First Amendment that subjects citizens of this Nation to death threats, ruined careers, damaged or defaced property, or pre-emptive and threatening warning letters as the price for engaging in "core political speech, the 'primary object of First Amendment protection.'"

That last argument is one that has drawn wide support on the court in other contexts. In McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission (1995), a 7-2 majority struck down an Ohio law prohibiting the distribution of anonymous campaign literature. In an opinion joined by five of his colleagues (Thomas separately concurred), Justice John Paul Stevens wrote that "the decision in favor of anonymity may be motivated by fear of economic or official retaliation, by concern about social ostracism, or merely by a desire to preserve as much of one's privacy as possible." The applicability of that observation to Eich's predicament is obvious.

In NAACP v. Alabama (1958), the Warren court unanimously quashed a state subpoena for the NAACP's membership list. "This Court has recognized the vital relationship between freedom to associate and privacy in one's associations," Justice John Harlan noted. "Inviolability of privacy in group association may in many circumstances be indispensable to preservation of freedom of association, particularly where a group espouses dissident beliefs."

Some gay-rights advocates are discomfited by what happened to Eich, most notably Andrew Sullivan , who writes:

The whole episode disgusts me--as it should disgust anyone interested in a tolerant and diverse society. If this is the gay rights movement today--hounding our opponents with a fanaticism more like the religious right than anyone else--then count me out. If we are about intimidating the free speech of others, we are no better than the anti-gay bullies who came before us.

Slate's Will Oremus makes the case for the persecution:

Opposing gay marriage in America today is not akin to opposing tax hikes or even the war in Afghanistan. It's more akin to opposing interracial marriage: It bespeaks a conviction that some people do not deserve the same basic rights as others. An organization like Mozilla might tolerate that in an underling, and it might even tolerate it in a CTO [chief technology officer, Eich's previous title]. But in a CEO--the ultimate decision-maker and public face of an organization--it sends an awful message....
Actually, Mr. Eich, right now we're in a world where you have to not be a bigot if you want to be an effective leader of an organization like Mozilla. And it's about time.

Therein lies the relevance of the NAACP case. Opposition to same-sex marriage might not have been a "dissident belief" in 2008, when Proposition 8 passed with more than 52% of the vote in liberal California. But as Oremus makes clear, it is today, at least in liberal parts of the country and certainly in the professional community of which Brendan Eich is (or was) a part.

As noted above, our view is that corporations have every right to send a "message," including by making otherwise lawful personnel decisions. But California's disclosure law turns out to have been a grievous violation of Eich's rights and the rights of others.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

From tomorrow's WSJ editorial:

But Justice Clarence Thomas made us think with his concurring opinion in 2010 in Citizens United that dissented on disclosure. "I cannot endorse a view of the First Amendment that subjects citizens of this Nation to death threats, ruined careers, damaged or defaced property, or pre-emptive and threatening warning letters as the price for engaging in 'core political speech,' the 'primary object of First Amendment protection,'" he wrote.

Justice Thomas knows how Southern racists tried to subpoena NAACP membership lists for intimidation purposes in the Jim Crow era. The Supreme Court ruled this was a violation of the First Amendment right of association. In our current age of growing liberal intolerance, Justice Thomas's warning takes on renewed meaning.

 
 

Who is online