Idaho school system removes book from curriculum after parental outrage
" SALMON, Idaho (Reuters) - The largest school district in Idaho has banned from its curriculum an award-winning book about the struggles of a Native American teenager after complaints by parents that the novel was rife with profanity, racial epithets and anti-Christian rhetoric.
The school board in Meridian, Idaho, voted 2-1 this week to keep the book, "The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian," off a supplemental reading list for 10th graders, meaning it will not be part of the curriculum at the high school, said school board clerk Trish Duncan.
The 2007 Sherman Alexie novel, which won the 2007 National Book Award for Young People's Literature, is still available in the school's library, she said."
http://news.msn.com/us/idaho-school-system-removes-book-from-curriculum-after-parental-outrage

"The book is described by publisher Little, Brown as a "heartbreaking, funny and beautifully written" tale about the experiences of a young Native American who leaves his troubled school on an Indian reservation in Washington state to attend an all-white high school in a nearby farming community."
"Gretchen Caserotti, director of public libraries in Meridian, spoke in favor of not placing restrictions on that or other books during a recent public meeting about the Alexie novel.
"Teen fiction is often a reflection and extension of adolescents' realities. We believe books are a powerful and safe place for kids to see outside themselves and explore a world that is increasingly diverse and complex," she said.
An ironic outcropping of the controversy is that the book is now in high demand in local public libraries, said Caserotti.
The novel was ranked second on a list of 10 books that were most frequently challenged or banned in 2012, according to the American Library Association."
Guess the mother didn't really want to learn what her kids were doing, saying, thinking, learning - eh?
Never let the truth be told, that way it never happened. This is how they keep the truth of their atrocities from becoming public knowledge and they have been doing it for hundreds of years.
I've read this book and I thought it was absolutely hilarious, sad, witty, enlightening, thoughtful, frustrating, and so, so, so damn close to the truth.
But then, I've lived that life and knew what he was talking about.
As only teen-agers can make it.
It mentions remembering history, but they are talking about tribal/family history.
Life is rife with profanity, racial epithets and anti-Christian rhetoric.
People had ought to just shut their mouths or else chew on their elbows...
I won't say it, 1stwarrior. I absolutely won't say it.
A Clockwork Orange was on our reading list when I was in junior high. None of us did any housebreaking, raping or pillaging.
I don't know what the problem is. Peyton Place was required reading when I was in school. They even had required places you had to read it, like in the back of the room, far end of the cafeteria, back of the bus and it was required you never let a teacher see you reading it. And you could only read little parts of it at a time and then let someone else have it. I never got to read the whole thing.
I think that they should be able, by the time they are in high school, to discern the qualities of a book on their own and make up their own minds whether it was worth their while to read. By the ninth grade your moral code should be well enough formed that you would be able to do this.
You know very well, Robert G, that your comment is argumentative and IMO foolish, something a child might say. The book that is the topic here has received accolades, such as the National Book Award, and is not just "any" book. One review I saw said:
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian is a novel about hope, about who has it and who doesn't, and about how hard life can be when hope leaves. And how life can change when hope reappears.
Teaching children to hope is not a good lesson for them, Robert G?
Is that something that innocent kids should be shielded from? I'll make this clear: I am totally against book burners, and more than that I believe that the realities of life should not be hidden from view, or else how does anyone learn to deal with or shield themselves from some of the ugly things that happen? Fortunately, when I went to school, which was probably before many NT members were born, it was a rare occasion that a book was banned, but then perhaps things were different in Canada, and not so restrictive as in the "freedom loving" USA.
Alright, think of this for a moment. How many of you had to read Shakespeare in High School?? Did you know that he was the second most scatological (John Dunne was first) in the Elizabethan Age? Read most - no, read any of his comedies and you'll see sexual innuendoes up the ying yang - but, it was "Required" reading - and still is. Where his books banned????
Very sad that this book was banned. Sad, not only because it was an excellent book, but told a very good story of coming of age of a very misunderstood people.
Real life experiences and truth,are not something that some can deal with, thus ''burn the book''.
The real beauty part is that by 'banning' the book, the dipshit parents have aroused enough curiousity that more kids will read it than would have otherwise...
That part is the beauty of it all Swamijim.
Now, if it were "50 Shades of Grey", I might understand .
Interestingly enough Robert, Sherman can reach across the age barriers when he is writing - similar to the way Shell Silverstein used to do. Much of what Sherman wrote about were/are relatedto his childhood and some of the "experiences" Indian kids, on reservations, have to go through in growing up. Those experiences can be transponded to folks growing up off the reservation. I can remember "learning" about the mysteries of sex when reading "Catcher in the Rye" and then all we guys talking about what we read. Of course, Catcher was a strongly banned book - which made it all the more interesting.
No, there were no long speeches about any particular subject matter - just your typical teen-age patter about many subjects - the same subjects that all teens are exposed too. That is what made the book interesting.
In other words. "IT CONTAINED TOO MUCH REALITY!"
The offended parents celebrated their victory over fact-based education with a marathon REALITY TV orgy.
To quote Mrs. Gump
"STUPID IS AS STUPID DOES."
"The book has been at the center of several controversies regarding the depiction of sex and violence in books written for young adults. Alexie responded to such complaints in a 2011Wall Street Journalpost entitled "Why the Best Kids Books Are Written in Blood", in which he argues that attempts to prevent school-aged children from learning about the harsher aspects of contemporary life are "way, way too late". He uses his own life as an example:
The wonderful thing about banned books is that everyone wants to read them.
You are determined to agitate aren't you?