The Sad, Scary Saga of Justina Pelletier
A Massachusetts judge on Tuesday granted the state permanent custody of an ill teenager who has spent the last year caught up in a dispute between her family on one side and Boston Childrens Hospital and the state Department of Children and Families on the other. While many facts are in dispute, one thing is clear: Justina Pelletier spent the past year in a locked psych ward , even though doctors disagree about whether her condition is psychiatric.
Its easy to follow Justinas case on Twitter and get caught up in the outrage . Whats surprising is to read up on it and have your outrage legitimized.
According to Patricia Wens excellent reporting in the Boston Globe , Justina had been a patient of Mark Korson, a metabolic disorders specialist at Tufts, for several years. He had diagnosed her with a mitochondrial disease that caused her to have trouble eating and walking. During a particularly scary spell in February 2013, he told her parents to take her to Boston Childrens to see a former Tufts colleague of his, a gastroenterologist.
The Pelletiers did just that. But they never saw the gastroenterologist, and Justina has not been home since. The doctors at Childrens diagnosed her with somatic symptom disorder, a psychiatric condition akin to hypochondria . When her father tried to have her discharged to take her back to Tufts, the Boston Globe reports, he watched a swarm of hospital security approach to guard each exit. The hospital filed an allegation of medical child abuse against the couple for seeking what the hospital deemed as unnecessary treatment and petitioned the state for custody.
What has ensued since is a harrowing medical and legal drama. Wens two-part series , co-written with Neil Swidey, that ran in December paints a picture that will likely terrify any parent who reads it, whether your children are healthy or need special care.*
Why cant doctors figure out if Justina is suffering from mitochondrial disease or a psychiatric disorder? Her doctor at Tufts (lets call this side team mito) points out that there is no test to confirm somatic symptom disorder, while doctors at Childrens (team psych) were troubled by the many medical interventions that Justina had been subjected to as a result of her disputed mitochondrial diagnosis. One doctor quoted by the Globe points out that the mere diagnosis raises suspicions: Its the kind of diagnosis vulnerable to manipulation by parents, Dr. Alice Newton said.
When parents disagree with doctors, a hospital such as Childrens has a huge advantage. Because the states Department of Children and Families lacks medical expertise, Swidey and Wen point out , it often turns to Childrens for assistance. So when Childrens files a medical abuse claim against parents, DCF turns to Childrens? This isnt a rare or theoretical conflict of interest. Childrens has had five similar custody cases in the past two years. Critics call it a parent-ectomy .
Apparently the Pelletiers can be difficult peoplethey have yelled at the doctors and threatened DCF social workers, and they refused offers for Justina to be put in a long-term care facility closer to their home. (Justina was recently moved to a residential psychiatric facility in Framingham, Mass.) And they are not giving up: There are reports that they are filing a writ of habeas corpus for wrongful imprisonment. But if I were a parent who felt a hospital was interfering with my rights and harming my child, I cant say that I would act any differently.
http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2014/03/27/justina_pelletier_ruling_boston_children_s_hospital_and_judge_perform_parent.html

I would get verbally abusive myself if some government department kidnapped my daughter.
I ran across this story a couple of weeks ago but the saga was so convoluted it was difficult to follow. It is indeed messed up when parents try to follow a doctor's orders and have a hospital take away custody of children.
This situation follows closely on the heels of a couple of children who have died because their parents refused medical care in favor of faith healing, which may have influenced the decision of the court.
It sounds like this time, the parents were trying to get medical treatment for their child, but another doctor who only saw her for a short time decided it was a mental problem instead of a physical one. They deemed her treatment "unnecessary" and took her away so they would not get the care she needed. This is some scary shit, when someone who knows nothing about your case can decide it is all in your head and have you committed.
So would I. the saddest thing about it is the child seems to be suffering the most.
I agree, they think they know whats best and they just take your kid! I don't think over a year in a nut house is the best thing for the kid.
I can't put what I'd do on this site. The one thing none of us can feel is that which we are not experiencing ourselves.
And the beat goes on, the beat goes on.