╌>

Outfoxed: how protests forced Mozilla's CEO to resign in 11 days

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  larry-hampton  •  12 years ago  •  20 comments

Outfoxed: how protests forced Mozilla's CEO to resign in 11 days

On a rainy morning this week in San Francisco, newly appointed Mozilla CEO Brendan Eich sat down for coffee with one of the people calling for his resignation. Hampton Catlin, a prominent developer of apps for the nascent Firefox OS, announced he was abandoning the platform due to Eichs handling of the disclosure that in 2008 he donated $1,000 to the fight against same-sex marriage. Californias Proposition 8, which passed with 52 percent of the vote in 2008, made same-sex marriage illegal in California until the law was overturned by the Supreme Court. Over the course of an hour, Catlin explained the suffering that Prop. 8 caused for him and his partner, a Brit who couldnt immigrate until marriage became legal. Catlin asked Eich for an apology. He didnt get one.

~LINK~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago
"

Instead, Eich resigned as CEO and stepped down from the board of the Mozilla foundation. "Mozilla prides itself on being held to a different standard and, this past week, we didnt live up to it," the companys executive chairwoman, Mitchell Baker, said in a blog post today. "We know why people are hurt and angry, and they are right: its because we havent stayed true to ourselves." Suddenly Eich, who formerly served as Mozillas chief technical officer and previously invented the programming language JavaScript, was out of a company he co-founded in 1998. "It may be challenging for a CEO, but everyone in our community can have different beliefs about all sorts of things that may be in conflict," Eich told CNET earlier in the week. But the challenge proved greater than his leadership.

"
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

JavaScript is not the same as the "Java programming language" . That was invented by Patrick Naughton . He ran into trouble with the law as described here :

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
10 to 15 years ago proponents of civil unions scoffed at those who said civil unions were a staling horse for gay marriage. According to these gay advoca It was right wing paranoia intended to scare voters. We know how that turned out.This man essentially restated President Obamas position on the subject from 18 months ago. He lost his job for it.It's amazing how fast things move from forbidden to compulsory in this society. Simply saying what the vast majority of people Beleived a few short years ago is now, for all purposes, a crime. Mao would be jealous. The American media and Hollywood knows how to force a cultural revelution better than Mao.
 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
am i understanding this right? a person was forced to resign his position of a company he co-founded because he believes marriage is between a man and a woman and donated to support that belief? what the hell is this country coming to? must we all walk lockstep with the gay agenda now?
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

The absurdity is just overwhelming. Can you imagine telling someone in 2004 that this would happen in 2014? They would think you are nuts.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
McCarthyism meets the 21st century.It's amazing that Andrew Sullivan has to be the lefts voice of reason:"As I said last night, of course Mozilla has the right to purge a CEO because of his incorrect political views. Of course Eich was not stripped of his First Amendment rights. Id fight till my last breath for Mozilla to retain that right. What Im concerned with is the substantive reason for purging him. When peoples lives and careers are subject to litmus tests, and fired if they do not publicly renounce what may well be their sincere conviction, we have crossed a line. This is McCarthyism applied by civil actors. This is the definition of intolerance. If a socially conservative private entity fired someone because they discovered he had donated against Prop 8, how would you feel? Its staggering to me that a minority long persecuted for holding unpopular views can now turn around and persecute others for the exact same reason. If we cannot live and work alongside people with whom we deeply disagree, we are finished as a liberal society."
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago
 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

You're opinions should cost you your job, according to gay Nazis and Stasi comrades united for Gay rights and a better society, and freedom loving Mozilla data collectors.

Geez Louise Robert G, such hyperbole.

Eich wasnt just some guy working in the cubicles he was the new CEO. His view that certain Americans should not be given equality under our laws was not a view shared by his company. He was given the choice of rethinking his position or stepping off. He decided to step off.

Did you also go all Nazis, Nazis, Nazis on Rand Paul when he kicked to the curb that fool that worked for him, the one that wore that stupid Confederate mask and called himself the Southern Avenger?

Once that guys neo-Confederate views became public Rand Paul decided he didnt want to be associated with those views.

Was Rand Paul wrong to let him go or was it his right to not want to be tied to that guys stupidity?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Some of us realize these people are the most intolerant people in this country. It is not tolerant to demand others think like you or follow the narrow line you have drawn.

When a nation allows people like this to control others personal feelings about an issue to such an extent, then we as a country have lost one of the most important freedoms we have and those unable to see this will be accomplices in the destruction of our society.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

If the Mozzilla guy wore a mask and called himself the Southern Avenger, I would note that his public behavior was a problem.

Lots of people wear costumes in public, (New York Mayor Rudolph Giulian seemed to spend a Lot of time in drag). It wasn't the guys mask that got him sacked it was his obnoxious personal views that Rand Paul didn't want to have around.

since a government pronouncement that you are "married" is not within their power to grant or sanctify.

Pure bull hockey.

If you want to clam "Holly Matrimony" for some religious reason then have at it but as long as there are State and Federal rights and obligations associated with people entering into a Marriage contract, then of course the government has the right to get involved and an obligation, under our Constitution, to treat everyone doing so equally.

A church can only sanctify a "Holly Matrimony" binding for people of their own flock but they don't have shit to say about anyone's marriage outside their own places of worship, however the Government has a say on ALL marriages.

This CEO and Rand Paul's staffer have every right to pursue their minority opinions just as their bosses have the right to say "That's not the face we want to present to the public".

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

Which can be done without government involvement in sanctifying your marriage

Wrong again Robert. My marriage needed no "sanctifying", there was no religious involvement at all and it lasted 20 years, till death did we part. No marriage Needs to be sanctified by some religious doctrine. Matter of fact your preacher, priest, imam can preform any ceremony you want but in the eyes of the Government you are not eligible for the perks of marriage until they give you that license.

Except for gays, most people don't give a shit if some retard government worker

Now you're just being disingenuous.

There are 1,000's benefits and rights that go along with that government issued license. To say that only gays care if they aren't being offered those rights when they marry just seems like the flailing of a person on the wrong side of history.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

Which is as creepy as it gets. So "Nazi" applies.

No it's not Nazism Robert it's Capitalism. This CEO holds a personal view that his company deemed would be held as abhorrent by a majority of their customer base. They reasoned that, "if we put this fool out front we'll lose money", so they cut their losses and let him resign.

Just like Rand Paul thought he would lose votes if he let his jerk stay on staff so he shoved him to the curb.

Anything else IS asking the government to sanctify and bless.

NO, again NO. The government is recording and keeping track of a marriage so they know who is legally qualified for the many rights that go along with marriage.

Your use of "sanctify and bless" crap is just adhomenim. Or as the Bard put it, "It is a tale. Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,. Signifying nothing"

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

"Sanctify and bless applies." You want MORE than equal benefits. You want the government telling you that you are wonderful. Making one wonder what you lack that the government can compensate for. You have a view of government that makes government .... godly. All knowing. All wonderful. God.

Robert, in your mind did the government "Sanctify and bless" your birth when they recorded it and issued a birth certificate, or maybe you felt the spirit and started speaking in tongues when the government registered your vehicles or property. The government recording marriages is just one of the millions of records kept in a civilized society. Again it's record keeping plan and simple. It has nothing to do with your personal religious beliefs.

Your characterization as to why Mozilla demanded a retraction of personal belief, if true, should draw criticism. Not support.

Why would you think that? It was a business decision and right or wrong it was theirs to make.

That you are comfortable with and would like working for people who are mindless drones, and demand that of their employees.

Again you resort to the sound a fury argument. When I got out of the Marines I went two year without a haircut just to get over my high and tight years. When I became a lineman for the phone company my first boss said boy you're going to be out working in public and there you're the face of this company. Son you got to cut that hair!

Old man Corbin was right I represented the company so it was their code I had to keep. I also saw a well respected long serving 4th level manager booted because he made the mistake of making a racial slur about another employ over the phone when he thought he was on hold and couldn't be heard. You can have your opinion Robert, just like this CEO but if you go public with same and it reflects badly on your employer don't whine when they decide you're bad for the bottom line and let you go.

Which I think is what Andrew Sullivan is saying. No difference between the religious right and gay fanatics. None.

Sure there's a difference the religious right try to pass laws that allow them to push their beliefs beyond their church walls. The gay community is just trying to reach equality under our public laws.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Totally disagree with you ArkansasHermit.

No it's not Nazism Robert it's Capitalism. This CEO holds a personal view that his company deemed would be held as abhorrent by a majority of their customer base.

The gay/lesbians had the same opinion as you have when they were going to protest the "Chick-fil-A.Appreciation Day" event promoted only by Mike Huckabee.

I think it was the busiest day in the history of the company. I know I went by several of them that day and cars were stopped on the highway to get into the parking lot and adjoining parking lots. Looked like they were giving away the food plus the money to buy another meal.

The gay/lesbians were suppose to protest this event. Thought that the majority of Americans were thinking just like them because the owner had said he believed in marriage between a man and a woman, the same thing Obama said before he was elected president.

Although the owner didn't discriminate against gay/lesbians for jobs it didn't matter. The intolerant gay/lesbians pretty much so said you're going to think like us or we'll run you out of business.

Well, you're right in one respect. It was Capitalism at work that showed them we would tolerate them, but they weren't going to be successful in their demands we agree with them.

My personal feelings are freedom to do what you or I like as long as it doesn't harm anyone else. If you want to marry your gay lover, I could care less. I won't tell you like Ron Emanuel told Chick-fil-A they weren't welcomed in Chicago.

You're welcome in my house straight, gay or whatever as long as you treat others like a decent human being.

I won't condemn you if you don't believe in a higher power, but I will believe whatever I want without your consent.

Your use of "sanctify and bless" crap is just adhomenim. Or as the Bard put it, "It is a tale. Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,. Signifying nothing"

And the statement above oh what can you say?

As far as Rand Paul, I agree he should have gotten rid of an intolerant person on his staff. And he did.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

I'm among a group of gays who feel that a vocal minority of the LGBT crossed the line in forcing the resignation Brendan Eich, thus violating his right to free speech. Considering his donation was made 8 years ago, Eich had a right to voice his non-confrontational opinion of Gay Marriage.

While I may not agree with Eich's beliefs, there is a strong case to be made for calling it intolerance when a campaign is mounted against an entire company (Mozilla) because a group of people disagrees with the personal beliefs of one employee.

The LGBT risks a backlash to this kind of activity in light of the fact we are still getting physically attacked by the neanderthal, homophobic goons from the right ( source )

Intolerance is a two way street.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

The LGBT risks a backlash to this kind of activity in light of the fact we are still getting physically attacked by the neanderthal, homophobic goons from the right

I hear you AeonPax. In a way it reminds me of some discussion I listened to back in the early 70s. Back then racial tension was so high that there were times the base I was stationed at would impose curfews, confining us to barracks to avoid confrontations in the streets.

Many times the black Marines would debate which would move their community toward equality faster, MLKs or Malcom Xs way.

I personally fall about 90% MLK 10% Malcom X but then Im white and have the advantage of hindsight as to how things have progressed so far toward equality for that community.

Eich had a right to voice his non-confrontational opinion of Gay Marriage.

I have just the smallest disagreement with the use of non-confrontational. There were two sides to prop 8. One side saying We are Americans and as such should be equal in the eyes of the law, the other side confronted them and said, No, we dont see you as Americans equal under the law and we are going to work to keep it that way. My opinion only of course. :-)

Did you also fell it was a step too far when several business dropped Rush Limbaugh because of the backlash after he called Ms. Fluke a slut?

Looked to me that some companies said Oh hell, its going to cost us money if we put Limbaugh out as the face of our business, while other companies didnt think it would hurt their customer base at all and kept their advertising on his program.

Again, these decisions don't look like Fascism to me but more like Capitalism.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

I think it was the busiest day in the history of the company. I know I went by several of them that day and cars were stopped on the highway to get into the parking lot and adjoining parking lots.

Great observation Sixpick and one I was also thinking of when I noted to Robert that I thought it was a business decision "For Better Or for Worse", knowing that calls for a boycott can cut both ways.

Just ask Disney if they suffered after certain Christian groups called for a Disney boycott because they started offering "Gay Pride Days".

Some boycotts achieve their stated goals, some do not, either way boycotts have a long and storied history in Americas march toward "equality for all".

Your use of "sanctify and bless" crap is just adhomenim. Or as the Bard put it, "It is a tale. Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,. Signifying nothing"

And the statement above oh what can you say?

LOL, ya that was a bit over the top but hell, I just got irritated with the constant use of that "Sanctify and Bless" stuff conflated with Government as if it was meant to mean something. Even after Robert tried to explain it to me I couldn't find the sense.

That's why I went on the rant asking if he thought other government records/documents represented some sort of Holy writ. Will the death certificate the government issues when it's time be them "sanctify and blessing" his "last rights"? :-)

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    12 years ago

Let's face it; the main weapon for fighting intolerance these days is even more intolerance. If someone disagrees, they suddenly become a "Them" and not an "Us". Me, I have the opposite problem; if someone agrees with me all the time, I start to look upon them with great suspicion. I believe my way may be best.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

Lol

Talk about serendipity Sixpic. Did you catch the news the CEO of Chick-fil-A has made over the last few days?

Seems that after Mr Cathy exercised his 1st amendment right and then Americans in general did the same on his position, (both pro and con), it looks like the companys general stance is now coming down on the side of Capitalism.

USA Today 04/08/2014

About two years ago, Cathy made headlines after conceding to being "guilty as charged," in confirming Chick-fil-A's support of the traditional family. Both ardent supporters and angry picketers showed up at stores. While Cathy's comments didn't hurt short-term business and even helped it Chick-fil-A executives recognize that the comments may have done longer-term damage to the brand's image at the very time it was eyeing major growth outside its friendly Southern market.

The national growth is about to go into overdrive and it has a huge, new product platform behind it. Its biggest-ever new product roll-out will be announced Tuesday: a Millennial-targeting grilled chicken line for which the company has spent the past 12 years testing more than 1,000 grilled chicken recipes and developing such super-secret grilling equipment that executives won't let it be photographed.

Seems now that the company is looking to expand their customer base into areas & demographics that would largely disagree with Mr. Cathys position, (as stated two years ago), hurting their bottom line, he is now trying to lessen the impact of what he said.

These days it's "All of us become more wise as time goes by," he says, apologetically, in a rare, one-hour sit-down interview. "We sincerely care about all people."

Chick-fil-A's socially conservative agenda, which formally led the company to donate millions to charitable groups opposed to gay marriage, has been tempered. This, just as the company aims to quickly expand into Chicago, New York and Los Angeles. Southern hospitality must give way to urban reality as the 1,800 store chain moves to compete with big city success stories like McDonald's, Panera Bread and Chipotle.

If nothing else, Cathy has listened. In 2012, Cathy not only heard from some unhappy consumers about his comments against gay marriage, but also from some store operators and employees. Now, he says, "I'm going to leave it to politicians and others to discuss social issues."

Looks like the bottom line always wins out in the end.

Of course, in this case, I agree with the direction the companies going in but I do realize that might not always be the case. :-)

 
 

Who is online