THE OTHER REFUGEES AND THE PATH TO PEACE
THE OTHER REFUGEES AND THE PATH TO PEACE
By Jonathan S. Tobin, Commentary, March 27, 2014
Today Canadas foreign minister proved once again why the Great White North is one of the worlds outliers with regard to the Middle East. Foreign Minister John Baird said that the Canadian government stated that the fate of the Jewish refugees from Arab countries should be both recognized and taken into account in discussions about Middle East peace. The statement followed Canadas parliament adopting a report on the subject and though Baird was careful to say that he didnt want the issue to become a point of contention in the talks between Israel and the Palestinians sponsored by the United States, the mere raising of the topic is enough to cause some of Israels critics to claim the Canadians are trying to sabotage the negotiations. While the Israelis have repeatedly raised the issue of the hundreds of thousands of Jews who fled or were forced to flee their homes throughout the Arab world in the months and years following Israels birth in 1948, the Palestinians not only refuse to discuss the matter, they regard it as a distraction from the nakbaor disaster, as they refer to Israels creation. But in doing so they make it plain that this issue is central to understanding why peace has eluded the region.
The Canadian report will undoubtedly be ignored by the international press that tends to treat any mention of Jewish refugees as somehow an illustration of Israels lack of contrition about the suffering of the Palestinians. But the more that one learns about the topic, the easier it is to understand that there was no monopoly on suffering in this conflict. Just as hundreds of thousands of Arabs fled or, in a few cases, were told to leave their homes in the former British Mandate for Palestine, almost an equal number of Jews throughout the Arab and Muslim world experienced the same fate.
Photos: A refugee camp in Israel 1950 for Jewish refugees from Arab countries, and Jewish refugees from Arab countries aboard an airplane flying them to Israel
The difference between the two populations was that the Jews were taken in and resettled by their brethren, either in the newborn state of Israel or in Western countries. Though their journeys and adjustment to their new homes was not always easy, none were allowed to languish in limbo. Today, they and their descendants in Israel or in the United States and other Western countries are members of successful communities where they enjoy equal rights.
By contrast, the Arabs who left the territory that would become the State of Israel were deliberately kept in camps to this day and denied any resettlement or citizenship in the countries where they found themselves. The reason for this was that they were useful props in the Arab worlds ongoing war to reverse the verdict of that war. Their future was held hostage to the struggle to destroy Israel, and the refugees and their numerous progeny have been kept apart and in squalor in order to further that effort. Their plight merits the sympathy of the world. So, too, does the way they have been exploited and abused by their own leaders and other Arab countries.
Click this link to read the rest of the article:
http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2014/03/27/the-other-refugees-and-the-path-to-peace-palestinians-1948/
Tags
Who is online
85 visitors

Now that the Arab League has involved itself in the Peace Negotiations by cheerleading the Palestinian narrative of 'The Nakba' and the necessity in including return of refugees, then what is good for the goose is good for the gander.
Yet again I am proud to be a Canadian for its moral stand, seeking genuine justice, notwithstanding the slings and arrows of the rest of the world.
You have every right to be proud, Buzz. In this situation, they have taken the lead on an issue that is fraught with landmines in the international wasteland.