It's time to reclaim Islam from the fanatics. Here's how -- Can my religion be reconciled with free expression? The answer is yes -- Irshad Manji -- The Spectator, 29 March 2014
I am not a moderate Muslim, I am a reformist. Rooting out corrupt practices can never be an act of mere moderation. Restoring integrity, or wholeness, is always a radical act. It transcends notions of left and right, emphasising the need to think independently. In Islam, independent thought has a strong history, not that youd know it from the news about bombings, beheadings and bloodshed. Jihad has become part of the Wests vocabulary and with good reason. But there is a lesser-known term in Islam one that has the capacity to change the world for good.
The idea is ijtihad, Islams tradition of questioning and reinterpreting. And it is absolutely fundamental to the spirit of the Quran. Islams scripture contains three times as many passages urging Muslims to think and rethink than verses promoting blind worship.
Thats nice in theory, but what about in fact? In the Islam of a millennium ago, ijtihad flourished. It was no coincidence that Islamic civilisation led the world in curiosity, creativity and ingenuity. But then the sun set on Islams golden age. Invaders from North Africa pillaged the pluralism of Muslim Spain. From Cordoba to Baghdad, much of the Islamic empire lapsed into defensiveness. Out of 135 schools of Sunni thought, just four survived. The gates of ijtihad narrowed and in some places closed, legitimising rigid readings of the Quran. To this day, Muslims still struggle with the idea of independent thought.
But a new generation of Muslims are pushing the boundaries. In growing numbers, we are speaking our truths to self-appointed authorities, be they our parents or their imams. I can attest to this because young Muslims have been sharing their stories with me since I wrote my book, The Trouble with Islam Today. It was published ten years ago, with the predictable noise from offended Muslims drowning out the support from many others.
Those others, often the children of conservatives, wrote to me about their desperation for a Muslim community that accepts their interfaith relationships. In 2007, I used my blog to publish a blessing of Muslim-Christian love, written in English by a scholarly imam who reinterpreted the Quran. It was downloaded so often that I had it translated into 20 more languages.
Last year, Al Jazeera aired an intense debate about Muslim reform between me and the British commentator Mehdi Hasan. Hate mail followed. So did love bombs. But I did not receive any death threats. To be sure, the reality remains that those who shatter age-old taboos within Islam do have to fear for their lives. While it is true that every religion has its extremists, in no other religion do mainstream believers routinely shrug off the murder of dissenters. This is a life-and-death difference. All the more reason for ijtihad to be revived in the 21st century.
Nowhere does the necessity of ijtihad seem more urgent than in the wars over freedom of expression. One might say that the UK led the way. More than 25 years ago, a puny hive of British Muslims demanded the death of novelist Salman Rushdie even before Irans Ayatollah Khomeini issued his infamous fatwa.
Inline sub2
Earlier this year, I watched the British brouhaha over my friend Maajid Nawaz, the prospective Liberal Democrat candidate for Kilburn and co-founder of the counter-extremism outfit Quilliam. Nawaz had tweeted a cartoon called Jesus and Mo. Jesus to Mo: Hey! Mo: How ya doing? The end. That was it. Two top-tier prophets swapping props.
The problem for some Muslims is that, according to tradition, Muhammad cannot be depicted in image lest he become an object of worship. But by insisting that he cannot be drawn under any circumstances, these Muslims make the prophet off-limits to anyone who does not believe as they do. They thus turn Mo into, well, an object of worship. It leaves a lot of us wondering what, if anything, has been learned since the Danish cartoons fiasco eight years ago.
Then, you will recall, a handful of journalists, politicians, diplomats and mullahs in Denmark engineered an epic cultural crisis. Months earlier, the newspaper Jyllands-Posten had published images that supposedly mocked the Prophet Muhammad. Even after the paper apologised, the controversy grew. In different parts of the world, Muslims who rioted against Danish insensitivity silenced the more reasonable voices within their faith.
At the time, I received a lot of emails, mostly from young Muslims. I am even more offended by the riots than by the cartoons! exclaimed Mahmood, a student whose reaction typified many others. Fed up with one upheaval after another, the Muslims who contacted me channelled their frustration into an urgent sense that Muslims need to reform ourselves.
The question is simple: can Islam be reconciled with free expression? The answer is yes. The Quran points out that there will always be nonbelievers and that it is for God, not for Muslims, to deal with them: The truth is from your Lord, so whoever wills let him believe; and whoever wills let him disbelieve. (18:29). Moreover, the Quran states that there should no compulsion in religion. (2:256). Nobody should be forced to treat tradition as untouchable, including traditions that result in the messed-up Muslim habit of equating our very human prophet with an inviolable idol. Monotheists are to revere one God, not one of Gods emissaries. That is why humility requires people of faith to lampoon themselves, and each other, once in a while.
I can hear the reaction already: as a reformist, I am cherry-picking verses from the Quran. Given that the call for reflection suffuses the Quran, I am on terra firma in highlighting such little-known verses. It is my detractors who select on the shaky grounds of their own politics. After all, they ignore progressive Quranic passages, another one being about the liberty to choose ones faith: Unto you your religion, unto me my religion (109:6). While serving as grand mufti of Egypt, Sheikh Ali Gomaa quoted it to conclude that if a Muslim leaves Islam, no power in this earthly realm has the right to punish him or her. The verdict shocked Muslims in Egypt and beyond. Cultural conditioning dies hard.
That raises a new question. When Islams beloved messenger is satirised, should Muslims sit there and take it? Our scripture recommends that we cordially walk away from those who ridicule the faith. It also advises that we remain open towards the offenders. Pack up in peace, then pick up the conversation once the dust settles. Granted, this is not Socrates approach to dialogue relentless, remorseless cross-examination but neither does there have to be the unctuous exchange of platitudes that so often passes for interfaith dialogue.
During the Danish firestorm, the Muslims who contacted me demonstrated that we do not think uniformly. Some even challenged me to plaster the cartoons on my own website. After much consideration (as encouraged by the Quran), I posted links to all the caricatures. Among them were sketches depicting Muhammad as a paedophile and as a pig images which had been fabricated by ultra-conservative Danish imams who falsely attributed them to Jyllands-Posten.
Hours after I uploaded the links, several readers emailed me in trepidation. Lise, a woman from Quebec, captured the sense of fear. I am very happy that Canada does not publish these caricatures, she said. We do not need the Islamic reaction. I agree. We do not need the Islamic reaction. We need diverse Islamic reactions: applause, revulsion, dismissal, embarrassment, nonviolent protest and peals of laughter.
The time has come for more of us, Muslim and non-Muslim, to hold the would-be censors to account by demonstrating moral courage. During my book tours, a pattern has emerged: on the campuses of western universities, good-hearted people whisper that they support my mission to reconcile Islam and freedom. Muslims fear community disapproval. Non-Muslims are terrified of being labelled bigots. Meanwhile, the Islam-supremacists who attend my lectures feel they have every right to champion their authoritarian interpretations of the Quran. The loathers of freedom appreciate their own freedom enough to deploy it to stifle the freedom of everyone else.
My call for moral courage is not about confrontation, but conversation. Ed Husain, the former jihadist who co-founded Quilliam, says he became radicalised in part by British societys low expectations of him as a young Muslim. Nobody ever said: youre equal to us, youre one of us, well hold you to the same standards, he explains. Nobody had the courage to stand up for liberal democracy without qualms. When people like us were holding events against women and gay people, where were our college principals and teachers?
Those educators would only have needed to cite chapter 3, verse 7 of the Quran. It states that God and God alone knows the full truth of how the Quran ought to be interpreted. (The genius of this verse soon dawns on those who try refuting it with their seemingly superior knowledge.) Suppose the defenders of liberal democracy took five seconds to scrawl Quran 3:7 on pieces of paper and calmly handed them to the Islamists in their midst? No doubt, any such gesture will be greeted with the cry of Islamophobe! You can set your clock to it. The obvious response to that is: Why does encouraging dialogue make me an Islamophobe? Would I not be keeping my distance out of fear if I were phobic? Conversations start with searching questions.
This brings me to sound one cautionary note. Islamophobia does exist, and it infuriates me that some who wish to wipe Islam off the map actually believe that their agenda helps reformist Muslims. It does not. By defining Islam in the same dogmatic terms as Muslim extremists do, Islamophobes gift those extremists with the authority to decide what Islam must be. In which case, Islam-haters are the allies of Islam-supremacists not of reformists.
For me, embracing freedom is an act of faith. Recognising the Almightys infinite wisdom means acknowledging my limited human wisdom. As a monotheist, I am not God. Nor am I entitled to behave as God. Hence my duty to let a thousand nonviolent flowers bloom. In short, to devote myself to Allah is to love liberty.
Irshad Manji is founder of the Moral Courage Project at New York University. She is the author most recently of Allah, Liberty and Love.
This article first appeared in the print edition of The Spectator magazine, dated 29 March 2014
Tags
Who is online
85 visitors

Nicely written.....If only.....if only, people on both sides of the debate would listen, research and openly consider his words.
I lived in Turkey for a year and never experienced any type of religious intolerance.
I would love to see this fella and Ayaan Hirsi have a sit-down...
Very thoughtful and well written. No one wants to think there are millions of people in the world who want to wipe them off the face of the earth without ever having even said "hello." The question is, how many feel as this writer does?
Irshad Manji is also a lesbian (not that there is anything wrong with that).
Thanks for the correction. And no, I don't think they would agree, but would make for an intersting discussion. It is quite illuminating that she opens here by introducing herself as a reformer rather than an moderate. Imho, it will require true radicals within the religion for there to be any hope at all.
Though laudable, courageous Muslims like Manji who see the need for reform, she is completely marginalized. Her audience basically is non-Muslims who desperately want to believe Islam is truly a religion of peace and one that can co-exist with others in the modern world. Every time she speaks there are Muslims who curse her and spit on her and threats have become part of her life.
No one holds that 1.5 billion or even a large proportion of Muslims are prospective terrorists or their supporters.The driving force behind Islam today is to become more fundamentalist and dogmatic. Reasonable Muslims see dozens of others killed or threatened and are cowed into silence and inaction. History has shown how power can be seized by a tiny minority of ruthless and dedicated ideologues. In 1917 the Bolsheviks who numbered less than 25,000 at the beginning of the year came to dominate a country of over 180 million and ruled by force and terror for over 70 years.
I am afraid the "Clash of Civilizations" foreseen by Professor Samuel Huntington over 20 years ago is going to get far worse before it even begins to get better. Sadly, in much of the Muslim world the inmates are running the asylum.
I feel likeI'mgetting old Robert, I could use a box of reminders everyday.
It's a tight-rope act for sure for her. Even just reading this article it seems that there were things to be expressed, but were not. As an example...
TheDenmarkjournalists did nothing but there job and didn't engineer anything, how was it that the diplomats were invloved to engineer the atrociousmuslims spreeof rioting, violence and murder?the mullahs on the other hand depicted many images that were not included in the original newsprint to encite their followers.That is a very real issue, yet seems to be somewhat glossed over here in this article.
What you say is true. So is Pokermik's statement above...
So while Manji would see herself as a reformer, and probably viewed as a wacko-liberal by her own people, she still doesn't go far enough.
Yes, a degree of surrender.