╌>

Obama unveils plan to change NSA data collection...At first I thought Thank you Edward Snowden! Until I found out this is another Obama lie/misdirection

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  12 years ago  •  9 comments

Obama unveils plan to change NSA data collection...At first I thought Thank you Edward Snowden!  Until I found out this is another Obama lie/misdirection

I thought this was great until I found out they are just shifting the responsibility of who is gathering this data...

One way or another, there's a good chance that the government's bulk collection and storage of telephone metadata will soon end.

How it will end and the specific rules by which government can still access phone data remains to be seen.

The Obama administration and the House of Representatives both have plans to transfer storage of data to private phone companies, but there are differences over the role of judges in approving government retrieval of certain records.

Phone companies and privacy advocates also have questions about the details of a new system involving the work of the National Security Agency.

In unveiling his plan Thursday, President Obama said he has decided that "the government should not collect or hold this data in bulk." He pledged to work with Congress on rules that would accommodate counterterrorism investigations while protecting constitutional liberties.

"I am confident that this approach can provide our intelligence and law enforcement professionals the information they need to keep us safe while addressing the legitimate privacy concerns that have been raised," Obama said in a written statement.

Under the administration's proposal, the government must obtain a judge's approval before accessing phone records, though exceptions could be made in cases of national security emergencies.

"Legislation will be needed to permit the government to obtain this information with the speed and in the manner that will be required to make this approach workable," Obama said.

The House plan would allow government agencies to obtain records from phone companies without prior approval from the special court that oversees the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The court would review the records acquisition later.

Rep. Mike Rogers, R-Mich., chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, said requiring judicial approval for record searches in every case would slow down probes, giving terrorism suspects "greater protections than those given to U.S. citizens in criminal investigations every day in this country."

Overall, however, Rogers said he's glad "the president has moved our direction" on an NSA overhaul.

The general idea of ending government storage of metadata appears to have bipartisan support.

House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, said this week that the Intelligence Committee's bill starts "a bipartisan conversation" about surveillance programs, and he added, "I expect part of this effort will include the end of the government holding onto bulk data."

James R. Clapper, director of national intelligence, said the president's plan with the passage of congressional legislation will ensure that "we have the information we need to meet our intelligence requirements while protecting civil liberties and privacy and being as transparent as possible."

As the administration and Congress debate new NSA rules, Obama has directed the Justice Department to ask the special intelligence court for a 90-day extension of the existing program.

Under both plans, phone companies would in some way be compelled to provide metadata, including incoming and outgoing phone numbers and call times, in a readily usable form.

The phone companies say they will want to study the details of what they will be compelled to do.

Randal Milch, general counsel for Verizon, said phone companies should not be required to do anything more for the government than what "they already do for business purposes." Milch said phone companies respond in a timely way but "should not be required to create, analyze or retain records for reasons other than business purposes."

Among other issues: possible compensation for the phone companies and lawsuit protection for claims made against them over these records.

Civil libertarians, meanwhile, generally criticized the House plan, saying judicial approval should always be required when government reviews phone records.

The Obama plan, they said, does not go far enough and should include restrictions on Internet activity and financial records as well. They say many questions on specifics remain.

Anthony D. Romero, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union, called Obama's plan "a major step" but said "this must be the beginning of surveillance reform, not the end."

Elizabeth Goitein, co-director of the Liberty and National Security Program at the Brennan Center for Justice, said Obama doesn't need to go to Congress "to end a practice that it never should have started."

"The very fact that the president's plan requires legislation means he has something in mind other than simply ending the program," she said.

Trevor Timm, executive director of the Freedom of the Press Foundation, said he supports Obama's emphasis on judicial review of government access to private data, but he said it's important to see the details of what emerges from Congress.

If the Obama plan winds up looking too much like the House Intelligence Committee plan, Timm said, "the NSA may also be handed broad new powers to violate the privacy of Americans while the data sits at the phone companies. "

Obama called for new NSA rules in a January speech , and he gave aides until March 28 Friday to develop legislation to end the NSA's ability to sweep up and store all kinds of telephone records.

NSA surveillance techniques became public last year with leaks from former contractor Edward Snowden. The revelations, including reports that the NSA has spied on foreign leaders, have triggered criticism of Obama.

Tweeting shortly after Obama's audience Thursday with Pope Francis, Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky ., said the president should have told the pontiff: "Forgive me father for I have spied."

Snowden, now living in Russia while facing charges in the U.S., praised Obama's efforts earlier this week.

"This is a turning point, and it marks the beginning of a new effort to reclaim our rights from the NSA and restore the public's seat at the table of government," Snowden said in a statement released by the ACLU, which is helping with his legal representation.

Congressman: Presidents Push To End Data Collection, Will Actually Increase Collection

Just by reading the name, the average American would believe that a new bill being crafted by the Obama administration to end NSA data collection, or a simultaneous effort being pushed through the House Intelligence Committee by Rep. Mike Rogers would lead to the end of data collection on hundreds of millions of Americans. After all, these bills with names like End Bulk Collection Act sound like they will free the American people from NSA spying.

Newspaper, television and internet story headlines read White House plan would end NSAs bulk collection of Americans phone data. Sounds like the NSA spying program is coming to an end.

Not so, says Michigan Congressman Justin Amash who voted against the House version of the End Bulk Collection bill. Amash, a Republican two term Congressman, was a guest on the Ben Swann Radio Show Wednesday. He says the bill sounds like it will lead to the end of data collection but when you get into the details, the bill could actually expand collection.

It actually expands the scope of collection, of unconstitutional collection. It is called the End Bulk Collection Act. It is like we are in some dystopian future where government calls a bill something that has the opposite affect of what title is. says Rep. Amash.

The major point brought up by the Congressman is that despite the name End Bulk Collection, the bill does not to end collection of data, rather it shifts the responsibility of collection from the NSA to private phone companies.

They are going to transfer where the phone data is collected so that it is not stored by the government but it is instead stored by the phone companies. Where it is stored is not really the main problem.

Congressman Amash goes on to say that by correcting who is storing the information does not to resolve the constitutionality of bulk collection of data.

The problem is the unconstitutional search and seizure of peoples information. Even if it is stored about the phone companies, the phone companies are now acting as agents of the government and provide the government even more information than they have today. That doesnt put us in a better position, it puts us in a worse position.

So how is it that the American public has no clue that the End Bulk Collection Act or the Presidents new proposal would actually increase bulk collection? Rep. Amash says you can blame that, in part, on a complacent media.

Last night I saw all these headlines about how the President and the Intelligence Committee were going to end the bulk collection of data as though they are resolving the problem. But the fact is they are not resolving the problem. I would love to hear more about the Presidents plan, maybe there are some good points to it. But overall, when you look at the two proposals either from the President or from the Intelligence Committee, they sound like theyre not moving us in the right direction and they are not doing what the American people want which is to protect their privacy under the 4th amendment.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

This is my biggest problem with Obama, he leads us to believe he is doing what we want when he is relly stabbing us in the back.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

IMHO - Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. I don't believe Obama on this for one damn second.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

The point isn't where they store the information, it's that they are storing it.

EXACTLY! This is just a Obama ploy to deflect the heat they are getting over the NSA.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

I was skeptical, it didn't take long to find the truth. The sad part is I am sure I will see articles praising him for it.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

It is hard to deny his talent for smoothly told lies ...

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

This is true.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

One thing you can count on.. If it comes out of Obamas mouth it is a lie.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

It is the phone companies information, not yours personally. I don't see how any of that info can be assumed to belong to the persons making and receiving the calls/texts unless the company specifically states that it will be deemed as belonging to the parties using the companies.

Hence, I don't see this as a large issue.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

AFTER a court order.

John, there are no court orders for collecting data on all Americans by NSA or they would have to increase the number of courts a hundred thousand times over.

Do you recognize this John?

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

John, this is one of our Bill of Rights as an American citizen. They may have never heard of NSA at that time, but they were aware if they didn't protect the people from the government, then one day the government would rule over the people and they would have no recourse.

Your request for examples of how real live Americans have suffered harm from having their phone numbers and records of their calls collected and stored for possible access after a court order (which there aren't any) may not be obvious to you, but with this activity you are setting a precedence that would allow the NSA or any other government agencies to intrude into the privacy of individual Americans and making the 4th amendment null and void not to mention the 1st amendment.

Not having the ability to understand the short and long term effects of actions in our government has allowed many to be blinded and ignorant of not only what has occurred, but also the future possibilities of such actions.

I Will Stand Up For You If You Stand Up For Me

I Was Silent When They Came for You So There Was No One Left to Help When They Came for Me

First they tortured a U.S. citizen and gang member
I remained silent;
I wasnt a criminal

Then they tortured a U.S. citizen, whistleblower and navy veteran
I remained silent;
I wasnt a whistleblower

Then they locked up an attorney for representing accused criminals
I remained silent;
I wasnt a defense attorney

Then they arrested a young father walking with his son simply because he told...
I remained silent;
Ive never talked to an important politician

Then they said an entertainer should be killed because she questioned the government...
I remained silent;
I wasnt an entertainer

Then they arrested people for demanding that Congress hold the President to t...
I did not speak out;
Ive never protested in Washington

Then they arrested a man for holding a sign
I held my tongue;
Ive never held that kind of sign

Then they broke a ministers leg because he wanted to speak at a public event
I said nothing;
I wasnt a religious leader

Then they shot a student with a taser gun and arrested him for asking a question of a politician at a public event
I remained silent;
I wasnt a student

Then they started labeling virtually every innocent and normal behavior as marking Am...
I remained silent;
I didnt want to be called a terrorist

Then they threw political dissenters in psychiatric wards
I remained silent;
I didnt want to be seen as crazy

Then they declared that they could label U.S. citizens living on U.S. soil as unlawful enemy combatan... without access to any attorney
I remained silent;
I didnt want to be labeled an enemy

Then they declared that they could assassinate U.S. citizens living on U.S. soil without any due proce...
I remained silent;
I didnt want to be on the list

When they came for me,
Everyone was silent;
there was no one left to speak out.

Link

 
 

Who is online



85 visitors