╌>

OPINION: It’s always ‘Groundhog Day’ with the Israeli-Palestinian ‘peace process’

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  12 years ago  •  9 comments

OPINION: It’s always ‘Groundhog Day’ with the Israeli-Palestinian ‘peace process’

OPINION: Its always Groundhog Day with the Israeli-Palestinian peace process

By Nicole Brackman and Asaf Romrowsky, Washington Examiner, March 19, 2014

4647_discussions.jpg

The 1993 movie Groundhog Day, in which the character played by Bill Murray relives the same day over and over again, is an apt description of official Palestinian attitudes toward Israel and the peace process.

The repeated Palestinian rejection of Israeli overtures raises the stakes and draws ever more attention to seducing the Palestinians to participate in talks. The peace process movie plays like a repeating loop, with new scenes punctuated by years and shifts in the political winds but without progress. The fatigue associated with this demand for peace circumvents any historical knowledge of the Middle East.

Moreover, with the ongoing suffering in Syria, one has to wonder where the need for attention is greater; and why the constant focus is solely on the Israeli-Palestinian dynamic, ignoring the real tragedies in the region.

As Secretary of State John Kerry prepares for yet another round of negotiations between the Palestinians and Israelis, demands that Israel submit to various concessions just to bring the Palestinians to the table are again emerging. Reports from February reveal a new (old) request that puts the onus on Israel to "prove" seriousness of intent: The Obama administration has asked Israel to impose an unofficial settlement freeze ... if a framework agreement is agreed upon. Though the Israelis have not yet responded, the pattern is true to form; a report from Feb. 16 highlighted a suspected "softening" in Mahmoud Abbas' position on the Palestinian refugees.

The "softening" was not flexibility at all, as was claimed. Rather it was a restatement of a commitment the Palestinians ostensibly made long ago but recanted -- that Abbas does not want to "drown Israel with millions of Palestinian refugees to change its nature in the case of a peace settlement. What's ironic about all this isn't just the obvious resemblance to Groundhog Day -- it's the utter disconnect between expectations and reality.

The illusion that the Palestinians have fostered in their national narrative (in which millions of refugees in their descendants return and create a new state) is as destructive to their own national aspirations as it is unworkable. Attachment to the right of return is an escape clause from any serious negotiations with the Israelis because both sides recognize it as a nonstarter with untenable political consequences for each of the respective populations.

Click this link to read the rest of the article:

http://washingtonexaminer.com/its-always-groundhog-day-with-the-israeli-palestinian-peace-process/article/2545935?recipient_id=14mcWCVNaKzrmQcLeFGH3lU0x7l-Zwgye-


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Same old, same old, same old, same old......

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

And the wheel goes round and round.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

I cannot help but think that neither the Palestinians nor the Israelis would be engaging in this charade if it weren't for continual international interference in the 'Meddle East'. Neither side appears seriously motivated to do anything except keep playing all factions against one another-- and keep collectingarms, economic & political support, etc etc etc. The inhabitants of that area of the planet have been fighting amongst themselves since before the birth of Christ, and are probably willing to keep on doing it until he comes around again. It's less like 'Groundhog Day' than it is 'three-card monte' or the classic shell game--- keep shifting things around and around and ask "Which shell is the peace accord under", while the suckers keep placing bets...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

It's not going to end. Israel is going to give up making concessions, releasing murderers, giving up land, always doing the giving when the Palestinians do fuck all to further peace negotiations. In fact it's a totally useless exercise to try to make peace when the Palestinians won't give up their goal of getting rid of the Jews and taking over all between the river and the sea, the north and the south:

"Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal on Saturday reiterated his movements refusal to give up one inch of the land of Palestine.
Mashaal, who arrived in the Gaza Strip for the first time ever on Friday, said: Palestine from the river to the sea, from the north to the south, is our land and we will never give up one inch or any part of it.

www.jpost.com/.../Mashaal-vows-Hamas-will-not-concede-land

Besides the fact that even if the Palestinians ever sign an agreement, they'll break it anyway:

"Every country's Foreign Ministry with well-educated bureaucrats would know that making an agreement with an Islamic-driven nation is like using disappearing ink. The leaders of the 22 Arab and/or the total 57 Islamic countries make agreements with impunity, knowing they can and will break them at any time convenient or necessary to them.
In fact, according to Islamic law, they must break said agreements made with 'infidels' (non-Muslims) within 10 years ...according to the Hudaibiya Treaty Mohammed made in the 7th Century with the richest of the Jewish tribes, the Banu Quraizah (allies of the Quraish Tribe).
He made that treaty while he was militarily weak so he could worship at Mecca. But, in two years he returned with a strong army, broke the 10 year treaty, brutally murdered and decapitated all the men, captured and enslaved the women and children of the Banu Quraizah Tribe. (1)
The very day Yassir Arafat signed the Oslo Accords he told his Arab audience in Arabic that the Oslo Accord was like the Hudaibiya Treaty. He would break it as soon as he was stronger. And, of course, he did as often as he could."

So why bother? Just let it remain at the status quo. Groundhog day, over and over and over and over again.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

I'll wholeheartedly second that!

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

here is the provided YouTube transcript Buzz (sorta accurate)...

0:10
yeah the awesome be what I think about
0:13
Damien Sandow situation now I have no
0:15
doubts and I don't disagree that the Palestinians are suffering
0:19
but what is the cause of their suffering it's not the site it is Hamas
0:24
if Hamas to model said we accept the existence of the State of Israel
0:28
we well not lauch terrorist attacks again the same
0:31
and we accept our previous agreements and commitments
0:35
suffering of others the palestinians will stop
0:38
soho to blame here I'm not that they are not suffering everyone knows that they
0:43
are suffering
0:44
but what's the cause of the suffering is it is really have what million israeli
0:48
arabs living in israel was the chills
0:50
and they are not suffering like the the Absolado actually controlled by
0:54
adapts so now you can with a situation where do you come to deny that is
0:58
suffering
0:59
but to be honest you have to say that the suffering of the Palestinians
1:03
is because of their leadership and the wrong decisions all but leaders like
1:07
Hamas
1:08
not because if Israel the moment property and leadership stops
1:13
its its its at Agence and it's a barbaric act itchy or two of the chills
1:18
okay then things would change and you will see no palestinian would be
1:23
suffering
1:24
that so I think the solution is in the handle the palestinians
1:27
now they have to take the decision to stop the suffering the that on people
1:32
by giving a hand full of peace to the israelis
1:36
you remember president sadat but isn't that want to try a night back
1:40
he give hand for of peace and love to the israelis
1:43
and he got right not back but the Palestinians
1:47
didn't do this hamas just want to kill every jew they promote this
1:51
I'm asking them to stop this and give a handful of peace to the israelis
1:57
and try it for once and be sincere about the
2:00
and they will see the results I have been to Israel twice
2:04
and I'm telling you that she was the not paid the adducts
2:07
Heath us we are causing the problem and we have to change
2:11
thank you
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Thanks for the transcript Larry. The point made by it is that it is the leaders who are unnecessarily continuing the animosity at the expense of the rank and file who would rather enjoy the lifestyle of the Arabs who live in Israel. Perhaps one day they will have their "Spring" and overthrow those who keep them suffering.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

...the leaders who are unnecessarily continuing the animosity at the expense of the rank and file who would rather enjoy the lifestyle of the Arabs who live in Israel. Perhaps one day they will have their "Spring" and overthrow those who keep them suffering.

Funny how the A.S. never seemed to have reached the oh-so-very-donwntrodden. Who woulda thoughthaving a terrorist organization for a government was such a bad idea.

Go figure.

 
 

Who is online




106 visitors