╌>

Anatomy of a Hillary Clinton pseudo-scandal: How Republicans and their media lackeys are trying to manufacture her downfall

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  lets-get-lost  •  11 years ago  •  30 comments

Anatomy of a Hillary Clinton pseudo-scandal: How Republicans and their media lackeys are trying to manufacture her downfall

Anatomy of a Hillary Clinton pseudo-scandal: How Republicans and their media lackeys are trying to manufacture her downfall

HEATHER DIGBY PARTON

http://www.salon.com/2015/08/24/anatomy_of_a_hillary_clinton_pseudo_scandal_how_republicans_and_their_media_lackeys_are_trying_to_manufacture_her_downfall/

Many years ago when political blogging was in its infancy, I coined the phrase Cokies Law, which referred to a specific comment by pundit Cokie Roberts about the Lewinsky scandal thatillustrated the precise way the beltway media excused their propensity for cheap gossip and scandalmongering. In discussing whether or not Hillary Clinton had actually blamed her husbands childhood for his philandering, Roberts said:

At this point it doesnt much matter whether she said it or not because its become part of the culture. I was at the beauty parlor yesterday and this was all anyone was talking about.

Cokies Law is the axiom that says the press can pass judgement about anything once its out there regardless of whether or not whats out there is true. This allows them to skip doing boring rebuttals of the facts at hand and instead hold forth at length about how it bears on the subjects judgement and the appearance of wrongdoing without ever proving that what they did was wrong.

You see, if the person being discussed were competent, it wouldnt be out there in the first place, so even if it is based upon entirely specious speculation, its his or her own fault for inspiring people to speculate so speciously. It all goes back to their character, which nobody is more equipped to analyze and dissect than celebrity political reporters and pundits.

And even if the charges are patently false, they are always far too complicated to rebut in detail; and, anyway, the other side says something different (aka he said/she said ), so w hos really to say whats true and what isnt? Itsstillthe responsibility of the target of those charges because he or she shouldnt have allowed him or herself to be in a position where someone could make false charges in the first place.

This is where we are with Clintons email pseudo-scandal from yesterday mornings Meet the Press :

CHUCK TODD: Let me bring in the panel. Jon Ralston, the lawyerly answer there from Howard Dean [who said that in Clintons public responses to the email controversy she sounded too much like a lawyer]. I thought was an interesting way Every defense theyve sounded off, thats what it sounds like. A lawyer, not a political consultant.

JON RALSTON: I guess what I thought from the beginning on that, I thought that was terrible for her that Governor Dean said that. But Chuck, it depends on what the definition of classified is, I think is what people out there in real America are thinking. Even if it wasnt classified, why did she have to do this? Was there sensitive information on there? Why did she have that on an insecure server? This is not, as Governor Dean said, a purely media-manufactured story. Sure, the medias been all over it. But its her handling of it. You know, someone shouldve given her this advice before that appearance in, by the way, Nevada, where shes at Heres the first thing you shouldnt do Hillary, joke about it. Dont joke about it, because people, even if they dont understand all the nuances, they know its serious. So dont say, Wipe it with a cloth, because you know in this world now, its going to go viral right away, which of course it did.

CHUCK TODD: Amy is there a competency thing about this? You know, I had somebody email me and they go, You know what, I dont think its a big deal, but jeez, if she cant handle this mess, what does it say about her managerial expertise as president?

AMY WALTER: Well, it goes to the heart of what her campaign message is, is Im one of you, and Im going to fight for you. But the reality is, and this is where the campaign still has its biggest problem, is explaining why on earth she set up a separate server in the first place. Normal people dont do that. Normal people who work in the government know what they have to do. So that just distances her even more, and it sets up this sense that she is

CHUCK TODD: Special. Elite.

AMY WALTER: shes special, shes elite, shes

CHUCK TODD: Doesnt play by the rules.

AMY WALTER: And that to me is the bigger problem here.

As for the elite, special charge, thats just cheap armchair psychoanalysis of both Clinton and the electorate. Its not political analysis; its beltway parlor games, and its not really worth discussing. Both Job Ralston and Amy Walter are excellent reporters and analysts but theres something about Clinton that turns all of them in to Cokie Roberts on the Sunday shows.

But lets dispense with the rest of this right now, because its not hard to do. First of all, the issue does depend on what the definition of classified is. If thats what the American people are thinking, then bravo, because the fact is that none of the emails that have been flagged were classified when she handled them. Various departments are looking at them now and reportedly deciding that maybe they should have been. Thats really it, as far as the classified documents issue is concerned, and the press shouldnt be dismissive of that fact.

As for whether she should have had a separate email server, well she did and thats that. Theyll be arguing about whether that was a good decision forever, but it no more speaks to her competence than it speaks to the competence of Colin Powell, who also used a personal email for his official correspondence and deleted all of them when he left. Or Jeb Bush, for that matter, who also had a personal server. It was obviously considered an innocuous procedure at the time, but if Clinton had been clairvoyant, as they apparently believe she should have been, she would have seen into the future, known that congressional Republicans would hold nine separate investigations intoa bogus scandal called Benghazi, and would have seen that they would throw everything at the wall and the one thing that would stick was her use of a private email server. Its fair to assume that, had she known all that, she would have done something differently to avoid the appearance of wrongdoing.

But whats important to note in all this that nothing that happened on that email server appears to have been corrupt, unethical, illegal or dangerous. Its all smoke, no fire. And thats the point. The smoke obscures the truth and makes everything vague and formless, leaving only an impression of being under siege.

One of the major effects of the patented Clinton Scandal thats become a fixture of political conversation over the past two decades is the helplessness in engenders in Democrats who feel like they are swimming in quicksand trying to make sense of the whole thing. They know its not a real scandal, and yet the press is blatantly aroused by the opportunity to speculate wildly about what it all means while the Republicans smugly repeat their talking points with robotic military precision. But again, thats the point. Its even got a name: Clinton Fatigue, which Charles Krauthammer, among others, declared was already in full effect many months ago :

Hillary Clinton is running on two things: gender and name. Gender is not to be underestimated. It will make her the Democratic nominee. The name is equally valuable. It evokes the warm memory of the golden 1990s, a decade of peace and prosperity during our holiday from history.

Now breaking through, however, is a stark reminder of the underside of that Clinton decade: the chicanery, the sleaze, the dodging, the parsing, the wordplay. Its a dual legacy that Hillary Clinton cannot escape and that will be a permanent drag on her candidacy.

You can feel it. Its a recurrence of an old ailment. It was bound to set in, but not this soon. What youre feeling now is Early Onset Clinton Fatigue. The CDC is recommending elaborate precautions. Forget it. The only known cure is Elizabeth Warren.

You know that Charles Krauthammer only has the best interests of the Democratic party at heart, right? You can almost hear him laughing maniacally as he wrote that.

I know many Democrats, would have loved to see Elizabeth Warren run, and many women, including yours truly, especially would have been thrilled to see two such formidable women leaders go head to head on the campaign trail. And Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden are welcome to join in too, as is any other Democrats who wants to try his or her hand. This is democracy and nobodys automatically entitled to be president.

But there are millions of Democrats who also really dont like the idea that Republicans are manipulating the system to choose their own rival and neither do they care for the media deciding who should be running on a Democratic ticket. And thats very much whats going on here. The Benghazi investigations are a joke, but they are providing the GOP with a excuseto go nosing around in Clintons business in a way that gives them access to information they can dribble out over time to create the atmosphere I describe. The political press is, as usual, helping to do their dirty work for them. They are Ahabs obsessively chasing their white whale with visions of pulitzers dancing in their heads.

The pundits all assumed that President Clinton would have to resign in 1998, but they underestimated the people they were dealing with. Im not talking about the Clintons. Im talking about the American people who, unlike the beltway elites who get nervous at the sound of a loud noise, tend to respond to this political gambit with a stubborn insistence that they should be the ones to make these judgements and choose their own leaders.

Democratic primary voters may very well decide they dont want Clinton as the nominee for president. But its highly doubtful they want a bunch of beltway elites and Republicans telling them they cant have her. Indeed, unlike the establishment, it tends to energize them to do the opposite. Just ask Newt Gingrich who lost his Speakership when he bet the House in 1998 on Clinton being vanquished by Ken Starr.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Cokies Law is the axiom that says the press can pass judgement about anything once its out there regardless of whether or not whats out there is true. This allows them to skip doing boring rebuttals of the facts at hand and instead hold forth at length about how it bears on the subjects judgement and the appearance of wrongdoing without ever proving that what they did was wrong.

You see, if the person being discussed were competent, it wouldnt be out there in the first place, so even if it is based upon entirely specious speculation, its his or her own fault for inspiring people to speculate so speciously. It all goes back to their character, which nobody is more equipped to analyze and dissect than celebrity political reporters and pundits.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

the issuedoesdepend on what the definition of classified is. If thats what the American people are thinking, then bravo, because the fact is that none of the emails that have been flagged were classified when she handled them. Various departments are looking at them now and reportedly deciding that maybe they should have been. Thats really it, as far as the classified documents issue is concerned, and the press shouldnt be dismissive of that fact.

As for whether she should have had a separate email server, well she did and thats that. Theyll be arguing about whether that was a good decision forever, but it no more speaks to her competence than it speaks to the competence of Colin Powell, who also used a personal email for his official correspondence and deleted all of them when he left.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

if Clinton had been clairvoyant, as they apparently believe she should have been, she would have seen into the future, known that congressional Republicans would hold nine separate investigations intoa bogus scandal called Benghazi, and would have seen that they would throw everything at the wall and the one thing that would stick was her use of a private email server. Its fair to assume that, had she known all that, she would have done something differently to avoid the appearance of wrongdoing.

But whats important to note in all this that nothing that happened on that email server appears to have been corrupt, unethical, illegal or dangerous. Its all smoke, no fire. And thats the point. The smoke obscures the truth and makes everything vague and formless, leaving only an impression of being under siege.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

I think she did it to herself but at any rate it's working. She's dropping faster than the stock market. The Democrats are in panic mode and are trying to dust off two-time loser Biden as plan B.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

18DARCY-HILLARY.jpg

In an Iowa campaign speech, Hillary Clinton joked about her email controversy and dismissed it as "the same old partisan games."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

I wouldn't expect you to discuss the facts of the matter. In hundreds of comments about various issues, you rarely do.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

It is, of course, a smear campaign by the right wing. Still, as my wife says, a large number of Americans are stupid and will think that something must have happened or why else is all of this talk about it.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

BTW, there has been no one presented by the GOP so far that Biden couldn't beat. In fact they have produced no one that my dog Sally couldn't beat. If I were not an atheist, I would be praying that the GOP is so fucking stupid as to run Donald Trump. Or that he runs as an independent, which, his "huge" ego will demand when realizes that GOP is going to be "dis-respective" to him by not nominating him.

There are far, far, far bigger problems and worries in the GOP then there are with Hilliary and Biden in the Democratic Party.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

Hurts, doesn't it.

When the media smears a Republican candidate, you find full justification in it, and yet, when your precious Hillary takes a shot, it's soooo not fair.

This is the game. If you don't like it, you shouldn't play.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Hilliary is not precious to me (in fact I was not a supporter of her's in 2008) but a Democrat in the White House for 8 more years is. If it's Biden instead, that's fine with me. I strongly doubt it'll be one of the clowns in the clown car on the GOP side and still have no doubt that even if the nominee is Clinton, she'll still win. So no, it doesn't hurt even a little.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

She decided to break governmental rules and the law (she fired a state employee for using private email to conduct work) to set up a private server solely to avoid congressional oversight and complying with FOIA requests. She gets caught with TOP SECRECT information on her poorly secured private server and yet she knows that no matter how many laws she broke her minions will mindlessly repeat her claims of a conspiracy.

She's terrible at governing but you have to give her credit. She knows how to manipulate ignorant democrats who will mindlessly parrot her talking points come hell or high water. She could be caught on tape discussing with Bin Laden the 9/11 attacks and her slavishly devoted followers will make the same tired claims of "conspiracy! witch hunt! and what does it matter if a few laws were broken and a few thousand people were killed."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

She could be caught on tape discussing with Bin Laden the 9/11 attacks and her slavishly devoted followers will make the same tired claims of "conspiracy! witch hunt! and what does it matter if a few laws were broken and a few thousand people were killed."

We have listened to a couple of months of this shit now with no end in sight. Every few days some new "bombshell" is trotted out that turns out to be a nothingburger. This is an obvious smear campaign.

If Hillary Clinton's e-mail set up bothers you so much, don't vote for her. She broke no laws or rules of the state dept. ( the state dept. spokesman reiterated again today that Hilary broke no state dept rules that were in effect), and it is a politicalharassmentcampaign, just as the seeded article lays out.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

She broke no laws or rules of the state dept. ( the state dept. spokesman reiterated again that Hilary broke no state dept rules that were in effect)

Of course she broke the law by having classified information on a private server. Of course she did. That's not even debatable. It doesn't matter if "no one was hurt." Ask Petreus.

What's more, even if her emails contained no classified information, by exclusively using a private server to conduct public business, she violated this regulation on maintaining federal records:

...

12.pdf

She also flagrantly violated State Department policy:

The State Department Manuel in effect since 2005 said said information that is "sensitive but unclassified" -- a broad category that covers anything from meeting schedules, to visa applications, to ordinary emails to other federal agencies -- should be emailed through servers authorized by the department.

The regulations are clear. She violated them, no matter how a spokesman spins. If, as her minion at state claims, she didn't break state policy, why did she fire someone for using a private email?

Ultimately, who are you going to believe her flunky at State or Federal Judge Emmet G. Sullivan of Federal District Court for the District of Columbia, who said that we wouldnt be here today if the employee had followed government policy,"concerningState's failure tofollow FOIA rules

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

If she is the candidate I hope they will.

Are you a liberal or a liberaltarian ?

I guess you can vote for the Green Party. Maybe they can crack 5% this cycle.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

This liberal will vote for the Democrat, because having any republican that is running now, in the White House, is far worse.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Yes, they will vote for her. You're talking about the same people that reelected Jesse Jackson Jr. knowing he was as crooked as they come and elected Jerry Springer mayor of Cincinnati.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I didn't vote for either of those people? In fact I've never even been to Cincinnati. Lumping all liberals together as a group is the height of stupidity, as we are far, far, far more diverse and different from each other then any other group in modern American politics.

The Right on the other hand can be easily divided. Those who love Donald Trump. Those who hate him and those who are terrified he might actually get nominated (and that terror is spread even among those who say they love him).

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Having the Obama SD say she broke no laws is as laughable as it it false.
 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

But your fellow liberals did and Hillary's worse than those two.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Sean, your attempt to nitpick this matter for purely political reasons is transparent, pathetic and pitiable.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

See the rest of my comment above. We do get 15 minutes to add to or subtract from or otherwise edit our posted comments. You know that? Right?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Forgetting all the violations of national security law, it's amusing to watch power worshiping liberals support someone who fired an employee for doing the exact same thing she did. And then watch them pose as the champion of the common man.

It's Machine politics at his finest, no rules for the bosses, jail for the little people.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Next you will tell us with outrage that she used cuss words in the e-mails. the horror !!! lol.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Is there any law you wouldn't excuse Clinton violating?
 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

If she's broken any laws she will be prosecuted. That would happen fairly soon I'd think.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Lumping all liberals together as a group is the height of stupidity, as we are far, far, far more diverse and different from each other then any other group in modern American politics.

It is inaccurate now that Hillary has laid a goosegg . But B4 that they were like peas from the same pod .

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Anyone that can manufacture her downfall deserves a round of applause. Karma baby.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

OJ Simpson has already proven if you have enough money you can get away with murder.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

It's a little early to be counting chickens.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Yet the Right-Wing already has her convicted and on her way to prison, when they have yet to prove she has broken an laws. If they had any real evidence she would have been indicted by now. She hasn't. Lets just wait until the FBI investigation is concluded before we start forming a lynch mob based on speculation.

 
 

Who is online






60 visitors