Kansas, Arizona win proof-of-citizenship requirement in voting suit
"....A federal judge has ruled that Kansas and Arizona should be allowed to require voters to provide evidence of U.S. citizenship, in a case closely watched by both sides dealing with the question of voter eligibility.
U.S. District Judge Eric Melgren in Wichita, Kan., ruled that the U.S. Election Assistance Commission had no legal authority to deny requests from the two states to add the citizenship requirement. In the ruling, released Wednesday, he ordered the commission to revise the national form immediately...."
http://www.latimes.com/nation/nationnow/la-na-nn-kansas-arizona-citizenship-voting-20140319,0,4652908.story#ixzz2wS76qIof
Tags
Who is online
90 visitors

This is a huge victory for the states of Kansas and Arizona, Kobach said in a prepared statement emailed to reporters. They have successfully protected our sovereign right to set and enforce the qualifications for registering to vote. We have now paved the way for all 50 states to protect their voter rolls and ensure that only U.S. citizens can vote.
Todays decision is an important victory for the people of Arizona against the Obama administration, assuring that only Arizona residents and not illegals vote in Arizona elections, Arizona Atty. Gen. Tom Horne said in a statement.
They won't cut the grass or trim the hedges.
That's what I thought when I first read the report.
The argument that this ruling might deter some from voting is a non-issue, imo. If voting is important, they will find a way. What should be more important is that those that are voting are entitled to do so.
Unless every voter is checked at every polling place, racial profiling will be the result
Which is exactly what's behind this.
But I'll listen to reason. Someone tell me
Will there be a streamlined, seamless, cost-free (poll-tax free) process for obtaining the required "proof" including convenient, numerous, easily accessed locations to obtain this "proof"? (I've been a citizen of the United States for nearly 70 years and I don't have any citizenship proof per se.) Do any of you?
Who will be specifically required to show proof at the polling places, by whom will they be checked?
Who will NOT be required to show proof at polling places, why not, and who will make those determinations?
Will anyone/everyone who in fact, is a citizen, but, who is nevertheless denied the right to vote based on a "failure to show proof of citizenship," have the right to appeal in a timely fashion, and, upon winning his appeal, be subsequently permitted to cast a ballot that will be counted?
NOTE:
My questions are clear and unambiguous; please do not declare that "the questions ought to be x, y, or z" instead," then bitch that I won't answer the so-called "correct" questions.
Mac, everyone knows what the answers are.
The bottom line is, everyone is required to shown proof, or no one.
Precisely the point.
14th Amendment of the Constitution contains
Further
AMac, why would we query that 'not' everyone would be expected to show proof? I had no reason to be suspicious.
It's mail-in here, maybe they verify citizenship by computer?
I agree with Kavika, in that, in order to avoid the real danger of discrimination everyone should show proof of citizenship!If everyone knew in advance that it was to be required then the charge of profiling is avoided.Would a state issued Birth Certificate suffice as proof? When and where I was born meant that records of the sort just did not happen.
You did not answer my questions you questioned why I would ask such questions.
You are "begging the question" (by definition).
I didn't say anything close to that and your sarcasm dodges the questions.
One part of your comment may however be accurate, namely
So let me help you to know.
No one is arguing that non-citizens should have the right to vote; the issue is whether or not the verification process will be honest, fair and evenly executed.
True, because I thought their statement was self-explanatory. The question I was asking was implicative of 'why you would assume 'not' everyone would be verified?
It could be analagous of going to your favorite ice-cream shop (if you have one) and assuming that they might not allow everyone every flavor or even patronage.. Why would they be prejudice ? As long as one is a paying customer, they should be allowed any flavor they want, yes? I would have no reason to consider that everyone wouldn't be treated fairly. The store owner 'might' hate a certain group of people and not want to serve them based solely on hate, but I don't think that would hold up in court.
What an exaggerated description . Racial profiling is the term used for serious breaches of law . This is no more than a minor inconvenience ...
Just answer the questions.
That is not yet determined which is exactly why I asked the questions.
You too beg the question(s).
But do tell; if it's "no more than a minor inconvenience" you can prove that by posting the process details as your very next comment.
"required documents" ---there are so many records a citizen acquires over their lifetime, that there has to be something.
I would think those negatives cited in you quote are just as destructive as a state wanting to manipulate the white vote - if they could; they would both be wrong. Fair and legal would be to show proof of eligibility, imo. Just because we were non-sensical in interpreting laws in the past, doesn't mean we can't start making sense now.
Logic tells me that they are assuming any 'citizen' person. Perhaps in 1868 it wasn't usual to have an illegal status, such that it wouldn't have been a necessary inclusion of verbiage.
Why don't describe where the line is between "racial profiling" and "a minor inconvenience" ? There is a difference ... right ?
You did exactly what you always do; avoid answering questions by asking other questions.
I will ignore you until you answer my questions and post the details of the "proofing" processes.
Starting now.
It is pointless to answer your question until you explain where the dividing line is . OTW you'll just move the goal posts . Its what you "always do" ...
Bye!
In time you'll discourage all those from coming to these discussions except for those who see things your way.
Have it your way.
That's 'assumption' for motivation of ' your assumption' that Az. Officials are trying to sabotage Latinos over becoming a majority. ---That is why I asked you for the reasoning you were using in making your assumptions. Your hypothesis could very well be true, but regardless of prejudice, they don't stand a chance of preventing a Latino citizen from participating as any other Az. citizen does in a state or Federal election. Showing proof is a good idea when a state or country has an illegal problem.
AMac, I don't see a "your way" or my way or our way. I see a right way (that could fall under the headings of moral and/or legal).
This is a huge victory for the states of Kansas and Arizona, - Famous last words. Wisconsin has had it's voter ID law shot down twice by a federal judge and it's a cinch that this case will go to a higher court and Wisconsin's is.
In a constitutional republic, it is an inherent quality that liberty and freedom be expanded, whenever possible. However, if such expanded freedoms have a cause to infringe upon the established rights of others, which would include a " chilling effect ", that law should be challenged in court.
This is not a case where there is a preponderance of evidence (as amac brought up) suggesting that voter fraud is an issue, rather, it is a not too subtle hint that those of difference races and cultures will be subjected to unwarranted scrutiny which in my estimation, violates the "Equal Protection Clause" of the Constitution. The effect would be less minorities voting.
For those of you who support this temporary victory, savor it while you can because it's gonna change.
True Ap, I remember a lot of the Wisconsin 'stuff.'
The ruling stands until appealed, anyway.
Just to note - There might not be a lot of 'proof' re voter fraud, bit I can see how easy it would be judging by how my district ran things. Before mail-in they had big print-outs with all of the residents names and addresses and just checked people off as they voted. That's silly. Anyone could be illegally living/renting here. So as long as the listed name and address was confirmed, they were clear to vote.
I don't have a political motivation for saying that; just using common sense. I understand the downside for Democrat objectives getting the poor and minority votes - I just think security is important in who is actually voting, and I would think everyone should desire that. A statement from elsewhere that I agree with:
"Defenders of voter identification laws argue that fraud is hard to detect but still a real danger and that Americans uncomplainingly present identification for getting on airplanes and numerous other things, so asking the same for voting, a basic right of democracy, is only appropriate. "
There is also this statement: "Congress holds full power over federal election rules, but indicated that states could require proof of citizenship in state and local elections."
And this: "Judge Eric F. Melgren of United States District Court in Wichita ruled that the federal Election Assistance Commission had no legal authority to deny requests from Kansas and Arizona to add state-specific instructions to a national voter registration form. The states sued the agency to force the action after it had turned them down. "
Chloe,
My point is that what one federal judge says in their ruling, does not equal a constitutional absolute. In this, and many other cases, a ruling can be petitioned to an appellate court, which in this case would be the Ninth Circuit, then, if necessary, SCOTUS.
In any or all of these cases, "common sense" is often times discarded in lieu of "jurisprudence"....which almost sounds like an oxymoron...a sad one. However, there are other variables involved.
Consider this;
"I'm troubled by having to pay the state to vote," she said during three hours of arguments.
This whole idea of a voter ID, however trivial it is to me, (I have no problem with it) has been festering in the legal system for almost a decade. It's about time a case gets presented to a higher court.
Aeon - point of clarification - Kansas and Arizona are covered by the 10th Circuit, not the 9th. At least, if appealed, the hearing with be a lot more fair.
Gotta agree with A Mac on this one
Everyone must show ID or no one must show it
The acceptable forms of ID must be made known well ahead of the election to citizens and citizens must have reasonable, no cost access to get an acceptable form of ID prior to the election.
Once the acceptable forms of ID are known to the public and opportunity to get the ID is given to the citizens there is really no reason that anyone should show up to vote without an appropriate ID
That is not the issue here; no one is contending that non-citizens should be allowed to vote!
The issue here is in regard to how the law will be implemented. Laws that are enforced inconsistently and arbitrarily are laws that are abused.
Until someone answers my questions, no one can definitively state that racial profiling is not only a possibility, rather, it's probable. I doubt that any fair skinned Caucasian or Caucasian-looking individual will be asked to prove citizenship at the polls.
Will everyone in these states showing up at a polling place be required to present proof of citizenship before voting? Will there be random checks? Will there be lists of names that poll officials will use as a data base of the "approved"? Will these states arbitrarily drop names from such lists like Rick Scott and Jeb Bush did in Florida?
BF second time in a week you have mocked me. If you can't answer the tough questions, don't bother commenting to me.
The Judge should be troubled by that; it's a poll tax.
The issue here is in regard to how the law will be implemented. Laws that are enforced inconsistently and arbitrarily are laws that are abused.
For whatever it is worth here Mac, IMO, the laws will not be implemented consistently by all of the states and profilingwill becomea matter of fact. Like it or not the Attorneys General from various states will interpret the law to suit their own agendas which does in fact favor profiling.
I stand corrected.
Mac, making it difficult for Indians to vote is still going on in some states. Montana and South Dakota being the two that are engaged in the practice. Both have cases in court now.
Without providing free ID, it is a poll tax.
No one has a Constitutional right to get on an airplane! That's a logical fallacy argument.
Further
In 5-Year Effort, Scant Evidence of Voter Fraud
And
After Signing Law Disenfranchising ID-less Voters, Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker Closes 10 DMV Offices
By Ian Millhiser
on July 25, 2011 at 9:50 am
Walker closed DMV offices in districts that voted primarily for Democrats making it almost impossible for people in those districts to get the ID's BUT DID NOT CLOSE DMV OFFICES IN REPUBLICAN DISTRICTS!
Well there are certainly some logistics to getting this done, but it certainly needs to be done. I am asked for ID at my precinct every time I vote and I don't have a problem with it.
Completely agree with your comment Tsula.
Too simple, the libs would never go for it.
Show a drivers license or SS card, or voters registration card what's the big deal? I get asked for one of the three every time I vote at my precinct.
I don't either as long as EVERYONE MUST SHOW ID AND ALL ACCEPTABLE FORMS OF ID ARE EASILY ATTAINABLE AND AT NO COST.
The "big deal" is when states require a particular type of ID then make it intentionally difficult for certain demographics to obtain that ID. I've posted specific examples of such "big deals".
Not everyone has either a military ID or a driver's license and the point is that states are intentionally make ID requirements anything but simple -- the opposite actually in some states.
Would you care to have an actual discussion sometime in the near future or do the quip-mockery thing that has killed membership on other sites?
Smurf comment today, Unicorns and Rainbows regarding my information about attempts to "wear down" liberal members on the original Newstalkers, that via a conspiracy hatched on another site. My information was verified by Bruce.
Is the process for obtaining the voter registration card made difficult by legislative action or, can any legitimate claimant easily attain one cost free?
When someone posts information that either cannot be refuted with specifics and/or is validated, to mock, quip, insult and not subsequently not recant when it's clear that the mockery was inappropriate MAKES MEMBERS LEAVE THE FRONT PAGE AND HURTS THE SITE!
The recent legislations are neither ordinary nor easy -- tortuous by design.
And only an insensitive, ill-informed a-hole would cite Selma, Alabama and simultaneously minimize the insidious legislative processes intended to roll back what some died for in Selma and elsewhere.
That's a low blow even from you, Robert G.
Not how it works in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and other states, in some cases, already knocked down by courts. And requiring anything with a cost amounts to a poll tax.
And now you piss on the act of Rosa Parks whose sitting in the front of the bus WAS INTENDED AS A DEFIANT ACT AGAINST RACIAL DISCRIMINATION -- acts like voter suppression laws disguised as "voter ID laws."
Equal Protection clause Constitutionally mandates that no special classes can be established by states.
First off, I agree with others who say that it must be applied evenly to avoid discrimination. It's the only way.
What I find completely ridiculous is the fact that there would be people in this country without a form of ID. It's 2014 not 1974. You need a form of ID for damn near everything in this country in this day and age.
I think the courts should solve this issues by determining what forms of ID are acceptable and if our politicians are so concerned that a voting bloc of theirs will need help in acquiring the required ID then they can use their campaign organizations to help people obtain the necessary ID. Similar to their efforts to get people to vote.
With as many as 20 million illegals in this country currently I believe that there is potential for abuse and with these numbers future elections could definitely be affected regardless of what has happened in the past.
One last thought is that the legal citizens in this country that don't currently have ID are most likely not the same people that head to the polling booths each election. Most likely they have absolutely no interest in voting. I feel like a voter ID requirement would have little effect on the actual number of people that intend on voting.
I don't see what the problem is.
Liberals are constantly contradicting themselves. Here in Charlotte the almost totally Democratic city counsel passed all kinds of restrictions against any kind of protesting anywhere near the DNC. You even had to have an ID if you were nearby not to mention going inside the little building where it was held instead of the stadium to avoid the embarrassment of all those empty seats.
Hell, you couldn't find a van for miles around Charlotte for that week as they were all leased by DNC and affiliates hoping to find people walking around on the street or neighborhoods they could haul down town to make it look like it was overwhelming, which they failed to do.
The mayor was promoted to Secretary of Transportation shortly after the event like Lerner after doing such a great job. He was black. You have to be black or a Muslim to get a position in Obama's administration now days or some ties to some radical group. Hell, you even have to be black or Hispanic to get special help from the government.
What's the problem? With you having to prove who you are at the DNC or anywhere near the DNC during 2012 here in Charlotte, why not have people voting produce the same sort of validity of who they are?
Read some of the comments and you will.
Two wrongs don't make a right.
North Carolina Passes the Country's Worst Voter Suppression Law
And thats just the start of it. In short, the bill eliminates practically everything that encourages people to vote in North Carolina, replaced by unnecessary and burdensome new restrictions. At the same time, the bill expands the influence of unregulated corporate influence in state elections. Just what our democracy needsmore money and less voting!
I want you to understand what this bill means to people, said Representative Mickey Michaux (D-Durham), the longest-serving member of the North Carolina House and a veteran of the civil rights movement who grew up in the Jim Crow South. We have fought for, died for and struggled for our right to vote. You can take these 57 pages of abomination and confine them to the streets of Hell for all eternity.
Here are the details of everything bad about the ball, via North Carolina Policy Watch. Its a very long list:
Hope this increases your understanding.
An unsubstantiable presupposition.
Already explained and debunked.
Irrelevant to the issue of the fair and equal implementation of any/all laws.
Many people, some who have voted legally for decades using various forms of ID, are being disenfranchised by these voter suppression laws.
Still ignoring the issue no one contends that illegals should vote! The issue is the intentional creation of tortuous requirements and uneven implementation of the laws.
As for Texas you need to update your knowledge.
Texas Judge Almost Blocked From Voting Because Of New Voter ID Law
Dan, I don't know what state you are from, but if you are from a swing state it does make a difference. In NC, a swing state, all you have to do is tell them your name and address to vote. Of course you have to sign to say you are that person. With every national election we have empty buildings become Community Organizations dedicated to going out into the community to help the people. These organizations will have a fleet of plain white vans. As soon as the election is over they disappear. I have a couple of very close friends who have been working the polls for years. They have cited many occasions where they felt they knew voter fraud was happening but couldn't do anything about it. As Maxine Waters said, "Obama has a database like no one has ever seen before."
Here's just one example. I have to get to work, but I will put this one on here.
This article is about a mentally retarded lady who has never voted in her 57 years of living on this earth. I know the liberals know what is happening. This lady didnt even know there were two parties but voted for Obama. I dont have to wonder what is going on. The liberals know but honesty is not a part of their agenda or theyre just uninformed to put it lightly.
FAYETTEVILLE OBSERVER
Concerns raised over possible exploitation of mentally disabled voters
Jimmy Green's stepdaughter had never voted before. The 57-year-old is mentally disabled, and Green said she doesn't understand the concept of casting a ballot.
But this week, she called her parents to say she had voted for President Obama. The care home in Fayetteville where she lives registered its residents to vote and drove them to the polls, Green said.
"My concern is that somebody told her who to vote for," he said. "She didn't even know there's two different parties."
Complaints of uncomprehending voters being ferried to cast ballots surface every election. And in a presidential race as close as this year's, with huge levels of early voting, any perceived irregularity is falling under intense scrutiny.
But federal and state laws are very clear - there is no competency test for voting.
"The law specifically says that anyone with a disability is allowed to have assistance from anyone that they choose," said Terri Robertson, director of the Cumberland County Board of Elections. "As long as they can communicate to us in some way that they need assistance and who they wish to have assistance from, the law allows it."
In 2010, Gary Bartlett, the state elections director, issued a memo to county boards clarifying the law.
"In the absence of evidence of systematic fraud," Bartlett wrote, "the presumption should work in favor of the opportunity of the voter to vote."
Don Talbot said he saw vans full of mentally disabled voters brought to the polls time and again during his years as a former precinct chief in Cumberland County. He said it often appeared they had little input in completing the ballot.
"The audacity of it to me, it is shameful, but both parties do it," said Talbot, a former Fayetteville city councilman. "When you haul people that are not competent and you do their voting for them, that's fraud."
Bob Hall with Democracy North Carolina, a voter rights group, said he hears protests about the opposite problem.
"We also get complaints from people who want to provide assistance being told they're not allowed to give it," he said. "They go overboard on the other direction."
It can be hard for observers to tell how much assistance a voter is getting, said Lisa Grafstein, a lawyer for the Disability Rights N.C. advocacy group.
"It is tough, because you can't really get in the middle of that conversation and know what was going on there," she said. "We can't put a block on a whole host of people voting because we suspect there might be some incidental instances of exploitation ... . I don't think the law can really draw a black line like that."
When exploitation does occur, the focus should be on the people manipulating the voters rather than stripping the rights of the disabled, Grafstein said. She likened their situation to that of an elderly person scammed over the phone.
"We don't take their phone away," she said. "We don't punish them for having been manipulated."
Robertson said she's heard general complaints this year but no specific allegations of voter exploitation. Incidents can be reported to the Board of Elections at 678-7733.
Jimmy Green has not lodged an official complaint about his stepdaughter being escorted to the polls. He said he fears reprisals against her from the care home.
"I'm not holding up for either party here in this case," he said, "but it's just not right."
Bartlett's memo acknowledged there could be instances when a voter who is not capable of communicating his identity or voting preference is permitted to vote.
"That consequence is preferable to the conflicting consequence of inappropriately disenfranchising voters merely because of their communications shortcomings," Bartlett wrote. "In the absence of systematic fraud, this imperfect outcome is simply one with which we must live."
Fayetteville is in Cumberland County and is almost totally Democrat and the biggest, newest and best looking building in town is the social service building. People from other states will stop and ask you where the Social Service building is located.
I was told by a liberal who knows the scoop, what these organizations do is have one White, one Black and one Hispanic go out into these communities and gather all the data they can including the number, ages and names of the children. As I was told, you can bet everyone in that house either gets a ride during the voting period or someone else votes for them. This of course is not going to show up as voter fraud, especially when 90% of the people working there are government employees.
Well good. Now's the time for you to help all those fraudulent voters to get ID's. I've read the law. Maybe you should too. Sorry it took so long. I Google NC Voter Law. The last time right after it was passed it it was on the first page before all the liberal sites pushed it back a few pages.
House Bill 589
Have fun. I know it isn't common for Democrats to read the laws, but if you find time, you'll find they've offered all kinds of ways to make it easier to vote than you're liberal point of view would have you believe.
I'm out of here.
No offense A Mac, but what do you think about this?
PA Democrats Took Bribes to Oppose Voter ID
This can't be true. Democrats taking bribes to vote for something they would vote against for free. The thing is why did the Democratic Attorney General shut the investigation down. You know what the reason was? Racism. Who would have guessed that? It seems Progressives are a race now. If you charge them with anything, true or not it is Racism. Beats me.
Tortuous requirements? Having a birth certificate which, by law, must be issued, is a tortuous requirement?
Name change - you are also required, by law, to get your social security card updated when you have a name change - no charge - done by mail. What would be so "tortuous" about getting in your car, driving five minutes to the voter registration office, and updating your voter registration. Or, they may ask/tell you to mail in copies of the official documents - $.49 for letter, $.20 cents for copying at Office Max.
Sixpick,
ANY PARTY THAT COMMITS ILLEGAL OR UNETHICAL ACTS SHOULD BE INDICTED AND PROSECUTED.
Any political conflict-of-interests to thwart justice should also be addressed via indictments.
What did you think I'd think?
Shall I post a list of similar and even more egregious acts by Republicans? Wrong is wrong.
Did you read about any of the impediments to the five minute drive? It's never a five-minute drive.
ALECs right wing agenda
I used to have a fake ID...when I was in high school, but I didn't use it for voting.
#1, when I was born 1925 and where I was born, the rez, there was no such law and it was even before Social Security even existed. It took 3 trips to the state capitol and a sworn affidavit, by our Town Clerk, identifying not only me, but the family, before the state would issue a State Birth Certificate, which I guard jealously. All of this so that I could join the Army and go to war! I should have hidden in the closet!!
In MN. a Tribal ID card was accepted as voterID. That is until, they tried to drop it at the last minute. This resulted in a law suit that forced the them to back down, and the Tribal ID was accepted.
There are instances of voter suppression of American Indians in some states.
You said exactly what I expected you to say, because we both love our country, but I guess my problem is the Attorney General ended the investigation. I personally don't think it is true for the simple reason why would you have to pay a Democrat to vote against something you would think they would be voting against anyway as there isn't much diversity in the Democrat voting record? As you know, I don't care for the Republicans either. There is a way to take this country back even with our different views on how to accomplish things, we have lost control over Washington. There is a legitimate way Article 5.
I know I said I was out of here, but I had to get some things together to carry with me and had to get my last fix.
No one is arguing the point that it should apply to everyone are they? So show a drivers license or SS card or voter's registration, what's the big deal?
In Albuquerque, it'll take you from five to 15 minutes to find the voter registration office. In New York, Chicago, Dallas, etc., it will probably take longer.
So did my brother, but it didn't help him much when there was a sting operation at a drive thru beer store. It did get him into a lot of places he wouldn't have been in otherwise, but after that sting, he kind of went a different direction.
So a drivers license may be difficult for some but every LEGAL citizen has a SS card ...what do you think is fair, and why is showing one of the 3 forms of ID I listed a problem?
BTW a state ID is free in most cases too. I still say what is the big deal. There are plenty of fair ways to do this.
I did direct other questions toward you for discussion, this comment was not intended for you unless you are a loony liberal that will shoot down any attempt to reign in illegal votes because you believe your party benefits from them.
Not all states accept SS cards as valid ID -- Ohio for one. And the ID issues are not the only impediments to voting.
12 Very Real Voter-Suppression Tactics Experts Now Worry Will Come Back
You need to get up-to-date on which states require what.
I have been the opposite and have provided specifics throughout -- why go trolling for loonies? Can't you accept the provided specifics?
We find loonies in all parties -- I'm trying to keep this point-counterpoint.
All of these list Drivers license or State ID card. I think this is reasonable, especially when the state ID card is free. I agree all the others listed are unacceptable ( I have had #1 happen to me) But let's keep on point, the question at hand is requiring ID to vote.
So how about this, every state requires a valid license or ID card. the state must issue the state ID or voter ID card for free. (i could be wrong but I believe every state has a voter ID card that can be obtained by a LEGAL citizen for free)...now what's the problem?
Kavika,
I didn't know that. Did Reservations in the past not keep records of births and deaths?
As long as provisions are made for i.e. elderly, sick, etc. and the locations to obtain ID are reasonably abundant, within reasonable distances based on area (rural, urban, public transportation availability) AND EVERYONE IS CHECKED FOR ID -- in other words, "even implementation of the law" -- we agree.
Fair enough?
I still don't see any implication in the report that 'not' everyone would be required to show ID. That doesn't even make sense to me to find any basis for it, legally or logically. Whenever we apply for various licenses and such in our lives, everyone follows the same rules here. I would think this situation would be across the board as well....why wouldn't it be?!! If I saw someone being favored or prejudiced, I'd be taking it to court. Anti-descrimination is a huge policy here and is not acceptable. Is that not the case everywhere?
Robert,
Very well said!
To note, I had not thought about the American Indian cultures in this, because I thought their genetics were historically, tribally well documented. I didn't know, just thought so. At any rate, I don't care who is a citizen; I just want them to follow the rules so that the rules apply to everyone in the same way. ..in everything.
BF - Same here. When we were on a paper system, we had to show ID or a voter registration card and the information was verified against their printout info.
That statement is false; but I'll give you a chance to document it.
Democrats do not advocate "non-eligible" voters diluting anyone's rights; that's a pure crap assertion. Democrats want to assure that suppressive laws don't disenfranchise eligible voters.
AP, yes - I am aware of many court cases having gone to an appellate court over the years; I didn't mean to suggest I was unaware, but rather, I was pointing to the 'principles' the issue is based on. Our laws were supposed to be based on morality and justice, but now they seem to be based on who has the most money.
Again,
"Congress holds full power over federal election rules, but indicated that states could require proof of citizenship in state and local elections." That statement should carry a lot of weight.
All that card did was get me in trouble...but I'd do it again.
That's not what I said.
You're a big Constitution guy when it suits you why play with words now?
equal protection: an overview
The Equal Protection Clause of the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution prohibits states from denying any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. See U.S. Const. amend. XIV .
Whatever law is put in place, to enforce it selectively, to selectively implement "probable cause" for example, becomes a "profiling" issue.
96, that's what was always required in my state. I've never seen inconsistency or discrimination in policy - I don't think any moral or ethical person would stand for it..
I agree, I see everyone else being asked for the same ID I am asked for at my polling location, drivers license or voters registration and picture ID (which is free in Michigan) seems fair enough to me.
Fair enough, I would prefer access by mail, then distance is not an issue, make people aware of it and how long it takes and keep the turnaround time reasonable (2 weeks or less), if they didn't have their poop in a group fast enough to vote by the time they get the ID in the mail, tough. Plan ahead next time. I think it would be a lot cheaper than millions of locations and free transportation.
Good idea. Here voter Id cards are automatically produced, just like a SS card. I think it was stated in the report as their thoughts that this issue is an example of states' rights. Yes.
In all of the years that we have voted here in Florida we have been asked for 2 forms of ID. One had to be a photo ID so our drivers licenses were used and accepted.I can not remembera time when I have been challenged.Since we have gotten older and less able to handle the stresses of physically going to the polls we receive our absentee ballots, on request, by mail. I don't know how they can be totally sure that we are who we say we are under those circumstances except by our registered signatures.
Absentee ballot is a good point, but at least they can confirm your name and the address it is being sent to, better than nothing I guess.
Mac, the 14th is protecting one that is born or Naturalized here for national/federal citizenship, and I read the E. P. clause attached to it to further protect a US citizen in a 'state.' I do not agree that it is saying it will protect a non-US citizen for voting rights. That does not make sense to me. Yes, they have to abide by our laws simply because they are on our soil, but that doesn't mean they are 'qualified' to receive our rights and benefits.
Two things, Chloe.
First, read it in its entirety.
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
"ANY PERSON."
To do otherwise constitutes a "presumption of guilt". If the government accuses or suspects a crime is about to be or has been committed, the law nevertheless proceeds on the
Presumption of Innocence
Second,
I have not and do not advocate protecting voting rights of non-citizens; by definition, THEY HAVEN'T ANY. My argument regarding these laws has ONLY TO DO WITH PROBLEMS RESULTING FROM UNEVEN AND/OR UNFAIR/IMPROPER ENFORCEMENT AND ANY/ALL RESULTANT IMPROPER DENIAL OF VOTERS' RIGHTS.
That's it and that's all. Any impediment to a (legal) citizen's ability to comply with these laws -- AND THAT'S WHAT HAPPENED IN WISCONSIN et al -- makes the law a fraud, not the voter's action or intent.
I understand and agree with that - fairness across the board - no discrimination. What I didn't understand from the start was why you think they could get away with handling a law unfairly to even suggest such a thing. See, in my state, anti- discrimination is fully enforced; discrimination will not be tolerated. Because I've neither been Party to it, nor witnessed it in my lifetime --is why it's not even a consideration. If someone feels they are being prejudiced or treated differently (through requirements) from other US/state citizens in Az., I would expect them to challenge it.
I agree with that. I've always thought that when they change a law on one side - any law - that they need to alter the other side of the equation to make it work. With this issue, I would think any and all US citizens have some form of proof of legality...usually a birth certificate. I coudn't find mine, so had another copy sent to me for $15.00. We should have one, imo, no matter the issue.
Really? Attempts and successes to fairly implement laws would preclude their very existence? Really?
The opposite is true.
More of your personal-insult bullshit.
You're apparently not nearly as bright as your avatar makes you appear.
Because a dozen people make the same error doesn't make the thirteenth person correct in asserting the same wrong information.
And American military personnel died so that Iraqis could get that vote and it's been explained here several times what this is about it's not about showing an ID, rather about making it difficult to comply and how any verification process must be fair and even-handed.
AND AMERICANS' RIGHTS TO VOTE WERE ALSO FOUGHT FOR and the bullshit legislation from Red States desecrates those battles.
Sheesh indeed.
You're righteous indignation is a bit myopic and disgusting.
If everyone must show an ID you would be wrong .
I agree you are bothered
But it's encouraging that you see yourself as pathetic and helpless there's hope in honest self-assessment.
You do realize that your comment is just demagoguery and name-calling, lacking anything remotely resembling debate
You do, don't you?
And your comment is pathetic.
That's correct; so now you might try and answer my questions as to whether or not that will be the case and the other related questions. And, there is still the issue of how easy or convoluted it will be to prove citizenship.
We may yet agree, Petey.
dennis,
It applies to laws generally; the possible exceptions may occur when a law is implemented arbitrarily, selectively and with partiality and that implementation must be overturned by another single act of law.
The Constitution was constructed by the Founding Fathers with a process to amend it which must be deemed a recognition that laws can and do change to reflect the times; this may apply to immigration, prohibition, the number of terms a President can be elected to the office, slavery, taxation, suffrage
But overall, if a nation's citizenry is to have faith in the concept of "A Nation of Laws," Justice must be blind (impartial)" and carry a double-edged sword (The sword in her left hand symbolizes the power or reason and justice).
Perhaps you are more attuned to "discrimination" than I am . What is so difficult or time consuming about displaying an ID ?
Birth certificate ?
Oh no, there is no voter fraud. Like this article from Florida.
Florida NBC affilate investigation finds dozens of illegal voters
Posted on March 19, 2014 at 9:16 pm
WBBH-TV reporter Andy Pierrotti managed to track down dozens of local residents who were (a) both non-US citizens and (b) registered to vote in the swing state. Many of them had illegally voted in recent elections.
The investigation began by examining state forms on which residents had declined jury duty by checking a box indicating that they werent US citizens, and were therefore ineligible to serve. Pierrotti then cross-referenced those results with local voter rolls, identifying at least 94 people who were registered to vote in the state of Florida. Next, he visited some of these people at their homes, where they admitted that they werent citizens and professed ignorance as to how they were registered to vote in the first place. But voting records
confirmed that theyd exercised their right to vote that, as non-citizens, they do not actually possess. The NBC 2 team interviewed a
number of these illegal voters on camera, including a Jamaican national who simply attested that he was a US citizen on a voter registration form, and voila! he joined the American electorate. It was a felony, but it was that easy.
[...]
A quick calculation, as a point of reference. This local reporter found 94 illegally registered voters in one small region using one narrow verification method. If you extrapolate his number over Floridas 67 counties, thats nearly 6,300 people. In 2000, the United States Presidency was determined by 537 Florida votes .
t is an article of faith on the Left that voter fraud does not exist beyond the imaginations of racist right-wingers, hellbent on imposing "unconstitutional" voter ID laws fashioned to "suppress" minority turnout in elections. These objections are race-baiting nonsense; they're unsupported by both empirical evidence and Supreme Court precedent. The high court upheld Indiana's law in a 6-3 decision in 2008. The ruling was authored by uber-liberal Justice John Paul Stevens. And after Georgia implemented its own law in 2007 (which survived a legal challenge), minority voter participation increased in the next two election cycles. ABC News has called voter fraud a " rare but real " phenomenon, evidenced by a number of relatively high-profile convictions in recent years. Congress defunded the left-wing group ACORN (for whom Barack Obama once organized) over widespread voter registration fraud and other outrages. The watchdog group True the Vote -- whose founder's businesses and family have been harassed by the IRS and other federal agencies -- documents voter fraud prosecutions in 46 states since 2000. Which brings us to a report that aired earlier this month on NBC's local affiliate in Ft. Myers, Florida. WBBH-TV reporter Andy Pierrotti managed to track down dozens of local residents who were (a) both non-US citizens and (b) registered to vote in the swing state. Many of them had illegally voted in recent elections. Here's the full report, followed by some analysis:
"We don't know how widespread this problem is because elections offices don't keep track of where non-citizens live," Pierrotti reports, "So we decided to do something that they'd never tried to do before: We found them on our own." The investigation began by examining state forms on which residents had declined jury duty by checking a box indicating that they weren't US citizens, and were therefore ineligible to serve. Pierrotti then cross-referenced those results with local voter rolls, identifying at least 94 people who were registered to vote in the state of Florida. Next, he visited some of these people at their homes, where they admitted that they weren't citizens and professed ignorance as to how they were registered to vote in the first place. But voting records confirmed that they'd exercised their "right" to vote that, as non-citizens, they do not actually possess. The NBC 2 team interviewed a number of these illegal voters on camera, including a Jamaican national who simply attested that he was a US citizen on a voter registration form, and -- voila! -- he joined the American electorate. It was a felony, but it was that easy. And if a news crew hadn't connected the dots, no one would have ever known. This passage in the report is crucial:
REPORTER: County supervisors of elections tell me they have no way to verify citizenship . Under the 1992 "Motor Voter" law, they're not required to ask for proof.
HARRINGTON: We have no policing authority. We don't have any way of bouncing that information off of any other database.
REPORTER: The only way supervisors of elections can investigate voter fraud is if they get a tip, so that's what our list became.
HARRINGTON: It could be very serious . It could change the whole complexion of an election.
Here's the problem: This handful of wrongs are now being looked at and dealt with, but it took an enterprising and creative journalist to uncover them. These are 94 cases he uncovered in his own backyard alone, using just one narrow method. How many people in this country are registered to vote, and actually do vote, who are not US citizens? We don't know. It is lunacy that election supervisors "have no way to verify citizenship" in many places, even at the point of registration. It's further lunacy that we would not require every potential voter to produce valid proof of citizenship before casting a ballot, from coast to coast. These steps are so basic, so fundamentally fair, and so rudimentary that it's difficult to accept that an entire political party is dead-set against these voter integrity efforts for reasons that are not nefarious. Only US citizens are allowed to participate in US elections under the law. Citizens who don't have proper identification ought to be able to obtain them quickly and easily. That's the reasonable recourse for the "suppression" non-problem. But every single person who wants to vote should prove that they're doing so legally. That's not racism; that's painfully basic common sense. Oh, and it's overwhelmingly supported by Americans of all political stripes .
Parting thought: A quick calculation, as a point of reference. This local reporter found 94 illegally registered voters in one small region using one narrow verification method. If you extrapolate his number over Florida's 67 counties, that's nearly 6,300 people. In 2000, the United States Presidency was determined by 537 Florida votes .
Oh no, the Democrats don't have a problem with voter fraud.
In every state voter ID has been enacted the minority voters increased. In Mexico when voter ID became effective, the number of voters increased tremendously.
If you ask all Americans about voter ID's you will find most are in favor of them. As the old saying goes, the one who squeaks the loudest get the oil. There are a small number of extremist who push the idea having voter ID's is to keep the minority from voting are squeaking the loudest and the media is promoting their position, so many Americans think there is no voter fraud and it is a made up idea by old white men, but in reality, we have no idea how many illegal votes are counted each voting cycle.
I'd like to feel confident as many Americans would like to feel their vote really counts. The Democrats know there is voter fraud, but it is in their favor so they keep trying to downplay it. And to top it off these extremists know the truth but their followers have never even read the laws and only depend on the extremists to give them their information.
Understand in solid blue or red states voter fraud is not significant, such as California or New York, although producers of tax dollars are running away from these states by the millions leaving only only the dependent on the government to vote.
Thanks for your contributions, Six. All very interesting.
Mac, I stand corrected. I did a little more research, and was shocked at how we bend over backwards to protect undocumented citizens. I can't believe that's what the Founders had in mind. I had no idea we've been doing that.
Depends on the state, Petey.
The "convolutions" come in the photo ID process. I posted earlier how Wisconsin, after passing its voter ID law, closed 10 DMV offices in districts that tended to vote for Democrats while not closing offices in Republican districts.
The DMV offices are where Wisconsin citizens must go to get the required ID!
Further,
Let's begin with the source of the story, townhall.com
You have your sources, I have mine.
Out of curiosity, how many cases of this supposed voter fraud the reporter uncovered, were prosecuted?
And with the irrefutable backup information and your track record as "Mr. Objectivity" who but an intelligent person could find flaw I'm your comment?
You may have a point regarding the low expectations thing; after all, while I never expect anything of value from your comments, I nevertheless read them faithfully.Ya' got me there.Read it slowly for best results.
Investigation Catches 94 Illegal Florida Voters, Likely Hundreds More
March 18, 2014
At least 94 non-citizens illegally registered as Florida voters despite opting out of jury duty based on their non-citizen status, according to an investigation by NBC News affiliate WBBH in Fort Myers. The discovery indicates hundreds or thousands of non-citizens are illegally registered to cast ballots in Florida and contradicts assertions by liberal activists that few if any non-citizens are illegally casting votes in federal, state and local elections in Florida.
WBBH conducted a public records search for people who responded to jury duty notifications by swearing under oath they are non-citizens and therefore cannot sit on a jury. Investigative reporters then cross-checked the names and addresses of people who opted out of jury duty with voter registration rolls. WBBH confirmed at least 94 non-citizens registered to vote yet opted out of jury duty. WBBH further confirmed non-citizens are actually voting in elections, and are not simply dormant registered voters.
The investigation raises serious questions about the number of non-citizens regularly and illegally voting in federal, state and local elections. There are undoubtedly many more non-citizens who have registered to vote yet have not been summoned for jury duty. Still others likely served on juries rather than checking the non-citizen box to avoid jury duty. Given that WBBH found 94 non-citizens illegally registered to vote under the narrow boundaries of its investigation, the likely number of non-citizens voting in Florida is in the hundreds or thousands. For context, the 2000 U.S. presidential election was decided by merely 537 Florida votes.
WBBH highlighted the 1992 motor voter law as a exacerbating the illegal voting problem. Under the motor voter law, people signing up to vote do not need to show proof of citizenship in the voter registration process.
Tampa Bay Times columnist Michael Van Sickler recently published an article ridiculing reports of non-citizens illegally registered to vote. In Fraud? What fraud? Another FDLE investigation comes up empty, Van Sickler claimed that because a suspected broker of illegal registration forms skipped the state before Florida law enforcements could apprehend her, no voter fraud occurred. Van Sickler similarly ridiculed other documented instances of likely fraudulent voter registration.
The Times has nevertheless verified non-citizens voting in Florida, as well as nearly 7,000 convicted felons illegally voting in the Sunshine State.
Illegal Aliens Caught Voting and Stealing Elections In Florida
Illegal Aliens Caught Voting and Stealing Elections In Florida
Illegals voted in 2012 In vast numbers
Illegal alien voters along with immigrants that are prohibited from voting were detected voting in Florida in 2012. As Florida approaches the 2014 mid-term election cycle supervisors of elections across the state will begin to purge voter records of illegals and those not eligible to vote in the state (i.e. convicted felons).
Each illegal alien or non citizen immigrant that registers to vote is committing a felony.
Each illegal alien or non citizen immigrant that votes steals a vote from a legal voter in Florida.
The problem is that the states do not check to see if voters are in the US as immigrants or legally or if they are voting in two states, a problem in Florida. Amnesty supporters like Senator Marco Rubio know this.
Like I said, there's no problem, even A Mac provided information to show that there was and is no problem at all. Heck, even the DNC here in Charlotte required ID's to get into that little building to see a bunch of nuts lie. No problem at all. You even had to have an ID during the DNC to be anywhere near it, not just in it. Anthony Foxx. Charlotte's former Mayor and the Democratic city counsel did such a good job of eliminating any possible protesting anywhere near the DNC, he was given the position of Secretary of Transportation after Obama was re-elected. No problem at all.
If you listen to the propaganda from the mainstream media or depend on the Department of Injustice Eric Holder there will never be a problem unless it doesn't help them politically to continue to lie like he did and go after Obama's, the biggest liar of all, opponents. I mean the evidence is there on that accusation.
And of course Salon is a reliable source for your information as a progressive website started by David Talbot, former Senior Editor of Mother Jones. Wow! What unbiased sources! Most of these people end up working in the White House like John Podesta who had the most visits to the White House oh a year or so ago. He founded Center for American Progress who owns ThinkProgress, 501(c)s with no problems from the IRS. Of course he's now the U.S. representative to the UN High-Level Panel appointed by obama. No problem, we're doing just fine. The president doesn't need the Supreme Court or Congress anymore and the agencies can do the dirty work for him without Congress approval or control, which means even though they don't seem to care what you want, don't bother calling any of them since they can't do anything anyway.
I'm going to stop tap dancing around your incessant use of "Philadelphia" and "Chicago" et al, and call it what it is "RACIST BUZZWORD PIECES OF RED MEAT"!
You and others like you toss that shit out there to titillate your bigot buddies; what you mean with that wink-and-a-nod bullshit is "Niggers with guns in big cities where all black people vote for democrats". Don't piss in my face and tell me "it's raining"!
When did I say that? Don't put words in my mouth. Post an exact quote with the link and we'll see what you're talking about.
Conflation bullshit -- drop the name of the black man in the white house and then obliquely imply I haven't explained the voter suppression tactics, the tacticians, the guilty states and the particulars. You can't mount a viable rebuttal so you talk shit, Robert G. And your "knowledge" of the ACA is primarily the lies that the Koch Brothers pay for in their ad campaigns -- some of which are now being attacked and debunked by the WSJ et al!
Looka' YOU; you use the names of major American cities as metaphors for the "N" word. I'm a victim all right -- haters like you victimize reasonable people with your rhetoric and demagoguery.
Noe that's a three-peat. And members of my party cross the street all the time -- often to get away from the stench of haters like you.
Fact-laden commentary there boy.
Or is it projection?
WTF do you know about Philadelphia or Chicago; you're a stereotype-squawking shill for a party that counts on a base of haters. You're an embarrassment to actual conservatives.
Tip of the iceberg
OK, I'm going to weight in on this. Many of you are so damn worried about illegal votes, are you as concerned about citizens of this country being marginalized and their votes being suppressed? I don't think so.
Perhaps you should spend more time being sure that legal citizens have the same opportunity to vote as you do.
If you don't think that voter suppression exists, do a little research.
Here is a start for you.
...
Yeah, watchdogwire.com another unbiased source
From watchdogwire.com page
Mocking are we?
94 names on the list all sent documents to verify their citizenship -- as should be the case.
But again I ask the relevant questions. In states that will require proof of citizenship to vote
I have not advocated that illegals should vote -- THEY SHOULD NOT!
I HAVE SHOWN WHERE SO-CALLED "INVESTIGATIONS" OF VOTER FRAUD WERE THEMSELVES, FRAUDULENT!
So what's your problem with anything I've written herein -- is it that I want laws implemented even-handedly? Is that it?
ONE MORE THING.
11.0 million REGISTERED VOTERS 94 may have voted illegally!
Kavika,
Here's some perspective on "voter fraud" in Florida.
11.0 million REGISTERED VOTERS 94 may have voted illegally!
Unless your wife has been diagnosed with breast cancer and she's uninsured then you might want to stick around.
Exactly my point Mac.
Many seem to think that it's fine to require voter ID, but in their minds, every citizen has a equal opportunity to vote, which is pure B.S.
They should spend more of their time insuring that ALL citizens have a equal opportunity to vote.
They want to scream about the constitution and rights, where are they when legal citizens aren't afforded those ''constitutional rights''.
Sorry, I must have missed that. Still couldn't find it. Could you help me out. Where does it say that?
Thanks for the links. I already know employers are dropping coverage and I know you are thankful along with the Jews for having George Soros deliver the death notes to them during WWII, which he has said not to long ago how that was some of the best times of his life, even though his father stopped him from doing it. I will not be attending gay training sessions either. Liberals are a race unto themselves. That's why if you disagree with them you are automatically a racist. I don't know about my heart. My blood pressure usually runs around 120 max over 70 max. I I know it probably goes higher and lower at times. I don't drink or smoke. I do drive quite a bit and I have to exercise to keep these old joints from getting stiff. Dr Ben Carson, oh he's the guy that got his first audit after making a fool out of Obama. What a great person. Has saved the lives of lots of children and never used a drone on a family wedding either. I haven't read the miracle food cures from the bible. I would imagine it wouldn't include bar-b-que though. I need to read that last one, but I think I will pass.
I didn't even know Donohue was still around. He's the one who thinks there are some angels out there who are not greedy taking care of the people, isn't he?
More mockery; not flattering if you are allegedly interested in having an actual discussion.
Play the video you posted Sixpick.
I feel like their should be satellite polls in this case, Kavika. I understand your position.
I believe there are 2 Native Governors in the USA. 2/50.... that's 4% of the states and they are Republicans. I don't care for the current crop of Republicans or even the many crops before them, but as the list I read, it sure doesn't seem like they've done anything for you. You might want to try another brand and see how it works out.
The Democrats have had the powers and so have the Republicans to do the right thing and neither have come through. But in your case there, it seems like the definition of insanity.
There are NO American Indian governors Sixpick. There is a difference between Indians from India, and AMERICAN INDIANS.
Try another brand...LOL...Let me see what the Repubs have done for Indians...Oh, that's right, NOTHING.
Their last try at making the playing fields even was VAWA..You know who voted against it.
''I think disinterest in voting is a player here, also''. Of course you would Robert, but then again, why would I take anything you post as accurate. Have you lived on a rez,do you know any Indians. I doubt it Robert. Your history of trying to''point the finger'' at anyone not white is well documented.
In another words, your full of it, as usual.
PERSPECTIVE
ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS?
Wouldn't that be every non-Native American other than Manhattan Island, isn't every place else in the U.S. technically the property of indigenous people from whom those places were stolen by the thieves who set up government and made laws to "legalize" all of the illegal acts they (sadly, WE) perpetrated?
I played it again A Mac and it didn't say anything like....
We're not getting anywhere here. You've already posted information claiming there is and we just can't trust anyone. With 12 plus million illegals in this country, which we always think by the media they are all Mexicans, but the fact is they are only part of the illegals in this country.
Something as valuable as our right to vote should be protected to make sure it is really worth something to us.
In Mexico the people didn't vote, because they thought it was rigged and it was, but once they put Voter ID on they had many more votes because the people actually thought their vote could really mean something. Right now I don't think my vote really matters.
In the last election in 2012 I didn't care for Romney, but I cared for Obama less, but I voted anyway out of habit.
No other president in my lifetime who had a record over his 4 years like Obama even had a chance of being re-elected, but he won.
I mean 50 million people in poverty, 50 million people on food stamps, 90 million people out of the work force, high unemployment in general and coming down because more people kept getting out of the work force.
Starting fires all over the world, class division like I've never seen before. Low approval rating before election that jumped right before election. Benghazi lies, IRS kept his opponents subdued before election.
Scandal after scandal requiring Executive Privilege to say his and Eric Holder's ass on Fast and Furious. There's no way he should have won.
Even today in your own state the Democrat Attorney General is shutting down investigations into Democratic fraud. We know the Republicans suck too, but this isn't a pretty picture.
The only was to regain control of the government is "Convention of States". We can all agree, I think we need to put term limits on Congress and The Supreme Court. That's only two things we really need to do.
Thank about it. Everyone of those assholes up there are filthy rich and they think of us as peasants to be ruled over. They don't think they are there to serve us. They could care less what we want.
I mean a $15,000 dress. How can they relate to us. One half million dollars for a speech. How can we be fooled into thinking they really give a shit about us. They are the elites. The wealth in this country is in Washington DC.
I want my vote to count. If it is not important to others then just don't vote, but I have investigated this with a friend of mine who has worked the polls for years. I guess if you are in a total red or blue state, you just don't understand.
Another ignorant statement Robert, but I'm used to them coming out of your mouth. In fact, I'd be disappointed if you didn't say something ignorant. It's you M.O.
Thanks Robert. I read that too, but let them continue to vote the way they want to vote. Working out really good for them.
No! I'm saying that there are laws that enable the amending and/or repeal of other laws and that by defined process, not anarchy or revolt. There is also the phenomenon known as "ex post facto" law.
An ex post facto law ( Latin for "from after the action" or "after the facts"), also called a retroactive law , is a law that retroactively changes the legal consequences (or status) of actions that were committed, or relationships that existed, before the enactment of the law.
In criminal law , it may criminalize actions that were legal when committed; it may aggravate a crime by bringing it into a more severe category than it was in when it was committed; it may change the punishment prescribed for a crime, as by adding new penalties or extending sentences; or it may alter the rules of evidence in order to make conviction for a crime likelier than it would have been when the deed was committed.
Conversely, a form of ex post facto law commonly called an amnesty law may decriminalize certain acts or alleviate possible punishments (for example by replacing the death sentence with lifelong imprisonment) retroactively. Such laws are also known by the Latin term in mitius .
dennis, I sense you're trying to get at something specific but for some reason, are not coming right out with it. If I'm off base with that, just let me know.
Tell it to the states making it harder to vote!
Sixpick,
Go to 1:08 in either video and watch closely.
Regarding
If Boobus americana would get off its dead ass instead of sitting home watching reality shows on election day, term limits wouldn't be necessary voting out an incumbent limits his/her term.
Assholes who vote their race (any/all), religion, gender or special interest without regard to any other issues are the ultimate problem.
And MONEY IN ELECTIONS FUELS THE IGNORANCE/STUPIDITY MACHINE! Elections should be public, tax-funded, no corporate, union, etc.. money.
''You are irrational, as usual''. True hurts doesn't Robert.
Of course your both avoiding the question of what have you done to insure equal voting for all citizens. Typical...
No, they just want to avoid giving equal voting opportunitiesto 6 per cent of the population Robert. Typical of the ''Take back America'' crowd.
Agreed on everything except when I see the Iraqi's proud to vote I realize only a small percentage usually vote in the elections until recently and that has been due to community organizing. And most of these people don't even know who the VP is. And that goes for both sides.
There are a lot of other things neither of us mentioned if we spend time thinking about it. Would be a good project or article. Do it, "What would you change about the USA if you could concerning politics". My addiction overwhelmed me today and I am now facing 400 miles before I arrive back home. I didn't accomplish anything. I'm going to break the addiction. I just enjoy it so much at times.
More perspective on that. If you wonder why Republicans/The Tea Party piss me off, read on my friend!
I'll bet that you and some others did not know
George W. Bush enabled an Iraqi constitution that guaranteed Iraqis all kinds of things that Republicans/The Tea Party aggressively deny Americans. 4,000+ Americans died so Iraqis could have the following: oh the fucking irony and disgrace!
JOBS & HEALTH CARE!
The right to vote
AMac...
Yes. There are two sides to every story. I see nothing wrong with exposing that political 'sides' each try to sabotage the other for their own promotion of wealth and power that results in benefiting 'both' sides.
The problem is - that game of 'lets try to destroy him' using the media causes some people to believe a 'side' is better than another. When in reality, imo, neither side's propaganda should be taken as the 'whole' truth. We all know that political journalism is paid to 'slant' - the event might be truthful, but they will intentionally leave out important details that incriminate them. I try to read the propaganda that comes from both sides.
To note: this is my opinion about political journalism in general. I'm not a propagandist, so that means when I seed an article in any political context --- I'm doing so to be informative of an 'event.' I am 'not' saying I am a follower of that journalist's interpretations or that I agree with that journalist. In other words, it's never about me. I don't seed to be 'pushy' or try to influence/sway others' minds. I'm just putting up articles of events that I think are important that can affect our lives -- it never has anything to do with whether I agree with it or not. My personality is less 'for or against' an issue, but more that of critique weighing pros and cons to form my own analysis.
I'm only saying this to explain myself in that it appears I've been misunderstood, misinterpreted and 'assumed' in the political topics -- resulting in personal attacks by some. I can agree with the handling of a political issue or particular legislation, but that, by no means, is to imply a pigeon hole - that I agree with every issue that a 'side' is trying to promote. To the contrary.
So yes, I find information of an event---no matter which 'side' it comes from---to be worthy of consideration because I try to let go of personal bias when analyzing.
One reason why, even though we usually disagree politically, I think highly of you and consider you a friend.
Didn't see anything in the article to the thread that dealt with Native Americans - don't think that's the subject here. There is nothing, absolutely nothing wrong with requiring that anyone who wants to vote in an election in the United States having to prove that they are citizens of the United States.
"The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof;" - state right, not congressional - state can require proof.
"Eligibility to vote in the U.S. is relevant at both the federal and state levels. Currently, only American citizens can vote in U.S. federal elections." - hint - state can require proof.
"Adult citizens of the Unted States who are residents of one of the 50 states or sometimes the District of Columbia may not be restrained from voting for a variety of protected reasons, stated in the aforementioned 15th, 19th, 24th and 26th Amendments." - hint - states can require proof.
Nothing else needs to be said. Kansas and Arkansas exercised their constitutionally guaranteed right to verify U. S. citizenship before allowing residents to vote.
It's equal opportunity to vote 1st. That would include American Indians.
It's not about state rights to require proof. It's about not putting up barriers to vote.
Hell yes, it's about Indians, and any other group that can be marginalized.
IT Hiccups of the Week: Kansas DMV System Prevents Proper Voter Registration
It was a leisurely week in the land of IT-related snarls and snafus. We start off with the continuing saga of problems plaguing the Kansas Department of Motor Vehicles modernization effort.
Kansas DMV System Slows New Voter Registration
In May 2012, the Kansas finally introduced a new US $40 million computer system to handle car title and registration processes at the Department of Motor Vehicles. But more than a year later, the system continues to cause problems for the state and its citizens.
Most visible have been the intolerable DMV office wait times , as the system has proved to be less than dependable. In fact, Kansas is still holding back $2 million of the $25 million contract with the system developer 3M until system reliability improves. That can't happen soon enough for those drivers using the Wichita and Andover DMV offices who are still experiencing three to five hour waits and recurring computer failures .
But now there's another problem:
Back in 2011, Kansaslegislators were considering passing a law that would require new voters to provide a birth certificate, passport or other documentation proving their citizenship when they registered to vote.According to a news story at the Lawrence Journal-World ,Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach assured the legislature "that a new computer system being installed by the Division of Motor Vehicles could seamlessly provide citizenship information to county election officials across the state.
The law passed, but the legislature decided to delay its start date from 1 June 2012 to 1 January 2013 to ensure the [DMV] computer system would be working properly, the Journal-World wrote. (This was over Kobachs strong objectionshe wanted the documentation requirement in place before the elections last November).
he wanted the documentation requirement in place before the elections last November).
Apparently, even that delay wasnt long enough.
According to the newspaper, the DMV claims that it is sending the required proof of citizenship information to Kobachs office, but most of the documentation doesn't seem to be finding its way back to county election officials. For example, the Journal-World says that county election officials in Douglas County report that some 80 percent of the voter registration forms it receives that were originally filed at the DMV are lacking the proper citizenship verification information. This compares to about 30 percent of all new voter registration forms filed (including those coming in from the DMV) since the law took effect in January.
Voter registration forms that dont have the proper documentation are placed in suspense until the proper documentation is provided by the potential new voter. However, there is no requirement (or money budgeted) for Kansas county election officials to contact a potential voter about their missing information. So a new voter may well have provided the required information to the DMV, but still have a suspended registration.
So a new voter may well have provided the required information to the DMV, but still have a suspended registration.
Officials as of yet can't pinpoint whether these documents are lost due to human or technical error.
Kobach admits, according the Journal-World says, that the DMV system isnt working as intended but said citizenship documents were being forwarded by email, which county election officials strongly dispute.
If something isnt done soon to correct the problem, the paper says that the ongoing issues leave the secretary of state vulnerable to allegations that the new requirement will suppress rather than encourage voter participation, something that U.S. Supreme Court took a very dim view to recently .
The Kansas DMV may have more headaches in its future: the modernization of the driver's license process is supposed to go live later this year.
True, 1st...the issue is relevant at both the Federal and state level. A state has a Constitutional 'right' to require proof of citizenship for voting and the job of the Feds should be (and I thought it was) to protect the states rights, among other things.
A state (or Fed or 'person') could have nefarious 'motivation' for why they are implementing, and I think that's immoral, if so; but if their action is Constitutional - is the bottom line.
______
Kav, I agree that putting up barriers would not be jurisprudent. I'm just asking -- don't American Indians (those alive today and of voting age) have proof of where they were born, day, time ?
Yes, they do Chole. The point is, as in lawsuits in MT. SD. ND and MNare the barriers put up to suppressive their vote.
But it does not have a right to violate other Constitutional rights
Once again, I have no objection to states requiring proof of citizenship as a criterion for the right to vote. I DO HAVE AN OBJECTION TO:
Selectively checking voters for proof on election days
Disparate levels of ease/difficulty in obtaining any/all required proofs of citizenship and other required voter ID
To avoid acknowledging these potential problems is to deny that elections can be stolen by targeting demographics and making it difficult for those demographics to vote.
I see. I didn't know of those.
If those involved feel they have been unfairly suppressed or prevented to participate as anyone else would be allowed to do that is a member of our citizenship, then seeking legal counsel is the right thing to do.
dennis,
First; Obama has deported more illegals than any President and that is one aspect of enforcement. You can say that enforcement is inadequate but you can't say that nothing is being enforced with regard to illegals.
I have more to say but I'm at dinner with my wife and am going to put my iPhone away. More later I promise.
__________________________________
I'm home and will continue my comment.
You probably know that the repeal of Prohibition in the United States was accomplished with the passage of the Twenty-first Amendment to the United States Constitution on December 5, 1933.
It repealed the National Prohibition Act , known informally as the Volstead Act which was enacted to carry out the intent of the Eighteenth Amendment , which established prohibition in the United States .
The Anti-Saloon League 's Wayne Wheeler conceived and drafted the bill, which was named for Andrew Volstead , Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee , who managed the legislation.
THE LAW WAS UNENFORCEABLE AND NOT FOR LACK OF TRYING; one reason was the corruption of law enforcement and government officials.
In Philly we have an expression "Money talks and bullshit walks." And one of the reasons that immigration laws are ultimately unenforceable or enforceable only to a point is MONEY.
Among those who benefit monetarily from illegal labor are the corporate farms big contributors to Republicans who speak out of both sides of their mouths on illegal immigration. For the xenophobes in its base, the Republicans are anti-illegal immigrant. But Republicans in the House won't even allow a vote on immigration reform.
Why is that? First to appease the base, but THE BIG REASON IS MONEY. Reform immigration laws and maybe the poorly paid illegal workers will have to be paid on the books, employers will have to pay decent wages, contribute to Social Security, etc. .
We're being lied to primarily because of hate campaigns and money.
Mr. Reagan open the illegal flood gates and to use a metaphor to explain why reform not only makes sense -- it's actually the best alternative -- "YOU CAN'T PUT THE TOOTHPASTE BACK IN THE TUBE." The problem exists and logistically, 20 million illegals can't be deported.
So address the problem and stop dancing around it any lying to the public. Here's what Republicans don't tell us.
Immigration Reform Boosts Economic Recovery
Business leaders use economic arguments to convince GOP to get behind immigration.
As a comprehensive immigration reform bill hangs in the balance on Capitol Hill, a new Bipartisan Policy Center study shows an aggressive overhaul could boost the country's anemic economic recovery.
The report found that during the next 20 years, immigration would bolster the country's economic growth by 4.8 percent. The report shows that immigration reform would reduce the country's deficits by $1.2 trillion during this time, as young, working immigrants take jobs and pay taxes.
[ READ: Business, Faith and Silicon Valley Leaders to Pepper House on Immigration ]
So, dennis. I have done my best to answer you.