A Stillborn Child, A Charge of Murder and the Disputed Case Law on ‘Fetal Harm’
Rennie Gibbs, a 16 year old in Mississippi when she gave birth to a stillborn child, is facing life in prison for taking cocaine during her pregnancy. Hers is among a burgeoning number of cases in which women are prosecuted for allegedly endangering their unborn children.
Rennie Gibbss daughter, Samiya, was a month premature when she simultaneously entered the world and left it, never taking a breath. To experts who later examined the medical record, the stillborn infants most likely cause of death was also the most obvious: the umbilical cord wrapped around her neck.
But within days of Samiyas delivery in November 2006, Steven Hayne, Mississippis de facto medical examiner at the time, came to a different conclusion. Autopsy tests had turned up traces of a cocaine byproduct in Samiyas blood, and Hayne declared her death a homicide, caused by cocaine toxicity.
In early 2007, a Lowndes County grand jury indicted Gibbs, a 16-year-old black teen, for depraved heart murder defined under Mississippi law as an act eminently dangerous to othersregardless of human life. By smoking crack during her pregnancy, the indictment said, Gibbs had unlawfully, willfully, and feloniously caused the death of her baby. The maximum sentence: life in prison.
Seven years and much legal wrangling later, Gibbs could finally go on trial this spring part of a wave of fetal harm cases across the country in recent years that pit the rights of the mother against what lawmakers, health care workers, prosecutors, judges, jurors, and others view as the rights of the unborn child. - http://www.propublica.org/article/stillborn-child-charge-of-murder-and-disputed-case-law-on-fetal-harm
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
There is substantial medical evidence; here and here that crack cocaine babies has reached epidemic proportions, especially within the black community.
The real issue here is the legal remedies for this, such as prosecuting the mother for murder. Some think this portends a creeping criminalization of pregnant women as a new front in the culture wars over abortion lead by the conservatives and in this article; M iscarriage, Murder, And Forgotten Women
My bottom line; this problem cannot be alleviated by simply charging a mother/female with murder.
Tags
Who is online
90 visitors

I agree with you AeonPax. Since this article drew your attention do you have any thoughts on a solution to a terrible problem like this? I really wonder. I don't think there is an easy answer. But what are your ideas of some possible solutions?
You are correct, it is a complex problem...or so it would seem. However, at the crux of this is unemployment among blacks which translates to Jobs, to wit; Report: Black community still suffering from disproportionately high unemployment rates . I talking meaningful, family supporting jobs.
Making matters worse, blacks also suffer from First Out, Last in when it jobs. Adding to that the prevailing racism for mainly conservative sources, the cards are stacked against a black worker.
A job is much more than just money, it is self-esteem and honor which appears to be lacking in the black community as of late.
If the umbilical cord was wrapped around the baby's neck and that is what killed her, not the trace amount of cocaine, then the mother should be found not guilty.
I agree that using drugs during pregnancy that causes the death of the baby should have consequences. But in the case of an umbilical cord around the neck, chocking would seem to be the cause of death, and according to law, not a prison sentence for the mother.
Medical experts vs. medical examiner/coroner - apparently the experts reviewed numerous reports of previous still births to reach their conclusion. The Jackson, MS medical examiner saw "Black" - hence she's guilty.
Gee I am having a real hard time connecting the dots. My understanding of cocaine is that it is an expensive "rich man's" drug, so what does unemployment have to do with snorting cocaine? Does welfare and/or unemployment really pay that much? Seems like a pretty poor excuse to me.
I agree that the other variables in this case should be looked into more carefully.
I'm thinking the same thing,1st. This is one of those cases where, if it were a white girl, they would not have given it a second look and the mother would have received sympathy and lots of support from church groups.
Sincerely hope she gets responsible legal representation on this, if indeed the cause of death is the umbilical cord. I'm so sick of people in law enforcement picking and choosing which parts of the law they have decided they want to enforce.