Viral Video (7 million views) Criticizes "Black Lives Matter"
Over the weekend, at least 7 million people watched Peggy Hubbard, a black grandmother, excoriate the Black Lives Matter movement in an emotional video posted to her Facebook page. 71,000 people liked the post. 16,000 people left comments. And discussions like this one on Reddit rippled out across the Internet.
Two breaking news events prompted the U.S. Navy veteran, who grew up in Ferguson, Missouri, to speak out and share her feelings. In the first, two white police officers killed Mansur Ball-Bey, a young black man. Police say that he tried to flee out the back door of the house where they were serving a warrant and that he pointed a stolen gun at them before they shot, a narrative that his family disputes.In the second news story, 9-year-old Jamyla Bolden was killed by a stray bullet from a drive-by shooting as she lay in her mothers bed. The perpetrator is unknown.
Youre hollering this black lives matter bullshit. It dont matter. Youre killing each other. White people dont care Youre shooting at the police. They drop your ass. Oh, he died due to police brutality. 327 homicides later yall want to holler police brutality? Black people, youre a fucking joke. Youre tearing up communities over thugs and criminals.
She had thousands praising and excoriating her.I had a lot of positive feedback from a lot of people from my black community to keep going, she wrote in a follow-up post. I also had a lot of negative feedback from people in b lack communities. On Saturday, after more reflection, she posted a new video . She began by apologizing for her profane language. That is not me, she said, explaining that she was very upset because of the deterioration of our society and our neighborhoods, and losing that little girl. As a mother, as a wife, as a grandmother I have a grandchild that age, and it broke my heart, because what if it was mine?
She pledged to refrain from profane language going forwardand said she has no intention of shutting up. Given all the comments I received, black and white, saying, Dont stop, we need your voice, Im going to keep going, she said. This is not a race issue. It never has been a racial issue ... This is about accountability and responsibility ... Last night we had another homicide and were saying black lives matter. Black lives matter, white lives matter, Asian lives matter, Hispanic lives matter, Lithuanian lives matter, Russian lives matter, life in general matters but its never gonna get better until we admit that we have a problem in our community.
* * *
If anyone is surprised by Hubbards emergence, or that there are like-minded black people who are encouraging her, it is only because large swaths of the media cover the black community as if conservative voices like hers dont even exist.
In fact, she is the latest incarnation of a black conservatism that has been around more than a century. Ta-Nehisi Coates wrote a 2008 feature story on its last public champion, Bill Cosby, who roiled American discourse on race with what has come to be known as his pound cake speech. He declared, Looking at the incarcerated, these are not political criminals ... People getting shot in the back of the head over a piece of pound cake! And then we all run out and are outraged, The cops shouldn't have shot him. What the hell was he doing with the pound cake in his hand?
With dozens of women now asserting that Cosby drugged and sexually assaulted or raped them, he is no longer a viable bearer of this message.
Many black people criticized Cosby for that speech. But Cosbys rhetoric played well in black barbershops, churches, and backyard barbecues, Coates wrote, where a unique brand of conservatism still runs strong. Outsiders may have heard haranguing in Cosbys language and tone. But much of black America heard instead the possibility of changing their communities without having to wait on the consciences and attention spans of policy makers who might not have their interests at heart.
With dozens of women now asserting that Cosby drugged and sexually assaulted or raped them, he is no longer a viable bearer of this or any other message. But the constituency for which he spoke did not disappear. It was bound to find another champion. In the era of social media, why not a heretofore unknown grandmother? Shes already being attacked in the awful way black conservatives so often areshe reports being called delusional, the white mans bed wench, and a house nigger. As yet, she is not being defended by the progressives who typically urge deference to women of color, condemn tone-policing, and insist that white people are speaking from a place of privilege when they disagree with a black woman.
Hubbards response to her diverse critics has drawn on the language of inclusion. I love my black people. I love my white people. I love my Hispanic people. I love my Asian people. My heart is so full of love for people that it has no room for hate, she says. The way I see it, its not a black race, its not a white race, its not an Asian race, its not a Hispanic race, its not a Latin race, its a human race. And right now, the black community, what were racing towards is the morgue. Lets stop it. If you want to help me, help me. If you dont want to help me get out of the way.
* * *
I share Peggy Hubbards alarm at murder rates in poor, black neighborhoods; her dismay at the death of a 9-year-old girl; her aversion to property damage; her belief in the importance of individual responsibility; and even her skepticism about protesting Ball-Beys death given the evidence that has so far emerged. But significant parts of her critique of Black Lives Matter seem unfair and wrong, even if the anger and frustration she feels is understandable given her life experiences: a brother and a son who apparently destroyed their lives by choosing to engage in crime.
Shes right that a young, black man in a poor neighborhood is much more likely to be killed by a violent criminal from a nearby block than by an abusive cop out patrolling. And its true that good cops are needed to protect people in those same neighborhoods. But the Black Lives Matter agenda isnt inconsistent with either of those propositions. The movement doesnt explicitly tout the importance of policing, but it does advocatereformingpolice departments, not abolishing them. And it does so with overwhelming evidence of deadly abuses and incompetence and the accurate perception that blacks are disproportionately victimized.
For those reasons, urging reforms that would reduce police abuses and improve training is eminently defensible, regardless of how many black men are killed by criminals. The young activists of Black Lives Matter can realistically improve policing policy by bringing the publics attention to a problem and lobbying for known remedies. In contrast, the problem of violent crime is longstanding universally acknowledged; and theres no reason to think murderers would murder less if these young, black activists loudly demanded it, especially given that lots of voices in the black community have long inveighed against and worked to stop black-on-black crime.
If President Obama, countless black parents, church leaders, and famous rappers havent yet stopped black-on-black murder by denouncing it, its reasonable to conclude that Black Lives Matter pays a low opportunity cost by focusing its protests on policing. Perhaps that reasonable conclusion is nevertheless incorrect; maybe violent crime reallycouldbe reduced if only more voices joined Hubbard in denouncing violent crime and touting the need for personal responsibility. If so, shed do better toorganize that movement than to complain that other people, whove spent more time and energy than she has on activism, have chosen a different goal.
Reforming police and reducing crime are both worthy projectsand despite what some defenders of status-quo policing would have us believe, they need not be at odds with one another . Note, too, that many of the Internet critics who want Black Lives Matter volunteers to spend more time protesting crime in urban centers have themselves done nothing in service of that goal besides criticizing Black Lives Matter.
Hubbards most unfair attacks are glaring to an individualist.
The fact that some young black men carry guns and commit violent crimes doesnt mean that other young black men and womenshould have their activism discredited.
Youre hollering this black lives matter bullshit, Hubbard said. It dont matter. Youre killing each other. In fact, the overwhelming majority of people hollering black lives matter have never killed and will never kill anyone. The vast majority of Black Lives Matter protestors are not tearing up the neighborhood either. These race-based generalizations rob their objects of individual identities. The fact that some young black men carry guns and commit violent crimes doesnt mean that other young black men and women totally distinct individuals who happen to share the same skin colorshould have their activism discredited, enjoy fewer civil liberties, or be at increased risk of being killed by cops. It is interesting that the various right-wing news sites that picked up this video failed to catch these flaws, despite fancying themselves champions of individualism, color-blindness, and the rights contained in the United States Constitution.
Hubbard was speaking off-the-cuff at a moment of high emotion; its possible that she hasnt fully considered all the implications of her views; but as stated, they are wrongheaded. She mightve been on solid ground if shed stopped at arguing that police were justified in shooting Ball-Bey and that Black Lives Matter was wrong to protest that particular killing; instead, she spoke as if the Ball-Bey encounter bears on the righteousness of protesting other deaths, like Freddie Gray, Walter Scott, or any of the other black men that police officers have been indicted for murdering .
* * *
Despite these significant disagreements, Im glad Peggy Hubbard spoke out on Facebook. Its generally a good thing when citizens earnestly express their views in public discourse, and she deserves kudos for trying to improve her community as best she can. She has articulated beliefs that are shared by a lot of people, which is itself an important service: Insofar as those beliefs are inaccurate or wrongheaded, better that they be aired and debated than invisible and unexamined.
This viral video and the comments around it also represent an opportunity for the activists of Black Lives Matter to understand how some critics of their movement perceive the world, to engage in conversation and debate , to refine any weaknesses in their own thinking that emerge, and to persuade their interlocutors to adjust some of their positions. In fact, despite Hubbards harsh words, Id bet that, properly engaged, she could be persuaded to voice support for at least a portion of the policing-reform agenda. If so, what an ambassador she would make to millions of potential converts.
Tags
Who is online
60 visitors

Credit where credit is due. She's got guts.
Interesting piece, she sure speaks her mind
It is hard to disagree with this woman, who makes a lot of good points. But as the article writer points out in his own way, the woman, like millions of people, misses the point about "Black Lives Matter". They have certain points that they want to make. "Black Lives Matter" released a list over the weekend of SPECIFIC reforms they want instituted in the nation's police departments and criminal justice system.
They believe that if they go off their message , to say "all lives matter", or to decry black on black crime such as the shooting death of the 9 year old girl, that they are then watering down or changing their specific message about the institutional mistreatment of blacks.
I have said, forever it seems like, on this forum, that police abuse toward blacks and "black crime" are two separate issues. One can be both against police abuse AND black criminals, but they don't have to be used in the same sentence as a matter of course.
You can look at her message or you can pick through it to find things you can try to use to discredit her message, but her message is hers. The Black Lives Matter campaign only addresses a small number of the deaths in the communities at large. What she is saying is to address them all.....in a way that will make a difference and help keep more alive.
LGL:
This whole post is just beautifully cogent and informative. Thanks, LGL! I learned from it.
Something seems not to be working in the Black Lives Matter leadership, else they'd not be protesting (as "police brutality") the death of a criminal who was shot and killed after shooting at cops. Cops have a right and duty to protect themselves and the public. And they appear to have been doing their job when they shot the man Peggy Hubbard mentions in her video (so far as we know at the moment).
Leadership need not be top-down or hierarchical to be beneficial and effective. There is such a thing as group intelligence, and BLM needs to find out how to nurture that collective intelligence in their movement. I say this also, in part, due to the ridiculous intervention of some BLM activists at a Bernie Sanders rally in Seattle.
It turns out their gripe was not with Sanders at all, but the Sanders rally was just a convenient crowd and microphone for these political demonstrators to hijack. Bad strategy, bad tactics, ... a dumb action. Very counter-productive to the movement.
---------------Note: It is my understanding that some BLM activists had been hijacking other microphones in other places in a similar manner, and not because of a gripe against the speaker, per se. But just because they can.