Adventures in Geology – 250 Gallons per Minute, or HUH?
At one time or another, I had worked in what seemed like nearly every small town in Indiana, and a few of the larger ones, as well. Therefore, I became intimately acquainted with every little swamp, hell hole, or nasty place in cities and towns, all over the state. Why is that? Because water wells are never placed so as to be convenientthey are stuck off by themselves in the middle of nowhere, or placed as an afterthought, next to where it is convenient. Like next to the fire station, for instance. Or out in Farmer Bobs field, because he was willing to sell an easement to the town.
A very small town in southern Indiana contracted me once, to look into why their wells were experiencing excessive drawdown. It is very hilly in southern Indiana, and quite beautiful there, but the only aquifer, or water-bearing formation that is any good, is the sands and gravels within the Ohio River. Wells in the Ohio River Valley are usually capable of producing 750-1000 gallons per minute, (gpm). That is equal to a million gallons of water per day, to 1.44 million gallons per day. Thats a lot of water! They had to have a main line running everywhere that feeds a nice sized population, not just the 236 souls of this small town. Also, I could understand the need for one good well, and one backup well, but three?
I drove to the small town and met with the water superintendent at the local coffee shop, which had about 10 rickety booths lined up against a dark brick wall, and served Pie, Any Time! My kind of place. Mr. Leaven, a large man, wore a toupe, which was too large for his head, and much darker than his own hair, making him look like he was a mushroom with a cap. Im going to call him Mr. Leaven, and he was a very nice fellowall people in the water industry are pleasant, lonely, and usually underpaid and underappreciated.
He took me down the big hill to the old town, where the wells were located. While at one time, it had been a bustling little community, the floods of the Ohio River had pretty much wiped it out. The hill going down to the old part was missing large chunks of its asphalt, and we skidded down the hill in his truck, feeling as if we were going to fall through the windshield, if not slide off the road to land in the treetops.
The newest building had been built in the 1930s, and it looked rough. There wasnt much left of the town, but a grid of sandy roads, and a few houses, here and there. There were plenty of abandoned buildings, all of whom were disintegrating rapidly, under the onslaught of nature.
Most wells in the Ohio River Valley are way up in the air, on stilts, so to speak, to get the motor of the pump up out of the 1937 flood level. The 1937 flood was a humdinger of a flood, and everything today, is jacked up above that elevation. These wells were no exception. They looked new, except that despite all their shiny blue paint, no one had re-welded the ladders back onto the stand pipe, so as one climbed, the ladders twisted and rattled.
Mr. Leven took me to the first well, and we climbed up the rickety ladder to look at the motor of the pump. It had a large motor on the pump, and had been recently painted, so it looked like new. The well was 24 in diameter, sufficient to produce way more than 1000 gpm, based on my previous experience in the Ohio River Valley. He said, This is our well #10. Its not a good producer, at all.
I asked him, How much water does it make?
He thought a moment, and said, 250 gallons a minute.
I made a face and said, Thats not much for a well in the outwash sands! He nodded. We climbed back down to terra firma, thank heavens. Im not fond of rickety ladders.
We got back in the car and drove a couple of blocks to another well site, and climbed up to see the motor of the pump. Again, it was a large motor and pump assembly, painted a bright blue, and the well was 24 in diameter. Mr. Leaven rubbed the stubble on his face and looked down on me, benevolently, and said, This well is our well #14. Its a pretty good producer.
I asked, How much does this well produce?
He thought a moment, and said, 250 gallons a minute. I nodded, mystified. This was a better well, but still only produced 250 gallons per minute? We climbed back down, got in the car, and drove a couple of blocks.
We climbed up to the last well, also 24 in diameter, and he said, This well is our well #23. Its my best producer!
I asked, How much water does this well make?
He patted the side of the gigantic motor fondly, and said, 250 gallons per minute! Bless it!
I thought a moment, and said, How is this your best producer when they all make 250 gallons a minute?
He smiled and said, Thats all our plant will take250 gallons a minute!
Oh!!! I said, and thought, Huh? Mr. Leaven, what is the difference between the wells?
He said, Well, sissy, the drawdowns the difference. This well hardly has any drawdown, and the worst producer has a lot of drawdown.
I nodded my head, Oh.
Then, came the kicker. Mr. Leaven smiled at me and said, All this water comes from Michigan, you know.
One could stand on the well and toss a rock into the Ohio River, but the water in this well must have traveled, via underground pipelines, all the way from Michigan. Some driller, (and I know who), had traveled up and down the Ohio River, telling every water superintendent he saw that their water came from Michigan. I could kill him, still.
Drawdown is the difference in the level of the water in a well from when it is resting, to when it is pumped. The resting level is usually a lot higher, but the more drawdown a water well has, the less efficient the well. Plus, it costs a lot more money to pump from the lower level of water all the way up to the top of the well, and all the way up the hill to the plant-- it adds a lot to the cost of electricity.
I said, looking at the pump motor, My, this well has a huge pumphow high in elevation is the plant?
He smiled at me, and nodded his head, Its got 24 impellors! Thats where we are going to, next, sissy! Impellors are the round balls on the piping of a pump, where the fan-like parts of the pump are located. 24 impellors could pump the water up about, oh, say 1500. I wondered on which mountain, this plant was located.
Every pump had a large valve with a wheel, next to the pipe leading down to the well. I asked, Are these wells valved back, Mr. Leaven?
Oh my yes! he said and grinned. If we didnt valve em back, theyd blow out our 4 line, all the way to the plant.
We jounced and bumped our way over the horrible road all the way up to the hills, and I thought, Someone sold this town huge wells, that were definitely unneeded. These wells should produce a lot more than 250 gallons a minute! And who designed those pumps? They are huge!!!
I asked him, Im not sure I understand your well numbering system, Mr. Leaven. Have you drilled 23 wells down in the valley?
Mr. Leaven chuckled and said, Sissy, thats what the wells cost us! $10,000, $14,000, and $23,000. That way we could keep up with their costs!
I smiled at him and said, Ingenious! Do you have well records?
Mr. Leaven nodded his head, vigorously, nearly dislodging his fine toupe, and said, Yep! All thats at the plant. Ill make you a copy!
Sure enough, when we reached the plant, which was located next to a stream, it was a brand spanking new, beautifully painted, compact plant. They aerated the water first, and then it went into the mixing basins, where coagulants and flocculants were added, stirred around, and then filtered. The last thing they did was add chlorine and fluoride, and they had a good water supply. And sure enough, the steam of water trickling through the aeration, (which was a stacked set of steel plates, with holes in it), was about 250 gallons per minute.
Mr. Leaven was very proud of his plant, and fond of his wells, and quite pleased to have company. All I had to do was figure out why there was excessive drawdown in the three wells. The solution is below, if you care to read it. But, for now, I wont bore you!
Never will I forget that the three wells, all pumped the same, 250 gallons a minute, but one of them was a good producer! Mr. Leaven was a lovely man, and I really liked his sweet wife. So many water superintendents in these small towns, are out and about, fixing mains and doing their best to keep the water flowing. If you know one of these guys, tell him hey for me!
The Solution:
The secret was in the records. Well #4, had been constructed with slotted screen, and gravel packed, excessively. Gravel packing a well means that a large hole is drilled, and a large casing placed in the well boring. Next, a smaller casing is installed in the center of the well, and a uniform sized, high silica gravel, is poured in the space between the casings. Lastly, the outer casing is backed out of the hole, leaving a uniform pack around the screen of the smaller casing. The size of the gravel is based on the size of the grains of the formation around ita gravel pack is designed to retain 40% of the formation, and the well screen is sized to retain 40% of the gravel pack. Its a neat trick.
The last thing the driller does is develop the well. That means that they use a cleaning tool, which is often a kind of pipe with double surge pads on either end. The driller plunges the surge up and down in the well, mechanically shaking up the gravel pack, and pumping out any sands or small bits that come into the well. A lot of drillers add hydrochloric acid, to dissolve any lime precipitates in the formations, and all of them add chlorine to disinfect the well. At the end of the process, you have a well-sorted gravel pack that leaves coarse material against the screen and grades into the finer grains of the formation.
Gravel packing boosts the possible production of a well in sands and gravels, because it allows a larger opening between the wires of the screen for the water to enter the well. It also straightens the path of the water through the formation.
Well #10 couldnt be cleaned properly, because the gravel pack was over 12 thick, and the energy from the surging tool couldnt reach the actual formation. Grading the formation stops at about 4 from the edge of the screen, so back in the formation, the water entering the well cavitates at the edge of the formation/gravel pack. The change in pressure at that edge, causes minerals to deposit on the grains of the gravel pack and the formation, gradually shutting off the flow of water to the well.
Especially in old wells, after cleaning, which opens up the easiest parts to clean, the well has channels in the formations around itthe water enters the well only at points along the slots in the screen, and the formation had stopped up. Nothing was going to fix its poor design, and it may as well be abandoned.
Well #14 had been constructed with good old wire-wound screen, but it had less screen, and the gravel pack was way too thick. It couldnt be cleaned properly, either, but with the introduction of enough hydrochloric acid into the well, it might dissolve some of the formation precipitates, and clean up to a point. I estimated that it could be restored to about 80% of its original pumping level, which was pretty good. Once a well falls to less than 60% of its original capacity, its shot. Rehabilitation is usually not a good investment.
Well #23 had been properly constructed with a 3 gravel pack, and well-developed, so it was in good shape. All it needed was cleaning, to remove any precipitates out in the formation, and it was good to go. You can easily see from the picture at the left, how a wire wound screen would open up a well to allow more water to flow in.
I made my report to dear Mr. Leaven and took him and his wife to dinner. Well #23 is still pumping, last I heard, and the small town is ready for expansion of its water supply, as soon as the plant capacity is increased, and the build a larger diameter main.
Thanks for coming by!
Tags
Who is online
103 visitors

After learning just how much psi the pumps were producing, and how much the wells were valved back, the piping sort of bulged to my eyes...
Things sometimes, just aren't what they seem!
This was very interesting, Dowser. Thank you for including the pictures so that I could see exactly what you were talking about. In case of a natural disaster, you are going to be one of the people I make room for on my ark.
Too much gravel ... Why didn't they think of that ?
Interesting Dowser, I learned a lot. I'm going to start digging my own well tomorrow, I'm really excited about it, and I'm going to use your information.
Very informative Dowser. It is amazing that some of the old wells still produce and do so very nicely. Loved the history and story of the town and it's water problem.
Thanks, dear Royal Lancer!!
Really, to me, this is all fascinating. Wells don't have moving parts, per se, but they behave mechanically...
Thank you so much for taking the time to read this!
Dear Mimi!!! Thank you so much! I would love to be in your ark-- and I promise to be good!
Pictures really explain what you mean, don't they? The old slotted screens are still around in use in the very fine sands that are sometimes found in monitoring wells, but they aren't used much today. A lot of well were drilled so that they would fail, and that's the sad truth.
Thanks so much for coming by! I love you very much!
They did think about it. It's called "repeat customers". A little driller's trick-- construct the well so that when you first clean it, and clean it well, it recovers beyond its specific capacity, (the amount of water per foot of drawdown), AND increaes the size of the gravel pack, so it can't be cleaned. When the well fails, then you get the $$ for drilling another one.
Thanks, Petey, for coming to see me! I really appreciate it!
Call me if you need anything, and I mean it. I am happy to help, all I can. I'll send you my phone # via email.
Are you digging the well yourself, or is a driller going to help you? Do you know what kind of rig they're using?
Thanks so much for coming by, my dear friend! I appreciate it very much!
It IS amazing, and every time I see one, I sort of pat its motor, Good Girl! The oldest wells I've ever worked on were drilled in the 1930's up in Illinois. They were large diameter, collector wells. They had a 18' inner concrete casing diameter, which was wound with metal fencing, and a 20' outer casing. They had put smaller diameter riprap between the two casings, as a gravel pack, and for 50 years, the wells pumped absolute boocoos of water! It was a miracle! Good Girls, all 5 of them!
Thanks, dear Larry, for coming by to see me! I really appreciate it!
I really appreciate your no nonsense approach to this subject Dowser . What you describe seems to be a problem in most fields requiring expert intervention ...
Dowser, I was kidding. I'm way to old to be drilling a well. Thank for the kind offer though my friend. Our complex uses a well, and if there is ever a problem, you'll be getting a call.
I can't tell you how many conferences I sat through where one drilling company said, "We can clean your well so good, it's better than when it was new."
Bunkum. A well is a lot like a new car-- we expect it to be as good as it can be, from day one. Gradual degradation of the performance of the well is to be expected, just like driving a car every day. If someone can develop the well so that it is better than it was new, it wasn't constructed or developed properly.
Secondly, this same drilling company, (and others, of course), are well aware that a poor well design will cause the well to fail. They want the repeat business. Pretty ding dang sad, I think!
Thanks again-- I'm being honest as I can be. My clients were always my focus-- and what was best for them. When I did my job right, the problems were solved, and they had a regular cleaning schedule, triggered by the actual performance of the well. Then, they never called me again, because they didn't need me! Oh well...
A lot of people feel that way. Louisville has fluoridated since 1958, and studies have been done to see if it has caused any health problems. To date, we haven't had elevated occurrences of anything unusual, no increase in bone cancer, etc.
Like anything, if you get too much of it, it's bad for you. We currently follow the EPA guidelines of 2 mg/l, which isn't much.
Thanks so much, Hal, for coming by! I appreciate your response!
Very, very interesting, thank you for sharing something I know you love!!
Thank YOU for reading it!!!
Well, it does have a health benefit, for your teeth. I used to teach school in a small town in western KY. The kids who were on well water had REALLY bad teeth, and those who had had city water, had great teeth. Other than that, I suggest you take it up with the water department. I'm not a company chemist, micro-biologist, etc. I'm just the geologist.
Besides, you're not even here-- your water supply may not have fluoride in it. Many groundwater supplies have a trace of fluoride in the water, because it naturally occurs in limestone. Ours has a natural background level of around 1.2 mg/l fluoride, and we just add a small trace amount to bring it up to the drinking water standard. Fluoride removal to "0" levels would actually cost more, an add a lot of other chemicals to the water, in order to be able to filter it out.
Huh? We follow EPA drinking water guidelines. As far as a water company, or public utility goes, that IS the only standard, except for state standards which may be even more stringent.
If you're speaking of medications, as in Lipitor, hormones, chemotherapy drugs, etc., you're right. That wouldn't be accepted as a general additive, but is often a factor in many surface water supplies, which accept sewage waste. The only way to cure that is to not poop. It costs WAY too much money to treat for those chemicals. However, we are a groundwater supply. We don't have to worry about that, a whole lot. Also, fluoride is a naturally occurring substance, that is often in the water to begin with. AND the EPA requires all of us to maintain specific levels of chlorine throughout the system for disinfection purposes.
How much fluoride is in your water where you live? Is your supply a surface water supply or a groundwater supply? Have you read your Consumer Quality Report from your water company? Need more info? Call up your water supplier and ask them-- they have to tell you, it's a matter of public record.
Thank you, so very much!!!
I was astounded, at first, to hear that all three wells pumped the same, and that one was called, "The best producer"!! What a hoot!
Take car, Mike!
I'll tell you what I know, which isn't much. Fluoride used in toothpaste and added to drinking water is the same kind. It is a halide, which means that it is a natural salt mineral, and occurs as a salt. It is associated with Calcite, the mineral, limestone, which is calcium carbonate, and some dolomites.
Kentucky was the leading producer of Fluoride up until the 1990's, when they found a mine outside of the country that could produce it more inexpensively, so the market here in KY dried up.
Fluoride is deposited due to superheated water, beneath the earth's surface, so it requires a magmatic intrusion of some sort, to be deposited. As the water cools, within the other rocks, it cools and crystallizes, or permeates other rocks around it. It is extracted by means of deep mines, and is often found in veins. The ore name is called fluorspar, and contains approximately up to 40% of fluorine, the mineral. Any ore that contains more than 40% is considered to be the pure mineral.
From Wikipedia:
Our fluoride is manufactured here in the US, and has nothing to do with the nuclear industry, if that is your concern. Every batch we receive is UL listed, meaning that it has been tested for purity and quality by Universal Laboratories.
Here is a really good factual article about how fluoride is produced.
This is not an article about fluoridated water vs non-fluoridated water in a public water supply. You are off topic, my friend. I hate to call you on it, but I'm no expert in water chemistry, nor am I a doctor. Please, take this elsewhere.
Dear Friend Dowser: Without liquid water, life as we know it would not be possible.
Thelight you shed on how we access it, keep it pure, and sustainable in this and other articles make them all a must read.
We are grateful for your educating us. It is a matter of concern to everyone.
Peace, Abundant Blessings, and Clean Pure H2O.
Enoch (On the Rocks).
How very true, dear Enoch! I think of all the water personnel, all over the US, like as not, underpaid, always under appreciated, who valiantly struggle in all kinds of weather to keep the water on. They are all good people...
I just thought everyone might like to know some of the ins and outs...
MUCH love to you, now and always, my dear friend!
I must ask you, Dowser, should there be fear regarding placing a pipeline filled with tar sands over the aquifer in the midwest?
Absolutely! Why not place it elsewhere? The Mississippi aquifer is one of the best in the country. Longest, deepest widest, and very prolific. It could act as a source of supply for many of the western states. So why ruin something now for the benefit of the few, when, down the line, it could be a life/death issue for everyone down the line?
Taking a long view... What if the drought in California and the western states continues?
California is precariously perched, as it is, with normal precipitation-- already they remove water from one watershed to use in another watershed, classic case of robbing Peter to pay Paul. We have placed one of our highest population centers of our country in the area with the highest temperatures, (highest evaporation rates), and the least amount of rainfall/precipitation in the nation, (lowest recharge to the aquifers). I just read where they are looking into desalination plants to provide drinking water. Those facilities require very high energy use, for dubious gain.
The cost of building enough desalination plants to supply the area, (so that so many people can water their green lawns), wouldn't, in the long term, cost any more than running water pipelines from the area of prolific production to the area of lower production.
Look at Las Vegas. The intakes behind the Hoover Dam have been lowered 200'. Las Vegas is currently mining water-- withdrawing a lot more water than can be replenished under normal amounts of precipitation. But, let's keep those fountains spewing millions of gallons per day into the driest air in the country, so it all evaporates... Let's keep watering those green lawns and golf courses.
So, by all means, put a tar sands pipeline over the most prolific and pristine water supply in the country. We have nothing to lose...
If the water runs out, it will be economic chaos for all of us, not just those in California, Arizona, and Nevada... They could prevent this by 1) using their water wisely-- no fountains, no lawn watering, no golf course watering, etc., 2) planning ahead for a water pipeline that will take water from where it is easily replenished to where it is barely replenished, and 3) protect the existing supply from contamination.
I don't know who thought all this up, but they need to be thumped. Oil is a vital part of our life, but, try to live without water.
Dowser ,
If there's one thing harder than fighting city hall its fighting a city hall which has mob backing ! Thanks for your perspective on Las Vegas . These are the kind of issues our politicians should be addressing but don't hold your breath on that ...
Having lived in Las Vegas for a number of years, let me add a few facts.
Las Vegas/Henderson have the most strict water conversation in the country, and have had for a number of years. If you put in grass for a lawn, you are only allowed a very small patch. You are subject to many types of water restriction. Most Casinos have their own wells.
Because of the long term drought, the intakes for water consumption for the Vegas area are close to being above the water line of Lake Mead which is appox down 120 feet. They are adding another intake below the existing ones, this is proving to be much more difficult then anticipated.
The Colorado River is the main water supply for many Western states, and that is a problem. It's the desert, and man tries to make it something different.
All golf courses are required to plant a drought tolerant grass, recycle water for watering and for the lakes.
I could go on, but this is a good start. Having lived in both California and Nevada for a number of years, IMO, California is the one state that is well behind the curve.
This is really good to know, Kavika. None of my water journals add this level of detail to their discussions! Thank you, very much!
The fact that most Casinos have their own wells are fine, but they are still removing water and wasting it by using it in the fountains. They are interrupting the flow of groundwater from toward Lake Mean, for their own uses. The fountains are gorgeous, granted!
From what I've read in my water journals, CA is way behind the curve, and need to look into long-term planning. Most of these articles also mention AZ and NV, as well.
Dowser, the Casino's use recycled water for their fountains.
Actually 99 percent of the water in Lake Mead comes from the Colorado River and the Virgin River.
The city of Phrump NV, about 60 miles away, and in a different county, sits on a large aquifer. LV has been trying to get their hands on that water, but to no avail thus far.
There is a battle right now between Clark County (LV) and White county, ranch and farm land. LV is trying to get their hands on that water as well.
The annual rainfall in southern NV is around 4 inches per year.
It was not stated as the purpose but I expect this movie attempted to address the water issue :
However it got distracted onto other more lurid details .
I remember this movie, but not much about it... I remember it being a good movie!
I don't remember it being about water, though... Not that it isn't, I just don't remember enough about it!
They may use recycled water, but, that area has one of the highest evaporation rates in the country.
Plus, the Colorado River may contribute much of the surface water, but where does the low flow surface water come from? Ground water. The base flow of the Colorado River is attributed as the contribution of groundwater to the river's flow. So, Lake Mead is also maintained by groundwater.
Here is the map:
This is in August, which is the driest, hottest month of the year, but it doesn't change that much for this area of the country. I'm not saying they are not trying, but I am saying why waste any of it? They are mining the groundwater.
The recycled water is very good to use, but the evaporation of the water is a problem. How much evaporates? I don't know. I appreciate Las Vegas' attempt at saving water, in all honesty. But, it isn't enough.
Where does that recycled water come from? It is pumped out of aquifers, that are very limited in recharge. They could use treated waste water to recharge their aquifers. That they are looking for other sources of supply tells me that they know it is running out...
There just isn't enough recharge to sustain the current usage.
Dowser ,
If you have the free time here is the full movie .
Chinatown
Won't cost you a dime ! There are several significant scenes about water supply history in the LA region . And there are allegations of chicanery about it . Yes its fiction but it might be based on fact ...
Thanks, Petey! Maybe tomorrow night!
Hi Dowser,
I've been traveling and not had much time to read things here on NT. This one I had to comment on.
I've done quite a few plant type evaporative and chilled water heat transfer systems which obviously included centrifugal pumps. My eyes popped at the pump diameters as well. What sort of motor horsepower were they using to drive these pumps, and at what head? I've throttled pumps back to achieve the proper GPM at pressure, but this sounds excessive. Obviously the fouled screens increase their suction pressures off the charts. Did you notice any problems with pump cavitation?
Like you said, the pictures tell you exactly where the problem is. Makes you wonder if the time comes if they could reduce the size of their pump/motor sets in the future.