╌>

President Obama's Executive Branch Power Grab

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  33 comments

President Obama's Executive Branch Power Grab

By Jonathan Turley

March 12, 2014

Recently, a bizarre scene unfolded on the floor of the House of Representatives that would have shocked the framers of the Constitution.

In his State of the Union address, President Barack Obama announced that he had decided to go it alone in areas where Congress refused to act to his satisfaction. In a system of shared powers, one would expect an outcry or at least stony silence when a president promised to circumvent the legislative branch. Instead, many senators and representatives erupted in rapturous applause; they seemed delighted at the notion of a president assuming unprecedented and unchecked powers at their expense.

Last week, Obama underlined what this means for our system: The administration unilaterally increased the transition time for individuals to obtain the level of insurance mandated by the Affordable Care Act. There is no statutory authority for the change simply the raw assertion of executive power.

The United States is at a constitutional tipping point: the rise of an uber presidency unchecked by the other two branches.

This massive shift of authority threatens the stability and functionality of our tripartite system of checks and balances. To be sure, it did not begin with the Obama administration. The trend has existed for decades, and President George W. Bush showed equal contempt for the separation of powers. However, it has accelerated at an alarming rate under Obama. Of perhaps greater concern is the fact that the other two branches appear passive, if not inert, in the face of expanding executive power.

James Madison fashioned a government of three bodies locked in a synchronous orbit by their countervailing powers. The system of separation of powers was not created to protect the authority of each branch for its own sake. Rather, it is the primary protection of individual rights because it prevents the concentration of power in any one branch. In this sense, Obama is not simply posing a danger to the constitutional system; he has become the very danger that separation of powers was designed to avoid.

A glance at recent unilateral moves by Obama illustrates how executive power has expanded, largely at the cost of legislative power.

The suspension of a portion of the ACA is only the latest such action related to the health care law:

The heart of the health care law was a set of minimum requirements for insurance plans. After Obama was embarrassed by the cancellations of millions of nonconforming plans (when he had said no one would lose a plan they had and liked), he created first one temporary exemption and then, recently, another, adding two years to the compliance deadline set by law.

On his own authority, Obama also chose other dates for compliance with the employer mandate.

Congress ended a subsidy for members of Congress and their staffs so that they would obtain insurance under the ACA on the same terms as other citizens. Obama ordered that the same subsidies would continue, in defiance of the law.

The president has shown similar unilateral inclinations in other areas:

He asked Congress to change the law to exempt from deportation certain classes of immigrants particularly children who are in the U.S. illegally. Congress refused to pass the so-called Dream Act, but Obama proceeded to order agencies to effectively guarantee the very same changes.

The administration ordered all U.S. attorneys to stop prosecuting nonviolent drug crime defendants who would be subject to what Attorney General Eric Holder called draconian mandatory minimum sentences. The new rule effectively negates sentencing provisions set by Congress.

Obama opposed the No Child Left Behind Act and in effect nullified it through waivers of his own making.

For years, the Wire Act was interpreted to mean that Internet gambling was prohibited, which some states and businesses opposed. The Obama administration declared the act would now be treated as having the inverse meaning.

Some of these changes are admittedly close questions, and federal agencies are given considerable discretion in crafting regulations.

For example, the Obama administration repeatedly asked Congress to limit greenhouse gases but was rejected. The administration proceeded to create its own national regulation of the gases along the very lines debated and rejected in Congress. Yet the new regulations are based on a broadly written Clean Air Act and were upheld in part by the Supreme Court. However, this major new regulatory scheme was still initiated without any approval of Congress.

Not even the power of the purse, which belongs exclusively to Congress, is sufficient to deter the White House. The Obama administration took $454 million from a fund established to help prevent illness and put the money instead toward paying for the federal health insurance exchange. Even leading Democratic members denounced this as "a violation of both the letter and spirit of this landmark law."

I happen to agree with many of the president's policies. However, in our system, it is often more important how we do something than what we do. Priorities and policies and presidents change. Democrats will rue the day of their acquiescence to this shift of power when a future president negates an environmental law, or an anti-discrimination law, or tax laws.

To be clear, Obama is not a dictator, but there is a danger in his aggregation of executive power.

Our system is changing in a fundamental way without even a whimper of regret. No one branch in the Madisonian system can go it alone not Congress, not the courts, and not the president. The branches are stuck with each other in a system of shared powers, for better or worse. They may deadlock or even despise one another. The founders clearly foresaw such periods. They lived in such a period.

Whatever problems we face today in politics, they are of our own making. They should not be used to take from future generations a system that has safeguarded our freedoms for more than 200 years.

Los Angeles Times

Jonathan Turley, a law professor at George Washington University, recently testified in Congress on the growing violations of the separation of powers.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I have heard a lot of talking whine about and discount any intrusion on the separation of powers by President Obama, but found this article to be quite interesting, because the issue made is not what the President is doing but rather the process.

Ihappen to agree with many of the president's policies. However, in our system, it is often more important how we do something than what we do. Priorities and policies and presidents change. Democrats will rue the day of their acquiescence to this shift of power when a future president negates an environmental law, or an anti-discrimination law, or tax laws.

To be clear, Obama is not a dictator, but there is a danger in his aggregation of executive power.

Our system is changing in a fundamental way without even a whimper of regret. No one branch in the Madisonian system can go it alone not Congress, not the courts, and not the president. The branches are stuck with each other in a system of shared powers, for better or worse. They may deadlock or even despise one another. The founders clearly foresaw such periods. They lived in such a period.

Whatever problems we face today in politics, they are of our own making. They should not be used to take from future generations a system that has safeguarded our freedoms for more than 200 years.

I do not agree with all of President Obama's policies and agenda nor do I think that the Republicans have all of (or of late any of) the answers to what ails the nation -

The sticking point in my mind is also whether this is right path to put the country on - over concentration of power in the executive branch, since it is logical to assume that future presidents might extend this precedent setting change in executive authority into areas that people who are cheering now might find unsettling.

I guess the question is simple for me - Is the separation of powers, as envisioned by the founders, still important to our country today?

I will be interested to see the answers to that question.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Im surprised that Jonathan Turley, a law professor at George Washington University, could not see the weakness in his own argument. The real executive power grab came during the Bush Administration but putting that aside, rule by Executive Orders is the weakest of all governance and can easily overturned by a change in presidency or a united congress.

Now speaking of our lazy, deadlocked, highly partisan, do-nothing congress, they have a constitutional duty to pass laws which they have not been doing and as such, have abrogated their lawful responsibilities. It is congresses failure that forced this situation.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The president is whining that Congress has forced him to use executive powers to pass legislation because they would not.

What he is overlooking is that those members of Congress were elected by the people of their states. If they are not representing those people, they will be replaced in the next election process. If they ARE representing the will of the people who elected them, that is the American way.

For him to wave around his pen without having the patience to wait for the people to speak via the election process shows him to be a dictator.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Yes, he is, when he feels he cannot wait for due process of Congress. Regardless of what he thinks of filibuster, it is part of government process, and regardless of what you say about the number of people who voted for Obama (I voted for him myself his first term), there are people who did not and who voted Republican for congressional seats.

And I repeat, if they do not like what their elected representatives have done, they will replace them. That is the American process that ensures checks and balances and for a president to consistently use executive powers to override congress shows him to have dictator tendencies.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A P

He mentioned the problems created by the antagonistic and dysfunctional congress, but opined that the consolidation of power in the executive branch was still a matter of concern

I also think that he mentioned that this same phenomena also occurred in the previous administration

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Turley does not say Obama wants to be a dictator, and in fact specifically says that he is not claiming that.

Totally agree - it is not really about President Obama per se but rather the diminishing separation of powers in the federal government process

It may not be surprising that the a move away from the separation of powers envisioned by the founders is happening, but it is still concerning.

I detected no hysteria in the article, he was merely pointing out a phenomena that is occurring in our government and expressing his concern about it, as it is likely to be continued and expanded in the future.

Thanks for the perspective.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

John

It is not about Obama it is about the process and the dangers of the process.

If executive power continues to expand without restraint, then it becomes accepted precedent and could pose challenges or problems down the road.

You mentioned the rules in the House and Senate and the problems they do and can cause. A lot of folks hailed the filibuster rule change as being "necessary" while it was decried by others. What do you suppose the reaction will be, if the Republicans gain control of the Senate this year and eliminate filibusters completely from the Senate effectively eliminating the voice of the minority party?

And if by some miracle they win the presidency (highly unlikely) and not the Senateand useexpanded executive power is used to broaden gun rights, restrict abortion access under government healthcare etc etc

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

John

Mr Turley indeed said that and was rather pointing out that the expansion of executive powers could pose problems and was contrary to the founders model.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

John

While I agree with Mr Turley and you on the president not being a dictator, your question is an interesting one

did Bush (and Obama)have dictator tendencies? (my edit)

I would probably say a tentative yes as to both having tendencies what with the patriot act and the current actions we are seeing, but both did what they did and the point remains that the weakening of separation of powers is not a good thing

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

John, if you have ever taken the time to read a fricking damn thing I have ever posted you would know that hell, yes, I believe Bush had dictator tendencies. I have said so repeatedly when I posted that Bush led us down the path to dictator rule when he implemented the Patriot Act.

When Obama signed it to continue it, he demonstrated that there isn't an honest president in any party that will EVERA give up that power. And now he has shown his idea of presidential power is closer to that of a dictator on a throne, right up there beside Bush.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Everyone seems to be missing the point of the article

It is not whether Bush did it too, or whether Bush and Obama both have the tendencies to be dictatorial, or whether both or neither are asshats.

The point of the article was that the erosion of the separation of powers is bad thing and that the separation is likely to be eroded more and more over time rather than lessening and as the executive branch continues to assume power with restraint we are deviating from the plan of the founders.

That was the point.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Kudos to Jonathon Turley, the hard to find intellectually honest liberal who apparently believes in the increasingly rare principle that the law should apply equally to all. Turley recognizes, that it's not Obama's actual polices that matter, it is the precedent he's set in how he goes about getting them that constitutes such a danger to the Republic. For Turley understands that should a Republican President with as few scruples as Obama every be elected, he could do untold damage to the liberal agenda simply by following the precedents set by Obama.

Obamaism, is of course, Ceaserism, without the brilliance and physical bravery. Like Obama, Caesar was happy to rule through the traditional Roman Constitution when his will was carried out. But the minute his desires were in any way thwarted, Caesar did not hesitate to employ extra constitutional means to get his way. Ultimately, Caesar ended the Roman Republic by starting a civil war that he claimed his opponents forced him into by not giving him everything he wanted. Hundreds of thousands died so Caesar wouldn't have his political will checked in any way.

The principle is echoed today by every Obama acolyte who claims the Republicans forced him to act unconstitutionally by not giving Obama everything he asks for when he asks for it. Because today's left doesn't view the law with the same general principles that have governed our nation since its founding. The founders, and independent thinkers today, believe that a law or precedent applies equally to all. Thus independent thinkers often reason by analogy to oppose Obama's power grabs, because they recognize that principle relied onby Obama henceforth apply generally, not just to the specific situation liberals want it to.

An argument based on generally applicable principles doesn't work with many liberals because their concept of the Constitution is consists of "What I like is constitutional what I don't, isn't." Thus the President can ignore immigration laws and direct INS not to enforce parts of the law he doesn't like without a peep from liberals who like the policy. But if a Republican President were to follow Obama's lead and order the IRS not to enforce collection of income above 20%, the Left would believe the country had ended.

For instance many of the people foaming at the mouth over the recent Arizona law being discriminatory, also believe that gay baker should not be forced by the government to make a cake that says "God Hates Fags." Similarly, as David French has pointed out, there is no chance that liberal judge would ever force a Mulsim Student Group to admit a hostile Jew to the group because that would be discriminatory. But that same judge will damn well force a Christian student group to admit an atheist without blinking an eye. Principles don't matter to many liberals, only getting their polices implemented by any means necessary does.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I didn't say they were unconstitutional, I said they were dictatorial. That is my opinion. As to being hyperbolic, that is my personality, one I have developed after years of working with the government and the public and being a good little soldier and having to keep my mouth shut at all the sleazy underhanded back room agreements that sometimes WERE unconstitutional and illegal, to boot.

Now in addition to being hyperbolic, I am a conspiracy theorist as well and it still amazes me how often my theories are correct.

Obama has used his little pen more often than any other president, I believe; now, how often do you think the next president, and the next, will use theirs? Once something has been cracked open, it is never sealed properly again.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Sean, today is the day I have to agree with you.41.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The real executive power grab came during the Bush Administration

Responses to acts of war usually have that kind of result . Terrorist acts may not be war under the formal definition but it is still a type of war . That makes Bush's acts justifiable based on historical precedent .
But Obama was not acting in response to war or terrorism . He has been usurping powers that belong to congress.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

did Bush have dictator tendencies? He did the same thing.

Responses to acts of war usually have that kind of result . Terrorist acts may not be war under the formal definition but it is still a type of war . That makes Bush's acts justifiable based on historical precedent .
But Obama was not acting in response to war or terrorism . He has been usurping powers that belong to congress.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

all hail the king

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Who stole your fish, fish?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago
  • it is not really about President Obama per se but rather the diminishing separation of powers in the federal government process

Now that is a truism. When congress abdicates their constitutional duties and responsibilities, it creates a power vacuum. It works for both sides .

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Not everyone. I read the article and found you are spot on in your assessment. While I can mount a good argument that the extremists on the Republican side are causing this deadlock, it does create too tempting of an opportunity for Obama (or any president) to slowly usurp congressional authority.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Appreciate the perspective

The author acknowledges the obstructive Congress as a factor in the actions being currently taken, but still sees the eroding separation of powers as a bad thing

As do I

Thanks again for the perspective

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Professor Jonathan Turley

You can view the video provided and/or hear the professor with the audio portion provided below the video since the video is very low volume.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

You may view this video if you are an exempt employee. There will be no overtime paid, understand?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The terrorists won . Bush started the reaction to terrorism but Obama expanded it [even though he campaigned that he was opposed to Bush's excesses ] .

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

The rise of the fourth branch of government

Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro professor of public interest law at George Washington University.

There were times this past week when it seemed like the 19th-century Know-Nothing Party had returned to Washington. President Obama insisted he knew nothing about major decisions in the State Department, or the Justice Department, or the Internal Revenue Service. The heads of those agencies, in turn, insisted they knew nothing about major decisions by their subordinates. It was as if the government functioned by some hidden hand.

Clearly, there was a degree of willful blindness in these claims. However, the suggestion that someone, even the president, is in control of todays government may be an illusion.

The growing dominance of the federal government over the states has obscured more fundamental changes within the federal government itself: It is not just bigger, it is dangerously off kilter. Our carefully constructed system of checks and balances is being negated by the rise of a fourth branch, an administrative state of sprawling departments and agencies that govern with increasing autonomy and decreasing transparency.

For much of our nations history, the federal government was quite small. In 1790, it had just 1,000 nonmilitary workers. In 1962, there were 2,515,000 federal employees. Today, we have 2,840,000 federal workers in 15 departments, 69 agencies and 383 nonmilitary sub-agencies.

This exponential growth has led to increasing power and independence for agencies. The shift of authority has been staggering. The fourth branch now has a larger practical impact on the lives of citizens than all the other branches combined.

Great Article Continue Reading

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

One thing that is happening is Congress and the Judicial Branch are becoming less significant while the Executive Branch and Regulatory Agencies are becoming more significant.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

You don't like the "Pure Food and Drug Act". Excuse me all to hell but I do.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

These are definitely not all Obama Executive Orders, but looks like somewhere other than what we think is the USA.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Dennis, you are correct but don't expect a response on that one. Actually we were able to obstruct some of Obama's policies but we were not able to obstruct the propaganda by the Obama Media. A liberal law professor, Jonathan Turley, ended this article by coming out and telling the truth about the direction this country is heading on either page 5 or 6 of this article. The jest of the speech is only about 30 minutes and clearly explains the direction we are heading in "Jonathan Turley warns America it is at a Tipping Point in the 21st Century." It is well worth the time to watch it.

 
 

Who is online


103 visitors