The hard lives — and high suicide rate — of Native American children on reservations
SACATON, ARIZ. The tamarisk tree down the dirt road from Tyler Owenss house is the one where the teenage girl who lived across the road hanged herself. Dont climb it, dont touch it, admonished Owenss grandmother when Tyler, now 18, was younger.
There are other taboo markers around the Gila River Indian reservation eight young people committed suicide here over the course of a single year.
Were not really open to conversation about suicide, Owens said. Its kind of like a private matter, a sensitive topic. If a suicide happens, youre there for the family. Then after that, its kind of just, like, left alone.
But the silence that has shrouded suicide in Indian country is being pierced by growing alarm at the sheer number of young Native Americans taking their own lives more than three times the national average, and up to 10 times on some reservations.
A toxic collection of pathologies poverty, unemployment, domestic violence, sexual assault, alcoholism and drug addiction has seeped into the lives of young people among the nations 566 tribes. Reversing their crushing hopelessness, Indian experts say, is one of the biggest challenges for these communities.
The circumstances are absolutely dire for Indian children, said Theresa M. Pouley, the chief judge of the Tulalip Tribal Court in Washington state and a member of the Indian Law and Order Commission.
Pouley fluently recites statistics in a weary refrain: One-quarter of Indian children live in poverty, versus 13 percent in the United States. They graduate high school at a rate 17 percent lower than the national average. Their substance-abuse rates are higher. Theyre twice as likely as any other race to die before the age of 24. They have a 2.3percent higher rate of exposure to trauma. They have two times the rate of abuse and neglect. Their experience with post-traumatic stress disorder rivals the rates of returning veterans from Afghanistan.
In one of the broadest studies of its kind, the Justice Department recently created a national task force to examine the violence and its impact on American Indian and Alaska Native children, part of an effort to reduce the number of Native American youth in the criminal justice system. The level of suicide has startled some task force officials, who consider the epidemic another outcome of what they see as pervasive despair.
Last month, the task force held a hearing on the reservation of the Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community in Scottsdale. During their visit, Associate Attorney General Tony West, the third-highest-ranking Justice Department official, and task force members drove to Sacaton, about 30 miles south of Phoenix, and met with Owens and 14 other teenagers.
How many of you know a young person who has taken their life? the task forces co-chairman asked. All 15 raised their hands.
That floored me, West said.
A trail of broken promises
There is an image that Byron Dorgan, co-chairman of the task force and a former senator from North Dakota, cant get out of his head. On the Spirit Lake Nation in North Dakota years ago, a 14-year-old girl named Avis Little Wind hanged herself after lying in bed in a fetal position for 90 days. Her death followed the suicides of her father and sister.
She lay in bed for all that time, and nobody, not even her school, missed her, said Dorgan, a Democrat who chaired the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs. Eventually she got out of bed and killed herself. Avis Little Wind died of suicide because mental-health treatment wasnt available on that reservation.
Indian youth suicide cannot be looked at in a historical vacuum, Dorgan said. The agony on reservations is directly tied to a trail of broken promises to American Indians, he said, noting treaties dating back to the 19th century that guaranteed but largely didnt deliver health care, education and housing.
When he retired after 30 years in Congress, Dorgan founded the Center for Native American Youth at the Aspen Institute to focus on problems facing young Indians, especially the high suicide rates.
The children bear the brunt of the misery, Dorgan said, adding that tribal leaders are working hard to overcome the challenges. But there is no sense of urgency by our country to do anything about it.
At the first hearing of the Justice Department task force, in Bismarck, N.D., in December, Sarah Kastelic, deputy director of the National Indian Child Welfare Association, used a phrase that comes up repeatedly in deliberations among experts: historical trauma.
Youth suicide was once virtually unheard of in Indian tribes. A system of child protection, sustained by tribal child-rearing practices and beliefs, flourished among Native Americans, and everyone in a community was responsible for the safeguarding of young people, Kastelic said.
Child maltreatment was rarely a problem, said Kastelic, a member of the native village of Ouzinkie in Alaska, because of these traditional beliefs and a natural safety net.
But these child-rearing practices were often lost as the federal government sought to assimilate native people and placed children often against their parents wishes in boarding schools that were designed to immerse Indian children in Euro-American culture.
In many cases, the schools, mostly located off reservations, were centers of widespread sexual, emotional and physical abuse. The transplantation of native children continued into the 1970s; there were 60,000 children in such schools in 1973 as the system was being wound down. They are the parents and grandparents of todays teenagers.
Michelle Rivard-Parks, a University of North Dakota law professor who has spent 10 years working in Indian country as a prosecutor and tribal lawyer, said that the aftermath of attempts to assimilate American and Alaska Natives remains ever present ... and is visible in higher-than-average rates of suicide.
The Justice Department task force is gathering data and will not offer its final recommendations to Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. on ways to mitigate violence and suicide until this fall. For now, West, Dorgan and other members are listening to tribal leaders and experts at hearings on reservations around the country.
We know that the road to involvement in the juvenile justice system is often paved by experiences of victimization and trauma, West said. We have a lot of work to do. There are too many young people in Indian country who dont see a future for themselves, who have lost all hope.
The testimony West is hearing is sometimes bitter, and witnesses often come forward with great reluctance.
Its tough coming forward when youre a victim, said Deborah Parker, 43, the vice chair of the Tulalip Tribes in Washington state. You have to relive what happened. ... A reservation is like a small town, and you can face a backlash.
Parker didnt talk about her sexual abuse as a child until two years ago, when she publicly told of being repeatedly raped when she was the size of a couch cushion.
Indian child-welfare experts say that the staggering number of rapes and sexual assaults of Native American women have had devastating effects on mothers and their children.
A majority of our girls have struggled with sexual and domestic violence not once but repeatedly, said Parker, who has started a program to help young female survivors and try to prevent suicide. One of my girls, Sophia, was murdered on my reservation by her partner. Another one of our young girls took her life.
Stories of violence and abuse
Owens recalls how she used to climb the tamarisk tree with her cousin to look for the nests of mourning doves and pigeons until the suicide of the 16-year-old girl. The next year, the girls distraught father hanged himself in the same tree.
He was devastated and he was drinking, and he hung himself too, Owens said.
She and a good friend, Richard Stone, recently talked about their broken families and their own histories with violence. When Owens was younger, her uncle physically abused her until her mother got a restraining order. Stone, 17, was beaten by his alcoholic mother.
Both Owens and Stone dream about leaving the rez. Owens hopes to get an internship in Washington and have a career as a politician; Stone wants to someday be a counselor or a psychiatrist.
Owens sometimes rides her bike out into the alfalfa and cotton fields near Sacaton, the tiny town named after the coarse grasses that once grew on the Sonoran Desert land belonging to the Akimel OOdham and Pee Posh tribes. She and her friends sing a peaceful, healing song she learned from the elders about a bluebird who flies west at night, blessing the sun and bringing on the moon and stars.
One recent evening, as the sun dipped below the Sierra Estrella mountains, the two made their way to Owenss backyard. They climbed onto her trampoline and began jumping in the moonlight, giggling like teenagers anywhere in America.
But later this month on the reservation, they will take on an adult task. Owens, Stone and a group of other teenagers here will begin a two-day course on suicide prevention. A hospital intervention trainer will engage them in role-playing and teach them how to spot the danger signs.
In Indian country, youths need to have somebody there for them, Owens said. I wish I had been that somebody for the girl in the tamarisk tree.
There is a short slide show within the following linked article:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/the-hard-lives--and-high-suicide-rate--of-native-american-children/2014/03/09/6e0ad9b2-9f03-11e3-b8d8-94577ff66b28_story.html

Many of us think our family dynamics aretypical and at least half-way normal. That is not so for those who live in Indian Country. They live and suffer in a world most people know little about.
Isn't it time to start caring?
It is impossible to place a price tag on what Native Americans have contributed to the historical and current fabric that is the United States. It is just as impossible to place a price tag on what they have suffered at the hands of officials in the way of unkept promises.
Somewhere a balancing of the accounts have to take place.
Dear Friend Al-316: It is long past time to start, but never too late to begin caring.
There are things which can be done to address, prevent, and reduce suicide. They require resources. What is the price tag of a human life?
Thank you for being a voice in the wilderness on this topic of pressing humanitarian concern.
Among the things North America needs to prioritize addressing are the very preventable high suicidal rates among segments of our population. Native Americans, Veterans, Students, the poor, indigent, infirm, elderly, disabled, mental hygiene challenged, substance abusing, physically, emotionally and intimately abused are prime among them. There are many who fit into a number of these categories.
There are opportunities to attract and engage resources for this problem. Every year billions of dollars in grants go untapped. Grant writers for tribes as for veterans groups can train and employ grant writing advocates to get the funds needed to address underlying causes. The tribes themselves can work to restore the indigenous cultures which protect their children.
May the Great Spirit Who Creates Life Help Guide and Motivate Us to Preserve and Improve It for One Another.
Enoch.
Thank you for this article. It was not only informative, but heart-breaking.
The first step toward solving a problem is recognition of the problem, and this article highlights the feelings of hopelessness so often experienced by our American Indian youth. It is a sad commentary that the reservations are a prison from which there is little hope for escape.
I hope that our tribes can have the resources needed to work through these problems. One thing that must change, is our national blindness to the problems of the American Indian peoples. Another, is the prevalent attitude that because they are Indians, it doesn't matter. Our history of treatment of the Indians has been utterly deplorable, which still continues today.
Again, thank you for this article.
There are some of us who think we are better then others around us.
If analyzed closely, I think anaccurate conclusion would be that some of us are better "off" than others.Too many times one person's difficulties are caused by another person's accidental and, sometimes, deliberate actions.
Thank you for your wise perceptions, Enoch.
I could not agree more, FLYNAVY1.
I think your use of the word "fabric" is perfect. I wish that I had thought of it. Thanks.
I've been living overseas on projects for the last few years. One of the things that has been driven home to me is that everyone in the United States (except NAs) came from somewhere else. Our diversity is truly one of our strengths that too many want to ignore. To continue to ignore this fact will cost us in every way imaginable at an ever greater rate.
I am in total agreement with you, Dowser.
As FLYNAVY! said, Native American Indians have contributed so much to the rich fabric of this country, and it was readily accepted. Why is it so difficult for us to acknowledge that and help them as they helped us in our time of need?
America is well known for its generosity and willingness to help others, but we sure fall short when it comes to recognizing the needs of our Indian brothers and sisters.
Thank you for your input, my friend.
Since we created a "system" that is the root cause of the majority of problems, we should have a responsibility toward cleaning it up. The "system" is not working, and has never worked, and has only destroyed the very core of the many tribal cultures.
Take care!
Al-316 - I know you don't want to hear this - but - I am glad you put this onthe front forum in a very big way. Yes, we'll get John and Aeon disputing everything that is said but who gives a shit. This is an everyday occurrence with us - our young people have nothing to live for because the U. S. government has and is doing their damnedest to keep us as a fourthworld country - way below the third worldrate, poverty stricken people in other countries.
Wind River reservation and Rocky Mountain reservation had stories such as this last year - and they are just the tip of the iceberg.
Thank you so much for the "picture" - I hope it gives some folks nightmares - they deserve them.
Hmmmm.........
1stwarrior. Should I find any irony in your statement given one of your more recent posts that makes use of statements like "his people"?
My intention is to not derail this important seed, but at the root of everything that is wrong with different races is the fact that we have unfortunately separated them.
Well, it's not actually the separation of races FLYNAVY - the Indians, unfortunately, hold two positions in the U. S. - a racial and a political. Right now, with this thread, it is a political position that has placed the Indians ina the lower level of concern by the U. S. government. 471 treaties signed and ratified between the two governments - all of which have been broken by the U. S (and stated in the above article), of which, the vast majority of them contained agreements - for the loss of your millions of acres of land, we will give you, until perpetuity, education, health care, housing, infrastructure maintenance, etc.. Congress, year after year, has reduced the funding for those programs until it has gotten to the point that there is almost no funding for the most important concerns - health care, housing and education. I seriously don't believe Congress has turned it into a racial "his people" - they are still operating under the political "those people".
My mistake then 1st.
I was lucky as grew up in the same town where Haskel Indian Junior College resides. As far back as I can remember, we were immersed in Indian culture and history as we had students from various tribes in almost every on of our classes through high school. I think we all came to the same conclusion that we need to be better at helping everyone.
You grew up in Lawrence???? Did/do you know Jesse James? (real name, believe me). He's lived there his whole life, is Indian, went to Haskell - great friend.
1stwarrior, my friend, I think most of us knowthe conditions described in this article are not unique to theGila River Indian reservation; nor is this a recently discovered problem.
It may sound cold and clinical to say this, but it seems endangered species get more attention and a let's-do-something-about-thisreaction then the plight of the American Indian.
No - facts, while seemingly cold, are, in reality, not -because they "should" cause you to do a reality check. Not toagitate the situation, reality checks for the Indian peoples never occurs in the U. S. - remember - " We are invisible. "
That is an excellent statement, 1stwarrior.
The problem I see in the way the groups keep trying to help the teens is this:
In addition to sending professionals to talk with and help the teens they need to be concentrating also on the adults who parent them. As the article stated, the parents and grandparents of these children and teens are the victims of the boarding schools. They were held against their will away from their families and stripped to the bone of their identities, their culture, their religion, their language, their innocence, their trust... young children lose their balance, their center, when they learn their parents are not the strength that can protect them from all evil.
Then they are returned, almost grown, in effect total strangers, to parents and grandparents and relatives and neighbors and a culture they no longer know and have been told is savage and evil and even unlawful in the eyes of this government they must obey. But wait! Now the Elders are saying it is okay to have the Old Ways, to relearn them, it was all a mistake, so GET OVER IT! Be an Indian.
The term "Post Traumatic Stress Disorder" doesn't even come close to what these returning young people must have felt and now, as adults, they struggle to try and bridge the gap between the call of the blood and the way of the white world.
FLYNAVY1, they do not want to give up the reservations, because they are sacred lands, the last of what belongs to them of what was forcibly taken. I have seen others comment that Indians should leave the rez and assimilate, but there is a spirituality to the culture requires the touchstone of the land connection.
The adults, the parents, need to be counseled for anything to work for the teens. They have to be given a heartfelt apology, in an intimate setting, by a person who admits to them they were wronged, they were abused and IT WAS NOT THEIR FAULT. Do it in a school gym, bring in the state senator, no TV cameras.
But the first step to healing this problem is for somebody to admit to the victims that there was a monster who was too big for them to fight, too big for their parents to slay, who hurt them. "I represent that monster, the US government, and I am so sorry. It was not your fault, what was done to you."
Those teens can't be help by counseling when they have to go home to someone more broken than they are.
OK, now I'm gonna cry - perfect mimi - perfect.
Did he have a drag car by chance back in the 1970s, or hang out at a bar called "Trails End"?
And that, unfortunately, is a very sad truth - that's why we will remain "invisible" to them.
And, as long as this present administration is in office, the poverty level is going to rise.
If you compare the way of the Native American to that of Western civilization the answer is obvious. They are completely opposed to each other. For instance, there is in Ojibwe culture the story of the Weendigo, the most fearsome of all creatures in Indian lore who descends on a village when its inhabitants become immersed in the sin of greed and self-gratification.
The Weendigo cannot be killed and will devour every person in the village until the people turn away from their selfishness and greed. Not exactly the philosophy of the Western idea of capitalism and "if-it-feels-good-do-it."
Another Indian Tribe believes that the measure of how wealthy you are is in what you are able to give away and share with family and other Tribal members, that it angers the Creator to selfishly hoard more than you can personally use.
I could go on, but as you can see, there is indeed a diametric opposition to the two cultures. It is not merely folk lore but goes to the soul of the Indian and those who ignore the tenants of the culture of their Tribe probably fight their own demons. Only when they walk on will they, and only they, know if the material gain was worth the compromise. (I am speaking here of those who indulge in illegal acts such as cheating fellow Tribal members, especially as concerns casino funds and things of that nature.)
This is the end resultof ''assimilation experiments'' by the US government. If your goal is to destroy a culture, the government calls it assimilation, this is what you get.
IMO, the government couldn't give a shit about Indian people. They only come to us when it times for the ''fund raisers'', lot's of promises, no result.
The best line that I've read is when the administration was holding a fund raiser, they were asking the Indian tribes to purchase tickets from $2500 to $10,000. One representative of a tribe said, and I'm paraphrasing here, when they keep a promise I'll think about donating. He then left the meeting.
It's not just this administration, but it's the practice of all administrations. Some are worse than others.
Kavika and 1swarrior,
In your experiences with political minions, do you find that they are even aware that all Indians are not the same, that there is not one voice for the entire collective of Indian People, that there is not one "Tribe" that can be brought under the control of one person?
Americans answer to many descriptions and hail from fifty different states and the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico, can be Republicans or Democrats or Independents or Libertarians, conservatives or liberals, but when is all is said and done, we are all under the umbrella of one President.
Do you find that politicians understand the concept of Indian Nations and their individuality?
There are some politicians that I've meet and a few that I read about that do know, and work very hard for Indians. Most, have little knowledge of Indians, our history etc. This is at the federal level mimi.
Those at a state level, county orcity, that I've meet are a mixed bag, some know nothing, some a little, some a fair amount.
The ones that impress me are the ones that want to learn and understand that Indians are part of their district.
This is only my experience mimi.
In all seriousness mimi - at least 60% have no knowledge of Indians except what they've sorta learned in school.
Good case in point - NT - look at who is reviewing and commenting on this thread, a thread that is very vital and digs deep into our souls and history. Why??? Because it is not taught in schools and we aren't the ones who are doing the teaching.
Most people who are not Indian have no idea how to even talk with an Indian, which, in my opinion, would help our kids tremendously by giving them acceptance, by letting them know that they are OK being who and what they are instead of ridiculing them without knowing they are doing it. Education can and will go a long way to helping our kids - but the outside world needs the education, not us.
1st, most every thread re Indians is ignored, except for a few of our non Indian friends. Now if the article is controversial, the ''clique'' will show up with their usual bullshit.
That is a fact of life, one that is not likely to change anytime soon. It's easier to blame us for everything, call us haters, drunks, etc then it is to accept the facts that this article points out. Yesterday was the perfect example.
We've had 139 views and seven people are commenting. Other people have to have views - why don't they voice them?
OK, that'll be another thread.
I think much of it goes to exposure.
Because I grew up in Lawrence, with Haskel in my backyard, was my NA exposure greater than people in other states, or parts of the Union? I have no way of gauging because I don't know any different.
Having a major university like KU in a small town, we had people from around the world bringing their cultures to us. My father in the early 1970s would have his engineering students over to our house for steak, pizza or burgers every semester. I remember Saudi students drinking beer, and laughing right next to Iranian students. The whole idea of racism is foreign to me, and it still is today.
1st, IMO the number of views is deceiving. Each time anyone, author or anyone else checks in, it's shown as a view.
I doubt if there were 139 separate people checking out the article.
Mrs D and I spoke for three hours yesterday about the ignorance of most people in this country about the situation with Indians and real life on the reservations. She said until she had met Kavika she had no idea Indians still lived on reservations, then qualified that with the statement that she had no idea of the poor quality of life, the abject poverty and lack of basic necessities on so many of them.
I told her that, growing up in the Deep South, we knew Indians were still on reservations, but we also did not know of the extreme poverty of places such as Pine Ridge or the lack of the US government to honor any treaties, or the theft of resources, or that Indians did not even own the land of the reservations.
Our vacations were always spent in the Smoky Mountains which is the home of the Cherokee reservation there, and of course all we ever saw was prosperity, beautiful Indians in the shops, and sitting down with us in the cafes and restaurants. We never knew that other reservations around the country were not as well off.
Another thing Mrs D observed was that while children in the inner cities living in poverty were disadvantaged compared to those with parents of higher incomes, even they were more advantaged than children living on reservations where the US government has miserably failed to live up to its treaties and commitments. Low incomechildren still manage to avail themselves of cell phones, ipods, television, even computers.. if not in their homes most can take a trip to the library or their schools have them available.
Indian children on many reservations don't have access to these luxuries are lucky if they live within 100 miles of a school.
There is a gross lack of information about the life of Indians in this country but the shameful truth is, the activist organizations that could bring about change in the perceptions don't give a damn and because no one is poking them with a cattle prod, neither do the politicians. This keeps the general population living with their myths of the "good life" of living as an Indian, free off the welfare of the government.
Mimi, I always look forward to your comments. They are interesting and add vibrancy which gives new dimensions to the topic. Thank you for sharing your perspective.
Generally speaking, squeaky wheels get the oil.
Compared to the number and the volume of squeaks generated by other groups, the Indian squeak never seems to get worse if you just listen.
When the squeak gets unbearably loud,people will listen. Then they will look and address the problems just to get the squeak to go away.
What is it going to take to change that even with the membership here?
Consider this a microcosm of the bigger national picture. Two suggestions:
1) Ask a member of you group write a specific opinion piece to open dialog as to why NA issues are not heard either nationally, or even here on NT.
2) Ask that non member you noted to do the same.
Sounds to me like a Neale and Kavika deal again. They used to do that on NV and had some really great threads and discussions.
Let me ask the NA crowd this question.....
Does some of the "invisibility" of Native Americans come from what I see as "quiet pride"? Just thinking about things for a second or two, I started thinking about Ira Hayes and what he went through as one of the men on Mt. Suribachi. I know that is making broad generalizations, but is it a component of it?
Thinking about some of the guest speakers we had in school growing up. One I'm remembering was Kiowa, and I think he said something along the lines of you being less than a man if you cannot feed the women and children of your tribe. Is the historical pressure to becoming what is considered a man, walled off by what can be achieved by many on the reservations?
I can't put my thoughts into words right now. It's like threading a needle with a sledgehammer.
We never advertise ourselves - that is pure selfishness. We will "always" ensure the proper person gets the respect they deserve. If, hypothetically, I caused a good thing to happen, I will give credit to the person who gave me the idea - because it was their idea and not mine.
FLY, you bring up some good points. From a cultural point of view, for the Ojibwe, the greatest human failing, is greed and selfishness. To point out what ''we'' have done would be considered self serving. The credit, for what ever is accomplished, is to be shared with others that may have a hand in it.
The Ojibwe story of the ''Weendigo'' is explains this very well.
Got you message, and replied. Looks like I have some homework to do.
As Kavika, 1st, and Gunny know, I have always felt that one reason Indians don't get the exposure that would propel them into the forefront of public awareness is because they cannot come together as "one" Indian bloc the way blacks and Hispanics do, to form a political power.
Each Indian Nation has its leader, and to try unite them all under one banner would be akin to bringing all the countries on Earth under one single voice to deal with an alien visitor from the Andromeda Galaxy.
To my knowledge, only Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull were ever able to bring more than one Indian Nation together against a common enemy.
Horribly sad , that's all I can say.
Yeah, well there was this fella called Tecumseh - from up North - who also did a decent job 'til Jackson got his brother killed.
No, Indians have always and probably will always maintain autonomy with their self-government. They have fought and died for the "right" to govern "their" people and they will protect that right 'til they die. That's just our way.
I know, 1st. I'm not and never would advocate that Indians lose that autonomy; I just wish Indians had more political clout to rattle those squeaky wheels.
Think I'll post a little article/thread of, pretty much, how we got here. Deals with a study called the Merriam Report and the resultant Indian Reorganization Act. It has been a long and horrible road.
Saw you posted that thread. On my way over there now.
History seems to confirm your suspicions, Mimi. This would help explain why some of the persistent problems never seem to find a remedy.
Assuming, for the moment, that you are correct ... thatsolidarity amongst the hundreds of tribes for any purpose is unlikely, what hope is there for the future?
I don't know, Al. We have hashed this over at great length, and I just don't know. If even the leaders of the different Nations could come together at the same time for a single, unifying platform, it would help. A slogan like, "This Land Is My Land" or something.
But they need to act, and soon.
It is almost as though each tribe does not recognize that they each share a common past and a common present.
Nor are they willing to put aside any real or perceived differences so that they can unite to accomplish a common goal.
Maybe this attitude is what causes activists and supporters to give up and walk away.
Now wait a minute 1stwarrior. I've been working all week. Most of you guys must be retired or something. I just looked at the one about the Saudi preacher or whatever he was tonight. It already had way over two hundred comments I believe it was. I don't know how many views it had or maybe I have that backward, but Perrie had already closed it down by the time I got to it.
I think it is a little unfair to make that accusation in such a blanket manner. I have to say when I see we don't need the education, they need it, is it the same when someone shoots your brother or keeps breaking into everyone's homes? Do you or the homeowners need the education? Where does this line of thinking come from?
It is not my intention to anger anyone. Let me say suicide is also genetic. And I'm not repeating something I've read. I know this from a very personal perspective. If you have no one in your family who has committed suicide or killed someone then it will probably never happen in your family, but it also works the other way as well.
I can't remember the name of the article or what it was about that I saw on NT maybe a month or so ago. The thought had not even crossed my mind that people avoid articles because of prejudices against another race, but I have to say I didn't see anyone I've seen thus far on this article, with the exception of maybe two and I remember it was an atrocity against someone in my opinion at that time and involved someone white. It kind of hit me like a rock that the reason may have been "good they're getting theirs" and I wondered if it were true, my feelings, that is. Coming back to this after finishing my comment: Now I think I remember what it was. If I'm not mistaken, it was about the girl taken away from her parents by the hospital. I may be wrong.
You see, most of you know each other evidently from the vine and I know none of you from the vine. I'm kind of like the outsider here and in some cases the uninvited guest.
Now to get back to the main subject which is why and what can be done about the elevated suicides being committed by Indians. You are correct, I don't know Indians as each of you do. I do know one thing, there is a concerted effort to eliminate the family in this country. I think having family is the most important thing in a person's life. Let me say family doesn't have to be blood brothers either.
Let me give you an example. This will be on my father's side. My great grand parents lived quite a distance from the nearest town. I was so fortunate to have 4 great grand parents who I would go and stay with when I was growing up. All I had to do was run across a field to arrive at either a great aunt or great uncle's house and let me tell you neither ever had any paint on them, nor did they have any running water or electricity, just two wood stoves, one for cooking and one in the main room for a place to be during the winter to gather with all the other family members. I had cousins, not just 1st cousins but 3rd cousins and more. Now that was family. My grand parents never lived any further than a mile or two from their parents. My parents, their children 10 miles and now we are in my generation. It's a 3 hr drive to see either my brother or sister in two different directions and I have cousins who live in Australia and all over the USA including Alaska.
Their children for the most part are good, but some have been in trouble usually from drugs or alcohol. These are two things that have to be eliminated from our family, since they are not conducive to a well balanced family or person. I would imagine that to be the case with Indians as well. An all out effort to rid alcohol from their lives and ours.
People even when they are poor have to reach out to others to promote a more healthy atmosphere for children to grow up in. Being poor doesn't automatically produce crime. I know this personally as well as I'm sure many of you do. In fact most poor people today have many more things than I had growing up and I bet more than most of you as well and we didn't seem to have the problems we have today.
A person with a good heart will not commit a crime against himself or another. You are blessed. Your ancestors suffered greatly and from that you are blessed. And you wonder how can he say such a thing? Well maybe your blessing has also been a curse as well. You see, I have to use myself when I say I wasn't given anything and so there was never anything taken away from me. I know I'll never be able to see it through your eyes so forgive me if I may seem hard when I say stand up and be all you can. Don't ever blame anything on anyone else unless all of your life has to be attributed to someone else and you have never had the ability to make it your life.
You know, if you don't fill your heart and mind with positive possibilities they will fill with hopelessness and desperation.
Well, I read every comment on this article and I can tell you that you can talk until you turn blue in the face, but until you put your ideas, which evidently have been around since the vine, into action, nothing is going to happen especially on here other than talk. You have to get into the machine. If you want to be a country western star, you must go to Nashville, so to speak. In the few years I've been here no one has changed their personal feelings enough to notice any difference. It's the same old people with the same old beliefs and opinions they had when they started. Now I have to say when I read the article about the "Redskins" some time back, I learned so much and it changed me forever. We all may have different political opinions, but there is no doubt the Indians really suffered during the early days of people from all over the world coming here.
If you really want to help, then you must go to the locations where these people are suffering and make videos or even movies. You must put this in front of the American people even in small segments. You must come together. You must organize. If you refuse to assimilate and don't get me wrong, I don't want to either, but you have to speak loudly and paint a big picture right in front of the American people.
It appears many of you are capable of doing these things. If you are retired then you must have more time to do these things. The problem with people like me is I have to work everyday while many can protest every day. While they are protesting I'm getting the shaft, but I don't have time to protect my interest.
Often we complain about how bad greed is and assume because someone has made a lot of money or even a modest amount more than average it is greed. If you want something other than Capitalism, what would it be? If each of you were worth millions of dollars the problem would be solved, right? Organizing and setting up a means for people to donate can bring in a lot of money if it is operated properly. You can't just sit here calculate, plan, talk and complain and expect anything to change unless you take action.
ABC and PBS have done extensive videos of the present conditions of the people on the reservations. Those videos have been shown widely to the general public who just happen to have ABC and PBS on their cable menu.
Very, very few congressional leaders and members EVER go to a reservation to substantiate what the Indians and the public is telling them. So, quite simply, you don't see a problem, then there ain't a problem. The last major political figure to go to a reservation for an in-depth review was Clinton in 1994. He stood there, on national television, and told the tribes that he would "Make" industries come to Indian country and introduce industrial complexes to the Indian communities and would offer huge tax incentives to industries for initiating business on Tribal lands. NO industry came to the reservations - NO tax initiatives were given - NOTHING was done to bring business opportunities to the reservations.
I could go on forever about what we, the Indian peoples, are doing and attempting to do to get out of our tracks - much of it dealing with your comments. But as long as CONGRESS and SCOTUS sincerely believe and act as though they have "Plenary" power over us - nothing's gonna happen.
I truly believe that unless there is an "uprising" that catches the attention of the media to the extent that it is broadcast nation-wide and raises the awareness of the public, things will not change.
That is the way the blacks and the Hispanics effected change and continue to do so... by media exposure.
Robert - dominant society had physicians available for all if they needed. The tribes had none which is why the health care clause was placed in a vast majority of treaties. As such, health/medical care clinics were built and staffed on the reservations until Congress decided they were spending too much money on the Indian problem so the funding got cut and the facilities and staff went away.
Can't very well live out in the open with no covering, so the Feds said they would furnish the Indians with housing - not necessarily water, heat, air, bathrooms - but that they would place a roof over their heads. Again - Congress blah, blah, blah, blah.
Hopefully you're not suggesting that the Indians don't deserve medical and housing?
I agree. There needs to be some noise to attract and keep peoples attention.
I just discovered an organization called "The Federation of United Tribes". It is new, but has a great web site:
Robert, back in those days, the Indians traded all that they had on promises made by the government.
We know now that the Indians kept their side of the agreement and the government failed to keep their side.
When you ask the question regarding the "general population benefit", are you referring to the Indian population or the non-Indian population?
Robert, back in those days, the Indians traded all that they had on promises made by the government.
We know now that the Indians kept their side of the agreement and the government failed to keep their side.
When you ask the question regarding the "general population benefit", are you referring to the Indian population or the non-Indian population?
Totally concur John - sadly, we were really never a part of "main-stream" America because we wish to maintain our self-governance. But, in the 1890 census, there were only 250,000 Indians out of 120 million that had been here when the Euros arrived, not a whole hell of a lot we could've done to gain the support of the larger community.
We are trying to grow - to gain that self-sufficiency - but there are a myriad of obstacles we have to overcome - specifically laws placed in our paths to impede our progress.
Hmmm - interesting and also right up the neighborhood of Kavika.
You are correct John.
Had Indians been allowed to trade their resources and land one on one with the settlers instead of with the government, and had the backing of local law enforcement (such as it existed at the time) to see that their transactions were honored, they would be the wealthiest people in the land today.
Unfortunately, they were forced to deal only with the US government, and there is no need to say again how that has turned out.
Oh believe me Robert - we have stopped thinking that
Thanks for your input.
Truer words were never spoken - sad but true.
Looking back, should the Indians have entered into those treaties? Probably not. But in actuality, the Indians really had no choice.
Much like what we are seeing in Crimea and Ukraine today, a much superior military might is exercising that power through clever words and intimidation. If Russia persists and invades Ukraine as it has in Crimea, The people of Ukraine may fight, but Russia will prevail. The Indians had no allies to come to their rescue.
The Indians accepted the best terms they could negotiate, but I think they suspected they would have a heck of a time enforcing those agreements because they had no leverage. Nor did they really have a choicebut to trust in the government; then and now.
And remember, the treaties were written in the White language, something the tribes didn't understand, so much of what was said was changed by Congress prior to voting for ratification and the tribes were not made aware nor consulted with prior to the changes. SCOTUS did say, later, that the treaties were to be administered as the Indians understood them to be written. Hmmmm.
Believe it or not, I started school in Tupelo, Ms. in a one room schoolhouse with grades 1 - 4 in it - and this was in the 50's. Dad's early school was one room with grades 1 - 8 in Milbank, SD. Been there, done that.
Whispering, he says - "You weren't supposed to tell."
EXACTLY!
Then the school boards starting "improving" the method of teaching, doing away with phonics, introducing "new math,"
and I am off topic.
But growing up in Tupelo, bad as it was, there were still"town" things to do, places to go. Children on reservations do not have that luxury. 1stwarrior grew up in the poorest state in the Union, and still had advantages Indian children on reservations do not to this day.
Of particular interest to me is that their web site includes a listing of all the federally recognized Indian tribes as well as all of the treaties. There is probably more but I ran out of time.
Sixpick - not a slam against others for not reading and commenting or for reading and commenting. Your story regarding the g-parents/aunts/uncles is exactly the "family" unit of the Indians. I have more g-parents than anyone should have - probably 'bout 16 now - cause we are always taken under the wing of our elders and cared for. That is what is missing from the Indians on the desolate reservations today. As a matter of government intervention into the family, i.e. allotment act, termination era, job-n'-alarm clock of the 60's - our family units are being broken apart - intentionally. The support group that we used to have - well, it just ain't there anymore.
That is what we are attempting to get back - the family, the spirituality, the culture and the traditions. With those ties again, we can slow down and stop the suicides - but we have to have our families back together.