Unemployment is Under 7%. So Why aren’t 93% of Americans Working?
Ali Velshi is the Host ofReal Money with Ali Velshi at Al Jazeera America
(NOTE: This was published BEFORE February's job numbers were released at 830 a.m. ET on Friday, March 7th, 2013, showing the Unemployment Rate unexpectedly INCREASED to 6.7%, even though 175,000 jobs were added. Which basically underscores the point of this post.)
Ok, suspense junkies, listen up!
The Oscars are over and March Madness hasnt begun yet, so I have a chance to direct your fleeting attention to what economic geeks like me consider this months real event: the release on the first Friday of every month of several key pieces of information about the health of Americas job market. Allow me to give you my take on which employment statistics are superstars, and which ones are supporting actors at best. (Not theres anything wrong with that, Jared Leto.)
Lets start with what I, and most economists, consider the real star of this show and its not the Unemployment Rate over which so many people swoon. The most important number we get every month comes from something known as the Establishment Survey conducted by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which is a division of the Department of Labor. Also referred to as Nonfarm Payrolls , this survey polls approximately 144,000 private businesses and government agencies about their workers.
The beauty of the Establishment Survey is that it produces a straight, representative count of the number of jobs created or lost in a given month. Theres only one way to read the net figure (jobs gained minus jobs lost): a high number is good, a low number is bad, just like box office receipts or points scored. While you can explain it, you cant really spin it, though people do try. When the data comes out at 8:30 a.m. on the first Friday of every month, THIS is my go-to number.
That said, the trend matters more than any one number. Every month people retire, pass away, go back to school or go to jail, leaving the workforce in the process. But also each month, at least 100,000 more people immigrate, graduate or come of working age than those who leave the workforce. Economists vary on the number, but most agree that just to stay level America needs to employ many more people (some say 150,000-200,000) per month than it discards from the workforce.
That brings me to the Unemployment Rate, derived from an entirely different monthly poll known informally as the Household Survey. Unlike Nonfarm Payrolls , it needs a big supporting cast of context around it to make sense. That context is the ebb and flow of changes in the total workforce that I just described. For example, the Unemployment Rate could rise because people lost jobs, or because they were feeling good about getting a job and started looking but havent yet found a position. So the rate may give us a misleading impression of the job markets strength or weakness. And because the number is often reported without context, it confuses people or leaves them thinking the data is wrong, or worse, its manipulated for political gain.
Its not. Despite allegations made by some (read: @Jack_Welch ) that the system could be rigged for political advantage, its actually pretty rigorous. Unemployment Rate data is taken from a monthly, representative sample, in which 2,000 highly-trained Census Bureau employees call about 60,000 households across geographic, demographic and socio-economic lines, gathering information on a total of about 110,000 people, representing everyone in those households over the age of 16. Interviewers get classroom instruction, are reviewed regularly and are shadowed by a supervisor at least once a year. The Unemployment Rate is sound. I just dont find it as satisfying at the Nonfarm Payrolls number.
If youve gotten this far, then stick with me through one more category. The job number Ive become a huge fan of is the Labor Force Participation Rate . It provides focus to a mind blurred by the contradictions that arise between the Unemployment Rate and the Nonfarm Payrolls number. Its the percentage of people of working age in the civilian non-institutional population (i.e. those who were available for work) who either had a job or who actively sought one in the previous four weeks.
Chart this number since 1997 or so and it looks like a steady plateau that suddenly becomes a ski hill heading south. In fact, todays Labor Force Participation Rate is the lowest it has been since 1978. For all of 2013, the percentage was 63.2%, which means 158,918,000 people who could be working either had jobs or were looking for work, and 92,535,000 werent. The rate peaked back in 2000 at 67.3%. Reasons for the decline since then are the subject of debate, but they include baby boomers retiring, adults going back to school in a weak job market, and people simply giving up on finding a job.
Whatever the reasons, this number will help you make sense of the drama playing out in Americas job market.

This article underscores the point that the most important statistic in the monthly jobs report is the labor participation rate, a point I have made many times here on NT
Child labor laws......
Care to elaborate
I was being facetious.
Broliver
Flew right over my head, my apologies for missing the point
WSJ today said the "Actual" unemployment rate is 21% - that is counting all unemployed, including even those who have dropped out of the looking category.
Statistics to one side, what I believe is more misleading is the nature of the jobs which are being generated. One needs to do no more than observe whilst out and about. In our region (New England), I see more and more folks in the 40 to sixty year old range toiling away at the local Burger Doodles, Starbucks and the like. Not to denigrate those positions, but if you are my age and working an entry level job, I would not think that is by choice.
The failure in my estimation, is the lack of development of viable growth type positions over the past forty or so years to replace jobs lost to out sourcing, automation and the dismantling of our manufacturing base. But regardless the employment picture in reality is much bleaker than we are led to believe, at least in the world I dwell in.
1stwarrior
That is the number that we should be concerned with in my view
luther28
Absolutely correct
The under-employed (PT vs FT, or in position no commensurate with skills and education) are a big problem in the economy as well
This whimsically written article does a very poor job of reporting the discrepancies between working and unemployed Americans and because of this, what the author is attempting to say or imply comes out misleading or skewed.
For example, he makes use of something called an Establishment Survey without attempting to explain what it is. In fact, there is no such thing officially known as a Establishment Survey. It is a colloquialism for the Current Employment Statistics or CES. If you look at my linked page, you will notice a nightmarish amount of data and different methodologies the government uses to produce these so called statistics. Anyone of those methodologies can be easily compromised for political purposes.
The problem with unemployment statistics (among other statistics) is the mathematical formulas or paradigms used to compute them. There are hundreds of different analysis formulas, each having their own, for lack of a better word; quirks and margins of error. Also, many different industries subscribe to different services that provide such data. As I stated, such stats can be easily manipulated as the BLS is under government control.
While the mission of the Bureau of Labor Statistics is eminent in its own fashion, it is by far not the only game in town for labor statistics and while it makes a good enough bases to write an article on, no company that I am aware of, uses only BLS stats and analysis alone for short/long range planning and as far as explaining any discrepancies, is woefully incomplete.
why is it the unemp rate does not account for those who stopped looking for work, with an adjustment for retirees?
A P
Sorry the article is below your standards and too whimsical
Appreciate the info and the links provided
Thanks
JoAnne
Because it would show too much bad news!
Obviously
I ran across an interesting article in the NYT which seemed to make some relevant points
...
Also from the NYT