Appeals court says school had right to ban U.S. flag T-shirts
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/appeals-court-says-school-had-right-to-ban-us-flag-t-shirts/
" SAN FRANCISCO - Officials at a Northern California high school acted appropriately when they ordered students wearing American flag T-shirts to turn the garments inside out during the Mexican heritage celebration Cinco de Mayo, a federal appeals court ruled Thursday.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the officials' concerns of racial violence outweighed students' freedom of expression rights. Administrators feared the American-flag shirts would enflame the passions of Latino students celebrating the Mexican holiday. Live Oak High School, in the San Jose suburb of Morgan Hill, had a history of problems between white and Latino students on that day.
The unanimous three-judge panel said past problems gave school officials sufficient and justifiable reasons for their actions. The court said schools have wide latitude in curbing certain civil rights to ensure campus safety.
"Our role is not to second-guess the decision to have a Cinco de Mayo celebration or the precautions put in place to avoid violence," Judge M. Margaret McKeown wrote for the panel. The past events "made it reasonable for school officials to proceed as though the threat of a potentially violent disturbance was real," she wrote. "

So, now the judges are more concerned about the rights of the illegal aliens??? WTF - it is Califorexico.
If they want to celebrate Mexican heritage celebration Cinco de Mayo, celebrate all they want to, but don't tell Americans they can't wear their American Flag T-shirts.
When will we learn to take care of our own and not toss them to the dogs while catering to people from other countries? Would you throw your own child out in order to take someone else child in?
I guess in California where the Illegals can practice law you can expect anything.
And I hear in NY they are wanting to pay for their college educations, while hard working Americans have to scrimp, save or borrow to pay their child's college education.
I for one am about tired of this BS.
It is only called Cinco de Mayo in the States. It isn't even a national holiday in Mexico. It is really nothing more than a day to celebrate drinking and partying, as I have been told here in El Paso, "We don't need a reason to drink and celebrate, it's what Mexicans do."
The really disturbing part of this is"to proceed as though the threat of a potentially violent disturbance was real". That statement, to me, gives way too much latitude.
So now the court has ruled that civil rights can be curbed in order to insure safety? Try to curb my civil rights and I can guarantee you will not be safe.
First we have to get some candidates that are worth a crap!
Most of those up there now are brain dead.
This entire scenario is troubling from the start, and on many different levels.
The ruling itself.
You can find a copy of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling here - -
The courts decision was based on sound jurisprudence but sound does not always mean correct or just. To this extend, it acted on the legal principle of the prevention of possible harm verses the expansion of liberty. The evidence the school provided to the court stated they knew well in advance that the Cinco de Mayo day they sponsored had in the past caused problems, specifically when a few students deliberately wore American flags to protest that event.
It has to be noted that the school had a dress code already in place banning the wearing of clothing which prohibits clothing that indicate[s] gang affiliation, create[s] a safety hazard, or disrupt[s]school activities.
On the day the student was asked to remove the flag shirt, there was a high probability of a physical altercation breaking out. So in this specific case, the one student who wore the shirt was asked to remove it. Subsequently the students parents filed a suit against the school alleging the violation of the constitutional right of due process, equal protection and injunctive relief.
The court found that there was no violation of due process or equal protection and that the dress code was legal.
Questions;
1) Should the school have cancelled a legitimate and legal sponsored event knowing of potential problems to head off these problems? Should a majority be punished because of the ideological objects by a handful?
2) Did the student involved deliberately wear with the idea of provoking an altercation, as opposed to merely expressing his views? Could this have been handled differently by the student or students in a more constructive manner?
Despite the gross overreaction of the right (I might call this another manufactured outrage), this event is NOT nor was ever adjudicated as an American flag violation nor as an immigration issue as the xenophobes imply. As I have indicated, this issue is being blown out of proportion by right wing political ideology as opposed to a prudent understanding of the facts surrounding it.
Oh crap.
Aeon - this was covered in depth on NV 'bout two years ago. The celebrators wore shirts of the Mexican flag, they marched down the main drag of town waving the Mexican flag, some of them carried the American flag upside down in the march and they told the "Gringos" to stay out of their way and that they were going to take this country back.
The kids who wore the American flag shirts did it silently, and did not, in any way, threaten or intimidate the celebrators - it was quite the opposite. Lot of information is not covered in this article.
The article YOU posted dealt specifically with this event; John Dariano, et al v. Morgan Hill Unified School which was adjudicated by the 9th Circuit this week. If you read the decision, it has absolutely nothing to do with any other events.
The article did not cover the event (a 2006 incident where a town, Pahrump, Nevada, made it illegal to fly a foreign flag) you mentioned because it it not related to this decision.
My comment deals only with the article and that particular decision. However, this is your thread and if you considerate relevant, so be it. All I'm saying is that the 9th's decision does not state or imply any mention any legal relationship to the the Pahrump, Nevada incident.
Typical 9th Circuit Whack-a-Doodle Decision. These clowns are so far left, they are found floating in the Pacific Ocean.
I would have more sympathy if they upheld a ban on ALL shirts decorated with a flag, but to target one infringes on their freedom of speech.
So, shoulkd we start celebrating the holidays of all the other countries in the world and not do anything to upset them during 'their' holiday? That's PC gone way too far.
They should no longer hold the "celebration" It is complete bullshz.
I agree, but they have had trouble with this "celebration" before so the smart thing to do would be to cancel it all together.
Agreed.
Remember, this is a 9th Circuit Judgement-hope it will go to SCOTUS. The 9th Circuit is famous for their off the wall rulings.
There is only one thing this ruling deserves
Flag on the play!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
A - What rulings exactly has the 9th decided that leads you to believe they are liberal? I ask because too often, the conservatives sound like a unified groups of sirens, babbling the same thing thing only because they heard it on faux or from Limbaugh.
B - To quote from the 9ths decision, page 11, second paragraph;
C - We already do. Christmas for example, was a German tradition. Also, they were NOT celebrating Cinco de Mayo (literally the 5th of May) per se as it's significance in Mexico is not universal nor even culturally related; it celebrates the defeat of the French Army at the Battle of Puebla.
The best analogy I can think of is that Cinco de Mayo is like a "Hallmark holiday." It was adopted in the US as an expression of cultural pride.
Cinco de Mayo should not to be confused with Mexican Independence Day, which occurs on September 16 and is not celebrated in the US.
Mike in Ga
My apologies for putting the nitrous in your engine
I feel the same about political correctness and I do not even want to get started on the NFL
No high hits, no low hits, no verbal hits, pretty soon the defense will have to stand at midfield and applaud after a touchdown is scored.
Robert G
Absolutely correct!
And if you help a guy up after not hitting him high or low or hard, then you get a pass to call him a poop head later in the game without penalty
No, but they (immigrants) helped very largely in my decision to move out of Cali.
This decision is based on the incident I mentioned above.
Since there is no school during the 4th, I doubt the school issue would be moot.
Here's the rest of the information - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Live_Oak_High_School_(Morgan_Hill,_Cal... ) -
On May 5, 2010, five LOHS students and administration attracted national attention to the school. Daniel Galli, Austin Carvalho, Matt Dariano, Dominic Maciel and Clayton Howard arrived at school wearing T-shirts and bandanas bearing emblems of the American flag . [ 3 ] The school's administrators, led either by Principal Nicholas L. Boden or Assistant Principal Miguel Rodriguez (reports vary as to which), sent home four of them for refusing to remove the T-shirts on the Pueblan holiday of Cinco de Mayo . School officials deemed the garments "incendiary" and "disrespectful," fearing that displaying the American flag would incite fights with the Mexican-American student body. The four students were told they could choose to change their clothes or go home for the day. [ 4 ] [ 5 ] [ 6 ] [ 7 ]
Some of Live Oak's Mexican-American students said that they felt disrespected by the boys' action and demanded an apology. One Mexican-American student stated, "I think they should apologize cause it is a Mexican Heritage Day. We don't deserve to be get disrespected like that. We wouldn't do that on Fourth of July ." [ 4 ]
The boys and their parents were livid over the school's actions, defending the students' right to wear the American flag. They alerted the local media to the event. [ 4 ]
The Morgan Hill Unified School District bureaucratically distanced itself from the actions of Live Oak school officials, characterizing the incident as "extremely unfortunate" and stating the matter was under investigation. [ 8 ] The school district superintendent, Dr. Wesley Smith, said, "While campus safety is our primary concern and administrators made decisions yesterday in an attempt to ensure campus safety, students should not, and will not, be disciplined for wearing patriotic clothing." [ 5 ] [ 9 ] [ 10 ] [ 11 ]
On May 6, approximately 200 Hispanic teens, most of whom were Live Oak High School students, walked out of their classes and marched through the downtown and to city hall in protest of what they regarded as disrespect from their American-flag-wearing peers. The crowd carried Mexican flags and sported the red, white and green of Mexico's national emblem. Two days later, a crowd of students led by several Hispanic students gathered in the amphitheater and held an anti-racism rally advocating acceptance and tolerance among the students. [ 6 ]
On May 7, the school district held a press conference regarding the incident, in which Boden apologized for the school administration's handling of the incident and explained why it handled it in the way that it did. [ 12 ]
On May 8, 100 members of the local Tea Party movement chapter protested in Morgan Hill in support of the four students. [ 13 ]
On May 10, the ACLU of Northern California sent a letter to the Morgan Hill Schools Superintendent protesting that the students' First Amendment rights had been violated and asking that the School District "take additional steps to inform students that their rights to free speech will be respected in the future". [ 14 ] On May 11, about 250 people attended the scheduled school board meeting . More than 30 people addressed the board about the incident, while many parents in attendance either cheered in unity or booed in opposition to the opinions expressed therein. [ 15 ]
On November 8, 2011 Chief U.S. District Judge James Ware of San Francisco dismissing the students' lawsuit. The Supreme Court has ruled that public school students have the right to engage in nondisruptive free speech, however, that ruling "does not require that school officials wait until disruption occurs before they act," Ware said in his ruling Tuesday dismissing the students' lawsuit. [ 16 ] On Thursday, October 17, 2013, in an online news story on the MSN website (an Associated Press article by Paul Elias ), it was stated that a three-judge panel of the San Francisco , California -based Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals was expected to rule on the lawsuit brought by three students who have since graduated, claiming their free speech and equal protection Constitutional rights were violated. [ 17 ] .
Aeon - I don't write BS articles (I did not "mention" the 2006 event in Nevada - NV stands for Newsvine- nice try). Before you decide to chastise me, you need to get your ducks in a row.
What the hell are you talking about and why should I care what was posted on newsvine?
Get a grip.
It needs to go to the Supreme Court. This ruling is a kick in the teeth to anyone who has ever served, as well as to the rest of us.
The information about Newsvine was a FYI, showing that this particular case/issue/concern had been discussed at length in the past. Remember, many of the folks on NT came over from NV and many of them may remember the discussions.
An apology from you would be accepted.
Even though El Dia de la Batalla de Puebla is only celebrated regionally in Mexico, it's a big party in the United States. Sure, we import a lot of holidays here to the U.S., but why do Americans celebrate a holiday that most of Mexico ignores? And the answer -- just like it is to marital problems -- is heavy drinking.
Interesting side note - well, for California maybe not. There was a note in the LA Times story in 2010 that stated over 60% of the Latino students at the school are illegal aliens. But, under Cali laws, the school can't "keepthose kind of records."
Go Mexicali.
And now we make it illegal for our children to show PATRIOTISM by making them turn their shirts with the American flag, (the Flag of the country that all those illegals want to come to) inside out. I don't think so, this is America you have two choices Love It or Leave It.
Think of this - an 86 y.o. man in NY gets severely beaten by four cops for JAYWALKING. Cops enter a house a kill a 80 y.o. man, lying in bed, unarmed on "suspicion" of drugs.
250 Latino kids march, howling obscenities at U. S. citizens, desecrating the U. S. flag, on TV, in the newspapers - and the U. S. citizens are in the wrong???
Beam me up, Scottie, no intelligent life here....
Yep.. see my post above...