╌>

The coming crash of American diplomacy in the Middle East -- Obama's policy failures on Iran, Syria and the Israeli-Palestinian dispute will have devastating effects. by John Bolton, LA Times 2/18/14

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  21 comments

The coming crash of American diplomacy in the Middle East -- Obama's policy failures on Iran, Syria and the Israeli-Palestinian dispute will have devastating effects. by John Bolton, LA Times 2/18/14

President Obama has three significant Middle East diplomatic initiatives underway, treating, respectively, Iran's nuclear weapons program; Syria's deadly, exhausting conflict; and the long-standing Israeli-Palestinian dispute. Into these negotiations, Obama and his administration have poured enormous amounts of American prestige, time and effort.

Although rarely considered collectively, these three efforts constitute a significant strategic package for a White House that all too often hardly bothers with foreign policy. These initiatives truly reflect Obama's view of America's international role: His is a world of rhetoric and talk, not power.

Thus, Iran has not feared U.S. military strikes against its nuclear weapons program, and now, as a result of November's interim agreement in Geneva, it does not even fear international economic sanctions. Neither the Bashar Assad regime nor Al Qaeda terrorists in Syria see any prospect of material U.S. intervention. And the main pressure being applied in the Israeli-Palestinian matter is against Israel, heretofore Washington's strongest regional ally.

As described below, all three of Obama's diplomatic maneuvers are based on errors and will almost certainly fail. And what will happen then? Failing on one is bad enough, but failing on all three will be devastating.

And it is no answer to say that deals may yet be signed. Covering failure with a piece of paper changes nothing. The Iran interim agreement, for example, is not a partial success simply because its later collapse will be due merely to poor implementation. Without a real meeting of minds, there is no true deal, as Iran's all-too-evident disdain already amply demonstrates.

The coming crash of U.S. diplomacy is not idle speculation about a remote future. Our declining prestige is already apparent globally; when all three Middle East negotiations fail conclusively, America's influence will fall further. Friends and adversaries alike are recalibrating their policies accordingly, particularly because the underlying causes of the three impending failures will spell trouble and misfortune elsewhere.

Obama's ongoing failures could have been avoided. A less ideological, more realistic and clear-eyed leader would comprehend American power and interests, knowing how to use the former to protect the latter, rather than making Obama's basic mistakes.

Obama's first error: misreading your adversary. There was never any chance Iran could be negotiated out of a nuclear weapons capability it has pursued for nearly 30 years. Efforts during the Clinton and George W. Bush administrations demonstrated how Iran deftly uses negotiations to gain political legitimacy, buy time to continue work on its nuclear program and evade international punishment. Hassan Rouhani followed precisely this playbook as Iran's chief nuclear negotiator 10 years ago. He is doing so again today as Iran's president.

The second error: not knowing who your adversaries are. Obama argued for three years that Russia shared his objective of a peaceful transition from the Assad regime in Syria to something else. This was never true. Moscow's support for Assad (as well as Iran's, directly and through Hezbollah) guaranteed he would only depart feet first. The U.S. could either have aided Syria's opposition or tackled the problem's root cause: the mullahs' regime in Tehran. Obama chose to do neither. His equivocation regarding Syria's chemical weapons program has provoked giggles or dismay at White House weakness.

The third error: not knowing who your friends are. The Palestinians lack legitimate governing institutions capable of hard decisions, including making perilous concessions and compromises, and overcoming resistance by Hamas and other terrorists. Without such institutions, no long-term solution is possible. Negotiating with the Palestinian Authority has less substance than negotiating with a hologram. Perversely, however, Obama treats Israel as the problem.

Not apprehending these realities or foreseeing their consequences debilitates the United States, discourages its allies and emboldens its adversaries. The coming collapse of all three of Obama's negotiations will convince foreign governments that his policies are dooming Washington's Middle East influence to precipitous decline. And since appearance is reality in international politics, America's ability to influence events in Egypt for example, where the military government is already reverting to pre-Sadat days, purchasing arms from Russia will sink further. Moreover, the opportunity costs of not focusing on threats elsewhere, such as China's belligerent territorial claims in its coastal waters, are enormous.

Iran will emerge more powerful, verging on deliverable nuclear weapons, while still financing and arming terrorists worldwide. Assad seems likely to survive, which is bad enough by itself, but it will be compounded by the affirmation it affords Iranian and Russian strength. Israel will trust Washington even less than now, and ironically, Palestinians will be even more anti-American because Obama will not be able to deliver to them the Israeli concessions he predicted.

Perhaps this prospect of massive strategic failure will awaken Obama and America as a whole, but that seems unlikely. Instead, the increasing danger is that only another 9/11, another disaster, will produce the necessary awakening. There is tragedy ahead for our country if we continue on this course.

John Bolton, the former U.S. ambassador to the U.N., is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and the author of "Surrender Is Not an Option: Defending America at the United Nations and Abroad."


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Screw John Bolton.... and the rest of the neocons from the last administration.

He and many others are the very reason we have so many dead in Afghanistan and Iraq and trillions in debt. They are personally responsible for implementing their failed...."Project for the New American Century."

The fact that you post something by Bolton further proves your blind allegiance to that same bunch of criminals.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Len, you posted an Op-Ed without comment. That's nice but do you agree with it? If so, why?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Iran will emerge more powerful, verging on deliverable nuclear weapons, while still financing and arming terrorists worldwide. Assad seems likely to survive, which is bad enough by itself, but it will be compounded by the affirmation it affords Iranian and Russian strength. Israel will trust Washington even less than now, and ironically, Palestinians will be even more anti-American because Obama will not be able to deliver to them the Israeli concessions he predicted.

Regardless of what anyone think of Bolton, and let me be clear that I hold no regard for Bush nor Cheney nor Rumsfield, and feel that every death in Iraq, and the destruction of Iraq's infrastructure is totally on their heads... that paragraph is undoubtedly true.

The way this administration has conducted foreign affairs and the way it is courting disaster by kissing up to Iran, it's hard to see any other outcome. You can "screw" the last administration all you want, but it won't change the outcome of the present one.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

For an ex-Navy guy I would have liked more specifics. I understand you bitterness about all the casualties we suffered but that in itself is not proof of policy failure.

Was Pres. Roosevelt the reason we had over 400,000 dead in WW-2?

Is Chamberlain style appeasement preferable to war?

Arguably an appeasement nation will eventually result in more casualties, civilian plus military, than a firm nation. Our nation today is wishy-washy, not firm, and the world, both friend and foe, know it.

Except for Syria, a plague on both sides there, I agree with Bolton's judgments. But even in Syria, Obama lost prestige for making a promise and walking away from it when push came to shove.

Bolton could have added the so-called "Arab Spring" in which we aided substitution of more hostile Islamist regimes for less hostile, if not friendly, ones.

And this is just about Obama's Middle East failures (which are likely even worse than his domestic failures).

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I read the seed and then came across this graphic which I thought hilarious and felt I had to share

4798_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Every day the US is subject to greater humiliations and challenges to its power and prestige.

Declarations from Iranian leaders rejecting the dismantling of their nuclear installations, coupled with threats to attack US installations and Israel, bespeak contempt for American power and convey a catastrophic erosion of US deterrent capabilities againstTehran.

As subjects of intense US appeasement efforts, the Palestinians are second only to Iran. And as is the case with Iran, those efforts come at the direct expense of Israel, the USs most important ally in the Middle East.

Yet like the Iranians, the Palestinians greet US efforts with scorn. Every day Palestinian leaders pile on their incitement against Israel and Jews and their derisive condemnations of the Obama administrations efforts to force Israel to cater to their every whim.

Since 1979, Egypt served as the anchor of the US alliance structure in the Arab world. It shared the USs opposition to Islamic terrorism, and waged a continuous campaign to defeat the forc es of jihad in Egypt, while remaining outside the circle of war against Israel.

When protests began in Egypt three years ago, rather than stand with its ally, Obama dumped Egyptian presidentHosni Mubarakand sided with the jihadist Muslim Brotherhood.

After winning a popular election, the Brother hood immediately set about transforming Egypt into an Islamic, pro-jihadist state. And yet, the administration opposed the militarys decision to oust the Brotherhood from power last summer even though the move prevented the most strategically vital Arab state from becoming the cen ter of the global jihad. It then cut US military aid to Egypt.

So now the military regime is renewing its ties with Russia, after ditchingMoscowfor Washing ton in 1974.

And so it goes, throughout the world.

More at: ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I was surprised that one of the Obama's biggest foreign policy failures-- Egypt-- was hardly mentioned. I haven't been following that story recently as much as I used to, but I did catch a headline that the Egyptians were negotiating with Putin (Peace Be Upon Him!) for arms. 18.gif Now that is indication of a major change in the balance of power in the region-- a highly significant foreign policy failure on the part of thee Obama admin. (For more on the dismal record of US policies vis-a-vis Egypt, you can ask Fada...)

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Likely the world's shortest book.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Because he was writing about currently hot issues. I mentioned it -- twice.

Egypt is on the back burner for the time being.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

The fact that you post something by Bolton further proves your blind allegiance to that same bunch of criminals.

You took the words right off my keyboard!41.gif

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

It's exhausting trying to keep up with all the administration's foreign policy failures. I doubt the internet is big enough to house a thorough treatment.

Libya is a disaster as well.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Egypt is on the back burner for the time being.

Unless, of course, you are an Egyptian Frown.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

For a while I thought I had Obama's foreign policy figured out . In the middle east he seemed to be going with supporting democratically elected governments even if they later went corrupt .

But with the latest policy on Venezuela . I am as confused as I was at the start ...

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Exactly what is our policy on Venezuela? I didn't think we had one, having been told to stay out of their politics and their country.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

...

The Obama administration was a bit more subtle, but also made it clear where it stood. When Secretary of State John Kerry states that "We are particularly alarmed by reports that the Venezuelan government has arrested or detained scores of anti-government protestors," he is taking a political position. Because there were many protestors who committed crimes: they attacked and injured police with chunks of concrete and Molotov cocktails; they burned cars, trashed and sometimes set fire to government buildings; and committed other acts of violence and vandalism.

An anonymous State Department spokesman was even clearer last week , when he responded to the protests by expressing concern about the government's "weakening of democratic institutions in Venezuela", and said that there was an obligation for "government institutions [to] respond effectively to the legitimate economic and social needs of its citizens". He was joining the opposition's efforts to de-legitimize the government, a vital part of any "regime change" strategy.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

And as is the case with Iran, those efforts come at the direct expense of Israel, the USs most important ally in the Middle East.

Maybe not. I agree much of his Middle East policy has been a disaster. (But then again, Bush's wasn't exactly a smashing success either).

However, if you separate all the talk from what's actually important (actions- - particularly supporting Israel in its recent time of greatest need) I give his policy regarding Israel good grades. (At this point all my pro-Israel friends on NT will begin yelling & screaming at me in unison Grin.gif ).

And apparently the Israelis themselves would agree with me:

pew+enemy.jpg (Link)

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

John Bolton is a diehard fan of war with Iran.. Of course he is disappointed with Obamas peace initiatives with Iran.

John Bolton: The Only Option in Iran Is War
Neocon John Bolton Calls for Israeli Airstrikes Against Iran

While I am against Obamas policies in Egypt and Syria, his use of drones in the ME, I am in agreement on a peaceful solution with Iran.

Bolton is dangerous loose cannon and was one of the key cheerleaders for the US-led war in Iraq in 2003.

This article is a strange dyslectic twist coming from a man who supports Obamas drone wars and saying that it was the right to do to kill hundreds of thousands of (Confederate) Southerners.
John Bolton: Right thing to do to kill Southerners

Bolton is a sick little man, in his chickenhawk sick little world, whose support base is a dying breed of people suffering from a diminished capacity to differentiate the horrors war from the cartoon fantasy of GI Joe.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

I do not heed such puny yocks
from one whose head is full of rocks.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Aeon,

I suppose you hate Abraham Lincoln too.

He is the one responsible for the killing of the Southerners.

Was Lincoln also sick?

A peaceful solution with Iran is like the late 1930s peaceful solution with Hitler.

I am amazed that you do not recognize this.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I suppose you hate Abraham Lincoln too.

He is the one responsible for the killing of the Southerners.

Was Lincoln also sick?

I am amazed that you do not recognize this.

I'm amazed you don't realize what shallow logic you use in comparing John Bolton to Abraham Lincoln.

30.gif

Then, on second thought, considering the source, it's not so amazing after all.

 
 

Who is online