Climate Change - The Myth of ‘Settled Science’ --- Computer models of climate change have been dead wrong, yet alarmists aim to quell debate. by Charles Krauthammer 12/20/2014
I repeat: Im not a global-warming believer. Im not a global-warming denier. Ive long believed that it cannot be good for humanity to be spewing tons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. I also believe that those scientists who pretend to know exactly what this will cause in 20, 30, or 50 years are white-coated propagandists.
"The debate is settled," asserted propagandist-in-chief Barack Obama in his latest State of the Union address. "Climate change is a fact." Really? There is nothing more anti-scientific than the very idea that science is settled, static, impervious to challenge. Take a non-climate example. It was long assumed that mammograms help reduce breast cancer deaths. This fact was so settled that Obamacare requires every insurance plan to offer mammograms (for free, no less).
Now we learn from a massive randomized study 90,000 women followed for 25 years that mammograms may have no effect on breast-cancer deaths. Indeed, one out of five of those diagnosed by mammogram receives unnecessary radiation, chemo, or surgery.
So much for settledness. And climate is less well understood than breast cancer. If climate science is settled, why do its predictions keep changing? And how is it that the great physicist Freeman Dyson, who did some climate research in the late 1970s, thinks todays climate-change Cassandras are hopelessly mistaken?
They deal with the fluid dynamics of the atmosphere and oceans, argues Dyson, ignoring the effect of biology, i.e., vegetation and topsoil. Further, their predictions rest on models they fall in love with: "You sit in front of a computer screen for ten years and you start to think of your model as being real." Not surprisingly, these models have been "consistently and spectacularly wrong" in their predictions, write atmospheric scientists Richard McNider and John Christy and always, amazingly, in the same direction.
Settled? Even the U.K.s national weather service concedes theres been no change delicately called a "pause" in global temperature in 15 years. If even the raw data is recalcitrant, let alone the assumptions and underlying models, how settled is the science?
Last Friday, Obama ostentatiously visited drought-stricken California. Surprise! He blamed climate change. Here even the New York Times gagged, pointing out that far from being supported by the evidence, "the most recent computer projections suggest that as the world warms, California should get wetter, not drier, in the winter."
How inconvenient. But weve been here before. Hurricane Sandy was made the poster child for the alleged increased frequency and strength of "extreme weather events" like hurricanes.
Nonsense. Sandy wasnt even a hurricane when it hit the U.S. Indeed, in all of 2012, only a single hurricane made U.S. landfall. And 2013 saw the fewest Atlantic hurricanes in 30 years. In fact, in the last half-century, one-third fewer major hurricanes have hit the U.S. than in the previous half-century.
Similarly tornadoes. Every time one hits, the climate-change commentary begins. Yet last year saw the fewest in a quarter-century. And the last 30 years of presumed global warming has seen a 30 percent decrease in extreme tornado activity (F3 and above) versus the previous 30 years.
None of this is dispositive. It doesnt settle the issue. But thats the point. It mocks the very notion of settled science, which is nothing but a crude attempt to silence critics and delegitimize debate. As does the term "denier" an echo of Holocaust denial, contemptibly suggesting the malevolent rejection of an established historical truth.
Climate-change proponents have made their cause a matter of fealty and faith. For folks who pretend to be brave carriers of the scientific ethic, theres more than a tinge of religion in their jeremiads. If you whore after other gods, the Bible tells us, "the Lords wrath be kindled against you, and he shut up the heaven, that there be no rain, and that the land yield not her fruit" (Deuteronomy 11).
Sounds like California. Except that today theres a new god, the Earth Mother. And a new set of sins burning coal and driving a fully equipped F-150.
But whoring is whoring, and the gods must be appeased. So if California burns, you send your high priest (in a carbon-belching Air Force One, but never mind) to the bone-dry land to offer up, on behalf of the repentant congregation, a $1 billion burnt offering called a "climate-resilience fund."
Ah, settled science in action.

Not only fish!
One of my eastern friends just visited San Diego. He said there are 100 (rough estimate) golf courses in the area and all had their sprinkler systems going full time to keep the greens green. The water came from draining California fresh water lakes. (We can't use salt water, can we!)
My California son was recently at Lake Tahoe and that lake is almost dry without the usual snow in the area.
What's more important? Green greens or a substantial supply of most green vegetables, and many common fruits for our grocery stores?
For liberal Californians, we see the priorities.
They did not learn the lesson of Joseph in Egypt from the Bible; how he stockpiled during the seven good years and was ready to handle the seven bad ones when they arrived.
In the New Age we will have science by mob rule.
I'd get behind the science party!
All the planks in their party platform supported by peer reviewed double blind studies.
I'm sorry but I cannot also "get behind" the science party .
The thing about science is EVERYTHING it deals with must be measurable . Not everything is ...
Go back to being bad lawyers? Work in the soup kitchens they all say they have worked in. Some even have photos of themselves working in them!!!!
True.... true.
But wouldn't you say that our current arrangement could use a severe dose of measurement and standardization in many areas?
Its not that I disagree with that . But instead of pushing measurement as the ultimate goal of all policy I expect a more useful approach would be to decrease the influence of lawyers in the game . Not sure how to accomplish that ...
I always looked at lawyers being much like the battle in electronic warfare.
Someone builds a radar that resists jamming, so you need to develop a new jammer to get around that radar and so on.
Laws are made by lawyers. Other lawyers work at finding holes in those laws. More laws are made to plug those holes and so on.
If you replace the name "Charles Krauthammer" with any conservative pundit or US politician, the statement would still have the same validity and credibility: None.
My beef with "Climate Change" is not mired in brainless political rhetoric, but in the science behind it.
"Climate Models" are computerized mathematical programs. Only about 5% (I reckon) Americans understand what a climate model is or the extreme complexity of climate itself. They can only be as accurate as the data that is fed into them. In this case, it's not the data that is wrong, but considering the age of the earth and it's abstruse dynamics, we do not have near enough data to come to any kind of postulation about future climate without a wide margin of error.
To use a computer maxim; garbage in, garbage out.
While I am a proponent of the Gaia hypothesis , such computerized simulations should be treated with caution but NOT dismissed.
Good thinking on your part . I expect that another decade or so may result in improved methodologies . But climatology is still far from a science at this point .