╌>

The Scientific Truth about the Movie Pompeii, 79 AD

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dowser  •  12 years ago  •  21 comments

The Scientific Truth about the Movie Pompeii, 79 AD

4812_discussions.png?width=350 Geology is not everyone's cup of tea. Let's face it, most geology occurs over periods of millions of years and with human's approximately 30 seconds of attention span, most people give it a big "Ho Hum".

However, occasionally something happens that is so immediate, so spectacular, that everyone pays attention, and true human drama unfolds. This is certainly true about volcanoes.

Pompeii and its sister city Herculeneum, is one of those moments of history that still fascinate us today-- even though, at the time, a lot of people didn't know about it, or quickly forgot that the city even existed. Buried for almost 2000 years, under a blanket of 14' - 20' thick ash, life went on above the city for, (in human eyes), a long time. The city was 'rediscovered' in 1738 while construction workers were building a summer palace for the King of Naples, Charles of the House of Bourbon. Further excavations followed, until, gradually, most of the city was revealed.

Volcanoes are a natural disaster-movie maker's dream. Since movies are made in Hollywood, some license is allowed as to the actual facts and effects of volcanic eruptions. (See Dante's Peak , Volcano , Supervolcano .) For one thing, one would never reach the peak and look over the edge at the lava floating around in a volcano, one's head would melt. No one could walk in a lava flow, one's blood would boil instantly. Ad nauseum .

The new movie Pompeii is no different from the others, but, perhaps, it is different in one way-- it's not about what could happen, but what did. What actually happened is pretty bad, without all the Hollywood add ons, and let's look at that:

First, there were no lava bombs- while colorful, beautiful, and deadly, the eruption of Vesuvius was not the kind of eruption that produces lava bombs. Besides, no lava bombs have ever been found in the city of Pompeii. So, remove the lava bombs from the movie, and you've got ash falling from the sky, covering and coating everything and suffocating the unlucky humans in its path.

Second, there is absolutely no evidence that a tsunami struck the City of Herculeneum. No giant wave swept in from the sea, because all the drama was taking place at Vesuvius, not the sea floor.

Yes, there was an earthquake. It caused some damage. It is rated, presently between 5 and 6 on the Richter Scale, so it could have been felt, and caused some of the stone structures to collapse. Of course, the falling ash caused a lot of roofs to collapse as well, but by that time, the air was so foul with ash, those killed by falling roofs at least died mercifully and quickly-- not gasping, choking, and fighting for air in the streets.

Lastly, most people died from the heat of the pyroclastic flow-- a burst of hot gases and ash that flowed from the volcano, superheated, and behaving like a liquid, until it dissipated over the sea.

Of historical note, Pliny the Elder was killed by the pyroclastic flow. Pliny the Elder had come with a Roman Fleet to rescue those he could. Just before they sailed, he was on land, down the shore from Herculeneum, and decided to walk out on the beach, ahead of his men, to check the conditions. The pyroclastic flow occurred, and Pliny the Elder was cooked. His men waited a while, and retrieved his body, and then they, and the Roman Fleet got the hell out of there.

Pliny the Younger was across the bay at the city of Naples, and wrote about the final pyroclastic flow, unaware that his uncle was being cooked across the bay, and it is his account that gives us the most information about the Vesuvius eruption of today.

So, while watching the movie, just keep in mind that there was no tsunami, and no lava bombs... And have fun!

Thanks for coming by!

Article: Ancient Catastrophe Brought to Life


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

I am not a volcanologist, but it always irritates me that Hollywood can't seem to just be realistic. What happened was bad enough!!!

Thanks for coming by! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Good article Dowser. Yup, the real story, without Hollywood adding to it was bad enough. The photo of the family is amazing.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

Heartbreaking, for sure... Those darling little babies!

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

It has been years since I have read Pliny the Younger"s account. Good article. Thanks.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

I've never read it-- and should!!! I've read about it, a lot, but not IT. I wonder if it is available on line? I'll go look...

Thanks, dear Grump, for coming by!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

irritates me that Hollywood can't seem to just be realistic.

I don't mean to change the subject but Hollywood is in the entertainment business . I am willing to give them artistic license . But when a politician takes such liberties with the facts it is far more alarming IMO .

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

You don't think that politics is entertainment?

I agree with you, Petey, but this is not an article about politics. It's about the real eruption of Pompeii, 79 AD. The real eruption was heartrending, sad, and dramatic enough... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

You don't think that politics is entertainment?

It has certainly become infotainment . This is a great tragedy IMO .

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

I agree with that, as well!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

Here's the letter he wrote . If you're interested!

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    12 years ago

I saw on the history channel thatwhen Vesuvius, still an active volcano next erupts it is likely that the city of Naples, with its four million residents, will experience lava flows into center city. This is based on mathematical models of projected lava flows.

The question for Vulcanologists is when to sound the alarm button. Not enough is presently known to be able to accurately predict whenVesuvius will blow. They know it will. Just not when and how badly.

The balancing act here is two fold. First, not to cry Wolf so people ignore present warnings when past evacuation ordersturned out to be false alarms. Second, not to wait until too late to call for an evacuation.

Here are some helpful hints I offer in the spirit of safety for humanity.

When there is seismic activity sufficient to register between a 6-10 on the Richter scale when my credit rating hits the ground, get moving!

When bursts of deadly gases from Ted Cruz making an ash of himself lead to respiratory failures, time to start evacuating.

When pyroclastic flows from Texan style five alarm chili start burning up the formica tables at Wendy's, its probably too late to do anything about anything.

Scientifically yours,

Enoch, trying to hold down mild chili at my age.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

I was there and seeing it close is really heartbreaking. The worst for me was to see that people live and are still building homes at the base of the Vesuvius. Incredible

Very interesting post Dowser, thank you

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

Enoch, your advice is always worth heeding. Thanks, loads.

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

Dowser, well written article, my friend.

In fact, it is more interesting and informative than your link. Thanks.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    12 years ago

I've been to Pompeii, it's kind of eerie, yet spectacular in a somber way.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

FUNNY!

You've hit the nail on the head as to the dilemma that presents itself to volcanologists. An evacuation would be a nightmare-- where would 1 million people go? How on earth do you feed them, clothe them, and house them?

Yet, no one wants to die by volcanic cooking. I certainly don't. Their deaths were horrible, bless them.

I can only eat the mildest of chili, myself. Nothing like that 5 alarm heartburn... Of the three things mentioned, I do think that Ted Cruz is the worst!!! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

Dear palma, you are welcome! I cannot imagine building a home there. It may be beautiful, but it's proven to be deadly. I've never seen it, but I know I'd be heartbroken, and fascinated at all the Roman history... both!

Take care, dear Palma!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

Thank you very much! I truly appreciate your coming by!! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

I bet it would be!!

I've never been to Pompeii, but I have gone to famous battlefields had that same creepy, eerie feeling that I was being "watched", somehow. It doesn't take too much imagination to imagine what it would have been like to live there, or to die there, so horribly.

Thanks for coming by, Wheel!

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

Yup, that's what I remember. Thanks for finding that.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    12 years ago

My pleasure! I wanted to read it, too! Grin.gif

 
 

Who is online