On Presidents Day - US Presidents in Their Own Words Concerning American Indians
From Washington to Obama - evolution
Indians and wolves are both beasts of prey, tho they differ in shape.
George Washington
If ever we are constrained to lift the hatchet against any tribe, we will never lay it down till that tribe is exterminated, or driven beyond the Mississippi in war, they will kill some of us; we shall destroy them all.
Thomas Jefferson
My original convictions upon this subject have been confirmed by the course of events for several years, and experience is every day adding to their strength. That those tribes cannot exist surrounded by our settlements and in continual contact with our citizens is certain. They have neither the intelligence, the industry, the moral habits, nor the desire of improvement which are essential to any favorable change in their condition. Established in the midst of another and a superior race, and without appreciating the causes of their inferiority or seeking to control them, they must necessarily yield to the force of circumstances and ere long disappear.
Andrew Jackson
Ordered that of the Indians and Half-breeds sentenced to be hanged by the military commission, composed of Colonel Crooks, Lt. Colonel Marshall, Captain Grant, Captain Bailey, and Lieutenant Olin, and lately sitting in Minnesota, you cause to be executed on Friday the nineteenth day of December, instant, the following names, to wit Text from President Lincoln to General Sibley ordering the execution of American Indians in Minnesota.
Abraham Lincoln
I dont go so far as to think that the only good Indians are dead Indians, but I believe nine out of ten are, and I shouldnt like to inquire too closely into the case of the tenth.
Theodore Roosevelt
All of our people all over the country except the pure blooded Indians are immigrants or descendants of immigrants, including even those who came over here on the Mayflower.
Franklin Roosevelt
The United States, which would live on Christian principles with all of the peoples of the world, cannot omit a fair deal for its own Indian citizens.
Harry Truman
There has been a vigorous acceleration of health, resource and education programs designed to advance the role of the American Indian in our society. Last Fall, for example, 91 percent of the Indian children between the ages of 6 and 18 on reservations were enrolled in school. This is a rise of 12 percent since 1953.
Dwight Eisenhower
For a subject worked and reworked so often in novels, motion pictures, and television, American Indians remain probably the least understood and most misunderstood Americans of us all.
John Kennedy
The American Indian, once proud and free, is torn now between White and tribal values; between the politics and language of the White man and his own historic culture. His problems, sharpened by years of defeat and exploitation, neglect and inadequate effort, will take many years to overcome.
Lyndon Johnson
What we have done with the American Indian is its way as bad as what we imposed on the Negroes. We took a proud and independent race and virtually destroyed them. We have to find ways to bring them back into decent lives in this country.
Richard Nixon
I am committed to furthering the self-determination of Indian communities but without terminating the special relationship between the Federal Government and the Indian people. I am strongly opposed to termination. Self-determination means that you can decide the nature of your tribes relationship with the Federal Government within the framework of the Self-Determination Act, which I signed in January of 1975.
Gerald Ford
It is the fundamental right of every American, as guaranteed by the first amendment of the Constitution, to worship as he or she pleases This legislation sets forth the policy of the United States to protect and preserve the inherent right of American Indian, Eskimo, Aleut, and Native Hawaiian people to believe, express, and exercise their traditional religions,
as he signed into law the American Indian Religious Freedom Act.
Jimmy Carter
Let me tell you just a little something about the American Indian in our land. We have provided millions of acres of land for what are called preservations or reservations, I should say. They, from the beginning, announced that they wanted to maintain their way of life, as they had always lived there in the desert and the plains and so forth. And we set up these reservations so they could, and have a Bureau of Indian Affairs to help take care of them. At the same time, we provide education for them schools on the reservations. And theyre free also to leave the reservations and be American citizens among the rest of us, and many do. Some still prefer, however, that way that early way of life. And weve done everything we can to meet their demands as to how they want to live. Maybe we made a mistake. Maybe we should not have humored them in that wanting to stay in that kind of primitive lifestyle. Maybe we should have said, no, come join us; be citizens along with the rest of us.
Ronald Reagan
This government to government relationship is the result of sovereign and independent tribal governments being incorporated into the fabric of our Nation, of Indian tribes becoming what our courts have come to refer to as quasi-sovereign domestic dependent nations. Over the years the relationship has flourished, grown, and evolved into a vibrant partnership in which over 500 tribal governments stand shoulder to shoulder with the other governmental units that form our Republic.
George Herbert Walker Bush
Let us rededicate ourselves to the principle that all Americans have the tools to make the most of their God-given potential. For Indian tribes and tribal members, this means that the authority of tribal governments must be accorded the respect and support to which they are entitled under the law. It means that American Indian children and youth must be provided a solid education and the opportunity to go on to college. It means that more must be done to stimulate tribal economies, create jobs, and increase economic opportunities.
Bill Clinton
Tribal sovereignty means that. Its sovereign. Youre a youre a youve been given sovereignty and youre viewed as a sovereign entity.
George W. Bush
We also recommit to supporting tribal self-determination, security, and prosperity for all Native Americans. While we cannot erase the scourges or broken promises of our past, we will move ahead together in writing a new, brighter chapter in our joint history.
Barack Obama

Although there's not a quote for him I think Jackson was one of the worst
He was listed 3rd here is just a portion of the quote given:
"They have neither the intelligence, the industry, the moral habits, nor the desire of improvement which are essential to any favorable change in their condition. Established in the midst of another and a superior race, and without appreciating the causes of their inferiority or seeking to control them, they must necessarily yield to the force of circumstances and ere long disappear.
Andrew Jackson
Yes, he was bad, but for me it's Washington and Lincoln.
Washington, who could not have survived that first winter at Valley Forge without Polly Cooper and her heroic battle to keep him and his troops alive:
Next is Lincoln, the two-faced god of freedom that ordered the death of Indians in Minnesota to make way for the white settlers. He is idolized as the epitome of the symbol of freedom for all mankind, as the symbol of equality for all mankind. He makes me sick.
I am glad to see I can still maintain a sense of respect for Thomas Jefferson.
And as long as we keep electing people that are of this frame of mind we will never see any serious changes being made with regard to the Native American.
He has excited domestic insurrections amongst us, and has endeavored to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian savages, whose known rule of warfare, is undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.
From the Declaration of Independence...That states the view of most to this day.
Thank you Larry, I missed that. I always think of Jackson and what he did to the Cherokees
This is the quote I mistakenly attributed to Jefferson. It seemed to me to be a warning that should the colonists seek to war against the Indians, it would turn into genocide, which would be a mistake. I suppose I gave the quote too much credit.
My mistake and my apologies.
still mimi, in many of the quotes and speeches that are not listed here there's always that sense of superiority they had in justifying the annihilation of the Indians, as if they were killing game
Anyone who targets woman and children for death and torture deserve the death penalty. They should be thankful they died easier deaths than their 800 civilian victims.
''anyone who targets woman and chidren for death and torture deserves the death penalty''...You are correct, there are a lot of whites that should be facing the death penalty. Wounded Knee, Sand Creek, Whitehill ring a bell with you? Oh, that's right, they give out Medals of Honor for killing Indian women and children.
You might what to get your facts and present all before making your comment Sean.
Like why the Dakota war started.
so why were the members of the Cavalry responsible for the killing of women, children and elders at Wounded Knee awarded Congressional Medals of Honor?
And the US government was ok with the slaughter of Indian women and children for the hundreds of years before that.
You really should try to be accurate Sean. Strawman argument on your part.
You really should check the massacre datesby the government before the Dakota war.
As you have no idea of the truth of the subject you are discussing you should educate yourself and come back for intelligent discourse.
In other words, it is best to remain silent and be thought an idiot than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.
Up until the late 1800's, it was not considered a crime to kill an Indian, for any reason, in some parts of this country. A white man could do it with impunity. He could also kill a Chinese without fear of reprisal.
Just out of curiosity - do you show the same concern with the "slaughtered defenseless Indianwomaen and children"?
Killed before and after?
You really should check the massacre datesby the government before the Dakota war.
And I can reference massacres of settlers that predate the Minnesotta Massacre as well. We can deabte the topic in circles but the issue here is President Lincoln's cconduct in the aftermath of the Minnessota Massacre.
Hundreds of Dakotas were sentenced to death in the aftermath of the Massacre. Lincoln pardoned or commuted the sentence of hundreds of condemned Dakota. Basically, anyone who could bring forth any evidence that they acted defensively was spared death. Only the worst offenders were actually executed.
Is it your position that the President was totally in the wrong for punishing those guilty of committing atrocities? IS it your position that Dakota were free to murder woman and children without fear of reprisal?
Hundreds of Dakotas were sentenced to death in the aftermath of the Massacre. Lincoln pardoned or commuted the sentence of hundreds of condemned Dakota. Basically, anyone who could bring forth any evidence that they acted defensively was spared death. Only the worst offenders were actually executed...
That is incorrect. The Dakota were not afforded lawyers, each ''trial'' took 5 minutes, and some that were hanged were innocent of any crime.
Is it your position that the killing and genocide of Indians was acceptable. It seems it was, since history tells a different story they the one you are trying to present.
You have not addressed the cause of the ''Dakota'' war. Another side step on your part?
Being an invading force, the government was taking our land/lives and we fought back. I would assume that is something that you would do as well, isn't it?
This is a good article regarding the treachery of the US government.
Do you agree that those guilty of murdering woman and children were properly executed?
I don't believe genocide is acceptable. I'm not sure why you believe objecting to the targeting and killing of woman and children counts as a defense of Genocide. They are not the same thing.
The causes of the war are irrelevant as a defense to the Dakota targeting innocent woman and children for slaughter. If the Dakota had attacked the military this would be a different discussion. Instead they attacked defenseless woman and children. Presumably, lincoln wouldn't have executed adversaries who fought against the army, instead of defenseless civilians.
I have no problem with Indians fighting back against the military. It's massacring civilians I have a problem with.
C'mon folks, get a grip!~! What the Hell they're only Indians.
Indeed we are but not to those who hate us as virulently today as evidenced by arguments against us by people who no longer can summarily shoot us as they used to do! My Grandfather always said that; while we were beaten in battle we were not and are not defeated. We arenow gaining many supportersby people who recognize the travesty playing out against us also even today.nvwatohiyadv Peace? Not as long as there are people who would not recognize the injustices perpetrated against us.
I read where people today, when reminded of the atrocities against our Fathers, claim that it was our fault because we fought back as they stole our lands. That is pathetic.
The difference here, Robert, is that Washington did not see or place himself and his fellow white men in the category, therefore elevating themselves far, far above the Indian, and giving themselves the authority and right to slaughter them indiscriminately as they did all beasts.
Do you see the difference?
Sadly, Grandfather, we understand what you are saying.,, at least, most of us do.
Like in here mimi?
They have neither the intelligence, the industry, the moral habits, nor the desire of improvement which are essential to any favorable change in their condition. Established in the midst of another and a superior race
Indeed! I will not be satisfied until MOST becomes ALL. The talk of equality does not extend to our people.
As I explained in another post. They were not afforded lawyers, and each ''trial'' took 5 minutes. Do you know which ones were guilty? Of course you don't.
Not taking the reason for the war is avoiding the context of the war. They were being starved to death Sean. That certainly does have a bearing on it.
If you are so against the killing of women and children, they you must be against what the US government, ''Indian Hunters'' and settlers have done for hundreds of years Sean.
Larry Cerhore posted an excellent article on the first treaty signed between the Delaware people and the government. You might want to read it, to see the treachery and killing of Indians by the government.
You also might want to research the ''Sandy Lake Tragedy'' of 1852 same area, where the Ojibwe lost to starvation 500 people, most women and children, because of the government and settlers.
You see Sean, if you choose to use one incident to cover 500 years of history, than I would ask you this question. Do you agree with the genocide of American Indians? You also have to ask yourself, why, in addition to the army, did settlers, Indian Hunters etc. kill Indians by the thousands?
You may want to read about ''
Robert, sometimes you astound me with your willingness to view a situation objectively.
I honestly wish we could share a Coke. (I promise not to sing.)
Yes, thank you, palma.
ROTFL...I think it was ''Bonnie Prince Charles''. Not sure though.
Sean - before you comment anymore, track down the book - "Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee", by Dee Brown, and read from pages 40 - 72 (Little Crow's War). You will find an entirely different story than the one you are spewing.
Get some education on the subject matter before you engage in the conversation.
You are correct mimi - it was Jefferson and it was in 1804 just before he sent Lewis and Clark out for their tour.
He had just agreed to by, from the state of Georgia, for $1.25M, 48M acres of land, East of Georgia (to the Louisiana border) and gave his word that the U. S. would move all the Indians West of the Mississippi. It was called the 1802 Georgia Compact. -
Sorry, I meant 40 - 65.
Then I'm glad that Governor Ramseyand GeneralPope got hung along with them for the murders, rape and burning of the Lakota in Little Crow's tribe "before" Lincoln got involved /SSS
And, please take into account that Col. H. H. Sibley had the military round up 1,700 women and children and put them in a compound/corral as prisoners - prior to the battle. The battle occurred because Sibley refused to give the Santee their rations - for two months - because Congress had used the ration money to fund the Civil War.
The Santee had killed 20 men, taken the tenwomen and children as prisoners, on a raid to the agency to get their provisions - the provisions the Agent, Andrew Myrick, refused to give - instead, telling the Indians - "If you're hungry, eat grass."
There were no women and children killed in that battle - only men.
Not according to Dee's book. Col. Sibley demanded the return of the hostages, to which, Little Crow said no, not until the rations were awarded - then everything went to hell in a hand basket - forts were attacked, troopers were ambushed, villages were raided - that's why it's called Little Crow's War - it was nasty on both sides. But, no, no women or children were killed by the Indians as a result of the non-issuance of rations.
However - two months prior to that, four Indians were trying to steal some eggs (no rations), the farmer shot at them, the Indians killed five people - three men and two women - not a part of the war, but may have been the catalyst.
Now, where are the words from the Original Founding Fathers?
I love it, I have a t shirt like it.
owever - two months prior to that, four Indians were trying to steal some eggs (no rations), the farmer shot at them, the Indians killed five people - three men and two women - not a part of the war, but may have been the catalyst.
The Baker Farm Massacre occurred on August 17, 1862. Every other source I've seen provides different details of what provoked the massacre, which included killing a young girl.
Regardless, the Dakota began attacking settlements and farms the next day. According to the Minnesota historical society 644 non combatant settlers were killed over the next two months. Only 100 or so soldiers were killed in the war which was over within 60 days of the initial massacre of three men and two woman you reference.
Here's an excerpt of the story of the Souix war to give an idea of what life was like for some of the white "prisoners":
The primary and secondarily sourced evidence that ordinary settlers were killed and tortured is overwhelming.
"you choose to use one incident to cover 500 years of history, than I would"
That is the opposite of what I'm trying to do. I'm trying to confine my discussion to the conduct of president lincoln, who I believe is being unfairly slandered in this matter. I'm not defending the conduct of Americans before and after Lincoln or what happened out of his control. If you want to claim that their conduct as often reprehensible, I won't dispute it. Either you think people guilty of rape and murder should be punished or you,don't. I don't understand why the fact that some get away with it justifies not punishing others when the chance arises. The right or wrongness of punishment depends on the guilt of the rapist/ murderer not whether someone else got away with it.
But it's clearer than ever after reviewing numerous sources that atrocities were committed against hundreds of settlers. Atrocities that deserve the death penalty. The American people were outraged and the pressure on lincoln to execute Everyone found guilty was enormous. By only ordering the execution of those guilty of killing and rapeing civilians, lincoln took a massive political risk akin to commuting the sentences of those convicted of giving material support to the 9/11 bombers.
Lincoln did his best to make sure only the heinously guilty were executed. He was far, far ahead of the standards of his time in the effort he put into,getting it right. It's pretty clear to me from looking at the reports of the trial that the executed with one exception were In fact guilty. A lot of effort has been spent trying to clear them and one mistake was found due to a mistake over names. The army got the identity wrong, hardly Lincoln's fault.
And Lincoln made a deal with Ramsey, governor of MN. that if he supported Lincoln during the Civil War, that he, Lincoln would drive out, or kill every Indian in MN. Yes, he was a real statesmen.
Andrew Jackson (March 15, 1767 June 8, 1845) was the seventh President of the United States (18291837). Based in frontier Tennessee , Jackson was a politician and army general who defeated the Creek Indians at the Battle of Horseshoe Bend (1814), and the British at the Battle of New Orleans (1815). A polarizing figure who dominated the Second Party System in the 1820s and 1830s, as president he dismantled the Second Bank of the United States and initiated forced relocation and resettlement of Native American tribes from the Southeast to west of the Mississippi River with the Indian Removal Act (1830). His enthusiastic followers created the modern Democratic Party . The 18301850 period later became known as the era of Jacksonian democracy .
I'm glad things have changed. It may not have changed as much as it should, but it was completely out of hand back then by all parties involved.
As I read the quotes I see that history is changing for the better. But then I read the comments and it is clear that some still hold some bitterness and hatred for their fellow man. The quotes also show us how mistakes were made in our history but they also show us where we are learning from those mistakes. I would like to think that this Great Nation of OURS ( The United States of America) has grown to be a Nation of laws where the individual as well as the groups of people are treated and protected equally and not a nation of People where one individual or one group of people are treated more importantly than the other...
I understand you would like to think that, LoneRanger.
Unfortunately, you are wrong. I take it from your comment you believe that Indians unfairly hold bitterness and hatred for their "fellow man." In order to learn the truth of the situation, you first have to disabuse yourself of the notion that all think as you do... not every non Indian considers us all to be "fellow men."
Therein lies the root of the problem.
I had that same feeling, ambi. There in lies the root cause of many of the modern misconceptions of the ongoing abuse of the First People by the government, even today. They are still trying to displace our people from their designated reservation place on the most remote and worthless lands they had. They, through the BIA are still refusing to account for the billions of dollars literally stolen from legitimate Indian revenues which they claim they are holding in trust for us. I had a Federally imposed story of the genocide I was going to post but itwas a long read and I expect it would like all others of its nature fallen upon deaf ears anyway. What the Hell we're only Indians, so what's so bad,right?
Sorry screminmi, but you are sadly mistaken on both counts. This is a nation of laws and not a nation of individuals. Thats a fact. And I said nothing about Indians unfairly holding bitterness and Hatred for their fellow men. I said SOME (individual comments)hold bitterness and hatred. notice I never mentioned any race of people.
No matter how perfect the world is there will always be individuals who are filled with hate and biggotry. that is also a fact. But as a nation of laws we can fight those individuals and or groups of people. And thats what makes this Nation of OURS so GREAT.
That's the way I read your comment also LR1, but I didn't have an agenda when I was reading it.
Spikegary, everyone has an agenda, to think otherwise is nave.
I have an agenda, and that is to fight for equal rights for Indian people. I have for decades and will continue until I die.
LR, yes there are bigoted people and always will be. Perhaps it would have been better if you had mentioned the people that you felt hold bitterness and hatred.
We are a great nation, but one with warts, that many refuse to acknowledge.
Hey I'm not a wart. Well maybe I am in somebody's eyes. Statement withdrawn.
Jefferson was a hypocrite through and through.
He also said he would free his slaves... ask Sally Hemings how well that worked out. Did you think he would be better with Indians?
LOL!
We proclaim ourselves a nation of laws, yet within this nation of laws, not one single treaty made with Indians in which promises were made in return for their release of millions of acres of ancestral land, has ever been honored. Not one.
I'll leave the particulars of how this nation of laws has twisted and outright shoved aside the law concerning Indians when it was inconvenient to adhere to its principles, to the Teachers and Historians of our group, Kavika and 1stwarrior.
This is a nation of laws and not a nation of individuals.
This may be a nation of laws for you but, let me advise you please, that there are individuals in this wonderful land who cherry pick just which laws they intend to follow and ignore the ones that might just be something to ignore and they do it every day. Our current laws are predicated almost solely on just who you are not what and which makes Law Enforcement a lose lose situation daily.
Yes but you have to understand, mimi that this nations of laws was/is meant only for the White Man. In their mind, that is. Genocide of the Red Man and enslavement of the Black Man are side benefits for them.
No grandfather, your not a wart...hahahahaha
Maybe not in someone's eye
Have you ever seen a red wart? Holy Cow!!!
Red wart!!!!! LOLOLOL
Sorry for the delay, just saw your request. The excerpt comes from about page 100
Information below tells how President Lincoln and Minnesota Governor Alexander Ramsey set out to exterminate Indians from their home land.
Authorities in Minnesota asked President Lincoln to order the immediate execution of all 303 Indian males found guilty. Lincoln was concerned with how this would play with the Europeans, whom he was afraid were about to enter the war on the side of the South. He offered the following compromise to the politicians of Minnesota: They would pare the list of those to be hung down to 39. In return, Lincoln promised to kill or remove every Indian from the state and provide Minnesota with 2 million dollars in federal funds. Remember, he only owed the Sioux 1.4 million for the land.
I'm looking for another article that is much more detailed. When I find it, I'll post it here.
Actually it isn't 38, it 40. Two more where hung at a later date.
Not a quote, but James K. Polk-Dem set four goals for his administration and two of these had major implications for American Indians: (1) the acquisition of the Oregon Territory, and (2) the acquisition of California and New Mexico. Polk himself had little direct contact with Indians, but the policies established during his administration had long-lasting ramifications for Indian tribes and Indian people.
MN support was very important to Lincoln.
1. The evidence is overwhelming that lincoln decided who and how many were executed. The only evidence of Ramsey's involvement is his pressure for lincoln to hang all 300 or that the people of Minnesota would lincoln hand wrote out the names he thought worthy of execution and personally brought the list to the telegraph operator so he could impress upon hi the importance of sending the names,correctly lest the wrong person be hanged,. These are not the actions of someone who would promise to indiscriminately kill or remove every Indian .
2. Indians remain in Minnesota on their own reservations to this day.
Most of the Dakota were driven out of MN Sean. The majority of Indians in MN are Ojibwe, of which I am a member of the Red Lake Band.
As for number 1. I'll have to go back and re read the article. I'm sure that it stated the agreement between Lincoln and Ramsey, and later the tactics that Ramsey used to purge the Dakota.