Paul Files Lawsuit Over Obama Administration Data Collection
Sen. Rand Paul invoked the ideals of the American Revolution Wednesday as he filed a class action lawsuit in federal court in Washington against President Barack Obama and his administration over the National Security Agencys collection of telephone metadata records.
Paul said the suit could involve hundreds of millions of Americans -- everyone who uses a phone.
Paul added that We fought the American Revolution because we were unhappy about British soldiers writing generalized warrants. We wrote the Fourth Amendment to be specific to the person, to the place and to the items.
He told reporters that Im not against the NSA; Im not against spying; Im not against looking at phone records. I just want you to go to a judge, have a persons name, and individualize the warrant. Thats what the Fourth Amendment says.
Lead counsel in the case is Ken Cuccinelli, the former attorney general of Virginia who lost last years gubernatorial election in that state. He said the goal of the suit is to order the NSA to stop its telephone data collection and to purge five years worth of records. If you look at several levels of courts, this will be a several years-long process, Cuccinelli told reporters.
Tags
Who is online
91 visitors

He has made Judges dependent on his Will alone, for the tenure of their offices, and the amount and payment of their salaries.
He has erected a multitude of New Offices, and sent hither swarms of Officers to harrass our people, and eat out their substance.
Perhaps you are right, but he is keeping the subject in the forefront and that is the real intention anyhow. He is educating people on what is being taken from them and that it is NOT OK.Many people are clueless as to the fact that they have lost their right to privacy, and even more are clueless of just how much they have lost, so there is still much educating to do. Sure it will probably fall flat eventually, but it will be front page news at least once again before it does and will therefore continue to cause the NSA and their puppeteers pain for their illegal actions. It's called keeping the pressure on.Sometimes you can't stop wrong doing, but you can certainly bring it to peoples attention.
Probably Hawaii.
Yeah! Sue the black guy who has moved to mitigate the practice
But don't go after the white guys who started it.
You asked for this.
THE GEORGE W. BUSH INDISCRETIONS NOT BEING ADDRESSED BY HYPOCRITE RAND PAUL AND TEA PARTY SELECTIVELY-INDIGNANT FRAUDS.
Spying on American Citizens, Without a Court-Ordered Warrant, in Vi... .
Directing Telecommunications Companies to Create an Illegal and Unc... .
Need the details; click the links.
We agree Gunny; the Paul lawsuit is strictly political simply because, if the guilt is shared, the pursuit of justice be evenly implemented.
If Paul was sincere, he'd invoke Congress to convene a War Crimes investigation against Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Rice and the attorneys who conveniently interpreted the laws regarding torture.
Spend a minute at the links the evidence is overwhelmingly specific and voluminous.
he Paul lawsuit is strictly political simply because, if the guilt is shared, the pursuit of justice be evenly implemented.
That makes no sense. The lawsuit is to stop an abuse and that's it. Its the opposite of political. It will simply stop all Presidents, Democratic or Republican from engaging in this behavior.
Its great you believe the 4th Amendment should only apply when the President is white. Otherwise, I have no idea why you have to drag race into this. If an act is unconstitutional, its unconstitutional and should be stopped whether its being done by a
Democrat or a republican. Its sad you can't even agree to that.
Its goes without saying, if Bush is a war criminal, Obama obviously is as well.
Why didn't Paul and you and other Republicans try to stop the (even more egregious) abuses that started under Bush?
Same 4th Amendment back then.
A crime is a crime, we agree; but you righties are only bitching about Obama -- and never did about Bush. I didn't say one was innocent and one guilty;on the contrary, I asked why you boys only just got indignant.
Don't piss in my face and tell me "it's raining". And don't put words in my mouth and/or misrepresent what I write.
Aside from political party affiliation and ideology, what's the most glaring difference between Bush and Obama?
The answer exists on its FACE.
George is to blame for starting it, Obama is to blame for continuing and radically expanding the monster. (contrary to his campaign claims)
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized*
*unless the prior executive was of caucasion skin color, and the current executive is not
According to who/what source(s)?
So, we agree JoAnne. Righties never went after Bush for what he started, and for what Obama has continued (and recently mitigated).
Selective, disingenuous
I have to agree with you on this 96. I think the American people are woefully ignorant about what is going on in our government. We are losing our privacy no one is even blinking.
Agreed; that's not my issue. My issue is the selective indignation and the fact that many of those who now (rightly) object to domestic spying, had no apparent problem with it when Bush started it.
I have been clear and consistent throughout this thread but no one has acknowledged the double standard I object to.
...
I have plenty more if you have the time to read/watch.
I haven't argued that Obama has not continued the domestic spying. Your contention is that he "radically expanded it". In fact, he recently moved to mitigate it (although it took an Edward Snowden) to force his hand.
Let's not exaggerate the realities. Wrong is wrong and accurate is accurate.
And I'm still waiting for everyone to acknowledge my point, that is, the failure of those who now castigate the Obama Administration's domestic spying, for neither in the past, nor in this thread, acknowledging the guilt of the Bush Administration for putting domestic spying in place -- along with torture and other Constitutional violations. Only BF has had the integrity to do so.
Selective indignation is hypocrisy.
In 2008-9, I published two books, much of which dealt with double-standard hypocrisy; here is a portion of one of those books.
Sorry, A MAc, but you are out in left field on this. Play the Race Card much? (yes, that was rhetorical). This is to stop the program not to settle old political scores.
Yeah, just now to stop the program.
Where were you indignant lovers of the Constitution when it all began and went on for years?
PLAY the race card? How about those who LIVE it?
But I'll listen to explanations as to why no Republicans bitched when Bush was the violator?
Try me.
Well I did admit that Bush started it. I have also many times said that Obama continues the worst Bush policies. As far as radical expansion...You really think the snooping and invasion of privacy has held at the level it was when Bush was president, and the Patriot act was passed the first time? Really?
Doesn't matter what I think; the one making the allegation has the burden of proof. If you can't verify it, then don't state it declaratively -- clearly state it as your opinion rather than in a talking down manner.
Fair enough; I'll accept your word.
But I still have a problem with claims that Obama expanded domestic spying particularly after he recently stated he'll rein some of it in (which is not the same as ending it).
Are you going to start speaking in tongues soon?
It is political because he is a politician and politicians do political things. He is simply positioning himself with some easy pickins from the tree of publicity.
Mac,
Bush is mostly to blame, He took advantage of a bad situation and passed something that otherwise would have never gotten through. Obama has plenty of blame to shoulder as well, he led us to believe he would do away with this BS (see prior video link) by saying he would protect us without invading out privacy, then signedthe Patriot act into law...again.... twice and, yes privacy abuse has gotten worse under his watch. I think for the most part Obama has continued the worst Bush policies and added a few of his own I constantly point out their similarities. You had to have seen me post this link before, you just probably ignored it.