CBO Estimates PPACA Will Push 2 Million Out of the Work Force
Obamacare will push the equivalent of about 2 million workers out of the labor market by 2017 as employees decide either to work fewer hours or drop out altogether, according to the latest estimates Tuesday from the Congressional Budget Office.
Thats a major jump in the nonpartisan budget agencys projections and it suggests the health care laws incentives are driving businesses and people to choose government-sponsored benefits rather than work.
CBO estimates that the ACA will reduce the total number of hours worked, on net, by about 1.5 to 2 percent during the period from 2017 to 2024, almost entirely because workers will choose to supply less labor given the new taxes and other incentives they will face and the financial benefits some will receive, CBO analysts wrote in their new economic outlook.
The scorekeepers also said the rollout problems with the Affordable Care Act last year will mean only 6 million people sign up through the state-based exchanges, rather than the 7 million the CBO had originally projected.
But over the long run, Obamacare will eventually catch up and by 2020 only about 30 million people will be without insurance coverage down from 45 million this year. That will mean about 92 percent of legal U.S. residents without guaranteed access to Medicare will have insurance coverage.
Taking the budget as a whole, the CBO said Congress has made substantial headway on cutting spending and raising taxes, which has cut the deficit in 2014 to just $514 billion.
That deficit will continue to drop in 2015, but will then begin to quickly rise, once again topping $1 trillion in 2022.
The CBO analysis said the economy isnt rebounding as fast as usual after such a deep recession, and said that poor growth means less revenue coming in to the Treasury Department which means the cumulative deficit over the next decade will be $1 trillion more than projected just last year.
Debt, which is the accumulation of those annual deficits, is already at its highest level since the aftermath of World War II, and the CBO says debt held by the public will be nearly 80 percent of gross domestic product by 2024, which is the end of the budget window.
The new report will give ammunition to those who argued that tax increases or spending cuts should have been delayed while the government pursued more stimulus spending to boost economic growth over the last few years.
But the CBOs report also suggests that the problems are more structural, given the aging U.S. population and womens participation in the labor force.
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/feb/4/cbo-obamacare-push-2m-workers-out-labor-market/#ixzz2sNM5crMR
Tags
Who is online
71 visitors

It's exactly what anyone with the tiniest understanding of human nature who looked at this monstrosity (after it was passed of course, Congress had to pass it before anyone could look look at it) predicted would happen. The incentives are so blatant for employers to act this way its hard to imagine the bills authors could have wanted anything else to happen.
Idiocy like this makes me believe Obamacare was designed to fail. Its purpose is too wreak as much havoc as possible within the healthcare system so that single payer becomes the simplest solution to the Obamacare disaster. The only way to make single payer viable is to separate voters from the employer based health care polls show voters overwhelmingly liked. Obamacare is doing a splendid job of accomplishing that.
In the meantime, sucks to be you Mr/Ms Middle class. Obamacare is going to make your life a nightmare for the next few years.
at what point, will one consider that the frequency and gravity of all the failurescan simplynot be unplanned, by any streatch of the imagination? the only logical, obvious as the nose on ones faceexplaination is, they are not failures at all.
rotfl
1- Article did not link to the CBOs study. Not good.
2 Article did not mention from what categories and fields the ACA is supposed to create unemployment from. Getting worse.
3 Article says substantially nothing.
PS - Found CBO report here - ...
Please, not the Washington Times.
The worst of the worst.
As for
Let's see; where have we heard this before, and again, and again, and
Barb-btco
This is from the CBO which President Obama and his supporters have continually quoted as they campaigned for support of the PPACA
I do not for a second doubt that more people will have access to health care services as a result of the PPACA
This article is about the CBO predictions of the PPACA effectis about the effect on jobs and the economy
As always thanks for the feedback and perspective
A P
Thanks for the link to this report
It is long an d I am looking through it (not reading every page) and it gives me the same general idea of the predictions as this article does but with a lot more detail
Thanks again
A Mac
Why not talk about the issue, the topic rather than dismiss it because the source does not meet your approval
I feel the same way whenever I see something from Fox News, the Huffington Post, and many other sources
The article is not about anything the GOP said or the Washington Times said it is about what the CBO said
As always I appreciate the enormous cut and paste in lieu of what you might think
There is no issue; the allegation has been debunked.
What I think is based on the information I posted that debunks the Washington Times' bogus claim. Were I to merely paste my opinion with no verification or validation, you and anyone else would have every right to challenge it.
That's the very point; the CBO did not say it! The right wing Washington Times said the CBO said it!
In plain English, the story is not true!
Let's have an understanding regarding what you criticize as "cut and paste". When I post information the rebuts an article or opinion, I do so as a way of saying -- here's what I, think, here's why I think it and here's my source(s) for thinking what I think.
Anyone can express an opinion, but, opinions that are contrary to facts are worthless at best and deceptive to dangerous depending on their nature and how widespread they become.
More-and-more I stay away from the front page because this should not have to be explained.
Based on the skepticism expressed above by A Mac and Aeon Pax
Here is a direct excerpt from the CBO report (AP's provided link) which says substantially the same thing as the article so perhaps the topic can be discussed since the source is the CBO not the Washington TImes
...
(page 123 of the report)
A Mac
Read the direct excerpt from the CBO report below
It seems that the CBO may disagree with you
But of course that would make them wrong, since you are right correct?
Mike,
The CBO is NOT saying it, the Washington, Times, Forbes and Republicans are saying it.
Again and I'm finished.
Go to page 31 of AP's linked report and tell me what the CBO'S PROJECTED UNEMPLOYMENT RATE IS BETWEEN NOW AND THE YEAR 2020.
Please post the information.
Translation RISING INCOME means workers will be able to earn in fewer hours what they previously earned working longer hours.
Anyone here who would care to earn his/her current wages while working fewer hours?
Do place your name on the record.
Further, in the time frame involved, how many workers will reach retirement age and leave the workforce?
There are a quite a number of gray areas.
Discuss those gray areas then and not the Washington Times
Thanks for the feedback
JOhn
Exactly what the title of the article said
Yes they will decide to accept benefits not to work rather than work
A great comment on the American work ethic and where it is going
The health insurance premium subsidies are phased out with RISING INCOME, therefore discouraging work, according to the CBO. The reduced hours will equate to a decline in the number of full-time-equivalent workers of about 2 million in 2017, rising to 2.5 million in 2024.
Translation RISING INCOME means workers will be able to earn in fewer hours what they previously earned working longer hours.
John
Interesting when the CBO says something that makes the PPACA or other Obama policy look good it is considered the gospel around here but when it is even slightly negative "nor is it anything more than a guess".
Seems like a double standard but I am getting usedto that
Thanks for the perspective
I also agree with your conclusion that the PPACA needs to be corrected
Barb btco
Because employees do that all the time right?
Read my additional comments. My rebuttal is not with the facts, rather how the facts have been misrepresented to create incorrect conclusions and bogus cause and effect relationships.
Rising incomes and NOT the PPACA will change the work force.
I have RiO; read my additional comments.
That is exactly what I am afraid of.....there are no failures...everything is going exactly according to plan...
A Mac
Huge assumption
That wages will rise enough to allow for that outcome
If it happens (big if) I agree it would be a good thing, but I have no confidence that it will happen anytime in the near future
And the CBO report is talking about people who will not be working at all (pushed out of the work force) but rather receiving benefits while not working.
Not exactly :
That is not rising incomes causing the change but tax disincentives to work.
You don't see a problem with the fact that people will "choose" not to work because they can make as much on the dole if they don't work as much...or not at all? Really?
Equally interesting; articles treated as gospel that regularly get posted when the "Obamacare" misrepresentations are published on every right-wing blog and invariably wind up on our NT Front Page.
I have posted additional comments that specifically address the projected work force causes and what the more likely causes may be.
Anyone care to address them, especially the HIGHER WAGES projection?
How about workers who become Social Security/Medicare eligible leaving the workforce in the projected time frame?
A Mac
This is not a right wing blog this is the CBO, perhaps you have hear of it
Located in Washington, does work for the Congress
I addressed your rising wage to offset fewer hours below and it misses the point that the report says that people will cease to work at all
You have cut and pasted a lot of stuff and I read most of it
I was thinking of discussing not cutting and pasting but thanks for the perspectives of others that you have shared
I appreciate the efforts to share info
A Mac
You are the master of cut and past so do it yourself
I have posted information from the CBO report which is the source of the information which I think is more relevant than outside reports
I'm not assuming this, the projected unemployment rate is on Page 31 of the CBO report LOWER UNEMPLOYMENT AND HIGHER WAGES.
Oh, yeah big talking point with not only no substantiation but the opposite!
Redistribution of wealth has gone to the top 1% while others suffer!
But it's good to see that the wealthy have their advocates, Mike.
CEO-To-Worker Pay Ratio Ballooned 1,000 Percent Since 1950: Report
Take it up with the CBO it's their assumption.
The report says rising wages, nothing about "on the dole"
Are we going to have a discussion or are we going to make up shit in order to make bogus points?
Ya' know what I'm really tired of this.
I'm out.
Unemployment rate is calculated by those collecting unemployment. If people choose not to work or choose to work less this would not show up on unemployment for more than what, 6 months? (and even then, only if they were let go) Are you really trying to say that REAL unemployment will drop? The reality is unemployment as it is measured today will drop...but that is not reality.... is it?
A new study finds that Obamacare's redistribution will be stunningly lopsided. Scholars at the liberal Brookings Institution have discovered that Obamacare will increase the income of Americans in the lowest 20 percent of the income scale, and especially in the lowest ten percent. But all other income groups -- even people who make very modest incomes in the $25,000 to $30,000 range, as well as all income brackets above that -- will experience a decline in income because of Obamacare.
In other words, Obamacare is going to cost some of the very people it was designed to help
John
On what do you base the fact that it will be self employed people that the report is talking about?
The report is talking about people leaving the work force and choosing to get government benefits rather than work
That does not sound like self employed folks to me
A Mac
So now the CBO is right
I get it
Mike
They are the absolute authority, if they support the correct side of a debate otherwise they are simply guessers like the rest of the world
I did not question the CBO, I questioned the intentional misrepresentation regarding the cause and effect implications, that by the Washington Times and other right-wing outlets.
The PPACA will not be the cause of the workforce change, rather a combination of factors higher wages, an increase in the age of the workforce social security/medicare eligibility
The implication and inference that the PPACA will be the direct and only cause of workforce changes by 2020-2024 is disingenuous. Again, I point to the graph at the top of page 31 of the CBO PDF link. It shows a decline in the unemployment rate over the period. That does not, as one person commented, indicate a higher "dole" (more individuals on unemployment), it indicates the opposite.
A Mac
That you cut and paste rather than discuss in your own words is annoying but I accept it
That your feelings are hurt when it is pointed out is ridiculous
I love books and I love to discuss books with other people, but we do not tear out the pages and hand them to each other, we talk about what we learned from the books, what we interpreted that the author meant and what the book's teachings mean in a broader sense.
Get over yourself and discuss what you think rather than sharing what others think
Mike
Page 30 is in chapter 1 and I am not seeing what you mean
Another insult.
Education "information about or training in a particular field or subject"
Much of what I think and share comes from what I have learned in the process of my education. I apologize for standing on the shoulders of giants.
If I just stated my opinion I'd be asked for validation, an/or likely be challenged by those of disparate opinions if I state my opinion and offer validation, I'm castigated for essentially giving opinion plus rhyme and reason.
Criticizing participants for offering too much information really?
As the cost of health care declines and wages increase, workers will not have to work as hard and as long.
Guess you missed this
...and I guess I missed the"rising wages" part...
Wow ... really ? That is not going to happen . Modern medicine is designed to make lotsa moola .
That's a positive; the headline presents the PPACA effects as a negative.
"Will Push" implies that workers will be forced against their preferences "Out of the Work Force".
THIS IS DISHONEST ON TWO COUNTS:
1) Workers will not be forced out of their jobs!
2) They will by choice, work fewer hours because the can make essentially the same wages while working fewer hours
Another insult.
If you don't care for my providing documentation behind my opinions, I'm sorry I wasted your time and mine.
Are you trying to say that contrary to everything I witness in everyday life, and read about the middle class, that middle class wages are actually on the rise? Or anyone's except the top 10% for that matter?
Let's hope so; do you think the working poor and the middle class will continue to elect the Paul Ryans and other anti-worker pimps for the rich?
Check some of the stuff the right-wing sources don't tell you.
"Let 'em eat cake" has a way of causing the criminal rich and their political pimps to lose their heads (elections). Look at Virginia, and watch Pennsylvania, Florida and other states in coming elections.
The wage disparity has gone on too long and once desperation becomes the prevailing feeling of working poor and middle class, first, they demonstrate (notice any minimum wage demonstrations recently).
You may be cheering for the status quo, if so, shame on you.
A MAc
That is not an insult
You have amazingly thin skin for someone so aggressive in commenting style
I suggested you might offer something that you thought rather than simply pasting what others think but choosing not to actually participate personally is your choice and I respect that
BTW Jon
It is the title of the article
So you and A Mac should send a letter to the publisher and editor of the paper and register your complaint about their choice of titles
The equivalent of 2 million workers will be removed from the economy that is the pont and that is accurately taken from the BO report
The CBO is not saying workers wlll be PUSHED out of the work force; the headline misrepresents the CBO report. In fact, the opposite is true; workers will earn more and work fewer hours AND INSTEAD OF YOU AND OTHERS ACKNOWLEDGING THAT, YOU ATTACK ME FOR POSTING THE VERY INFORMATION THAT VERIFIES IT!
Show me where the CBO implies that. Workers will be able to afford more because their wages will increase the opposite of being subsidized. From the same author in the same publication.
You seed an article verbatim and get on my case for both telling you what I think about the seed and backing up my reasons!
In the world where credibility matters, be it a term paper, a thesis for an advanced degree, in a court of law or before an arbitration hearing, when one puts his name and reputation behind something, he does so by validating and verifying his presentation.
That's the standard I go by even if it's (only) on a blog.
From Brookings
And why shouldn't the lowest income demographic benefit when the 1% has seen a 1000% jump in their incomes since 1950 while everyone else remains relatively flat?
Or would you prefer they remain poor, uninsured and just die because staying alive and healthy is just too much of a burden on the rest of us poor 1% folk my heart goes out to you.
Its soooo clever how you ignored what she said . Nice tap dance ... very artistic .
Are you her representative?
I posted directly from the article she linked.
You don't provide any information so get off my ass.
From the Brookings Report JoAnne linked
Which is better than ignoring info that someone else has posted . Yes , that is what you did . Deflections from the point that was made are all you've got .
No .
Instead of your one-line rhetorical, no-substance comments, when I post a specific comment, you need to respond with a specific comment.
Everything you can't adequately handle you call a "deflection".
Get off my ass either have a discussion or don't address me.
I responded to your comment regarding JoAnne's link. I quoted the Brooking's article; I saw nothing to corroborate JoAnne's numbers so now it's on you. Either verify JoAnne's assessment of the Brooking's article, acknowledge the accuracy of mine or butt the f out.
John
Read the report John, 2 the equivalent of 2 million full time workers
It was pretty obvious to everyone else but I am glad to explain it to you
As always thanks for the feedback
A Mac
The article I posted is from the Washington Times and the information it links to is from the CBO - bot well known organizations that you must have heard of.
I stand by the comments that I have made, but the information they are based on is from the CBO
I am quite confident that the CBO needs no validation from me or even from A Mac
Thanks for all the information and for the back and forth
Barb btco
I love it when you get all sarcastic .......
I noticed that you ignored my question but that is okay the answer is obvious from your quip
John
And I thought you were going to get through an article without name calling and insults but you couldn't for it
Glad to see you can spell so well, next article we will do some math ok?
John you are an intelligent man, even though you have pronounced biases
I think that the million was portrayed as the equivalent of 2 million full time employees has been and continues to be obvious to everyone
It is a lot of fun when you get all holier than thou and decide you have to explain what is really true to everyone
Keep it up
Petey and A Mac
Please do not say "ass"it is offensive and adds nothing substantive to the discussion
a shame no one warned about all this before the election, and the re-election.
OK : Reread Joanne's comment but this time don't ignore what she said . And stop cursing just to distract from your irresponsible inattention .
I already asked that he not say ass