Abbas Ends Chance for Peace, Statehood
When people are informed that there are peace negotiations going on between Israel and the Palestinians, most do the obligatory eye-roll, with the accompanying sarcastic sigh of 'Yeah, this'll work... again'.
This time is no exception.
In an interview with the New York Times this week,President Abbas made clear that there would be no Palestinian recognition of Israel as a Jewish State. His exact words were "This is out of the question". There's not much ambiguity in his statement, as you can see. Everything was put on the table by the agreed upon mediator, the US. There were a number of provisions that both parties found objectionable. The idea is to sit down, face to face and hammer out compromises. This does not appear to be in the cards.
Invariably, Israel will be the singled out as the intransigent party, and be held solely responsible for the lack of progress. At this point, the issues no longer figure in the discussion. For those opposed to Israel's existence, it will be business as usual, as they boycott, divest, sanction, propagandize and incite to violence. For Israel, it will be business as usual, defending itself in the media and at its borders.
Just another day in paradise...
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/03/world/middleeast/palestinian-leader-seeks-nato-force-in-future-state.html?_r=0
Tags
Who is online
71 visitors

From the NY Time interview:
On recognition of Israel as a Jewish state, Mr. Abbas said, This is out of the question, noting that Jordan and Egypt were not asked to do so when they signed peace treaties with Israel. He presented a 28-page packet he has been distributing widely that included a 1948 letter signed by President Harry Truman in which Jewish state was crossed out and replaced by State of Israel; statements by Israels founding prime minister, David Ben-Gurion; and a paper on Edwin Montagu, a Jewish member of the British cabinet who opposed the 1917 Balfour Declaration supporting a national home for the Jewish people in Palestine.
Mr. Abbas sites different agreements with different countries. They were different in that they could be trusted. The Palestinians have already abrogated several agreements in the last 40+ years. Perhaps they should have stuck to those agreements.
They also commonly invoke the need for new agreements, yet they site old agreements that they feel Israel should apply in this case.
I think I may vomit.
If you have an extra bucket, pass it this way.
It's not the peace partner role. It's the victim role.
When you're a peace partner, you look for ways to solve the problem.
When you're a victim, it's all in the hands of the other guy, and it's the other guy's fault if things don't work out, because you're a victim.
I think the Arab Winter is cold enough without another one...
Its too much fun rabble rousing against Israel to even consider recognition ... If they did how will they ever attain the same level of fun ... and UN payments ?
Seriously though, this "movement" was created solely to create a narrative of "the struggle".
If they were to actually sign on the dotted line, they would cease to function as originally intended, and, as you pointed out, would forever suckle on the teat of the UN.
Jonathan,
Not that I disagree with you, but just for clarification, what is the real difference between recognizing the "State of Israel" and a "Jewish State"?
And if there is no real difference, why not call him on it?
You play cards, right?
The difference is critical to Israel, and Jews throughout the world. If you've noticed, the world is becoming less welcoming to Jews again. Last time that happened, there was no Jewish State, and therefore, nowhere for these threatened people to find refuge. That resulted in the extermination of 40% of the world's Jewish population.
To others, it appears semantic.
To those negotiating with Israel, it's a fallback in case they get too close to an agreement. The Palestinians will never agree to peace with Israel, because that is their function; they were created for the purpose of "the struggle". A treaty would render them useless to their handlers.
I have been a proponent of Israel accepting whatever Kerry brings to the table, as I am fully confident that Abbas would never agree.
I agree. But no matter if you refer to it as Israel or the Jewish state, it will still operate as a Jewish state. So I say call him on the BS.
Which is why I am laughing at this. I totally agree. But I also think that it would be grand to show the PA as liars and remove the victim card while showing that the PA is not operating in the best interests of thePalestinians.
Alright already.
I've been cooking up an article in my brain for a couple weeks now. Here's the Readers' Digest version, just for you.
Kerry et al are cooking up a document that will serve as the basis for a peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians, which will 1)give the Palestinians statehood while 2)guaranteeing Israel defensible borders. What we know of the agreement is that there are a number of points that at least one of the parties will find, at best, difficult to swallow. What this means is that there will need to be a number of compromises made in order for the agreement to fly. We know from history that the Palestinians are not the compromising type.
Allegedly, in the document, we have
1)The Palestinians stipulating that Israel is a Jewish State
2)The creation of the State of Palestine will obviate the need for "right of return", and therefore there will be no "right of return"
3)The IDF will have a permanent presence in the Jordan Valley
These are just 3 of the items that will eventually appear in the document. If ANY ONE of them appears, the Palestinians will not agree. It's a lock. Therefore, it should be incumbent upon Bibi and the entire government of Israel to agree to whatever it is that Kerry puts on the table. The Palestinians will not accept the deal, and the world will see Israel, sitting at the table alone, while the perpetually intransigent Palestinians are finally, globally recognized for what they are.