Excessive Force Case In NJ Highlights Lack Of Nationwide Police Accountability
Only 1 percent of all complaints made against New Jersey police officers for using excessive force, among other types of police brutality, were deemed legitimate and investigated by internal review teams between 2008 and 2012, according to an investigation [ 1 ] by a local newspaper.
Are U.S. police ever accountable for their actions? Only 1 percent of complaints made in the last 4 years against New Jersey officers for using excessive force and alleging brutality, bias and civil rights violations were actually investigated -- The other 99 percent? Dismissed.
The other 99 percent of complaints alleging brutality, bias and civil rights violations by officers at more than seven dozen police departments in central New Jersey during that five-year period were reportedly dismissed by internal review teams as being frivolous, lacking sufficient evidence, or in some cases the investigation was never closed, but the officers were still exonerated.
Since the national average is not much better with just 8 percent of all police brutality complaints nationwide being investigated many have begun to question whether police officers in the U.S. are ever held accountable for their actions.
Pete Eyre, of the organization Cop Block ,which works to hold police accountable, told MintPress that while the percentage of complaints varies slightly between police departments, only a miniscule amount are ever investigated.
The fact that almost all police complaints made are deemed not sustained isnt surprising, since Looking past stated veneer of accountability is a process of asking the friends of the aggressor to conclude that yes, they were indeed at fault.
The incentive of those investigating is to side with their colleagues. Theres no real negative consequence for that occurring and thus, it is the norm. Even if a community views their local police as largely being heavy-handed or corrupt, the police outfit a coercive monopoly cant easily be fired in lieu of a better alternative, Eyre said.
But South Brunswick Police Chief Raymond Hayducka, a former president of the New Jersey State Association of Chiefs of Police who has been called upon to provide expert testimony on police matters and worked on the revision to the states internal affairs guidelines, insists that Agencies do a good job of self-policing.
Representatives of Union County and Somerset Prosecutors Offices agreed , saying that there is nothing wrong with its policies, noting that investigations of police brutality are conducted when they are warranted no more, no less.
But in a breakdown of each police departments police brutality complaints, the Central Jersey Courier News and Home News Tribune found that in many towns and cities not a single complaint was investigated.
In Elizabeth, N.J., for example, there were 203 recorded complaints in the five-year period and not one was found to be substantial. Similarly, Woodbridge, N.J., had 84 complaints, New Brunswick, had 81, Perth Amboy had 50 and Linden had 33.
Part of what is so surprising about some of these shockingly low rates of investigating claims of police brutality by New Jersey police officers is that there were low numbers across the board, including at some departments that have a notorious reputation for using excessive force.
In Edison, N.J., for example, there were 32 recorded complaints of excessive force, and one officer in particular was the subject of 11 of those complaints. Yet none of those complaints were determined to require further investigation.
Tags
Who is online
60 visitors

"As MintPress previouslyreported, each year there are thousands of claims of police misconduct. According to the CATO Institutes National Police Misconduct Reporting Project , in 2010 there were 4,861 unique reports of police misconduct involving 6,613 sworn officers and 6,826 alleged victims. Most of those allegations of police brutality involved officers who punched or hit victims with batons, but about one-quarter of the reported cases involved firearms or stun guns."
Internal investigation is a joke. What is needed is an independent review board. Not a bunch of cops making excuses for one another.
It isn't just that they don't investigate themselves. They believe they are a power unto themselves and are to be obeyed at all cost.
Why Did Police Beat an Elderly Man for Jaywalking?
One must remember also that the Supreme Court has ruled the police have no duty to protect us.
Dear Friend Kavika: Well said! I totally agree.
E.
I commented on another thread that there is no greater farce than a body or entity doing an "internal investigation" of itself.
The AMA, law enforcement, the banking industry, and especially, Congress or any other government institution.... it's ridiculous, and like asking members of a family to turn one of their own in, especially when a negative finding will result in a hefty financial penalty.
Dear Friend Mimi: I so agree. A joke in bad taste.
Does no one else not see the huge conflict of interest i internal investigations?
E.
Most policedepartmentshaveCivilianReview Board's, but onceagainthe power of the police prevails.The problem with CRB'sis, they only serve to placate the community into believing there is civilian oversightwatching what the cops are up to.
Generally, the power of a CRB is restricted to reviewing an already completed internal police investigation, and commenting on it to the Chief of Police. Citizen review boards have not been very effective at causing reform, as they are often co-opted by the police department whose investigations they are supposed to review, and thus wind up agreeing with the police department in almost all instances.
However, they are beginning to create CRB's withinvestigatory as well as review authority. There are even some thatwill conduct parallel investigations to supplement the internal affairs investigations.
In a few localities, the review board has subpoena power and can force a police officer to testify. A few jurisdictions even grant sole investigatory power to their civilian review boards.
But it is very rare for a civilian review board to have the final say as to the disposition of an investigation or discipline to be imposed on an officer.These decisions generally continue to be the province of the chief of police
I firmly believe if all police depts. do not soon have an independent CRB, complete with subpoena power,investigatory,review, and final dispositionauthority, we are at risk of becoming a police state.
I wish you would join our Police Brutality & Misconduct group and seed that story.