The chart is simply a collection of facts which I presented without bias or position
And by the way when you insert, except in a statement of certainty (see your comment) it disproves the certainty that you are stating, just a bit of info for you
Clinton had the Dot.com boom where many became millionaires and many lost it as Clinton was leaving office. Bush had the Mortgage Boom for the biggest part of his terms in office. Although I didn't like Bush, he did try to get some regulation on the mortgage fiasco, but was blocked by people such as Barney Frank (headmaster) pardon the pun and Maxine Waters (everyone is a racist if they don't want everyone to have a home of their own even though they never planned on paying for it).
The chart is what the chart is. After reading the link and grasping the math, one needs to understand how the Gini index for the above chart is calculated such as before tax/after tax measurements, economic inertia, Etc.
There are about a dozen things I would want to know before I was satisfied with the slopes of the resultant lines. For me it is kind of a statistical hack job from someone with a political agenda to push.
The chart is one thing, methodologies notwithstanding, but the slopes/lines superimposed on the graph appear to be drawn by someone who failed their sixth grade section on charts and graphs, and most certainly never had a course in statistics (or maybe just assumed that no one in the target audience had).
The take away from this chart should be that the income gap is trending upward and has been for at least as long as the period shown, and that the people who produced this graphic should not be trusted because they obviously intended to mislead.
I am reading your chart, and I am not sure if they are using the new math or what?
The Clinton years went up from it's lowest .45 to about .4625 a difference of .0125
The Bush years went up from it's lowest .4625 to .47... yet it says 0 increase? There is an a difference of .0075
Obama had the worst increase. .4675 to .4775 but that is still only a 4 year picture. The rest has yet to be seen. And frankly, the only one here who can be happy is Clinton. Heck if he didn't have that dip from the really low year in '95 his index would have been from his second lowest amount .4550, his difference would have been .0075, the same as Bush.
But from an economist POV it's a trend that is the issue, and the trend is way up.
Thanks for the link-- lots of interesting info there!
I wonder, though, if trying to achieve more equality of income is always important.
For example, if there's very little inequality, because everyone is very poor,many even starving to death (parts of Africa) that's not great.
But what if a country has a lot of inequality-- a large number of billionaires, but also high employment of, say, well paid blue collar workers who can afford more than the mere basics. A nice house, a small vacation home in the mountains or at the shore, a few good cars, low cost adequate healthcare, certainly able to afford food and clothes (and of good quality), a nice vacation or two...living well--but of course way below the billionaire level. Huge income disparity. What if everone here keeps increasing their income-- but the wealthy do it faster, thus increasing the inequalty over time?
That was exactly the intention of the chart from my point of view
That the income gap had been trending upward for the past nearly three decades and that none of the past two or current presidents had made progress in arresting that steady increase.
I presented the facts if you want to offer context to the discussion and talk about the discussion rather than about me and my motives then go ahead and do so.
As to being a poor debater, you should check a mirror - attacking the other side rather than addressing the point is not a style of debate
even assuming he wanted to
He talks about it enough that one is led to believe that he has some desire to do something about it, but it is mostly talk (likewise earlier presidents)
Based on the wiki info about the Gini coefficient it is not a measure of universal prosperity :
Gini coefficient can rise if some or all income brackets experience a rising income. Feldsteins explanation is summarized in Table D. The table shows that in a growing economy, consistent with Pareto improvement principle, where income of every segment of the population has increased, from one year to next, the income inequality Gini coefficient can rise too. In contrast, in another economy, if everyone gets poorer and is worse off, income inequality is less and Gini coefficient lower.[64][65]
Income inequality from 1994 to 2012
John
Of course it has been developing over time
As to your question, it is irrelevant due to that pesky constitution which precluded President Bush from serving more than two terms
And the chart points out what happened to income equality during the administrations of the past three presidents.
res ipsa loquitur
John
The chart is simply a collection of facts which I presented without bias or position
And by the way when you insert, except in a statement of certainty (see your comment) it disproves the certainty that you are stating, just a bit of info for you
John
Your ignorance of the facts as you try to divine what someone else is thinking is showing again.
I presented a set facts without purpose except to generate a discussion of changes in income equality over the years
John, just because you are incapable of understanding the chart, it doesn't mean EVERYONE is. I understand what Robert is saying just fine.
Clinton had the Dot.com boom where many became millionaires and many lost it as Clinton was leaving office. Bush had the Mortgage Boom for the biggest part of his terms in office. Although I didn't like Bush, he did try to get some regulation on the mortgage fiasco, but was blocked by people such as Barney Frank (headmaster) pardon the pun and Maxine Waters (everyone is a racist if they don't want everyone to have a home of their own even though they never planned on paying for it).
Do you even know what a Gini index is? Link
The chart is what the chart is. After reading the link and grasping the math, one needs to understand how the Gini index for the above chart is calculated such as before tax/after tax measurements, economic inertia, Etc.
There are about a dozen things I would want to know before I was satisfied with the slopes of the resultant lines. For me it is kind of a statistical hack job from someone with a political agenda to push.
But... the chart is what the chart is.
The chart is one thing, methodologies notwithstanding, but the slopes/lines superimposed on the graph appear to be drawn by someone who failed their sixth grade section on charts and graphs, and most certainly never had a course in statistics (or maybe just assumed that no one in the target audience had).
The take away from this chart should be that the income gap is trending upward and has been for at least as long as the period shown, and that the people who produced this graphic should not be trusted because they obviously intended to mislead.
Robert,
I am reading your chart, and I am not sure if they are using the new math or what?
The Clinton years went up from it's lowest .45 to about .4625 a difference of .0125
The Bush years went up from it's lowest .4625 to .47... yet it says 0 increase? There is an a difference of .0075
Obama had the worst increase. .4675 to .4775 but that is still only a 4 year picture. The rest has yet to be seen. And frankly, the only one here who can be happy is Clinton. Heck if he didn't have that dip from the really low year in '95 his index would have been from his second lowest amount .4550, his difference would have been .0075, the same as Bush.
But from an economist POV it's a trend that is the issue, and the trend is way up.
Beat me to it Brolly!
Of course there is my favorite graphic for this:
Thanks for the link-- lots of interesting info there!
I wonder, though, if trying to achieve more equality of income is always important.
For example, if there's very little inequality, because everyone is very poor,many even starving to death (parts of Africa) that's not great.
But what if a country has a lot of inequality-- a large number of billionaires, but also high employment of, say, well paid blue collar workers who can afford more than the mere basics. A nice house, a small vacation home in the mountains or at the shore, a few good cars, low cost adequate healthcare, certainly able to afford food and clothes (and of good quality), a nice vacation or two...living well--but of course way below the billionaire level. Huge income disparity. What if everone here keeps increasing their income-- but the wealthy do it faster, thus increasing the inequalty over time?
Which is better?
John
Bullshit!
I made no argument that anyo of the three were better (or even good) at controlling or improving the income gap
As usual you assume what you want to assume in order to argue and attack rather than talk about the points of an article
John
A chart does not imply anything, it presents data points
You inferred what you assume that I wanted the chart to say and as usual you were wrong!
You are right about the Clinton years and by the way with all his flaws, I voted for Bill twice !
Exactly
Brolly
That was exactly the intention of the chart from my point of view
That the income gap had been trending upward for the past nearly three decades and that none of the past two or current presidents had made progress in arresting that steady increase.
Broliver
I do know thanks for the info
Perrie
I wasn't sure what that meant eitherbut it might be that the final figure was lower than the highest figure reached during the period
And I am not sure that means anything either
Perrie
A very good chart that shows the stagnation of the middle class and working poor and the rise of the mega rich
And it moves too!
Very cool
John
A couple of points
I seeded the chart which shows that the Income Gap has indeed soared under Obama, but that was not the point
The point was that from 1994-2012 (see my first comment) has gone up steadily and that none of the three presidents had stopped that upward trend.
The title of the graph was the author's not mine, so send a scathing email to him if you think he overstepped.
Your whining is what is weak here
Show me that the income gap has not gone up during the Obama administration or accept that it has
John
I presented the facts if you want to offer context to the discussion and talk about the discussion rather than about me and my motives then go ahead and do so.
As to being a poor debater, you should check a mirror - attacking the other side rather than addressing the point is not a style of debate
He talks about it enough that one is led to believe that he has some desire to do something about it, but it is mostly talk (likewise earlier presidents)
Based on the wiki info about the Gini coefficient it is not a measure of universal prosperity :
Gini coefficient can rise if some or all income brackets experience a rising income. Feldsteins explanation is summarized in Table D. The table shows that in a growing economy, consistent with Pareto improvement principle, where income of every segment of the population has increased, from one year to next, the income inequality Gini coefficient can rise too. In contrast, in another economy, if everyone gets poorer and is worse off, income inequality is less and Gini coefficient lower.[64][65]
You are right Petey, I t must be taken in context to actually make sense of the measurements. Other than that it is almost meaningless.