Income Inequality: Fact And Fiction
The word is out: Expect President Obama to advocate government measures to reduce income inequality both in his State of the Union address and throughout this election year. Well, what else would you expect? Every year Obama recycles his message about redistributing income in the name of fairness.
Americans who hope for more such fairness should be very worried about Obamas agenda. Yes, it sounds very much like what they want, but if Obamas presidency has demonstrated anything, it is that he produces results that are the opposite of what he preaches (Exhibit A: Obamacare). Indeed, I dont think Americans should be surprised if we get more of what weve gotten during the last five yearsthe one percent and Wall Street prospering while the 99% and Main Street have languished. Under Obama, yes, stocks have soared, but a shrinking job market keeps lowering the labor force participation and the median income of the middle class has fallen.
The fact is that Obama hasnt spent his time in office shrinking or even trying to shrink income inequality. Instead, he has concentrated on increasing income for his cronies (e.g., green boondoggles), political allies (e.g., labor unions and big business), and the governing elite, while simultaneously waging economic warfare against those he ideologically opposese.g., the coal industry and Republican-leaning constituencies such as small businesses.
All of this was to be expected given the long-standing ideological beliefs of the presidentbeliefs that he tries to downplay and disguise, but which periodically bubble to the surface. Obamas economic philosophy and his concomitant animus against the middle class are unmistakable.
Regardless of partisan preferences or political leanings, nobody who wants the USA to prosper should favor political attempts to modify the natural disparities in labor compensation that emerge in a market economy. Doing so alters incentives in dangerous ways.
The more that government makes the economic rewards of labor more equal, the lower the marginal utility of making the sacrifices necessary to acquire additional skills. Why go to eight years of college, then go through ones 20s and 30s working 50-, 60-, or 70-hour weeks if your resulting income is going to be redistributed to the guy with a high school education who works a lot fewer hours per week so that your lifestyle is only marginally more affluent than his?
And think of the moral hazard such a policy creates for lower-skilled, lower-income workers: If they can receive a guaranteed income that affords them a comfortable standard of living without having to invest the time and effort to improve their skills and productivity (i.e., the value of their labor) then why would they bother trying to improve?
Government redistribution designed to reduce income inequality rewards and subsidizes those who are less productive and penalizes the productive. The result is that the ranks of the unproductive swell while those of the wealth-producers shrink. Society gets poorer. History shows us the corrosive effect of such policies. The Roman Empire rotted from within as government redistributed wealth from the more productive to the less productive.
Sadly, in his zeal to fundamentally transform America, this president calls for policies that lead to the same tragic fate that befell Rome. Like a magician, Obama is a master of misdirection. By drawing our attention to the inequality of incomes, many fail to perceive what he is actually accomplishinga significant increase in the inequality of political power. The power of the leviathan government in Washington continues to grow while the rest of us are increasingly oppressed by that power. This is the real inequality that should concern us.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/markhendrickson/2014/01/24/income-inequality-fact-and-fiction/

A look at income redistribution and some of its potential negative effects -
Rather than attempting to raise the middle by tearing down the top, efforts should be made to raise the middle by raising the bottom
All of this was to be expected given the long-standing ideological beliefs of the presidentbeliefs that he tries to downplay and disguise, but which periodically bubble to the surface. Obamas economic philosophy and his concomitant animus against the middle class are unmistakable.
I'm not going to get into the redistribution angle of this story. I think there are steps that need to be taken to correct some things that let the wealthy get disproportionately wealthy in the last decade plus such as Dodd-Frank and the too big to fail bailout bullshit. The president could push for some things that wouldn't be crazy socialist shit like Republicans try to claim. I'm just going to comment on this one paragraph I quoted above.
Anyone that has studied Obama and his past has to admit that he is a redistributionist. He studied it, wrote about it, and even talked about it. Hell he campaigned on it. Granted he was very vague in his campaign but what do you think he meant by "Fundamentally Transform" America? Income inequality is exactly what he meant. He just hasn't had the political capital to enact what he really wanted. Now he's just working around the edges.
Dan
I agree that things need to be done that will insure that good paying jobs are created, that people are educated and trained to perform those jobs and that income tax codes (personal and corporate) are reformed to insure that there are predictable and steady flows of revenue to support the social safety net
The point I got from the story was that simply redistributing wealth with the thought that giving to the bottom income levels is the way to raise middle was foolhardy
Appreciate the feedback and perspective
I completely agree Robert. To simply give more to the bottom will just move everybody except the rich to the bottom because in the end it's the middle that the money will be taken from. Same as everything else this government has tried to do. Taxes, healthcare, welfare, etc. It all comes out of the middle class pockets. With the government being completely polluted with the rich, how could anyone really ever expect it to change?
an
Time to change the players that make the decisions
Since as usual you have absolutely nothing to say of substance on the topic and choose to assume your attack dog mode, your comment is worthy of only one thing
John,
I am saying this as a member.. but this is abrasive way of discussing the article is what 1st whole article was about. Did you miss that memo? You might be within the CoC, but this doesn't make people want to respond either.
No one denies that there are people at the lower end of the wage chain and that those people need to earn more in order to live better. They also need to be better educated, better trained and able to take and succeed at the new, more technically challenging and demanding jobs.
The argument being made and if you read the article and my initial comment you would note that I agree that the lower earners need to be raised as part of a strengthening of the middle class and the working poor in the country.
The best way to improve the overall society is not to tear down the top but rather to raise up the bottom and thereby strengthen the middle.
If you could get by your hate speak, labeling and whining and discuss the issue you would understand that but you prefer the former to the latter and therefore would rather attack and spew bullshit then to civilly and sanely discuss this or any other issue
I heard snatches of an interesting talk on NPR. It started with the study by Oxfam about the 85 wealthiest people control the same amount of wealth as the 3.9 billion poorest on the planet. There were 2 other guests, one was Sam Pope, a Wall Street wonder who eventually found greed to be an addiction. I only heard bits because I was in the car running errands but I found the link (hope it works). You can skip the Oxfam part by going to the 20 minute mark.
I think you might find this interesting.
This 52 minute show features three points of view, Oxfam, Tim Hartford from the Financial Times and Sam Pope, reformed Wall Street wonder who sees greed as an addiction.
I don't really care who's interested, I'm just sharing info, take it or leave it.
pat wilson
Thanks for sharing the link, I will check it out
Sounds interesting
John
Actually you have to read and understand the article to get the point.
For instance the point (that you say is not in the article) is made for raising the abilities, education, training and wage earning potential of the lowest level of earners when the author says the following -
I know that interpreting and understanding the meaning of the words is tough work sometimes with all the political speak and rhetoric, but this one is pretty clear if you take the time to read it and think about it for a second.
Thanks for stopping by, as always your perspective adds zest to the discussion
John
It is you who does not get it and when you don't get it you label and name call which is somewhat pathetic
You conveniently ignore the point which is that the :low skill workers: which you harp on are better served by obtaining new skills and education and therefore broader employment opportunities than they are by government programs.
We are seeing more and more movement to on line shopping and automation in the service industries which will eliminate more of the "low skill", "low paying" jobs.
A simple example for you to consider, a business has ten customer service (or cashiers) employees paid $8.00 per hour and the minimum wage is raised to $12 per hour and the company decides to expand automated processes which now only require 4 customer service employees making $12 per hour - was the overall long term effect positive or negative?
Answer the question if you like or simply fire off another characterization whichever you like