Supreme Court Will Consider Whether Police Need Warrants to Search Cellphones
The Supreme Court on Friday agreed to hear a pair of cases about whether the police need a warrant to search the cellphones of people they arrest, presenting a major test of the meaning of the Fourth Amendment in the digital age.
The court has long allowed warrantless searches in connection with arrests, saying they are justified by the need to find weapons and to prevent the destruction of evidence. The question for the justices in the new cases is whether the potentially vast amounts of data held on smartphones warrant a different approach under the Fourth Amendment, which bars unreasonable searches.
The lower courts are divided. In one of the cases the court agreed to hear, the federal appeals court in Boston in May threw out evidence gathered after the police there inspected the call log of a drug dealers rudimentary flip phone. Today, many Americans store their most personal papers and effects in electronic format, on a cellphone, carried on the person, Judge Norman H. Stahl wrote for a divided three-judge panel of the court.
That information is, by and large, of a highly personal nature: photographs, videos, written and audio messages (text, email, and voice mail), contacts, calendar appointments, web search and browsing history, purchases, and financial and medical records, he added.
When the full appeals court declined to rehear the case, Chief Judge Sandra L. Lynch said she hoped the justices would soon address the very important and very complex questions presented by it. Only the Supreme Court can finally resolve these issues, and I hope it will, she wrote.
In urging the Supreme Court to hear the case, United States v. Wurie, No. 13-212, Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli Jr. said courts have long endorsed inspection of anything carried by the people they arrest, including wallets, calendars, pocket diaries, address books and pagers.
In February, a state appeals court in California applied the principles established in those cases to allow a search of a smartphone containing much more information than the one seized in Boston. That case arose from the arrest of David L. Riley, who was pulled over for having an expired auto registration. The police found loaded guns in the car and, on inspecting Mr. Rileys smartphone, entries they associated with a street gang.
A more comprehensive search of the phone led to information that linked Mr. Riley to a shooting. He was later convicted of attempted murder and sentenced to 15 years to life.
His lawyers asked the Supreme Court to hear the case, Riley v. California, No. 13-132, to determine how the Fourth Amendment applies to a device that happens to include a phone but is in essence a computer capable of storing a virtually limitless amount of information. They argued that a warrant should be required before allowing the police to rummage through the digital contents of such a device.
In agreeing Friday to hear that case, the justices said they would decide a narrower question than the one proposed by Mr. Rileys lawyers, that of whether evidence admitted at Mr. Rileys trial was obtained by a search that violated his Fourth Amendment rights.
The court on Friday also agreed to hear a third case, Lane v. Franks, No. 13-483, on the First Amendment rights of public employees. It concerns Edward Lane, a former director of a youth program at a public community college in Alabama.
Mr. Lane was subpoenaed to testify at the corruption trial of a state legislator accused of accepting paychecks from the program without doing substantial work for it. The legislator, Suzanne Schmitz, was convicted and sentenced to 30 months in prison.
Mr. Lane was fired, and he sued the president of the college, Steve Franks, saying that his termination was retaliation for his testimony and a violation of his First Amendment right to free speech. Mr. Franks said he let Mr. Lane go for financial reasons unrelated to his testimony.
The federal appeals court in Atlanta said it was unnecessary to decide who was right because public employees have no First Amendment protections in any event for statements they make as part of their official duties.
Since the record fails to establish that Lane testified as a citizen on a matter of public concern, the appeals court said in an unsigned opinion, he cannot state a claim for retaliation under the First Amendment.
Other courts have said that subpoenaed testimony is protected by the First Amendment.
Society has a strong interest in facilitating sworn testimony in public corruption investigations, lest the corruption continue unchecked, Mr. Lanes lawyers told the justices in a petition urging them to hear the case. Public employees have vital information relating to fraud, waste and abuse in the government. If the First Amendment fails to protect them when they speak out, there is a substantial risk that they will be deterred from coming forward.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/18/us/supreme-court-to-consider-limits-of-cellphone-searches.html?ref=us&_r=0
Tags
Who is online
70 visitors

Are smartphones and the data they contain exempt from search by police officers at the time of detention or arrest as wallets, purses, pockets etc are?
The SCOTUS has decided to tell us
This could get interesting ... The results could ruin the plot lines of several popular TV detective shows as well ...
Petey
I am expecting some convoluted "non ruling" with limits in these situations and not in those situations etc
You are right about the TV shows though, if they can't find the guy by tracking his phone no crimes will be solve din the allotted 52 minutes
Finally.....not that I store anything on it.
You're close. Rulings seem to rarely boldly change the law or rewrite that law, rather it is more about the legality of the enforcement policy put in place by the law.
This case might set a de facto precedent for the use of password protection of a device in this situation. However, invoking the Fifth Amendment, when asked for your password/pin, wont let them in so easily.
Frankly, if his device was PW protected, there seems to be an 'expectation of privacy' in the data. Using the phone in public is a different mater.
One Miscreant
Good point and that may actually be the path that they take in the ruling, which some might see as the east way out for the court and still leaving a little too much invasion capability for the police.
A P
I gotta agree with you that most people would not store incriminating evidence on their devices but what do you think about the authorities being able to access call/text history but not the calls/messages themselves
Venturing a guess on what the SCOTUS will do is that they will rule that what is stored on a cell phone requires a warrant to obtain.
UNLESS.... The phone is the issued property of a government organization. In that case, the phone has been issued by a party from the people, in order to do the work of the people in which case its contents and transmissions/receptions should be considered public property.
What I don't have worked out is how they deal with a government issued phone being used to discuss matters with a private citizen.
Just my opinion.
FLYNAVY1
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
At first I thought the very same thing, then I though about the correlation of police going through a suspect's wallet (which they are able to do) and going through the call log of the phone (assuming it was not secured by a password) and the expectation of privacy seems very similar to me.
Of course I am not a lawyer, nor do I play one on TV so this is a country's guys view on a complex issue
Just one more tool the government monkey's will put on "Big Brothers belt" under the guise of public protection. We need to stop allowing government state, federal and local from assuming rights they don't have and define their abilities with a more critical eye towards their need to know in the first place.
Larry
Interesting rhetorical position, but what are your thoughts on what the SCOTUS decision will say about the authorities right to access telephone information?
By the way, you talk about "their" (I assume you mean the authorities) need to know, but the decision will be more about their right to know rather than the need
SCOTUS in my opinion, is in this case out of line to even hear this issue. The police have no right to any communication unless they can prove a crime is being or has been committed and even then they should never be granted a blanket authorization. Look at NSA's current abuse of the power they have been given. Anytime a Police or Spy agency asks for that kind of blanket authority (or right as you call it) there is strong reason for the public citizens to be concerned.
Unfortunately I think SCOTUS will error in the favor or the police.
Larry
The SCOTUS is accepting these wo cases in order to decide on the very issue of when and how much access the authorities have in accessing data (or not) that is on a suspect's phone
I see no conspiracy of the powers that be here and welcome a decision from the SCOTUS on what should and shouldn't be done
Do you really think SCOTUS said one morning we need to decide this issue now before we're asked to? Don't kid yourself they wouldn't have come up with this on their own. There is an outside influence driving the need for this decision.
That influence would be the "Big Brother" faction.
I believe that SCOTUS will allow complete non-warranted access to cell phones by the police. It just seems to be the direction we are headed in as a country.
Larry
If you stop and think for a minute without emotion, two lower level courts have decided the issue in opposite ways which means a standard needs to be set.
That is what the SCOTUS is designed to do and that is why they decide to consider issues and cases
The time for deciding this issue is now
No conspiracy here
Chucky
I think it will be a split type decision where it is okay of this, but not okay if that
In my view the "this and that" will be whether the phone is secured by password at the time it comes into the possession of the authorities
The supreme court must rule on the points of law. Not there issues individuals or groups feel are important. Maybe other legal venues can interpret the law, but the fabric of our society relies on the courts constitutional responsibility.
The invasion issue is part of that responsibility. Just like it was in Miranda.
This is also the reason a case like Roe v Wade is so difficult to change. It will take a case and legal issue(s) that are more significant than the considerations of a woman's constitutional protections. To date, there is none, nor will there be...
I agree. Your wording is the current implementation of the law. A major crime wave would change that, so why would a terror threat? Crimes are crimes, period. Felony's are also a threat to society. We saw how these rights were trampled with the Boston bombing house to house. Everyone was guilty, treated like a suspect and removed from their homes at gun point. When the authorities knew the suspect was wounded and a mere bloodhound would lead them to him. That is how quick this will turn, if the government is given the authority to change policy policy any time they feel the need.
think obama will remind roberts to vote the right way, or else?
JoAnne
"or else" what?
Your one line slaps at the president are all flash and no bang
What mysterious power to you think the president has over the chief justice?
That depends on the expectation of privacy, real or perceived. All cell phones, for example, should be sold with a label attached to them, like with cigarettes, warning of the limits of legal privacy you can expect.
This is why I would support a legal review of this by the Supreme Court.
A P
Once we get this court decision and know what the limits on privacy, concerning the cell phone and other electronic devices carried on our person, are then I think your idea of a warning label is a good idea.
rio, i refer you to your own articles headline.
Joanne
The title to the article
has absolutely nothing to do with President Obama.
Your incessant juvenile, irrelevant slaps at the president are extremely tiresome since they seldom have any relevance to the topic at hand