The medical schools have purposefully limited the number of doctors, physician assistants, etc., trained. The schools need to take in more students to make health care more available. Do I need to see an MD for a sinus infection? Probably not. A nurse practitioner will do just fine and should cost less than seeing the MD and, if there is a problem the nurse practitioner can't handle, refer me to the MD. We can change the delivery of services in a major way, but doctors are resisting.
Yeah, I don't like paying the nurse the same as the doctor for minor illnesses. In Spain, you can go to the pharmacy with a sinus infection or allergies, be examined by specially trained pharmacists who will prescribe medications for you as part of their service at no extra charge. You don't need to see the doctor unless referred to the doctor by the pharmacist. When I have a sinus infection, I know what I have (I have had 1 or 2 a year for 20 years or so) and I don't need to see the doctor - just give me a Rx. Simple.
But fish, you just said you got medical care faster & cheaper in the third world...
BTW-- many meds are significantly less expensive in other countries, since their gov'ts limit the amount of profitCorps can gouge on selling the medications there. Here in the good ol USA you paid 30X as much for the same medication, 'cause us Americans don't believe in 'marxist solutions' to healthcare provision...
Here is what I would do, if this were up to me to solve.
Plan A. (Top Ten List):
1. Universal health care from cradle to grave for all lawful U. S. Citizens. Everyone where who belongs here goes on Medicare, Parts A, B and D.
2. Eliminate Medicaid as unnecessary. See 1.
3. Single Payer. Cut the ribbons out of multiple redundant and costly administration. Streamline.
4. Publicize (reverseprivatization of Medicare).
5. Universal Public Option Health Care. See 1. (If peoplestill want private insurance, they are free to buy it on their own. But they must pay into the system).
6. Make competitive bidding mandatory for all delivery of health care products and costs. just like any other area of government. See 1and 2 above.
7. Payment by most realistic outcome, not a la cart by service or product provision.
8. Lift the ceiling on capping payments into Medicare. Most have no ceiling on payments. It doesn't belong for the top to geta way out of paying their fair share.
9. Universal coverage means just that. No cap on coverage, what ever you earn.
10. Beef up staffing and enforcementof anti-fraud in Medicare. Wring fraud out of the system, and you make it all more than affordable.
Since none of this is up to me, what will I do? Most probably move to Israel as soon as Mrs. E. retires from hercareer. Unless I can get back in the executive suite, in order for Mrs. E. when she survives me, and our son, daughter and their families to inherit what I busted my chops acquiring all my life, I need to live in a country where the government makes sure people get what they need affordably. Otherwise, if I stay here between Medicare claw backs, Medicaid claw backs. inheritance taxes. hospitals, doctors, clinics, Big Pharma, and nursing homes my wife and children will get nothing.
As Chester A. Riley once said, "What a Revoltin Development This Is"?
Years ago (forty or thereabouts) when I first moved to CT I suffered a spider bite. The local Doc charged me the princely sum of $5.00 for the visit. For my recent eye exam, the Doctor billed the insurance company over $500.00.
Now I'll give that the cost of doing business has increased over the past forty years, but really?
Dear Friend Ambivalent: Presently there is payment by service. That incentivizes treatment, not cure. Most drugs don't cure anything. They get you hooked on taking the scripts for life.
Payment by outcome, prevention and reduced cost makes more sense and will contain costs.
Payment by outcome will drive down costs. It may also, if not properly handled, disincentive taking difficult cases where the prognosis isn't good. Care givers still need to be paid.
Payment by realistic outcome can address this concern. If someone isn't expected to survive for very long, they still need care. If someone already has a disease, and it can't be cured, but can be managed, that is a realistic outcome. It is better to prevent diabetes than treat it. But if a person already has it, and keeps their sugars in a normal range, long term expensive and dangerous consequences can be avoided, lessened, or postponed. Same for cancers and heart disease.
A realistic outcome for an incurable near term lethal disease or disorder would be minimal discomfort, but not heroic efforts which will bear no fruit. Running a tab on treatments which cannot cure, just to gain fees makes no societal financial or humanitarian sense.
Enoch's listing is much of what ''health care'' is in Australia. I lived there and my children still do. There system is quite good, and it's what some in the US would called ''socialized medicine''. Everyone is covered that is a legal citizen. You are allowed, if you so choose, to have a private insurance policy. If you do have a private policy you still are required to pay into the public system.
I will add that the care for children is outstanding.
Dear Friend Ambivalent: Long term hospice, or for a fraction of the cost, pay family care givers so they can afford to tend to the dying family member. It is exit life where you lived it. This is Cheaper and does not affect quality of care (generally improves it).
Single Payer regarding health insurance and salaries, NOT FEE FOR SERVICE, for physicians. Any subsidies going to hospitals should be prorated and inversely proportional to CEO pay/bonuses/stock options. The higher the CEO pay, etc., the lower the subsidy.
If we weren't talking about treating human illness and the saving or preservation of lives, I'd agree with your apparent premise, Robert G, that premise (IMO) being value based on supply and demand regarding quality of service.
But if paying the amounts discussed raises the cost of "staying alive" via insurance costs, deductibles and so on, then value vs. VALUES is my issue.
I have no problem paying good "wages" -- in part, made a career of fighting for it, but "good wages/fair wages" are thrown out of whack when outrageous wages and bonuses are ultimately subsidized by those literally making life and death decisions to contribute to such compensation.
It's one thing to voluntarily buy a ticket to a football game for a couple hundred and quite another to have to choose between, life, death or personal bankruptcy in a health crisis.
I'm saying that HEALTH CARE SHOULD NOT BE A COMMODITY!
If a Hospital or Health Insurance company can afford to pay its CEO millions annually (I'm not talking about physicians or health care provider personnel), I have a problem with that particularly when patients and workers ultimately pay for it!
At point here is as well as not addressing HC costs in the ACA, it doesn't address this issue of "commodity" either. HC remains a commodity even with the implementation of his HC law.
Let me be clear; I was and still am quite disappointed that Obama did not go for Single Payer and, that there is no public option in the ACA.
The only right you have to HC is the right to pay for insurance to receive it. if you can't pay for it we the Government have the right to take it from another person and give it to you, under the false pretense we are protecting your right to HC.
Disagree here; the ACA prevents people from gaming the system as they did pre-ACA, by going o ERs uninsured, being unable to pay and consequently having health insurers add $1100/year to my policy to make up the losses.
The "commodity" issue is an easy fix single payer. I have posted the specifics and logistics a number of times and will do so again if requested.
You now seem to be separating those listed MD's from the CEOs of those hospitals, in those mulit-million compensation numbers.
I was probably unclear on that; I only meant to castigate the CEO compensation although I would like to see good SALARIES for health care PROVIDERS rather than fee-for-service which promotes unnecessary (lucrative) procedures.
I have seen this before. I agree with this guy.
We have a precedent with an accompanying model - Medicare.
The government already negotiates costs for everyone 65 and older.
How much of a stretch would it be to get them to do it for people 64 and younger as well?
Yes.
Why are American health care costs so high? Because we pay more.........
The medical schools have purposefully limited the number of doctors, physician assistants, etc., trained. The schools need to take in more students to make health care more available. Do I need to see an MD for a sinus infection? Probably not. A nurse practitioner will do just fine and should cost less than seeing the MD and, if there is a problem the nurse practitioner can't handle, refer me to the MD. We can change the delivery of services in a major way, but doctors are resisting.
Capitalism. Next question?
Some things are not practical for profit.
Yeah, I don't like paying the nurse the same as the doctor for minor illnesses. In Spain, you can go to the pharmacy with a sinus infection or allergies, be examined by specially trained pharmacists who will prescribe medications for you as part of their service at no extra charge. You don't need to see the doctor unless referred to the doctor by the pharmacist. When I have a sinus infection, I know what I have (I have had 1 or 2 a year for 20 years or so) and I don't need to see the doctor - just give me a Rx. Simple.
But fish, you just said you got medical care faster & cheaper in the third world...
BTW-- many meds are significantly less expensive in other countries, since their gov'ts limit the amount of profitCorps can gouge on selling the medications there. Here in the good ol USA you paid 30X as much for the same medication, 'cause us Americans don't believe in 'marxist solutions' to healthcare provision...
Here is what I would do, if this were up to me to solve.
Plan A. (Top Ten List):
1. Universal health care from cradle to grave for all lawful U. S. Citizens. Everyone where who belongs here goes on Medicare, Parts A, B and D.
2. Eliminate Medicaid as unnecessary. See 1.
3. Single Payer. Cut the ribbons out of multiple redundant and costly administration. Streamline.
4. Publicize (reverseprivatization of Medicare).
5. Universal Public Option Health Care. See 1. (If peoplestill want private insurance, they are free to buy it on their own. But they must pay into the system).
6. Make competitive bidding mandatory for all delivery of health care products and costs. just like any other area of government. See 1and 2 above.
7. Payment by most realistic outcome, not a la cart by service or product provision.
8. Lift the ceiling on capping payments into Medicare. Most have no ceiling on payments. It doesn't belong for the top to geta way out of paying their fair share.
9. Universal coverage means just that. No cap on coverage, what ever you earn.
10. Beef up staffing and enforcementof anti-fraud in Medicare. Wring fraud out of the system, and you make it all more than affordable.
Since none of this is up to me, what will I do? Most probably move to Israel as soon as Mrs. E. retires from hercareer. Unless I can get back in the executive suite, in order for Mrs. E. when she survives me, and our son, daughter and their families to inherit what I busted my chops acquiring all my life, I need to live in a country where the government makes sure people get what they need affordably. Otherwise, if I stay here between Medicare claw backs, Medicaid claw backs. inheritance taxes. hospitals, doctors, clinics, Big Pharma, and nursing homes my wife and children will get nothing.
As Chester A. Riley once said, "What a Revoltin Development This Is"?
Years ago (forty or thereabouts) when I first moved to CT I suffered a spider bite. The local Doc charged me the princely sum of $5.00 for the visit. For my recent eye exam, the Doctor billed the insurance company over $500.00.
Now I'll give that the cost of doing business has increased over the past forty years, but really?
Dear Friend Ambivalent: Presently there is payment by service. That incentivizes treatment, not cure. Most drugs don't cure anything. They get you hooked on taking the scripts for life.
Payment by outcome, prevention and reduced cost makes more sense and will contain costs.
Payment by outcome will drive down costs. It may also, if not properly handled, disincentive taking difficult cases where the prognosis isn't good. Care givers still need to be paid.
Payment by realistic outcome can address this concern. If someone isn't expected to survive for very long, they still need care. If someone already has a disease, and it can't be cured, but can be managed, that is a realistic outcome. It is better to prevent diabetes than treat it. But if a person already has it, and keeps their sugars in a normal range, long term expensive and dangerous consequences can be avoided, lessened, or postponed. Same for cancers and heart disease.
A realistic outcome for an incurable near term lethal disease or disorder would be minimal discomfort, but not heroic efforts which will bear no fruit. Running a tab on treatments which cannot cure, just to gain fees makes no societal financial or humanitarian sense.
Clearer?
E.
Sorry Fish, sadly we became an also ran some time ago, folks are just beginning to take greater notice of it
Enoch's listing is much of what ''health care'' is in Australia. I lived there and my children still do. There system is quite good, and it's what some in the US would called ''socialized medicine''. Everyone is covered that is a legal citizen. You are allowed, if you so choose, to have a private insurance policy. If you do have a private policy you still are required to pay into the public system.
I will add that the care for children is outstanding.
If only.
Dear Friend Ambivalent: Long term hospice, or for a fraction of the cost, pay family care givers so they can afford to tend to the dying family member. It is exit life where you lived it. This is Cheaper and does not affect quality of care (generally improves it).
A FOR-PROFIT System with 31 cents of every premium dollar going to CEO pay and waste!
Single Payer/Universal Healthcare/Medicare-for-All is the way to end that racket!
Single Payer regarding health insurance and salaries, NOT FEE FOR SERVICE, for physicians. Any subsidies going to hospitals should be prorated and inversely proportional to CEO pay/bonuses/stock options. The higher the CEO pay, etc., the lower the subsidy.
You tell me.
If we weren't talking about treating human illness and the saving or preservation of lives, I'd agree with your apparent premise, Robert G, that premise (IMO) being value based on supply and demand regarding quality of service.
But if paying the amounts discussed raises the cost of "staying alive" via insurance costs, deductibles and so on, then value vs. VALUES is my issue.
I have no problem paying good "wages" -- in part, made a career of fighting for it, but "good wages/fair wages" are thrown out of whack when outrageous wages and bonuses are ultimately subsidized by those literally making life and death decisions to contribute to such compensation.
It's one thing to voluntarily buy a ticket to a football game for a couple hundred and quite another to have to choose between, life, death or personal bankruptcy in a health crisis.
I'm saying that HEALTH CARE SHOULD NOT BE A COMMODITY!
If a Hospital or Health Insurance company can afford to pay its CEO millions annually (I'm not talking about physicians or health care provider personnel), I have a problem with that particularly when patients and workers ultimately pay for it!
Let me be clear; I was and still am quite disappointed that Obama did not go for Single Payer and, that there is no public option in the ACA.
Disagree here; the ACA prevents people from gaming the system as they did pre-ACA, by going o ERs uninsured, being unable to pay and consequently having health insurers add $1100/year to my policy to make up the losses.
The "commodity" issue is an easy fix single payer. I have posted the specifics and logistics a number of times and will do so again if requested.
I was probably unclear on that; I only meant to castigate the CEO compensation although I would like to see good SALARIES for health care PROVIDERS rather than fee-for-service which promotes unnecessary (lucrative) procedures.