Ohio killer executed with untested two-drug cocktail
An Ohio man who raped and stabbed to death a pregnant woman became the first person executed with a previously untested two-drug cocktail on Thursday.
Dennis McGuire, 53, whose arguments that the new protocol could cause terror and agony were rejected by a federal judge, was pronounced dead at 10:53 a.m.
An Associated Press reporter who witnessed the execution wrote that McGuire appeared to gasp several times and made several loud snorting or snoring sounds during the more than 15 minutes it took him to die.
His stomach rose and fell several times as he repeatedly opened and shut his mouth his adult children watching from a few feet away as they watched.
Another witness, Columbus Dispatch writer Alan Johnson, reported McGuire "gasped loudly for air for about 13 minutes prior to his death," his chest heaving and his fist clenched. "Deep, rattling sounds emanated from his chest."
Ohio adopted the new protocol a combination of thesedative midozolam and the painkiller hydropmorphone after the manufacturer of the old drug, pentobarbital, stopped selling it for lethal injections.
McGuire was convicted of raping, sodomizing and slashing the throat of 22-year-old acquaintance Joy Stewart, who was eight months pregnant at the time of her murder in 1989.
In a bid for clemency last month, McGuire's lawyers argued that he had been mentally, physically and sexually abused as a child, which affected his brain development.
After the Parole Board turned him down, McGuire tried to get his execution halted on the grounds that the two-drug method might lead to a condition called "air hunger" before his actual death.
The court rejected the argument even as it acknowledged that his execution would be an "experiment" that could go wrong.
McGuire had also asked Gov. John Kasich to delay his date with death by offering to become an organ donor, but the request was turned down because he didn't identify any family members who could benefit.
The condemned prisoner who was supposed to be the first person executed with the new cocktail, child killer Ronald Phillips, won an eight-month reprieve by asking to donate a kidney to his mother and his heart to his sister. The state is studying the feasibility of that.
McGuire was moved to Ohio's death house on Wednesday and was given a last meal of roast beef, toasted bagel with cream cheese and onion, butter pecan ice cream, fried chicken, potato salad, fried potatoes with onion and Coca-Cola, officials said.
He was was awake all night talking on the phone and writing letters and had emotional visits with his son and daughter and other family members. He declined breakfast and a shower on Thursday morning.
Tags
Who is online
70 visitors

So, to summarize, a man who raped, sodomized, and murdered an eight month pregnant woman by slitting her throat, was arguing against the state over carrying out his death penalty on the basis that the method might cause him terror and agony. When that didnt work, he tried to delay his execution by claiming he wanted to give some organs away to family members, only none of his family members had unhealthy organs needing replacement. For his final meal, he ate roast beef, toasted bagel with cream cheese and onion, butter pecan ice cream, fried chicken, potato salad, fried potatoes with onion and Coca-Cola. In a recent bid for clemency, he claimed to be a victim of childhood circumstances that affected his brain development.
Seems to me that this monster had been using his evil brain just fine, at least when it comes to trying to get himself out of being punished for one of the most heinous crimes imaginable. I wonder if his eight month pregnant victim experienced any terror and agony during her rape, sodomizing and murder? I wonder if her last meal was as nice as his was? I have no sympathy for this piece of shit. If he had any shred of dignity whatsoever, he would have taken his punishment like a man, instead of leaving an image of a selfish weasel.
I realize that there are cases where capital punishment has been misused, but I'm still opposed to the fact that capital punishment could possibly be more expensive than incarcerating a monster for 50+ years.What if that were not the case? What if our legal system were structured such that for people who are unambiguously guilty of heinous crimes worthy of capital punishment were no longer given access to decades of expensiveappeals? What ifcapital punishment were to cost 5% of what it costs to incarcerate for life? Would you still be anti-death penalty?
Non-story. He contributed to science by showing one would die from the drug cocktail. Probably his only contribution to society. I don't have an ounce of pity for him.
Sounds like the drug combination has been tested now and it works!
It took 25 years, and then an extra 15 minutes to get rid of this monster?! Bullets are pretty dang cheap and quick.
I all for allowing organ donations from death penalty convicts . It is a serious waste to not attempt to set up such a process . Sure it would preserve his life until such time as a suitable donee could be found . Also there is the expense of doing the genetic testing . But the saving of another life would make it worhwhile ...
If he volunteered to donate his organs then I would consider that to be practically a confession ...
Not if it was voluntary ...
I believe that saving another life makes it of value . The pursuit of legalized vengeance accomplishes almost nothing except to placate the victim's family ...
That is my POV . If I was unjustly convicted of such a crime I would not consent to organ donations ... as a form of protest at my untimely demise . But the protest would be more prominent if it was made public somehow .
You might choose differently . So be it .
Well the drug combination works and now we know what to use the next time...
Sorry Gunny, but I think you are going soft.....
Death by the medieval method of "sawing" for this animal is what I have in mind. Do it publicly as well.
Of course I all for public lashings and hangings as well. Why should criminals benefit from their crimes with three hots and a cot for the duration of their incarceration? I would think the lingering thoughts of red hot pokers, and iron-maidens would reduce the recidivism rate among convicted criminals.
Don't even get me started on conjugal visits. Thankfully, those seem to be coming to an end, since it is a financial burden on the state to accommodate them.
I admit that I don't know the specifics of the evidence that convicted this guy, but what if his crimewas caught on camera, in his place of work, and he left his DNA all over the victim? Can we please just admit that therecan becircumstances where guilt is not questionable?
Seriously? You're going to fall back on a religious "commandment" to base your secular opinion on? I suppose thenthat murder is wrong, but no more wrong than being jealous of your neighbor's donkey, or saying Jesus Fucking Christ, since they all are part of the same meager set of life rules that were supposedly written by the hand of God himself. And since that meager set of "commandments" fails to include anything about rape or child molestation,we should legalize those? If you want to voice an opinion, you would be wise to leave religion out of it.
I believe they use phenobarbital....
Dear FriendBadfish" Actually the relevant Commandment doesn't say "You shall not kill". It says, "You shall not murder".
The Hebrew terms Lamuut and Lirogh are never used interchangeably in Scripture.
The Commandment is, "You Shall Not Murder". What are the distinctions betweenmurder and killing Scripturally, in the original languages?
If you take the life of someone(s) who present an existential threat to yourself, family, innocent bystanders, community orcountry you are not only allowed to use lethal force, according to Scripture, you are morally required to applyit. This includes military service, law enforcement, and legal penalties for violating the law.
That does not mean the decision to use or refrain from using lethal force should be taken lightly. The Sanhedrin (original Court of Divine Law) in the First and Second Temple periods were considered a tough Court if it imposed the death penalty even once in seventy years. But that penalty, to protect society, was still there for a reason.
The cost factor wasn't part of the equation for Biblical Society. The fact that you cannot reverse a death sentence was.Proof was uncovered after an execution of an innocent even then. For this reason, there were set up six cities of refuge. Those convicted of capitol crimes were sent to a city of refuge, if the convict requestedand the Judges approved it.
They would live out their days in this city. It cost to the governmentnothing There were no appeals. Only those incarcerated in the city entered, and never left (unless evidence came to life proving them innocent. Then they were released back into society).
Taking life, for self-defense individual or collective protection, reactive or proactive is allowed, and sometimes mandated. Murder is not.
Murder is clear cut. If you killa neighbor to take theirspouse, property, settle a vendetta, kill a victim so they cannot testify against you at trail (including someone a perpetrator rapes) or run amuck due to mental hygiene challenges society cannot allow this. It violates such concepts of justice as protection against future murders from the perpetrator,no proper punishment,no disincentive to others to abstain from murder, etc.
Your stronger Scriptural argument is toadvocate for cities of refuge. They cost tax payers nothing. They protect citizens. They dissuade, to the extent any punishment demotivatesothers to do the crime. If proven not guilty, the residents of city of refuge are simply freed. Whatever life goes on and how it occurs within the city of refuge is solely up to its residents. They live there, they do what they do to survive. They may not leave. If they try to or succeed at escape, the death penaltyis immediately imposed. No trial.
If the Scriptural and post Scriptural documents of the origin of Biblical handling, in their original languages still don't meet your requirements of conscience, you can go with a more original series of suggestions on how tohandle this.
You brought up Scripture, and from a mistranslation misrepresented its posture. Not intentionally. I bring upso you can either use it accurately, or go with something else you feel better represents your views.
Speaking only for myself, although I see I am not alone here in this, I feel the death penalty was appropriate for this person.
Tzedek Tzedk Tirdof (Justice, Justice Shall You Pursue- Torah)
Enoch.
Dear Friend Hal: see mypost to Badfish.
His is not an accurate depictionof what therelevant religions say, neitheris yours.
I suggest if you wish to disagree about capital punishment, you too ought to leaveyour understanding of religion out of it. Otherwise yours is a straw man argument as well.
You cannot deal a body blow to something you fight if your argument is based on its mischaracterization. You never punch anything that way.
To make factually incorrect statements about religion leaves you on the same grounds as those who claim atheists and agnostics cannot lead a moral life. It simply isn't the case. Better not to do to others what you don't not care to have them do to you.
Peace and Abundant Blessings.
Enoch.
Point taken, Enoch. Bringing religion into an argument for or against capital punishment is not a functional approach. We all have our own opinions on the relevance of ancient scripture in relation to the present state of humanity. That said, it is hard to for me to take anything seriously in a doctrine containing rules establishing how god thinks humans should live, which include requirements about how your garments are to be constructed, or what kind of animalsare not to be eaten. Biblical doctrine is written by man, and man is an evolving species. Human evolution requires a flexibility that religious doctrine cannot accommodate.
If a licensed anesthesiologist says no human can survive being injected with X cc's of any particular cocktail of lethal drugs, then let a layman inject double that amount into those who legally deserve it - problem solved.
Personally, I think a city of refuge would be a disaster. I would list the reasons why, but it would take an hour that I don't wish to waste on such a crazy prospect. To me, that's just one more example of how meaningless the biblical doctrine is to managing modern society.
Yes, but it would make a great science fiction or action plot
Yeah I was thinking along the lines of "Escape from New York" but instead of a city, have the convicted tagged and dropped off on a planet, or wilderness area set aside under a great force field or something of the sort. Survival and team building would then be the name of the game. Kind of like Survivor made real a-la "The Hunger Games".
And to return to topic, I disagree with the death penalty on principle.
Dear Friend Hal: Bringing religion into a secular system of justice may be off-point. Bringing secular concerns into a religious system of law is in the same boat. It is germane in both cases if accurately presented because its a viewpoint held by one or more citizens affected by it.
In a democratic republic such as the USA or Canada secular law is worthless unless evenly and fairly enforced to one and all consistently. If a law isn't good enough for everyone, then it is not good enough for anyone. No one person or group should have advantage in the formation of laws which affect all. No legislation without representation!
That you may not care for religious viewpoints doesn't mean they cannot be considered in laws affecting everyone, including religious citizens.
Be careful about precedents you want to set. They can come back to haunt you. The same posture can and often is done to you and yours. The Commandments monuments laws in Oklahoma is an example of trying to silence your voice as an Atheist about what does and doesn't belong on public property. May I assume we both agree that religious monuments and scenes have no place on public property? I see it as a violation of the Constitution. The Ten Commandments (aseret Ha Debrot, or Asurat Luchot Ha Brit) come from my Scripture. I believe in them fo me and mine. I do not think they belong on public propert5y. Why should followers of non-Jewish religions, and no religions at all be paying for that? Doesn't that make them second class citizens? How can society sustain itself when it ignores the rights of all its own?
We don't share the same epistemological approach to some matters. My recommendation to you as tho Badfish is to avoid using something to make a point when what you wish to introduce as evidence is incorrectly stated. It weakens both your cases. I am not saying that either of you cannot or should not make your cases. I merely present stylistic considerations to you both in order to help each of you present your opinions most favorably.
I encourage all to air their views in the open light of public display. I concur with John Stuart Mill, in his seminal writing on The Four Arguments About the Freedom of the Speech. Our first amendment was greatly influenced by the Utilitarian philosophy of Mr. Mills. The truth will sort itself out in the minds of objective and level headed readers, who have no ax to grind.
There is certainly a place for faith in religious life. Depending on the religion it may have a more or less prominent role than that of wisdom. revelation, reason, and inter-subjectively verifiable sense experience. The role of faith for us in the believers camp is not to blindly accept what someone who self-identifies as antithetical to what we base our lives on simply because he makes unsupported statements about the origin of Divine Law. That you feel Religious Law is of human origin is your opinion. You are entitled to your belief for yourself. We are by no way bound by it.
Man is indeed a species in evolution. So is man's understanding of Divine truth through revelation. Does the hard tight bud of a flower in winter look anything like the same bud after winter subsides, snow and ice melt? With time, moisture and sunlight warmth the flowers gradually open up to disclose the same internal beauty that was there all along. Revelation is a process. Our view is that it take times to mature. It needs to unfold in the context of history. But the flower is and always was the same flower.
Over 93% of all Torah law can be found in the Code of Hammurabi from ancient Sumaria. To me, that simply shows that the Laws of G-d which are perfect, eternal, immutable preceded history as part of Creation. We Jewish people were not the first offered to accept these Laws as the guidepost to living life. We were and remain the only ones who choose to follow it. Like spatial and temporal relations, as in the Allegory of the Cave by Plato, the forms are eternal (laws), the content with which they are instantiated are temporal (customs, traditions, interpretations). This is how we see it.
It does not bother us that you and others disagree. We wish you well with what you choose to do. We do so sincerely. We know how well what we are doing works for us. How meaningful it is to us. We want no less for you in how you best choose to walk through life's journey.
It is our contention that the righteous among all nations will have a share in the world to come. These are the words of Rabbi Yochnan ben-Zakkai in Pirke Avoth (Sayings of the Fathers).
Note he doesn't say that only people of his (my) religion will have a share in the world to come. Neither does he say people of non-Jewish Religions, Atheists, Agnostics, and those who simply don't care at all about religion will not have a share in the world to come. All he said is that the righteous shall have a share in the world to come. That isn't binding on you. It is on me. I will take righteousness where ever I can find it. Happily will I form coalitions with those who are people of good will.
Lumping all religious people together in a preconceived and self-serving painting with too broad a brush doesn't square with the facts on the ground any more than is doing so with over generalizations about Atheists.
I concur that doctrine divides. Religious non-religious and anti-religious doctrine. It is more divisive than inclusive. It isn't designed to be inclusive. If the Torah and Halacha (Rabbinic Law) don't do it for you, then you are safe to abstain from it. Nothing bad will befall you now or in the future for living your life honestly on your terms.
A society is only as free as its citizens are free to make choices which do not involve or harm others. It is not the choice made, but the fact that we have a choice that makes a society free for consenting adults to decide how best to live their lives.
I and others like me are not locked into being locked into things we do not opine to be right moral choices. Not by our heritage, and not by false characterizations of others. You get to choose for you, me for me, etc.
Where we need to give up some freedom to ironically gain freedom, we can and should find common ground to achieve a greater good. An on-point example is having and consistently and objectively enforcing laws against sexual abuse, and murder. Rapists and murders will have their lives curtailed. All citizens will be free to live their lives with less fear of being raped, assaulted and slaughtered.
Why disparage what I do because you don't believe it. Don't believe it, don't do it. Better to work with me in supporting civil and criminal laws that protect innocent citizens against perpetrators.
In life, you get back the respect you give out. You will never see me take cheap shots at non-Jewish religions, or those who are not religious. I have not walked a mile in their shoes. Who is to say that what wouldn't work for me at all isn't just precisely the best possible course of action for them? I have no problem with ideological diversity, as for bio diversity. It increases chances of survival of the species.
It also doesn't predispose people to abstain from working with me where we do agree, for the betterment of humanity.
To Peace, Harmony, Fellowship, Common Ground Coalitions and Abundant Blessings for Us All.
Enoch.
As noble of a statement as that is, itprobably fails to connect with atheists for the simple reason that it assumes that our consciousness and life forceare destined to remained eternallyentangled and advance into a "world to come", once our biological shell is done with it. (note: I started to expand upon this statement, but realizedthatmy response wasexpansive and deeply off topic relevant to this article, so I saved it to create a separate article. Hopefully I will finish that and post it in the near future, and your input would be welcome when that happens.)
That is good to hear.You and I may not be so different on the inside .... aside fromthat whole "belief in god" thing. People often accuseus atheists of being hateful of anyone who has religion. This is ridiculous. I can't imagine going through life using "belief in god" as the initial criteria of who I choose to care about, or respect, or love. In fact, to my knowledge I am the only true atheist friend thatI have - for no other reason that I just don't personally know any other atheists. There are a few agnostics in my life, but there are far more religionists/believers who I am close with. I may have problems with how some people use their religion, but the fact that they are religious is typically of no more consequence to me than the color of their hair is.
Dear Friend Hal: I look forward to that article. I enjoy reading your posts. Yours is a viewpoint which should be expressed and given a fair hearing.
A close friend of mine, who was one of my writing partners on another site and I got and get along famously. He wrote under the pen name Grisham, as John Grisham is his favorite novelist.
In person, and on-line we enjoyed a friendship and kinship of common ground on many topics. Our differences make us unique. Our similarities make it easy for us to unite and work productively.
He is a self-proclaimed Atheist. I am proudly a practicing Orthodox Jewish Rabbi and Chaplain.
Our friendship, writing partnership and support when the trolls, snarks, re-regs, and other ne'er do wells reared their ugly heads was based upon mutual respect, sense of humor, many commonly shared values hopes dreams and aspirations.
Most of all, we both cannot make it through a week without many cups of fresh brewed dark roast from Tim Horton's Coffee Shops.
One can honestly debate the belief of whether there is or is not an after life. No one can dispute the value of a hot Grande and an everything topped toasted bagel with a shmear of Smart Balance on a light less, frozen gusty winter morn.
Peace, Blessings, and Abundant Bagelach with Shmears and a piping hot Columbian, Brazilian Kenyan blend to us all.
Enoch.
I know Grisham quite well from newsvine. In fact, you may not realize it, but you and I have had plenty of respectful discourse on newsvine as well. I was Future History there. It was my disrespectful discourse thatgot me booted, at a time when I could barely stand to be there anymore anyways,so I was testingTyler's and Sally'slimits. I don't miss it, but it's good to see you here now.
Looks like Grisham isn't too active there anymore either. Coincidentally, I was just checking his homepage there yesterday to see what he was up to. I'm unsure whether he would like it here, as he excels at atheistic commentary, which generally goes over like a lead balloon here. Perhaps you should invite him over here anyways.You two aregood people.
Dear Friend Hal: Grish was, is and always will be the best.
He is presently concentrating on his professional writing career, and rebuilding some aspects of personal life.
He is gone from Newsvine. I am only partly there.
I keep Chaplains Corner open as a library and resource center. I also provide free Pastoral Services and referrals to anyone who requests them in the confidentiality of private email.
For many reasons I am far less involved, if at all at the Newsvine.
Last year, I was part of a process that helped seven people across the globe who were in the "Red Zone" about committing suicide. All are working through things locally where they live.
All are still with us. If not for that, I too, like you and Grish would have hung up my Liederhosen and scooted.
A problem with these internet blog sites is that they do not pay anything. For some that is a real issue. Times are tough, and people have bills to pay. I understand.
I am too new here to know what does and doesn't go over like a lead balloon. For my part, I am sincere in encouraging everyone to express any viewpoint which doesn't call for or lead to violence.
Its a big planet. There is room for everyone. Reality is complex. It is, I feel, naive to assume any one system or methodology of thought will work for everyone all the time. I think we are all better off for seeing the world through the eyes of others from time to time. We are all still ourselves. We need make no apology for that. Rather we should lead with our strengths, be there for others when and as needed. We should also be open to the wisdom of others, even and particularly when it isn't compatible with what we do. Its a great way to shore up our weaknesses.
Understanding where others come from also leads to a more peaceful and harmonious planet. What a wonderous gift to give us to be able to see ourselves as others see us.
To that end I think that believers will better serve G-d by service to humanity if they do not get too full of themselves, or too smug about their status. Many of the things which bother Atheists and Agnostics also bother me about some aspects of some religions, including my own. It is not uncommon for me to find I have more in common with followers of non-Jewish religions and no religion at all than some in my heritage, including in Congregations where I served as Senior Rabbi. As the late Scholar Ernst Simon once quoted Gershom Sholom, who said "I cannot Daavin (Pray) with people with whom I can converse, and cannot talk with people with whom I can daavin". Life is like that. It does keep things interesting.
I am glad we had this back and forth Hal. I feel like we now have hooked up as News Talkers. We found our common ground. We can go forward together, disagreements and all. We have more that binds us than separates us.
This makes Grish proud and happy.
Your Good Friend, Enoch.
Dear Friend Badfish: The original Ten Commandments were written in Hebrew.
I read it in Hebrew. The translation to which you refer is not correct.
There are problems reading things in translation. Meaning is lost. Sincere, hard working honest translators get things wrong daily.
The Hebrew words for "kill" and "murder" are distinct. They are never used interchangeably in Hebrew and Aramaic Scripture in their original languages. The same is true for level of commentary such as the Tosafoth, Breita and Rashi Script.
See Talmudic Tractate Meshechet Sanhedrin for a very thorough commentary on this Commandment, and its relevance to the death penalty in Jewish Law. Also read the relevant chapters of the Kitzur Schulchan Aruch (Code Book of Jewish Law). The difference between killing and murdering, and its implications for society, including in criminal law with capital punishment is as clear as ca be on a very consistent basis. Great care was taken on this matter within the Jewish legal system.
This matter gets ll the more complex, and the need for care in capital punishment all the more difficult in multi-group societies such as the United States. The death penalty is not equally applied state to state. It is not equally enforced among various racial, religious, gender, ethnic, intelligence level, and socio-economic groups. All citizens ca be a victim equally. Conviction and execution is not so uniform, That is a good argument against capital punishment where I think you are on safer ground.
Religion is not automatically against the death penalty. Not any one religion and all the people in it. Different religions have all the more diversity of perspective on the matter. The Ten Commandments in their original language are more than clean on this dichotomy.
Christianity is a separate and distinct religion from Judaism. It has been so since it splintered away from us. I would ask someone better versed in Christianity than am I to address both translation problems and doctrinal considerations from their viewpoint.
I made the suggestions to you because yours is a valid point of view, which deserves a fair hearing and serious consideration. It is best not to contain in an advocacy anything which is factually incorrect. It deters and distracts from the main point of the Tour de Force of the argument.
All best wishes for a great weekend, my good friend.
Enoch.
If everyone is so worried about the killer's comfort while he dies, surely someone can donate an automobile, a piece of garden hose, and the state can come off the money for a tank of gas.
Pull the auto into the observation area, seal it off, give the killera Xanex, handcuff him to the steering wheel, turn on the ignition, and walk out.
Easy, not too expensive, and fairly humane.
Problem solved.
Enoch,
I have enjoyed very much the discussion here between you and Hal. Thank you. It has explained some points that have troubled me for some time.
Your friend, Mimi
Dear Friend Mimi: I enjoyed conversing with Hal. We now know each other better, and are closer for it. We can understand better from where each of us is coming. As ever, mutual respect and open communication does wonders.
How goes the New Year for you and yours? Well I hope. May 2014 be your best year yet.
Peace and Abundant Blessings. Your Good Friend, Enoch.