Emails tie Christie administration to bridge controversy
Explosive emails released Wednesday are casting a potential cloud over New Jersey Gov. Chris Christies presidential prospects for 2016.
The revealing conversations between state officials suggest for the first time that politics -- from the highest levels of Christie's administration -- may have played a role in last fall's controversial closure of local access lanes to the congested George Washington Bridge in Fort Lee, N.J. in the midst of Christies re-election campaign.
Democrats have charged the closures were an attempt at political retribution for Ft. Lee Mayor Mark Sokolich, a Democrat who declined to endorse Christie's re-election effort last year and whose city sits in the shadow of the bridge.
But the emails threaten to undercut the governor's strong denial that politics played any role in the closure.
"Time for some traffic problems in Fort Lee," Christie Deputy Chief of Staff Bridget Anne Kelly wrote to Christie Port Authority aide David Wildstein on Aug. 13, weeks before the lane closures that snarled traffic on the first day of school in New Jersey last fall.
Wildstein replied, "Got it."
In one of the more revealing exchanges, an unidentified person sent this text message about delayed school buses to Wildstein on Sept. 10, the second day of the lane closures:
"Is it wrong that I am smiling?"
Wildstein: "No."
Person: "I feel badly about the kids. I guess."
Wildstein: "They are the children of Buono voters."
Buono is the Democrat whom Christie defeated in last year's gubernatorial race.
Christie has denied involvement with the lane closures, and "absolutely, unequivocally" denied that the closures were politically motivated after accepting the resignation of a top port authority official in December.
Ahead of his reelection last fall, Christie was seeking endorsements from North Jersey Democrats to promote his ability to forge bipartisanship. Christie and his team did attract several endorsements from North Jersey Democrats, but there were some holdouts, including the Mayor of Fort Lee, just across the Hudson River from Manhattan.
One day last September, two bridge access lanes to the George Washington Bridge from Fort Lee were cut off a bridge that is the busiest in the world, according to the Port Authority.
New Jersey Port Authority officials said it was for a traffic study. But the mayor of Fort Lee charged that it was political retribution for not endorsing Christie, something thought to be a far-flung charge. That is until a hearing looking into the matter in December seemed to give some credence to that theory.
A New York Port Authority official testified that he was unaware of any such study. Two Christie appointees wound up resigning.
Now these emails, released to state investigators by subpoena, reveal the greater depth to which Christie aides sought payback against Fort Lee Mayor Mark Sokolich, derided by one Christie aide in the released emails as a little Serbian and threatening that it will be a tough November for him.
NBC New York and other news outlets report that Wildstein supplied the exchanges in response to a subpoena by state lawmakers investigating the lane closures. Wildstein, the former port authority's director of interstate capital projects, resigned in December shortly before Bill Baroni, the deputy executive director of the New York-New Jersey Port Authority, also resigned.
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

Yes, apparently it is wrong that you were smiling. Why would anyone expect less of a politician?
no worries, the fat man's force field from french kissing the king is well intact.
My guess is that the two appointees who resigned over this, are no longer on good terms with Christie's aides, and welcomed that subpoena. Not sure who was on the recipient list for the emails, but if the ones who resigned were on it, they probably handed them over with a smile.
However, it would not surprise me one bit if the subpoena was just part of a parallel construction plot.
So a pat on the back and a hand shake is french kissing ? Ridiculous.
Big worries!
E-mails of public officials and employees are considered public records under the Public Records Act.
Given the use of e-mail as a primary means of modern communication and correspondence, it's not only logical, but inevitable that investigations into possible government corruption will generate subpoenas to access e-mail records. The destruction of such e-mails potentially constitute destruction of evidence and obstruction of justice.
As more facts become known, I think things will get even worse for Christie. This will probably end any chance he has for getting the Republican nomination.
According to the actual NBC report Christie was not involved . It was his deputy chief of staff who was responsible :
This is an Easy Fix by Chris Christie
By: Erick Erickson (Diary) | January 8th, 2014 at 05:35 PM | 16
First, it actually is pretty brilliant that Christie came out using Barack Obamas standard excuse of not knowing and being misled. Thats well played.
Second, this is such an easy fix. Christie can turn it around quickly. He needs to follow through and see that heads roll. Then he can point out that he has actually fired people, unlike President Obama.
Oh, well heck, as long as he says he was unaware then clearly he was unaware.Shame on those topChristie aides - it's hard to find good help these days, huh?
If nothing else, Christie may be charged with using public funds for political purposes, and further, the death of the 91 year old woman might constitute a "wrongful death" charge;
The terms misfeasance and nonfeasance are most often used with reference to the conduct of municipal authorities with reference to the discharge of their statutory obligations , as in the case of failure to repair public highways; but in other cases the courts are astute to find evidence of carelessness in the discharge of public duties and on that basis to award damages to individuals who have suffered thereby.
Malfeasance in office , or official misconduct , is the commission of an unlawful act, done in an official capacity, which affects the performance of official duties. Malfeasance may be grounds for a for cause removal of an elected official by statute or recall election .
Don't we just love it when the Darrell Issa fan club suddenly remembers the "presumption of innocence" tenet?
It's so fuckin' heartening.
Ask redstate.com what it thinks will happen when Christie's staff members have to testify under oath?
And yet it meant so little to you until now.
"Scandals"?
"Presumption of innocence" prevails in the absence of satisfaction of "burden of proof."
Remember when
NO EVIDENCE!
All you need to do when making an allegation is TO PROVE IT!
Easy, huh?
What you want done on behalf of Christie, AND RIGHTLY SO, is the SATISFACTION OF THE BURDEN OF PROOF.
But with Obama, you want the "INNOCENT UNTIL CHARGED" standard invoked.
That's called a "double standard," a.k.a. "hypocrisy".
Mike, we know how they knew about the emails.
That's how they got them. When you're dealing with a bunch of liars and corrupt individuals fighting each other and unfortunately they do the same to us this is what you get. We know we paid with Air Force One for Obama to fly all over the country promoting class division at our expense and I have a lot more info that proves we actually paid for Obama's 2nd election, but with Eric Holder being the Supreme Justice in the USA and Harry Reid we don't have much of a chance to convict this tyranny even with proof.
Personally, I could care less if it is true or not. I'm tired of providing fall men for the elections and Christie is just another one like McCain and Romney were. Christie was stupid enough to kiss the snake and think he was immune from his venom like most of the Republicans seem to be. When you are fighting a war for this country you must never ever forget the enemy is not trustworthy and will stab you in the back.
Evidently they must have doubts in whether Hillary could bet him or they would have left him alone. Otherwise as in all Obama's elections the object is to destroy the opponent. You don't have to tell the truth and you don't have to really have anything to offer. Obama destroyed all of his opponents right up to McCain and Romney, which they used every method they could to destroy them as well. It's the Democrat way of winning elections.
If this takes Christie out of the picture for the Republican nomination, I am delighted. We need a real candidate for a change who really represents the majority of Americans in this country for a change.
I understand when Christie found out about this he was outraged. He has called for a full internal investigation using all resources at his disposal, to inquire upon any communications between his office and the Transportation Authority. In an obvious display of concern, Christie stipulated that it is inexcusable for an executive to use one of his administrative arms to profile and punish one of his political opponents. Animated, swinging his clenched fist, Christy assured the people, and specifically the mayor and people of Fort Lee, that he would discover, and bring those responsible to justice!
Dear liberals, please see above and replace:
Christie with Obama
Transportation Authority with IRS
Mayor and pople of Fort Lee with conservative groups seeking tax exempt status.
AND CRY ME A FING RIVER!!!!
With JW's support.... I rest my case.
Yes Petey, didn't he say the first time he heard about it was when he read it in the newspapers with the rest of us, I think it was Friday or something.
The hypocrisy comes from all sides; but in matters of making allegations, there is a burden of proof that must be satisfied
Burden of Proof
What we have in the various so-called Obama Administration "scandals," are charges, NONE OF WHICH HAVE SATISFIED THIS STANDARD!
And the same relentless Obama-detractors that come here and run with every dead-end allegation, now come to defend Christie's right under the law.
The hatred of Obama comes through loud and clear with every witch hunt albeit each one goes on DESPITE THE FAILURE TO PROVIDE PROOF!
Maybe they will use the Lerner tactic. Oh that's right, she got a promotion for a job well done, was to be head of the IRS on Obamacare and I believe resigned so she wouldn't have to go before Congress anymore.
But Obama, of course, will have no such advantage.
I see.
I don't see anyone saying he is innocent. I hope he gets canned. I really do. I want a real candidate who is standing with the people for a change. I'm tired of the Democrats picking the Republican candidates to be the fall guy.
good morning Amac sir. remember, obama did let that one guy go, who was due to retire in 2 weeks anyway, with full pension/benefits.
perhaps he can use that to his advantage.
Yea, what difference does it make? Probably some state workers just walking around one night and decided to work on the lane.
Let's hope so Krish.
That's an intriguing statement; I'd be interested in seeing some clarification, Sixpick.
Unless, of course, that unlike the Obama "scandals," there's a legitimate (un-Issa-like) investigation and the existence of proof regarding Christie.
No one is likely to "fall on their sword" to protect Christie if in fact, he overtly or, in subtle ways, ordered the lane closings. It's one thing to fear for your job and another to be charged with "perjury" and "obstruction of justice."
Time will tell.
"Transparency and the rule of law will be the touchstones of this presidency,"...period
There are reasons why, under the American Judicial System, individuals do not have to prove their innocence, rather, their accusers are obligated to establish proof of guilt.
Among those reasons is the idea of thwarting witch hunts.
Believe me, Mike, I see
Say what?
thats true, if there is nothing to directly link christie to personally giving the order to attack his political apponents, then he should be absolved.
even if the head of the transportation authority visited the gov mansion 100 times or so beforehand (for easter egg hunts)!
does anyone think we should hold the highest executive officeto an even higher standard than the govnr?
Is CSPAN on in the middle of the night in Hawaii?
Agreed that Obama has allowed too many important questions to go unanswered -- and EVERY PUBLIC OFFICIAL WHO MAKES ANY PORTION OF GOVERNMENT OPAQUE, DOES A DISSERVICE TO THOSE HE/SHE IS SUPPOSED TO SERVE.
That is why I question the disparity between the degrees of righteous indignation from the right-wing when it comes to Obama vs. Christie when no hard evidence has been presented.
When I address the charges against Obama, I do not declare his innocence arbitrarily, or, in some instances, not at all. WHAT I DO PRESENT IN THE WAY OF ARGUMENTS ARE EITHER VIABLE, POSSIBLE EXPLANATIONS WITH SPECIFICS, or questions arising from the LACK OF EVIDENCE.
The visits to which you allude were documented and many in conjunction with meetings involving hundreds of attendees.
If you haven't read any of the revealed e-mails in the Christie matter. JoAnne, you may find your conflation is not analogous.
Still, while we always disagree on politics, good morning to you.
EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER THE LAW!
No bias or subjectivity in that proclamation.
But let's hold off until there is testimony heard under oath. If Christie's news conference words are corroborated, then Mike, you could be right. BUT, if it turns out to be blowhard, bully bullshit, the opposite will obtain.
This thing is playing out like a Sopranos episode, with all the lies and false sincerity, minus the violence. Gandolfini would be impressed.
Someone might be getting fitted for a pair of concrete sneakas.
Are you talking about John Podesta?
People like Rowe are picking our candidates and in the last several elections and many Republicans didn't vote because they knew these people didn't represent them for one thing. Rowe has lots of money behind him like Obama and the people are becoming much more aware of it. The Republicans in Washington for the most part are just RINO's.
Sorry Gunny. I read A Mac's comment and answered it before I read your comment, but looks like we're on the same page. LOL
In what world does agovernor's top aidedo something so blatantly obvious and damaging, with zero consultation from their boss? What you are seeing is little more than good acting. You don't get to be governor without the ability to put on a show.
can the witness first take the oath, then give a prepared statement, then plead the 5th?
"reward our friends, punish our enemies"
sounds like a viable presidential candidate to me...now if he can just stop talking about fiscal responsibility, he should win by a landslide.
Not UFOs -- IRS.
Good one! But there is to this day, no proof of the allegations re: the IRS "scandal".
I've got a term for you - " Occam's Razor"
You obviously have not seen some of the other Christie news conferences.
Wow! JoAnne, do you know the origin of that statement?
I always knew you had a "pro-labor" side.
the "press" has asked Christie so many questions in todays conference, that they have actually exceeded all questions posed by the "press" to obama on: NSA spying, IRS profiling, fast and furious gun running, benghazi gun running, FOX news reporter accusations, AP reporter accusations, law of the land changes by executive order, refusal to execute the laws of the nation...combined
perhaps we should consider the musings of jackson lee, and replace the phrase "scandal investigation expendatures", to "transitional governing fund"
to remove the stigma, and any racist undertones.
And if that were your boss, would you ever do something as crazy as what was supposedly done without his knowledge?
he is
"too big to fail"
btw, i sent that to hiis office already, so its patented!
would love to see him debate what difference does it make hillary. the fat man would not be worried about the fat press attacking him for going after a woman
You know that's not the fucking issue!
Chris Christies problem is that hes really, truly a bully
think podesta will hire kelly?
WILDSTEIN JUST STATED HE IS TAKING THE 5TH ON ALL QUESTIONS!
he fired...a WOMAN...time to call that sandy reacharound chip
But what do you call what is going on with Christie right now? Sounds like a witch-hunt to me.
And if that were your boss, would you ever do something as crazy as what was supposedly done without his knowledge?
are we still talking about christie or obama?
christie should handle this like obama did unemployment insurance: get a bunch of victims to stand behind him, and demand money.
if he can get one of them to "faint", behind him, with his back to her, so he can "catch" her, that would be great too.
now that i think about it, kelly probably already works for hillary
What do you think will happen ... and why ?
Hey man, I asked you first, but I'll step up.
If Kelly et al haven't been threatened/blackmailed or paid off/promised something down the road, they'll testify honestly and, if they were ordered overtly or tacitly by Christie or a proxy to close the bridge lanes, they will throw the culprit to the wolves and save their asses.
Otherwise, they'll all plead the Fifth and take their chances with contempt charges. If she/they are able to plea bargain, I'm guessing, given Brigit Kelly's lack of official authority to direct the Bridge Commission, etc., I find it hard to believe that those who had the power to close the lanes would have done so unless they got the order directly from Christie or, believed Kelly was speaking for Christie (WITH HIS OVERT OR TACIT GO AHEAD).
Your opinion, Petey?
BTW, Christie said today he lost two night's sleep over this, but also said that yesterday was the first he heard of it.
Your a math guy -- do the calculation.
I doubt Christie would be so petty as to approve of any such foolishly vindictive action , especially one with such large public consequences . He is just not that stupid ...
i think carson is terrified of being clarence thomased by the democrat owned press.
I agree . When is Obama gonna fire the EPA chief ? And Eric Holder ?
You don't know politicians then, and that shocks me given your consistent willingness to run with every allegation against Obama regardless of the absence of evidence.
Beyond that, it's not stupidity alone that makes politicians perpetrate acts of retribution, it's THEIR ARROGANCE THAT MAKES THEM BELIEVE THEY CAN DO SO WITH IMPUNITY.
Possibly when there's a VERIFIED ACT OF MISFEASANCE
Darrell Issa bullshit investigations in which only friendly witnesses are called to testify don't count.
You don't need to commit malfeasance or even misfeasance to be fired ... just incompetence . The fact that these 2 are still in office implies that Obama is incompetent for not taking the needed action ...
You have successfully changed the discussion to Obama.
Do it again and I'll raise the issue of your selective indignation towards Obama while, to my knowledge, your never having said a word about George W. Bush's 30 plus violations of the Constitution WITH THE LIST OF VIOLATIONS AND THE EVIDENCE.
I answered your EPA/Holder question. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WHAT YOU REFERENCE AND THE CHRISTIE ISSUE IS THAT THE INCIDENT -- THE BRIDGE LANE CLOSINGS -- HAVE BEEN VERIFIED.
That makes one a witch hunt and one based on facts.
Further, the e-mail that said "Time for some traffic problems" and the "Got it" e-mail response, WAS ONE MINUTE! Smoking gun much?
VERIFIED!
Your opinion regarding incompetence ever hear the term "for just cause"? Make your case with specifics not declarations.
Here's how to get the truth (if it's not what Christie offered).
Charge Brigit Kelly with contributing to the "wrongful death" of the 91 year old woman who died, possibly because of the delays on the bridge! Cite Christie's claim that she lied to him, thus implying that she may have ordered the bridge lane closings on her own!
Tweet, tweet, tweet.
Further name Wildstein and Bridge Authority higher ups in the charge.
Responses? Anyone?
If she is made the scapegoat, she'll answer all questions under oath and I would not be surprised if some of the players, including Kelly, will be allowed to testify with various degrees of immunity, Mike.
Regarding,
The Governor alleges he knows nothing. If under oath, one of the players claims to have acted on Christie's orders (overt or implied, and including but not limited to the threat of firing), he could be indicted, impeached, recalled or imprisoned.
Time will tell maybe.
Immunity can be nullified under certain circumstances; again.
And this case will open other cans of worms regarding Christie's culture of retribution -- guaranteed. This is only the beginning.
My good friend, the only thing Christie accomplished today was to paint himself into a corner. Should evidence surface to the contrary of his performance today, he will be twice scorned -- once for being a liar and once again for letting the "littler people" take the rap.
I would strategize if I were Hillary's advisor, by pointing to the dichotomy between Darrell Issa witch hunts that go nowhere except to Tea Party regurgitations ad infinitum vs. events that are substantiated by empirical information.
Two can play by the Christie ROE.
His entire set of responses was part of a contrived "I'm the victim", "I'm hurt," "I've been betrayed" puppy dog eyes bullshit show.
But, to be fair, we still don't know.
I've done 2 articles about the EPA's incompetence :
...
...
Enjoy !
Can you translate that into English ?
In other breaking news... Christie said that she had nothing to do with the bridge closure but blamed it on her stylist Phillip Bloch, saying that he wanted those lanes closed to get her wardrobe to her, but she will not be firing him, since he she always looks so fine because of him.
Jesus Christie!
Who knew?
It is? I'm talking about Christie.
I KNOW! Beautiful and devious... a deadly combo.
How about a charge of "reckless endangerment" or "risking a catastrophe"?
I'm buyin'!
I'm drinkin'
That's just silly . Bush hasn't been in office for years . I think there's a statute of limitations on those items you want to dredge up ...
The Convention on the Non-Applicability of Statutory Limitations to War Crimes and Crimes Against Humanity was adopted and opened for signature, ratification and accession by United Nations General Assembly resolution 2391 (XXIII) of 26 November 1968. Pursuant to the provisions of its Article VIII (90 days following the deposit of the tenth ratification), it came into force on 11 November 1970.
The Convention provides that no signatory state may apply statutory limitations to:
As of August 2012, 54 UN member states were parties to the Convention.
Let's get the party started.
Ah yoose tawkin' ta me?
Hey; it ain't no Bensonhurst it's Bensinhoist.
Whats wif yooze?
The docket must be followed chronologically then.
Yeah, that cuts both ways doesn't it? Exactly why I raise "selective indignation" to the the Obama-haters when they relentlessly pick and choose ONLY the indiscretions of Obama while avoiding the same indiscretions by Bush.
And the Bush indiscretions are heavily documented (as I have posted many times) while the Obama "scandals" are not. Shall I once again post the Darrell Issa "There's no evidence" videos?
Be it Obama or any other official, if the evidence is clear, then
But spare me the Darrell Issa witch hunts that go nowhere.
That would be the "elephant in the room".
Sorry couldn't resist. And with that, good night all.
LOL Hal! Didn't think of her! Good one!
Don't be silly Mac . That does not have the force of law . And the UN has such a selective focus on its incriminations[the general assembly works by unpopularity ] that it is a joke . I have to think that your reply was as well ...
After revelation that Christie asked Cuomo to back off bridge lane closure inquiry, top aide resigns
The WSJ published this on December 12th, long before the current revelations. Why would Christie be pressuring Coumo about stopping the investigation into the lane closures if he wasn't involved?
This was a vicious political maneuver that may have cost one woman her life, prevented first responders from reaching their destinations (which might have cost other injuries or death), kept people from earning a living and children from attending schools. Every person involved should face criminal charges.
Has anyone ever been prosecuted under UN resolutions ? This ain't the Geneva Convention !
After revelation that Christie asked Cuomo to back off bridge lane ...
The WSJ published this on December 12th, long before the current revelations. Why would Christie be pressuring Coumo about stopping the investigation into the lane closures if he wasn't involved?
This was a vicious political maneuver that may have cost one woman her life, prevented first responders from reaching their destinations (which might have cost other injuries or death), kept people from earning a living and children from attending schools. Every person involved should face criminal charges.
Yes . But who was responsible for doing it ?
We really are far afield but, since I started it, let me punctuate it here
You may ask (and with legitimate reason) why Bush was never prosecuted. The answer is "the lack of the political balls" of the Congress including this awful action
The self-serving culture of politics with few exceptions, is one of the most revealing elements of human nature.
There ya go . It was the security council & not that silly-ass general assembly . That's why I look on what Mac was referring to as just fluff .
I know this is a serious allegation, and I hope they get to the bottom of it. But I must admit I am so so so tired of every so-called scandal having the word -gate attached to it. It is high time for journalists to stop referencing an event that occurred before anyone under the age of 40 was even born!
If we use our office computers and send e-mails, they are the property of that organization, New York Port Authority is an agency of both NY and NJ State Govt. so, not too hard to get their hands on those e-mails, especially, if someone on the NJ side pissed off someone on the NY side of the Port Authority..Don't forget when Christie was first elected, he stopped a construction project that would have opened up more lanes in the Holland Tunnel and put hundreds of construction workers out of work which adversely affected New Yorkers, Christie refused federal $$$$ to continue the project Corzine started, so there was no love lost between NY Port Authority workers and Christie, Cuomo gets along with Christie, but that's as far as it goes...
If you don't know nuttin, then you shuddin say nuttin!!!!!!
That's scary . Considering the GA works on the principle of picking on the most unpopular member I'm surprised more damage has not been done . If a member nation drops out does that mean it is no longer subject to that court's jurisdiction ?
The colloquialism here in Philly for such a phenomenon is
"Money talks and bullshit walks!"
That's what the investigation is hoping to learn; I suspect that Wildstein's invoking the Fifth and his attorney asking for Wildstein's blanket immunity is a clue to where the answer will be found. If the contempt charge against Wildstein sticks, he'll tell all (IMO).
Beyond that, even if the bridge scandal is not "solved," now that other victims of Christie's retribution tactics are coming forward, "official misconduct," which is clearly defined under NJ law, may be his political Waterloo.
Yeah, why?
Obama did not lie to get us into the the Iraq war, which is primary the issue that would make Bush a possible war criminal.
TheAfghanistanwar is a different issue with a different set of circumstances. The pentagon Generals advised Obama we had to re-gain certain ground before we could safely pull out our troops.
It wasn't until after muchconsiderationand study that Obama gave the 30 thousand of the 40 thousand troops they asked for.
As far as W being charged as a criminal; I think Vincent Bugliosi got it right in his book The Prosecution of George W. Bush For Murde r - watch the video, you'll understand.
I read the book in 2008 and nothing so far has been done, but there is no statue of limitations for war criminals, ....... we'll see what the future brings.