Amending the Constitution is Unconstitutional According to HUFFPO "Legal" Reporter
Key figures in the crowded Republican field have spoken loud and clear about their desire to do away with birthright citizenship for the children of immigrants.
Donald Trump went a step further Tuesday when he said in a CNN interview that children born to immigrants under the present constitutional order "do not have American citizenship."
In other words, the citizenship they were born with is invalid, a notionTrump said he'd be willing to "test out" in a court of law.
But one needs not go that far.
The same would be true fora Republican-backed bill with a similar goal that's pending in Congress.
The reason these proposals could be found unconstitutional is rooted in the very thing Republicans are attacking: the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
Because for all the provisions and principles that the 14th Amendment stands for -- and birthright citizenship is only one of them -- one of the amendment's cornerstones is its promise of equal treatment for everyone.
"No State shall ... deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws," says the last part of Section 1 of the amendment, also known as the Equal Protection Clause. The Supreme Court has ruled that the clause applies to states and the federal government alike.
Over the years, the clause has been read broadly to mean that no government entity can pass a law that singles out or discriminates against anyone on the basis of their race, national origin or other protected characteristic. It generally means that no official actioncan treat people differently because of who they are.
That is the principle the Supreme Court has upheld in a number of historic rulings -- from Brown v. Board of Education in 1954 to Obergefell v. Hodges , June's historic gay marriage case.
In the latter, the court applied the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause to invalidate a number of state bans on same-sex marriage, which the court found denied gay couples' right to "equal dignity in the eyes of the law."That is, those bans put them on unequal footing with everyone else.
This concept covers Latinos, too. The Supreme Court long ago ruled that equal protection of the laws applies fully to them -- in a little-known case that, as history would have it, was decided mere days before the landmark Brown ruling. The court has also ruled that equal protection applies to undocumented immigrants.
As a result of this and other precedents, federal courts can and will scrutinize any law or ordinance specifically targeting Latinos. And judges will be punishing in their review, applying a stiff constitutional test known as "strict scrutiny."
"Strict scrutiny, like a Civil War stomach wound, is generally fatal," wrote Supreme Court reporter Adam Liptak in a recent New York Times article. The specifics are complex, but all that basically means is that most discriminatory laws will simply fail under the test.
So if any of the GOP proposals to strip immigrant children of birthright citizenship make it into law, it won't be long before they are challenged in court and, ultimately, found unconstitutional.
Lawsuits under the 14th Amendment can be messy, and one would hope that anti-immigrant sentiment never reaches a point that federal courts have to get involved. But if past cases have taught us anything, we can rest assured that the judiciary won't let the likes of Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa) run roughshod over the Constitution with ideas that purport to fixit.

How this guy passed 8th grade, let alone was hired as a "legal affairs writer" on a major left website is beyond me.
It's quite possibly the dumbest thing ever published on the Constitution.
(a) Though the Fifth Amendment does not contain an equal protection clause, as does the Fourteenth Amendment, which applies only to the States, the concepts of equal protection and due process are not mutually exclusive. P. 499.
(b) Discrimination may be so unjustifiable as to be violative of due process. P. 499.
Apparently one needs a law degree to appreciate the fine points ...
The Constitution can be amended for any purpose and for any reason. The Constitution can be theoretically amended to deport all HuffPo readers. There is no such thing as an unconstitutional amendment.
While Amending the Constitution can not be unConstitutional, any attempt to change the 14th Amendment via only a law (as opposed to a Constitutional Amendment being introduced to change that part of the 14th Amendment and it succeeding to become a part of the Constitution (not likely) ) passed by Congress to try to over-ride birth right citizenship will certainly be immediately challenged and will almost certainly be declared UnConsitutional when it reaches the Supreme Court. However not because of the case he cites (which would not be on point), but because of Supreme Court ruling in The US V Wong Kim Ark in 1898. I doubt if even the most conservative Supreme Court will overturn that ruling. Not impossible, but there's just not very much of a chance of it happening, IMHO.
Randy, Randy, Randy - quit trying to be a lawyer.
Let's just go back and cut and paste our last debate about this. It'll be faster and much easier.
No one has to amend the Constitution anyway. The Fourteenth Amendment doesn't guarantee nor grant citizenship to a child born from illegal immigrant just because the child is born in the United States. Yes, it has been functioning that way, but it isn't the way the Fourteenth Amendment is meant to be interpreted. You can read this and get a better understanding if you want to do so.
What Subject to the Jurisdiction Thereof Really Means
...
If you take the time to read even a small portion of this you will realize the children of illegal immigrants are not citizens of the United States. It is explained numerous times.
Now take a look at the Fourteenth Amendment:
Amendment XIV
Section 1.
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof , are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
I know this is only Section One, but that is as far as you need to go to realize an illegal immigrant's child isn't automatically an American Citizen just because he or she is born in the United States.
Now it is clear this is true, but this is just another thing about this country that has ignored the Constitution and as the fellow up there once said, "We make it up as we go along".
Well, eventually you get so far off track the Constitution becomes just a piece of worthless paper as it has become today when the Judicial Branch writes laws instead of interprets them unlike the powers the Constitution really grants them and the President runs the country with Executive Orders as Obama and many others have done beyond their legal right to do to such an extent.
Got a link to the article?
Steve I believe the link to the article is:
but it doesn't make any difference anyway. The comment I put up right above your comment here clearly explains why an illegal immigrant's child is not a citizen although the Constitution is just a piece of paper today.
That's nothing more then the Federalists (and your) opinion. The SCOTUS says otherwise, and the opinion of the federalists carries no weight of law. They (SCOTUS) ruled that any person born in the US IS in the jurisdiction of the US by definition. That is exactly what the 14th says and there is no other way to interpret it. That's what the SCOTUS has ruled and it hasn't been considered again by them in more then 100 years. They are not going to overturn Wong. You want to stop birth right citizenship? Passing a simple law will not work. You HAVE to pass an amendment to the Constitution to do it. Nothing else will make it past even the most conservative Supreme Court.
There's a big difference in the Wong case. His parents were here legally. Although I know it doesn't matter and it is the opinion of many scholars, not just mine the intention in the 14th amendment did not consider illegal Aliens located in the USA at that time or that case.
Do I expect anything to change? No I don't. The Democrat leadership wants a totalitarian government and the Republican leadership wants cheap labor. They both are one in the same. They want the government to be over the people run by the elite and big corporations and that's just the way it is becoming more with each passing year.
What do you NOT understand about this statement Randy?
"whether a child born in the United States, of parent of Chinese descent, who, at the time of his birth, are subjects of the Emperor of China, but have a permanent domicil and residence in the United States, and are there carrying on business, and are not employed in any diplomatic or official capacity under the Emperor of China, becomes at the time of his birth a citizen of the United States."
Illegal aliens do not have "permanent domicile and residence in the United States" - LEGALLY. They are in the United States illegally making their child an illegal alien also.
This is a wonderful debate.
But most forget the basis for being a citizen.
In the beginning it was just show up and declare yourself as a citizen, obey the laws and be of good moral character..
Once the constitution was written, congress brushed up the rules with the citizenship act of 1790.
And we go from there.
It might help the debate to understand how we arrived at this citizenship conundrum...
I would consider the term jus soli , and keep it in mind as you read.
Looking to the Founders: Determining Citizenship
It appears to me that the founders intent was that if you are born here you are a citizen. not only that, if your father was a US citizen, then you were also.
Birthright citizenship has been around since the beginning of this nation. Long before it was codified in the 14th amendment as part of the constitution.
Your born here, you belong here. Your born into the family, your ALWAYS a member.
End of story.
The correct interpretation of the 14th Amendment is that an illegal alien mother is subject to the jurisdiction of her native country, as is her baby.
Over a century ago, the Supreme Court correctly confirmed this restricted interpretation of citizenship in the so-called 'Slaughter-House cases' [83 US 36 (1873)] and in [112 US 94 (1884)]. In Elk v.Wilkins, the phrase 'subject to its jurisdiction' excluded from its operation 'children of ministers, consuls, and citizens of foreign states born within the United States.' In Elk, the American Indian claimant was considered not an American citizen because the law required him to be 'not merely subject in some respect or degree to the jurisdiction of the United States, but completely subject to their political jurisdiction and owing them direct and immediate allegiance.'
Congress subsequently passed a special act to grant full citizenship to American Indians, who were not citizens even through they were born within the borders of the United States. The Citizens Act of 1924, codified in 8USCS1401, provides that:
The following shall be nationals and citizens of the United States at birth: (a) a person born in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof; (b) a person born in the United States to a member of an Indian, Eskimo, Aleutian, or other aboriginal tribe.
Fortunately, we have the highest possible authority on record to answer this question of how the term "jurisdiction" was to be interpreted and applied, the author of the citizenship clause, Sen. Jacob M. Howard (MI) to tell us exactly what it means and its intended scope as he introduced it to the United States Senate in 1866:
Mr. HOWARD: I now move to take up House joint resolution No. 127.
The motion was agreed to; and the Senate, as in Committee of the Whole, resumed the consideration of the joint resolution (H.R. No. 127) proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the United States.
The first amendment is to section one, declaring that all "persons born in the United States and Subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they reside. I do not propose to say anything on that subject except that the question of citizenship has been fully discussed in this body as not to need any further elucidation, in my opinion. This amendment which I have offered is simply declaratory of what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country.
It is clear the framers of the Fourteenth Amendment had no intention of freely giving away American citizenship to just anyone simply because they may have been born on American soil, something our courts have wrongfully assumed. But what exactly did "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" mean to the framers of the Fourteenth Amendment? Again, we are fortunate to have on record the highest authority to tell us, Sen. Lyman Trumbull, Chairman of the Judiciary Committee, author of the Thirteenth Amendment, and the one who inserted the phrase:
The provision is, that 'all persons born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens.' That means 'subject to the complete jurisdiction thereof.' What do we mean by 'complete jurisdiction thereof?' Not owing allegiance to anybody else. That is what it means.
but have a permanent domicil and residence in the United States
That does not mean they were citizens or even resident aliens (and they were neither), because The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 made it illegal for any Chinese person to become a citizen. A Mexican who is here illegally can (and most do) have a permanent domicile and residence in America simply by renting an apartment or house. That part of the ruling (as interpreted by the SCOTUS) simply means the Wong's parent were living here. That's why the SCOTUS ruled the way they did by deciding that since Wong had been born in San Francisco that the 14th Amendment granted him automatic citizenship simply by being born here. And it has never over ruled that. Complain to the SCOTUS if you don't like the 14th Amendment. The only way to get around the 14th and to stop birth right citizenship is to pass a Constitutional Amendment that over rides that portion of the 14, because the SCOTUS today would rule the same way as they did in the Wong case.
The problem is that that is not how the Supreme Court sees the 14th. Pass another amendment, because you're not going to change their minds on this. Not even the current Robert's court will over turn that. The 14th says what is says and what it was intended to take care of is irrelevant. It says nothing about what the authors intended, so the Supreme Court will not take the intentionon into consideration. Just what it says. The authors of the 14th should should have added that meaning, that intention, into the Amendment, but they didn't, so anyone born here is a citizen, by birth right until you change the Constitution to say otherwise.
well randy when you have the congressional minutes of the discussions as to what it actually means . vs what the courts think it means and interprets it as you can see the problem, and yes I agree , it will take a constitutional amendment to do that, and make it very plain and simple, not a law but an amendment.
In the same respect , the authors words as to the scope and what certain phases mean do have to be taken into account , like it or not. at least we are not in a brasario (sp)system anymore....
It appears to me that the founders intent was that if you are born here you are a citizen. not only that, if your father was a US citizen, then you were also.
It appears to me the same because of the use of by the SCOTUS the term (as you pointed out) jus soli. America IS a jus soli nation.
Ultimately, whether the 14th amendment requires birthright citizenship depends on which side of the bed Justice Kennedy wakes up on.
What's not debatable is that the author of this piece, a supposed legal affairs writer for HuffPo, doesn't understand how the Constitution operates. The idea that an amendment can be unconstitutional is simply bizarre.
I was curious to see if anyone would defend it. I't's a good sign no one did.
Ultimately, whether the 14th amendment requires birthright citizenship depends on which side of the bed Justice Kennedy wakes up on.
On that we certainly can agree. Depends on if someone files a challenge and if the Supreme Court decides to hear it or not. If Congress did get through a law trying to end Birth Right citizenship, then it certainly would be challenged by many, many civil rights groups and a almost certainly a stay issued on each courts decision until it works it's way through the federal court system. If it's not fast tracked then there is a possibility that the court would have a new justice or two. Some of them are getting very old. Still, if it's the same group, I'm betting that that the new law would be found to be unConstitutional based on the 14th Amendment and that even some conservatives, like Roberts, would vote against it.
I have no doubt that if Congress passes a new law, not a amendment, that those documents would be presented by the side that wants the new law. If Congress does get a Constitutional Amendment through both Houses (and that would depend greatly on the 2016 Congressman and women and Senate elections) that intention would probably be used at many state legislatures before they vote to ratify or not.
It's a very difficult thing to do, to change the Constitution and I for one am glad it is or we would be amending it after every social change or new Congress. Then we'd have hundreds of Amendments, most of them overriding one or more of the other hundreds passed earlier. It would be chaos and our government and court system would grind to a complete halt.
I just like read the thing for myself rather than being told what something says.
Perhaps the author read your post. It now has slightly different language, duly noted at the bottom of the article.
Still, it is difficult to see how any amendment, as opposed to a law, would be unconstitutional other than not having gone through the correct process.
Amendments are not written in stone . The one on prohibition was repealed ...
Fortunately, Congress "can't" pass a law to void an amendment. One of the purposes of SCOTUS is to determine, according to "Marbury", is to ensure Congress doesn't pass any laws that "could" be unconstitutional - Marbury v. Madison
Interesting passage.
I would ask the question as why these people are excused from the law. the answer is very simple. They are foreign nationals in the employ and representation of their government. By their very nature and the nature of their position they CANNOT be US citizens. Therefore they are excluded. Anyone else physically born in this country the opposite will result. that is clearly stated by the lead in section of his proposition thus...
So what it appears you are arguing is jurisdiction, so what is complete jurisdiction?
And, I don't care who Lyman Turnbull was, he is NOT the highest authority in our system of jurisprudence. The constitution is and the intent of the founders is as interpreted by the Supreme Court.
You mention the Indian Citizenship Act. It was intended to correct a conundrum in the law concerning citizenship of indians. on the one hand many states held that the Indians were a separate people becasue they had a set aside which was their reservations and these were commonly known as Nations. Making them separate countries. where federally, the nation had taken jurisdiction over all Indian lands by both right of conquest and right of trust. The Federal government created the department of Indian affairs to administer the lands in trust for the Indians. When the feds did this and created the department they forgot one thing.
When the US completed the purchase of Louisiana in 1802 all residents of said territory were granted full citizenship, including the Indians. when Mexico ceded California and the southwest territories to the US at the end of the Mexican War the same thing happened. All residents became US citizens with full rights appurtenant to such status. Same thing with the Conquest of Hawaii, the purchase of Alaska, the annexation of Puerto Rico, the Gasden purchase and all the like.
The original intent was that anyone living within the boundaries of the US especially those born here are automatically citizens with the full benefits thereof.
Including the Indians. but since the states refused to recognize such citizenship for the Indians Congress passed an ACT making it so. it is an issue I agree with 1st warrior on, one that disgusts me that it took so long for the national government to finally force all to recognize Indians as the proud citizens they are. By golly they damned well earned it.
the framers of the Fourteenth Amendment couldn't care less about citizenship, the Fourteenth wasn't devised to deal with the issue.
It has been applied retrospectively to the issue. and is actually insufficient to fully resolve it in my learned opinion.
The "Complete" jurisdiction issue is applying a qualified standard of jurisdiction. Which the federal courts have rejected everytime such has been argued before them.
The question is one of second impression, and to resolve it under the constitution they will go all the way back to the original framers intent. Which as previously linked to is one of if you are born here you are a citizen here, if you were born to an American Father, then you are a citizen, no matter your national heritage, NO exceptions. (How many Korean GI children had to be repatriated to the US after the Korean War? How many Vietnamese children? Japanese Children? German Children?)
The last time they had to do this was on an issue of first impression over the second amendment. and if you read that decision and every one like it, they specifically and in detail outline the line of research they go through.
Which always starts with the founders original intent before it reaches congressional intent.
No lawsuit in effort to disenfranchise American citizenship birthright will succeed before any federal court. On any grounds.
Doing such will take a constitutional amendment, or, convening a constitutional convention.
Good luck with either of those.
All amendments have to fully pass in the legislatures of two thirds of all the states. Otherwise, it is nothing but a bunch of scribbling on wasted paper.
And that is BEFORE it ever reaches a court.
And three fourths of all of the various state legislatures must vote in favor of it. All of the states, sometimes in a set number of years. The Equal Rights Amendment didn't become part of the Constitution in the 1970's because the sponsors could not get enough state legislatures to vote in favor of it, to ratify it, in (I believe) seven years.
Yeah there were a few that never had an expiration date placed in them, they are still sitting there waiting to reach their approval.
Congressional Apportionment Amendment Pending since 1789;
Titles of Nobility Amendment Pending since 1810;
Corwin Amendment Pending since 1861;
Child Labor Amendment Pending since 1924;
There are also two that have failed to gain passage,
Equal Rights Amendment Failed in 1979, Ratification extension finally failed in 1982;
District of Columbia Voting Rights Amendment Failed 1985
It is not easy to get an amendment passed and some just plain get forgotten or the issues are resolved in other ways. (the Corwin Amendment was made moot by the outcome of the Civil War for example)
They are only time limited if a time limit for ratification is placed in the amendment itself before Congress passes it.