Hillary Clinton was director, for 6 years, of Wal-Mart
In 1986, Sam Walton, the founder of Wal-Mart , had a problem. He was under growing pressure from shareholders and his wife, Helen to appoint a woman to the companys 15-member board of directors.
So Mr. Walton turned to a young lawyer who just happened to be married to the governor of Arkansas, where Wal-Mart is based: Hillary Rodham Clinton .
Mrs. Clintons six-year tenure as a director of Wal-Mart, the nations largest company, remains a little known chapter in her closely scrutinized career. And it is little known for a reason. Mrs. Clinton rarely, if ever, discusses it, leaving her board membership out of her speeches and off her campaign Web site.
Fellow board members and company executives, who have not spoken publicly about her role at Wal-Mart, say Mrs. Clinton used her position to champion personal causes, like the need for more women in management and a comprehensive environmental program, despite being Wal-Marts only female director, the youngest and arguably the least experienced in business. On other topics, like Wal-Marts vehement anti-unionism, for example, she was largely silent, they said.
Her years on the Wal-Mart board, from 1986 to 1992, gave her an unusual tutorial in the ways of American business a credential that could serve as an antidote to Republican efforts to portray her as an enemy of free markets and an advocate for big government.
But that education came via a company that the Democratic Party and its major ally, organized labor has held up as a model of what is wrong with American business, with both groups accusing it of offering unaffordable health insurance and mistreating its workers.
So rather than promote her board membership, Mrs. Clinton is now running from it, even returning a $5,000 campaign donation from the giant discount chain in 2005, citing serious differences with its practices. But disentangling herself from the company is harder than it may seem.
Despite her criticism, Mrs. Clinton maintains close ties to Wal-Mart executives through the Democratic Party and the tightly knit Arkansas business community. Her husband, former President Bill Clinton , speaks frequently to Wal-Marts current chief executive, H. Lee Scott Jr., about issues like health care and even played host to Mr. Scott at the Clintons home in New York last July for a private dinner.
And several months ago, Mrs. Clinton helped broker a secret meeting between a top Wal-Mart executive and former Democratic operative, Leslie Dach, and leaders of the retailers longtime adversary at the United Food and Commercial Workers union, according to several people briefed on the matter, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to do so publicly.
The goal of the meeting was to tamp down the rancor between the company and the union, which has set up a group, WakeUpWalMart.com , that has harshly criticized the chain and leaked embarrassing internal documents to the news media, though an accord has not yet been reached.
Mrs. Clinton declined to be interviewed for this article. In a statement, her spokesman said, Wal-Mart is now one of the countrys largest employers, and Mrs. Clinton still believes it is important to try to influence the decisions they make because they can affect so many people.
In Mrs. Clintons complex relationship with Wal-Mart, there are echoes of the familiar themes that have defined much of her career: the trailblazing woman unafraid of challenging the men around her; the idealist pushing for complicated, at times expensive, reforms; and the political pragmatist, willing to accept policies she did not agree with to achieve her ends.
Did Hillary like all of Wal-Mart practices? No, said Garry Mauro, a longtime friend and supporter of the Clintons who sat on the Wal-Mart Environmental Advisory Board with Mrs. Clinton in the late 1980s and worked with her on George McGoverns 1972 presidential campaign.
But, Mr. Mauro added, was Wal-Mart a better company, with better practices, because Hillary was on the board? Yes.
Mrs. Clinton was not Mr. Waltons first choice for a woman on the board. That honor belonged to an executive at Nordstrom, the upscale department store. But Nordstrom opposed its employees sitting on a competitors board, so Wal-Mart turned instead to the 39-year-old Mrs. Clinton. They offered her about $15,000 a year for her time, generally four meetings a year.
She was a logical candidate: the wife of the governor, a Wal-Mart shareholder with stock eventually worth nearly $100,000 and a highly regarded lawyer at the Rose Law Firm, which had represented Wal-Mart in several cases.
But if her circumstances made her a natural choice for the board, her often liberal beliefs did not and she struggled to change the rigid, conservative culture at Wal-Mart, achieving modest results.
Early in her tenure, she pressed for information about the number of women in Wal-Marts management, worrying aloud that the companys hiring practices might be discriminatory.
The data she received would have been troubling: by 1985, there was not a single woman among the companys top 42 officers, according to In Sam We Trust, the 1998 book about Wal-Mart by Bob Ortega.
John E. Tate, who served as a director with Mrs. Clinton from 1988 to 1992, recalled that by her third board meeting Mrs. Clinton had announced that you can expect me to push on issues for women. You know that. I have a reputation of trying to improve the status of women generally, and I will do it here.
Mr. Walton appeared relieved to have a woman on the board to deflect criticism, telling shareholders during the annual meeting in 1987 that the company had a strong-willed young lady on the board now who has already told the board it should do more to ensure the advancement of women.
Still, the boards discussions did not translate into significant progress. By the late 1990s, after Mrs. Clinton had left the board, Wal-Mart had added a second female director, but the number of women in senior management remained paltry, according to company records. (Today, 23 percent of Wal-Marts top 300 corporate officers are women, but the company is fighting a class-action lawsuit claiming sex discrimination filed on behalf of 1.6 million current and former female employees.)
Mrs. Clinton had greater success on environmental issues. At her request, Mr. Walton set up the environmental advisory group, which sent a series of recommendations to the companys board.
When it came time to pick members, Mrs. Clinton, who led the advisory group, reached out to at least two colleagues from the McGovern presidential campaign Mr. Mauro and Roy Spence, who headed an advertising firm in Texas that did extensive work for Wal-Mart.
Under her watch, the advisory group drew up elaborate plans. Consumers would bring in used motor oil and batteries for recycling. Suppliers would reduce the size of their packaging. And Wal-Mart would build stores with energy-saving features.
Wal-Mart executives put much of the program into place. In 1993, for example, they opened an experimental eco-store in Kansas, with skylights and wooden beams from forests that had not been clear cut.
One executive derided it as Hillarys store because it was more expensive to build than the average Wal-Mart, but several of its features, like the skylights that cut energy bills by reducing the need for artificial lighting, were widely copied across the industry.
We were on the leading edge of something that is being mandated now, said Bill Fields, the head of merchandise at Wal-Mart in the early 1990s who worked closely with Mrs. Clinton on the environmental project.
For Wal-Mart, the largest employer in Arkansas, Mrs. Clintons presence had obvious advantages: on matters big and small, the company had the ear of the governors wife.
For Mrs. Clinton, being a director at Wal-Mart gave her access to several of the states most powerful business executives. In the early 1980s, for example, Mr. Walton was instrumental in building support for a corporate tax program, pushed by Mrs. Clinton, that financed a major education overhaul in Arkansas, a signal achievement of her husbands governorship.
Though she was passionate about issues like gender and sustainability, Mrs. Clinton largely sat on the sidelines when it came to Wal-Mart and unions, board members said. Since its founding in 1962, Wal-Mart has fought unionization efforts at its stores and warehouses, employing hard-nosed tactics like allegedly firing union supporters and spying on employees that have become the subject of legal complaints against the company.
A special team at Wal-Mart handled those activities, but Mr. Walton was vocal in his opposition to unions. Indeed, he appointed the lawyer who oversaw the companys union monitoring, Mr. Tate, to the board, where he served with Mrs. Clinton.
During their meetings and private conversations, Mrs. Clinton never voiced objections to Wal-Marts stance on unions, said Mr. Tate and John A. Cooper, another board member.
She was not an outspoken person on labor, because I think she was smart enough to know that if she favored labor, she was the only one, Mr. Tate said. It would only lessen her own position on the board if she took that position.
Mr. Tate, a prominent management lawyer who has helped stop union drives at many major companies, said he worked closely with Mr. Walton to convince workers that a union would be bad for the company, personally telling employees when he visited stores that the only people who need unions are those who do not work hard.
A spokesman for Mrs. Clinton said, Wal-Mart workers should be able to unionize and bargain collectively.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/20/us/politics/20walmart.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

first i hear of this was yesteday on cnn. imagine, walmart, the lefts villian, guilty of all things against the worker class, prime example of greed, justification for maximum wage arguments....and hillary was a director for SIX YEARS
"at this point, what difference does it make"
but, what if the NYT prints it?
Actually, associating herself with a successful business is probably one of the biggest achievements of her career. . Too bad for her she didn't pick up any tips about executive management before she her train wreck of a 2008 campaign. Seriously, she's been a spectacular failure at pretty much everything else she's tried.
Well, at least you didn't call me a terrorist for criticizing Hillary and her still illusory accomplishments. That's progress.
Then may I assume you'd prefer she'd been a Community Organizer instead? Can't have it both ways -- castigating Obama for being a community organizer and pro union while posting an article which, I assume is a way of castigating Hillary for working for anti-union Wal-Mart?
So which is it?
I insist.
Otherwise, Happy New Year JoAnne.
Oh, like Bernie Maddof or Jesse Jackson she's quite accomplished in enriching herself. No doubt. I like to think a politician's accomplishments are measured in doing something for the public good rather than simply exploiting your public position to making yourself rich.
If exploiting her connections to government to enrich herself counts as an accomplishment, then I concede she is very accomplished.
ur belief that only Democrats and swindlers enrich themselves with government connections is a hoot.
It certainly would be if I believed that. I don't.
he got herself elected to the US Senate and appointed to US Secretary of State.
She "won" a Senate seat that was gift wrapped for her in one of the bluest states in the country. She failed miserably in the two biggest management challenges she has faced, overseeing Hillarycare and running a competitive campaign in 2008. She simply has not accomplished anything of note for the country with the positions she was given.
What stands out about her Senate career? Her support for the Iraq war, the Patriot Act? Maybe falsely accusing military leaders of lying when she was sucking up to the progressive wing of the party?
As Sec of State what were her accomplishments? Ignoring Ambassador Stevens requests for security? failing to negotiate a status of forces agreement in Iraq? Maybe calling Assad a reformer? Or was it her support for the Muslim Brotherhood's overthrow of an American ally? Another George Marshall she was.
Because she stood by Bill, she's been given every chance in the world to accomplish something and has done nothing but enrich herself and her friends.
She's one of us.
I don't expect many to actually view this video. This is just some extra info to add to what JW has put in his comment. Just listen to it if you find some extra time to do so.
arly, you know absolutely nothing about NY outside of NYC. It's about as red as it gets.
Yeah its a real battle ground state. In the last four Presidential elections, among Democrats John Kerry performed the worst by receiving 58% of the vote. Everyone else has gotten 60+%.
Its congressional delegation consists of 23 Democrats and 6 Republicans, and 6 Republicans is actually an improvement over what it was. That's as red as it gets?
I provided the link. Read it for yourself, if you're able.
Who's "divisive?"
Reconcilethose two statements and get back to me.
So what's the big deal JoAnne? She was on the Wal-Mart board for 6 years and then she left. Maybe she didn't like the way they were doing business.
And if you didn't know anything about this, it's just one more thing you don't know anything about.
Wikipedia ; (My emphisis)
A native of Illinois, Hillary Rodham was the first student commencement speaker at Wellesley College in 1969. She then earned a J.D. from Yale Law School in 1973. After a brief stint as a Congressional legal counsel, she moved to Arkansas and married Bill Clinton in 1975. Rodham cofounded theArkansas Advocates for Children and Families in 1977. Becoming the first female chair of the Legal Services Corporation in 1978, and the first female partner at Rose Law Firm in 1979, The National Law Journaltwice listed her as one of the hundred most influential lawyers in America. As First Lady of Arkansas from 1979 to 1981 and 1983 to 1992 with husband Bill as Governor, she led a task force that reformed Arkansas's education system . During that time, she was on the board of Wal-Mart and several other corporations .
Got any other "new revelations" about Hillary you would like to enlighten us with JoAnne?
Seriously, that is a pretty asinine comment!
From Wikipedia posted in the above comment ;
Co-founded the Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families in 1977.
The first female chair of the Legal Services Corporation in 1978
The first female partner at Rose Law Firm in 1979
The National Law Journaltwice listed her as one of the hundred most influential lawyers in America.
As First Lady of Arkansas .......,she led a task force that reformed Arkansas's education system.
Why is it that conservatives spend all their time try to attack and tear down the people and policies of theLeft, rather than advocate for, and promote the people and policies of the Right?
Could it bethatthe Right has little or nothing to offer?
Why don't you take a look at the video above Jerry and maybe you'll become a little more enlightened. The Clinton scandals are scandals that keep on giving. I notice very rarely do Progressives respond to facts that are put in front of them, but rather deflect onto other comments. Could it be Progressives can't face the truth and have developed a means of dealing with it this way?
Just progressives? Every human being tends to hedge and deflect that which represents a flaw in character or judgement; but since you decided that it's rare for progressives to respond to facts that are put in front of them (us), I figured, "WTF? Could it be Conservatives can't face the truth any better, and, have developed a means of dealing with it this way?
Get started acknowledging and no deflecting.
Good deflection there A Mac. You should apply for a position in the Obama Hillary Regime.
Your the deflector; I gave you an opportunity to acknowledge a load of facts and all you did was attack the messenger. All you had to do was acknowledge that both sides are scandal-ridden and that both sides have their deniers. But you did exactly what you accused progressives of doing!
As for Hillary, Obama, MLK, JFK, RFK, Jackie Robinson, Native Americans or Jesus of Nazareth, when the good old boy power brokers feel threatened, they demagogue, sabotage, steal ("legally") and murder -- they do everything they can to prevent change that erodes their control.
The "I hope he/she fails" agenda is not new. The racists, misogynists, anti-semites and all haters have hoped it forever -- but not only hoped for failure on the part of the ground-breakers, worked to make it happen regardless of who it hurt!
A Mac I'm sorry you just either don't get it or it is your intention. I put a video up that actually has many of the people involved in Hillary Clinton's life on the video and not one person even acknowledged I had done so.
Not one of the comments you have put up involves Hillary Clinton or anyone who is contemplating running for president in 2016.
You tell me I attacked the messenger when you didn't even address the message I put up. The same thing happened the other day. I had ask, "Give me anything Obama has done to help the economy." You put up an article talking about how the economy had improved since Obama was elected into office.
I even gave you a couple of examples of how George Bush had harmed the economy so you would have a better idea of what I was looking for and as far as I know you still didn't answer the question. In all honesty, I haven't been back there to look at it. After a few times of just receiving deflections to answers, a person realizes that's all they're going to get.
But have no fear. You are the perfect Progressive in that respect and even in the video as well that characteristic is covered. They always deflect from any controversy when the truth hits them in the face.
Don't worry though. It is a common Progressive tactic to do just exactly what you have done. I'm not even going to ask you if you were aware of it. I don't expect to make any headway by doing that either.
So we end this with me putting up a video with a lot of information about Hillary Clinton who may become President of the United States and just wanted someone from her camp to please address some of the things in the video that are pretty disturbing, so I guess I should be happy you at least came back with a bunch of Republican scandals of people who are not in office, have no plans of being elected to anything and have no bearing on the future of this country.
Wow it's a long way back up there to that video. You even have Jimmy Swaggart in that comment. I never said Hillary Clinton hadn't accomplished anything. I just think her morals are pretty low, but of course with the new bar set by Obama I guess she qualifies a lot better now.
I also believe she is much smarter than Obama. There's just no comparison there. She is slicker than a grease pig. But anyway here is the video again if you would like to address the video.
Oh, I get it.
Did you not make a blanket-indictment-generalization about progressives?
Namely,
Both/all political parties are vulnerable to legitimate criticism; that's the issue on which I challenged you and you went right past it to attack me for joining the pissin' contest by posting scandals in kind.
Anyway, on to more important stuff
Like EAGLES/SAINTS game.
See ya' tomorrow.
Hope your team won or is winning.
I just about as soon have her as Chris Christie anyway. I hate suspense and with Chris Christie we'll be wondering when he is going to destroy the country and with Hillary we'll have no doubt it. She will do it as soon as she can. LOL
Ever since Obama has been elected we've made such progress I can't wait to see how well Hillary will do. She did such a great job in Egypt and Libya.
Just look at them today.
Oh by the way.... the first picture is Egypt and the second is Libya Al Qaeda with flags. I'm sure she'll do the same for us. Isn't that nice? Oh heck.... She's already on the way to the White House!
I have two comments to Hillary Clinton serving on the board of Walmart, both equally relevant:
"Who cares?" and "So what?"
Thanks to Sixpick and Egilman for wishing the Eagles a win but alas, once again, it's "wait until next year."
Of course your opinion has nothing to do with the fact that you're a dyed-in-the-wool radical Right Wing extremist!
I would like to see one of those polls Egil. Maybe you can dig a up a link for us?
Reply by JoAnne Odel on Friday
"at this point, what difference does it make"
If Hillary was a Tea Party member who once worked for an anti-union, slave-wage company, they'd be singing her praises!
Her 2016 candidacy is feared.
Aside from which, the haters on the right demagogue every individual who threatens the "white male" establishment. No politician and no other human being lives a "perfect" life; we are all subject to be fairly criticized.
FAIRLY CRITICIZED.
If Hillary is to be castigated for her time with Wal-Mart, that on the basis of her present and more liberal views regarding the workplace, then let her detractors come forward and explain their silence regarding Mitt Romney's expedient and hypocritical "revelations" in 2012.
Well, okay, maybe I was being a little too curt about it. Obviously she was just the token "show female" on the board due to the negative publicity that Wal-Mart had for its policy of not having women in high positions. Being as outnumbered on the board as she was she at least encouraged a few "token" improvements in that policy.