Out of jobs, out of benefits, out of luck
(CNN) -- The old deal made rough sense.
The United States would provide only a very thin social-insurance cushion for people of working age, but jobs would always be available. Critics might deride the jobs as McJobs: often poorly paid, often offering scanty benefits. But better McJobs than No Jobs. To anyone who proposed tighter job protections or more generous social benefits workers came the crushing answer, "Do you want us to be like Europe?"
While American generated tens of millions of low-wage service jobs, the economies of Europe struggled hard not to lose jobs, even during good times. The tradeoff was patiently explained by free-market economists and is by now familiar to us all. More job rules mean less jobs; fewer rules will bring more jobs.
And for a quarter-century, from 1982 until 2007, the old deal held true. Wages didn't rise much, but demand for nurses' aides, fast food servers and other low-wage service workers surged and surged -- so much that for the first time since 1913, the United States again found itself welcoming a mass immigration of poor people, arriving legally and illegally from Guadalajara and Guangzhou, eager to accept America's abundant $9-an-hour jobs.
Then, suddenly, the old deal broke down. It broke down as abruptly, as utterly and as seemingly irretrievably as a previous old deal broke in 1929. Mass and long-term joblessness characterize the U.S. economy of 2014 as surely as plentiful low-wage jobs characterized the U.S. economy of 15 years ago. Look at the output statistics, and the United States has recovered from the crisis of 2008. Look at the job numbers, and it seems the United States never will.
What are Americans to think of and do about their new economic dispensation?
One answer is to deny that the dispensation is new at all.
Republicans in Congress are working to repeal the emergency job benefits put in place in 2009, on the familiar theory that if we quit paying the unemployed, they'll stop being unemployed. Extended unemployment insurance coverage lapsed on Saturday; 1.3 million long-term jobless lost benefits that day, and those still receiving benefits will lose them if they remain without work for longer than 26 weeks.
Food stamp coverage has been cut once and will probably be cut again in 2014. Proposals to raise the minimum wage gain no hearing in the Republican-majority House of Representatives, whose members condemn such proposals as job-killers.
Yet these familiar arguments bump into an unfamiliar situation. Almost six years after the economic collapse of 2008, the ratio of job seekers to unfilled positions -- which peaked at 5.5 to 1 -- has declined to 2.9 to 1, a ratio that would until now have indicated severe recession.
The huge backlog of unemployed workers exerts downward pressure on the wages of those still working. The old employment deal seems a formula for a massive write-off of the great majority of working Americans lacking specialized skills.
On the other hand, nobody seems to offer any credible new deal. Some cities and towns are experimenting with higher minimum wages. That may put money in the pockets of some workers at Wal-Mart and Starbucks. But people who can't find work at $9 won't find it easier to find work if their price is raised to $12.
In a major economic address delivered in Osawatomie, Kansas , in 2011, President Obama speculated that more public-sector hiring might do the trick. But how many people can government employ? And how sustainable is it for government to raise its payroll at exactly the same time as it is also shouldering the rising costs of Medicare and Social Security for retiring baby boomers?
These are questions that will dominate American politics for years to come. As the European experience of the 1990s sadly reminds us, mass prolonged unemployment is not a problem that recedes rapidly in a peacetime economy. People who have been out of work would find it hard to return to work even in a strong job market -- and this job market remains desperately weak.
What we can at least do is refrain from further penalizing people whose problems nobody knows how to fix.
People who can't work still must eat. Americans in distress have a claim on the rest of the nation. Extend unemployment insurance. Sustain food stamps. While we're looking for a new deal, at least quit deluding ourselves that the old deal is still operable. It's not. It has passed on, from everywhere except our increasingly outdated memories.
http://www.cnn.com/2013/12/30/opinion/frum-joblessness-benefits/index.html?hpt=hp_t4
Tags
Who is online
66 visitors

Thoughtful observations that come from a conservative writer.
But to make the claim that Republicans are working to eliminate benefits on this subject is an out and out lie....
It sure looks like they are. The republicans want cuts and the democrats want taxes. I don't know the answers to these problems but kicking millions of people to the curb, literally and figuratively is not going to help the economy or the budget deficit.
Is unemployment insurance an entitlement program ? People pay in to it through payroll deductions, no ? Maybe it's an entitlement when their benefits exceeds their contributions ?
Yes we will see a lot more on disability. It has nearly doubled since Obama took office. Nearly 50 million are on food stamps. There are more people on disability than the population of NYC now. We're paying American's around $200 million not to work. About 16% of people are considered in poverty and 20% of children live in poverty and this has gone up every year since Obama has been in office. In other words this country is walking on crutches. What happened to all those promises. Can't someone look back past today and see what has happened. That "Hope and Change" was just a con.
Six, you gotta remember the state of our economy when Obama took office. It was circling the drain and Obama and his staff were trying everything possible to put out the fires. Maybe some of the decisions were wrong. But if I had to go back to Nov. 2008 and choose again, it sure wouldn't be McCain (and Palin).
Not necessarily. This is an cerebral paradox: does ideology trump "common sense?"
Pat
Actually the Republican leadership has said that they will renew the extended UE benefits so long as it is paid for with spending reduction in other areas of the budget. The challenge is that the Democrats and the Republicans are not in agreement on what spending to cut to offset this expense.
I agree with Egilman that to say the Republicans are working to eliminate the benefits is at best an erroneous exaggeration at worst a blatant lie.
Thanks to Eric Allie Townhall Cartoons for the graphic
Barb
Happy New Year
It is a minor point, but there are a coupe more folks that make up "Republicans" than just Rand Paul and many of them including the leadership have said they will support the renewal of the extended UE benefits if agreement can be reached on spending cuts to offset the cost.
I keep hearing about all the foodstamp fundsters in republican states. I don't think any of the tea party republicans were elected to expand the welfare state. The people elected them to cut spending not increase it. You will be surprised how many will find a way to feed themselves once the checks stop coming. If need be they can eat poke salad and muskrat. Man found a way to feed himself for hundreds of thousands of years prior to the foodstamp.
pat.... Obama had total control of both houses and the presidency for the first 6 months of taking office and for all practical purposes had almost absolute control of both houses and the presidency for two years.
What did he do to help the economy? Let me answer that for you. Nothing.
It was all about Obamacare which I can tell you is not going to help the economy one bit. I know someone my age paying $5,000 a month more money isn't going to help them economically. I know someone like me increasing my income by $11k and only being able to put less than $2k of it in my pocket isn't going to motivate me to increase my income.
Face the reality. Obama has done nothing the entire time he has been in office to help the economy. In fact he has done everything in his power to harm the economy. He has spent almost the entire time campaigning while every moment was spent on trying to figure ways to help the economy. Sure.
You see Pat, he isn't thinking about Americans. He wants to legalize all the illegal immigrants which will take more jobs from Americans so he can get their votes. That's the only concern he has. He is not concerned with the economy of the United States. He's concerned with the one party control so he can do things to us you just aren't able to imagine at this time. Can't you see where we are headed?
In a few years there will be drones all over the skies. You won't be able to go camping without their knowledge of where you are and who you are. All you phone communications, computer activity and everything about you will be under the eyes of big brother.
Maybe you don't, but I remember Russia being the country that had this sort of society and people were trying to escape it when I was growing up. Why don't you just look at what Obama has said, promised and has actually done?
He's the biggest con artist in that office in my life time. You may not like what I have to say, but there are some who know and many who don't, but all will come to know in the future and when they do see reality, they will not like it.
I can tell you if I had two years off from work it would be like pulling a rusty nail out of concrete to get me back to work. I had two months off after an operation and was beginning to like it. Try smoking cigarettes for two years and quitting cold turkey on the first day of year three. It is a fact that most people find jobs right before their unemployment runs out, but with the Obama economy with over half the new jobs created in 2013 being part time jobs I can understand how it may be more difficult to find a job. With the lack of confidence in this president most companies are trying to wait him out of office and hoping he doesn't do irreparable damage during the meantime.
Stop Robert !!!
Happy New Year !
pat.... Obama had total control of both houses and the presidency for the first 6 months of taking office and for all practical purposes had almost absolute control of both houses and the presidency for two years.
C'mon now, did you forget about the "filibuster" ? Now define "control" for me.
Did you miss the fact that the author of this article is a conservative republican ? This was the whole point of my article. The oddness of that. Egilman was offended. He should take it to Frum, not me.
Happy New Year to you and all NT'rs
They had the 60 votes until Kennedy died. They also had two independents that always voted Democrat. That's why they didn't send Obamacare back to the House because they lost the filibuster when Kennedy died and Scott Brown won.
Still..... what has he done? Don't want to sound mean to you Pat. You seem like a very nice person. But it has been 5 years since Obama was first elected and until we don't have to depend on these crutches which have grown by leaps and bounds in the last 5 years. I won't list them. Hope you have a Happy New Year Pat and many more to come.
Pat
Just amplification to your point that "it isn't Obama's fault"
Happy New Year to you as well
Pat
Wasn't a problem with the PPACA was it???
Hypocrite and Tea Party mouthpiece Ran Paul in a recent interview asked, "Why should we borrow money from China to pay unemployment benefits to Americans?"
Paul never asked, "Why are we borrowing money from China to pay for George W. Bush's bullshit Iraq war and to give tax breaks to the wealthiest Americans?
When a Republican cries "less government," he doesn't mean "less government" for himself -- he means for all but the criminal rich.
Sorry A Mac, but the Iraq War didn't cost $6T plus and the tax breaks have been for almost all those who paid Federal taxes. Just tell me what has Obama done to improve the economy? He has had 5 years to make things at least a little better. I don't think I have to go over all the crutches this country is using just to stay afloat again, I hope.
Give them something to do to earn the money. We do need things done in this country. At least FDR did put people to work instead of just sending them a check for listening to the radio.
As I said, most companies are trying to wait Obama out of office because of their lack of confidence in him and his policies which are constantly attacking them and hoping he doesn't do irreparable damage during the meantime.
There is no confidence in Obama and for good reason. All he has done is campaign doing his best to give as much candy out as he can in order to obtain a one party rule.
He doesn't give a crap about the economy. He says he does but stop listening to him and watch his actions then you will understand.
Egilman,
Not sure which "messenger" you refer to.
Can you clarify your comment?
Right! It only cost a Trillion or so and over 100,000 lives and the middle class tax payer made up the revenue shortfall.
Check your 401k. Check the jobs numbers (despite all of the Republican efforts to keep the numbers down).
Rand Paul and every politician (both sides) that displays selective indignation is a hypocrite!
Happy New Year to you as well my friend!
"Long term unemployed are being hired at a much lower rate than other jobless." Thanks to Johnson and his creation of a societydependent on government some have been unemployed for four generations.
I moved from the Detroit area where people expect things to be given to them to Vail, Co where people are expected to work for the things they need. People come from all over the world to work here. Many come from South America and some from as far as Australia. I prefer the mountains over the beach.
That's the injury-to-injury factor; employers place a stigma upon the long-term unemployed and, additionally, hire younger so-called "more qualified" instead.
BUT LET US NOT PRETEND THAT THE SAME CORPORATE WHORES IN HANDOUT WELFARE/BAILOUT/PAY NO OR LITTLE TAX MODE -- THOSE PIECES OF SHIT WHO OWN THE LEGISLATORS
EXPORT GOOD AMERICAN JOBS TO CHEAP LABOR MARKETS!
And companies like Wal-Mart that pay below poverty wages, force employees onto food stamps which means they are indirectly subsidized by tax dollars!
Lyndon Johnson has nothing to do with the current, residual fucking that Wall Street and the Bush (look-the-other-way) regulators caused (as they currently continue to get bonuses).
WTF is it with the Tea-Party/Republican BLAME-THE-VICTIM bullshit? Is it because the panderers-to-the-bigot mob in this country have convinced ignorant whites that it's the ONLY THE BLACKS who are on welfare?
Happy New Year, one in which I will pull no punches or, at some point, ignore the "fuck-everyone-else-I-got-mine" alleged "people".
Maybe you missed some of the realities.
How Michigans Emergency Manager Law Guarantees Corruption
Corporate Influence in Politics
by Ed Brayton
Speculative; besides, money that is extended as food stamps or unemployment compensation goes directly into the economy and helps an economy that is 79% consumer driven.
That creates profits>jobs>more tax revenue>less need for unemployment compensation.
Until the greedy corporate pigs and their Republican pimps create rather than export jobs and, stop paying below poverty wages causing the legal right of THE WORKING POOR to be food-stamp eligible, the blame-the-victim and demagogue-by-demographic bullshit campaign will go on.
Proud detractor of
There is truth to what you say. For over a decade now, the Democrats have been talking (not doing anything) about immigration reform. On the other hand, the people most objecting to this are your god fearing, gun hugging, Jesus loving, flag waiving TRUE Americans.
The fact is, there are most likely 20 million Mexican illegals here. Rapid or eventual roads to citizenship, which would include amnesty, is the only logical and cost effective ways to go.
While the Democrats haven't been eager to make this an issue, the corporations could benefit by gaining more legal customers and more tax collected but the Republican base is xenophobic. That would mean a large wave of new voters for the Democrats.....and I don't blame them seeing that the Republicans have been overtly hostile to Hispanics.
Yet illegals keep coming.
As long as they can find work here, they'll continue to come. I'd like to see an American tourist boycott of (i.e.) Mexico with the caveat to Mexican entrepreneurs who pay slave wages, thus encouraging the impoverished to come here.
And Mexicans are not the only illegals who come here for work and send their wages back to family in their homeland.
And let's be clear; Republican hypocrite legislators publicly decry illegal immigration while subsidizing their biggest employers (Agri-Corporations) through the Farm Bill -- THAT WHILE CUTTING FOOD STAMP SUBSIDIES TO AMERICA'S WORKING POOR, OUT OF THE FARM BILL.
Hypocritical pigs!
Because while he deports illegals, he's the only hope for creating some sort of Immigration Reform.
Think of it as trying to walk a fine line and hoping to create some common sense laws based on wait for it
REALITY!
Even for liberals, ideology can and often does trump common sense...
True enough
Ahhhhh - going back to the "good old days"??? In 1975, I was laid off from an iron foundry and was ONLY allowed to receive unemployment benefits for 13 weeks - max. I could not apply for food stamps until the 13th week. I had to show the employment office records/documentation that I had applied for at least 10 jobs per week to continue drawing unemployment. AND, I had to show up at the employment office for counseling each week.
Today??? 2.5 years of unemployment benefits - and people are bitching it's not long enough. They don't have to verify they are looking for employment. They don't have to go to counseling each week. They can apply for welfare/food-stamps immediately. Hell, we've got over 30% of the workforce who has quit looking for work because they are making as much or more being unemployed than when whey were working.
System is broke and we have turned into a welfare country - and people still bitch that they aren't getting enough from the government??? Gimme a break.
Give them something to do to earn the money.
I agree and some programs that do that already exist. I also think prisoners should be productive on some level.
1stwarrior..... Don't forget free Obamacare as well which really is Medicaid for them. Of course I wouldn't expect them to have the money without a job and still be able to pay the premiums.
But for anyone and I mean anyone to try to say Obama has done anything and I mean anything to help this country is a complete denial of reality.
He is using the Cloward-Piven strategy perfectly when in NYC for every two working individuals there was one on the entitlement roster during the 1970's due to the Cloward-Piven strategy from Columbia University which had increased the entitlements 10 fold and if it hadn't been for a $2.3 billion dollar bailout President Ford finally agreed upon they would have gone bankrupt.
It was a Democrat mayor during the financial disaster and a Democrat mayor after him. It's true evidently there aren't enough real jobs out there when over half the jobs created in 2013 were part time.
Let me tell you what really gets you. These people who are working two jobs to make ends meet are receiving less than 20% of the money from the 2nd job because of Obamacare. I've put these examples up before. Anyone interested in this information look HERE and HERE . This example was a 63 old in California.
If $35k won't do it for you and you take on another job and make another $11k on the second job with Obamacare, Federal Taxes and State Taxes, a person 63 will put less than $2k of that $11k in their pockets. That's $8k you end up paying with the extra premium you will pay in premiums for your Obamacare healthcare, plus the taxes you'll have to pay on that extra $11k. That's really motivating, isn't it? NO.
But this is the way to destroy the middle class which even with all the smiles and lies is the objective of this president. Of course it is a waste of time evidently to even bring it up, since the American people who are receiving everything for free are completely content with it, not realizing they will have the company of the middle class in the not to distant future. Then there will be the chosen elites and the rest of us.
That's when it will finally dawn on them what has happened, but it will be way too late and not just the middle class will suffer, but the whole country will never be the same as Obama said about Egypt when he, Hillary and the CIA put the Muslim Brotherhood in place over there.
Don't think it can't happen here.
I agree, however, since we're discussing loss of unemployment benefits, singled out Rand Paul for his selectively indignant comment regarding that subject.
Any way, dennis, a Happy, Healthy and Prosperous New Year to you.
Not all asses possess magic; some are just full of
you know.
Sorry A Mac but the question was....
Let me say Obama didn't end the Iraqi war. The ending of that war was already agreed upon before Obama was even elected by Bush and the the Iraqis. Although Obama took credit for ending it and before he was elected it was the first thing he was going to do, he didn't do anything but wait until the agreed time arrived to end it then led the public to believe he got those boys out of Iraq. That's like the water boy claiming to have won the ball game because he made sure all the ball players had water to drink.
I didn't care for Bush, but Bush, even McCain who I didn't care for tried over 20 times to get the housing market to regulate itself, but the likes of Barney Franks, who was over it, Maxine Waters and other Democrats would not allow it to happen, even going as far as saying they were being racist for even suggesting such a thing. ACORN, Obama's brown shirts, protested in front of the banks President's homes if they didn't want to go along with the processing of loans the banks knew would never be paid back. Frank Raines and many others with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae made millions for processing these bad loans. So in saying this when the House was taken over in 2007 by the Democrats and Senate was taken over by the Democrats in 2008, Nancy spent more money than any other House Speaker in the history of this country. I mean more than all of them put together.
I know the 401ks went down to 50% or less as the housing bubble burst and has since regained what it lost and then some. Obama didn't have anything to do with it though, unless you can tell me something I don't know.
So with the housing bubble being the initial reason for the whole fiasco we lost 9 million jobs rounded out and we're still down 3 million. Don't get me wrong. Obama hasn't inherited a gold mine. Bush was a piece of crap in my opinion and spent like a drunken sailor as well, but what has Obama done to help the economy.
The oil is being produced from private land under agreements made under Bush not Obama. Public production of oil is not the reason for the increase of oil production. That's one thing he could have done to help the economy but he hasn't as far as I know. In fact it appears he has gone the exact opposite direction on that.
As far as the increase in jobs under Obama the biggest loss of jobs were during the first few months. The article says 13 months which makes it sound like the bottom was falling out for 13 months, but it was only the first few months into Obama's 1st term when most of the job losses occurred. Of course Obama was campaigning that entire time and had nothing to do with those jobs coming back. It's hard to stop a train and it's just as hard to start it back up once it has stopped. So I don't blame Obama for not whipping us back into high gear. But what has Obama done to help the economy? We're still at least 3 million jobs down from when the Democrats took over Congress. We were spending like drunken sailors until the 2010 election helped slow it down.
What a misleading statement that is. The only thing that is on the level about that whole piece is neither president was worth a crap. Any ideas why there were so many jobs created during Clinton's administration. I have two reasons I can think of.....
As far as Federal spending has grown let's just say all spending is relative to the circumstances. If the economy is good then generally the Federal Spending will be higher but not necessarily. Of course Bush's Federal spending was high. He had us over there in Iraq. And as you said that was $1T of it. We were winding down per agreement that Bush and the Iraqis made before Obama was even elected. So figures can be misleading. The the author forgot to put that information in his article.
This country is being held up by numerous crutches. Need I say more?
We've nearly doubled the Federal debt under Obama and will have by the time he leaves office. And that isn't something to brag about, but if Obama had kept his promise to go line by line and cut spending as he said then maybe he couldn't take credit for that.
Wind and solar power produces 4% of the nation's power. It doesn't take a mathematician to figure a 157% increase as being nearly insignificant and what has the cost of that been? I can give you a list, a big list of companies that received lots of money that no longer exist if you like. But investigations indicate Obama's campaign supporters received the money and made off with it.
Now to end this.
Bush sucked. Obama sucks. Bush had to deal with the housing bubble but didn't have the balls to make it happen to stop this catastrophe before it blew up even with a Republican Congress most of the time.
Obama has pushed, even advertising on TV and radio to put as many people on entitlements as possible. He has over regulated companies so much many have just gone out of business. His first jobs czar was shipping jobs overseas faster than a lightning bolt. He has lied just about every time he opens his mouth. Look back at what he has said and then look at what he has done. That's all it takes to see this. He will say anything to promote his ability to gain one party control in the United States. He disregards the Constitution and has gone against the laws of this country way too many times. Now..... the Republicans are no better. When they should be jumping up and down about it they just go along with it. And some of the policies they even initiate themselves. It's the government against us. Presidents come and go. I wish the same applied to Congressman and Congresswomen but unfortunately once in for a couple of terms it seems nearly impossible to rid ourselves of the ones who are doing us in. Take Harry Reid for example. Just during his last election he was down by 3 points a couple of weeks before the election, but won by about 6 points. Now that is a nice little example. You think everything was on the level there? Maybe the Unions who operated Las Vegas voting machines in 2010 made the difference. What do you think? Anyway I think Harry Reid is one of the most corrupt politicians in Washington. Of course there are many Republicans as well. I say the lot of them need to go, but they have such a strong foot hold I doubt they are going to turn loose. It is going to have to start at the bottom up.
I don't want to put people in low income jobs Pat, but I know keeping busy is the best cure for being out of work as you've shown by producing the above link. I was out of work for two months due to an operation. The recovery period wasn't pleasant until the last couple of weeks but if it had been let me tell you, I was beginning to like it for those two weeks. LOL
I can't imagine being out of work, not having to look for work for 2 years and then jumping back into the work force. Can you imagine pulling an old rusty nail out of a concrete floor?
I understood the question did you simply reject the answer because you didn't think anyone could provide one?
No offense A Mac, but you didn't answer the question.
Obama didn't do anything to make the economy better as far as I can understand. Just tell me what he has done in your opinion to improve the economy, that's all I'm asking. I really don't have much time now and should have never responded to your comment until later tonight, but I can tell you a couple of things Bush did to hurt the economy. First was getting us in that Iraqi War which cost us a bunch of money and then not having the balls to overcome the liberals who fought to give everyone a home whether they could pay for it or not.
Do you know of anything Obama has done to either help the economy or hurt the economy?
Got to go. My obligations are calling me. By the way. I really hope you had a nice Christmas and a Happy Day yesterday. And I hope this country comes around and finds itself in a much more prosperous position for all in the coming years. later. six
Interesting...you learn something new everyday.
No generalization in that statement.
While the bigoted, zeal-without-knowledge "grownup" is instructed by Rush Limbaugh.
Or we deal with reality rather than stereotypes
Red States Feed at Federal Trough, Blue States Supply the Feed
Learn the significance of the term "WORKING POOR" you not-so-learned whatever you are.
Make cogent comments and get the fuck off the cheap shots.
I'm more than tired of your crap.
I tried to save you the embarrassment of being associated with the Romneyism.
63 weeks - one year and three months - not much of an incentive to get people looking for work, eh?