╌>

MY OPINION: Federal Judge's Ruling WILL BE APPEALED AND OVERTURNED

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  13 years ago  •  14 comments

MY OPINION: Federal Judge's Ruling WILL BE APPEALED AND OVERTURNED

United States District CourtJudge Brian Cogan ruled that the Affordable Care Act cannot force religious nonprofit organizations to pay for birth control for their employees.However, the judge didnt stop there.

Cogan went on to completely blastObamacares contraception mandate and the Presidents unconstitutional way of enforcing it with these three very compelling points:

I expect an appeal on that ruling and base my expectation on the following question:

WHAT IF AN APPELLATE CONTENTION IS "Women who are taking i.e.

Gonadotropin-releasing hormone (Gn-RH) agonists and antagonists. These drugs block the production of ovarian-stimulating hormones, lowering estrogen levels and preventing menstruation. This causes endometrial tissue to shrink. Gn-RH agonists and antagonists can force endometriosis into remission during the time of treatment and sometimes for months or years afterward. Because these drugs create an artificial menopause, taking a low dose of estrogen or progestin along with Gn-RH agonists and antagonists may decrease menopausal side effects, such as hot flashes, vaginal dryness and bone loss. Your periods and the ability to get pregnant return when the medication is stopped.

ARE NOT USING THEM AS "BIRTH CONTROL" MEDICATIONS RATHER, AS CANCER-INHIBITORS.

"BIRTH CONTROL" IN THOSE INSTANCES ARE TANTAMOUNT TO "SIDE EFFECTS" AND CONSEQUENTLY, EMPLOYERS WHO DECIDE ON RELIGIOUS (et al personal) GROUNDS TO DENY COVERAGE FOR SUCH MEDICATIONS, THUS ARBITRARILY DETERMINE A WOMAN'S "INTENT" AND DENY ACCESS TO A CANCER-INHIBITING MEDICATION ON SPECULATION -- ON A RELIGIOUSLY AND PERSONALLY-MOTIVATED ASCRIBED INTENT.

Addressing the question, what then?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The rhetoric on this abounds.

Just address the question I posed as if you are either representing a plaintiff or a defendant and ONLY ADDRESSING THE BASIS OF THE APPEAL AS I WORDED IT.

I would very much like a woman's opinion (as well as opinions of all members).

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago
1. Why do you beleive the department of justice failed to pursue this line of argument?2. Are birth comtrol pills fda approved for use to fight cancer and are they prescribed to patients solely as a cancer inhibiting agent?
 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

i agree, the constitution is just a document written by a bunch of old white guys.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

1. Why do you beleive the department of justice failed to pursue this line of argument?

I can't say, Sean; but I believe it will be raised in the appeal process.

2. Are birth comtrol pills fda approved for use to fight cancer and are they prescribed to patients solely as a cancer inhibiting agent?

"Birth Control Pill" is not a medical term, it's a generic categorization of medications that regulate female hormones. Some are over-the-counter, some are by prescription.

IRONICALLY, as misplaced endometrial tissue grows, it can cover or grow into the ovaries and block the fallopian tubes. This can make it hard for women with endometriosis to get pregnant. Thus, "birth control" can be the very opposite effect and intent of taking such medications.

Endometriosis is a condition that causes tissue resembling the tissue found in a woman's uterine lining to grow outside the uterus. It can cause pelvic pain, infertility and very heavy periods. The growths can also cause problems in surrounding organs like the intestines and bladder.

While there is no cure for endometriosis, there are many treatments for the pain and infertility it causes.

Physicians can recommend over-the-counter or prescription drugs as a first step in treatment. (Judge Brian Cogan's decision, issued on Dec. 13 but made available electronically on Monday, said the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services could not implement the regulations, which require the Catholic religious groups and their health plans to provide insurance coverage to employees and their covered dependents for Food and Drug Administration-approved contraceptive methods, sterilization procedures, and patient education and counseling, because they violate the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act).

  • Hormone treatment. Pills, shots or nasal sprays may be a good option for women who have small growths without severe pain and do not want to become pregnant.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

i agree, the constitution is just a document written by a bunch of old white guys.

"Just" a document; does that minimize parts like the 2nd Amendment to "just"?

Beyond that, I'd appreciate a woman's perspective on the issue as I've presented it.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago
Upon reflection it apears that the simple answer is that a drug prescribed to treat endometriosis would not be birth control or contraception and thus not a problem. Insurers approve the use of certain drugs in some situations and not others all the time. I don't think this presents a particularly challenging dilemma. If the drug is being prescribed and is approved for use to combat a specific illness, it would be approved under the catholic plans. . It simply depends why the drug is being prescribed.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

You may be correct, Gunny.

Time will tell.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It simply depends why the drug is being prescribed.

And Sean, that may be the very argument that settles the appeal; a compromise.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

good afternoon Amac sir.

imo the contraception issue is moot, as every woman has access to cheap contraception. the entire issue is exploited.

i can honestly say i dont care for my husband having to subsidize birth control fora woman he does not know, who can for the most parteasily afford it herself. of course, if she cannot afford birth control, could simply acheive the same thing by holding a dime between her knees.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

imo the contraception issue is moot, as every woman has access to cheap contraception. the entire issue is exploited.

Irrelevant; if the law says the woman's insurer must cover medications, in effect, it's her option as to whether or not she accesses the "cheap" or the prescription version.

i can honestly say i dont care for my husband having to subsidize birth control fora woman he does not know

Every taxpayer subsidizes people he/she does not know, and every taxpayer is as well, so subsidized. Your house (HOPEFULLY) will never be on fire, but your taxes have, just in case, established and sustained your local fire department -- also FEMA, also the military, police

________________________________

Enjoy your weekend my friend.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

So, if an employer learns that one of his female employees is using a prescribed 800 MG Ibuprofin tablet between her knees, that as a means of birth control, does the employer then have a legal argument that his employee is acting contrary to his (the employer's) religious beliefs and that he can somehow modify her benefit?

Next example.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I once was taking Depo-Provera which is birth control shots you take roughly one every two months. What it does is prevent ovulation. One side effect was weight gain, which is why I went off.

However, another side effect doctors discovered was good. There are some women suffer from Dysmenorrheaor menstrual cramps. Very painful. Since Depo prevents ovulation, there is no monthly discharge hence no painful cramps. Doctors now have started to prescribe Depo as a way to prevent this pain.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    13 years ago

What an amazing and seriously crazy society... pharmaceutical companies, doctors, conservative groups, churches, and now lawyers and judges--- everybody wants a piece control of the vagina. We'll be lucky if somebody doesn't suggest that nookie should be 'prescription only'...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Because "birth control pill," etc. is a generic ascription, and, "contraception" is as well, since many of these so-called "contraceptive" medications ARE NOT PRESCRIBED FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONTRACEPTION, RATHER AS TREATMENT FOR A CONDITION KNOWN AS ENDOMETRIOSIS, the employer, it can be argued, is making a judgement based on a medication side-effect and thus completely discounts its primary (and often its ONLY) use by women.

If the employer is asked during the appeal process:

"Which of your religious beliefs are violated when you (through employee benefits you provide) are asked to pay for a medication prescribed for the purpose of treating a condition resulting from the appearance of endometrial tissue outside the uterus and causing pelvic pain?"

What's his answer?

Asked another way; "Can an employer justifiably/Constitutionally deny employees benefit coverage regarding medications that MAY be used for 'contraceptive' purposes but which are prescribed specifically for non-contraceptive, verifiable purposes?

Can said employer, by inference alone, decide how medications so prescribed, will be used, and base his alleged claim of "violation of his right to 'religious freedom' on such an inference?

 
 

Who is online





89 visitors