Duck Dynasty, Freedom of Speech, Culture Wars, or Contract Law?
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
The US Constitution
Our freedom of speech is protected by our government from our government. The reason that we can express our views, no matter how offensive in public, is because this was the very act that wasn't allowed during our colonial period. As time has progressed, we have tried to define this more and more by law, but from a Constitutional standpoint, your freedom of speech is protected from our government in public: to wit: The Westboro Baptist Church. They are free to be offensive and protest our dead service men, while they are on public property. They are not allowed to protest on private property. Private property by virtue of it being private, lets the owners define their rules for what they will and will not accept as speech, which also includes freedom from our government infringing on that choice... but I digress.
In our recent rash of celebrities that have offended one group or another, is a test of our Constitution. Only in offense, is the clarity that they have the right to do so. Whether it's Rodger Waters on Israel, or Phil Robertson, a star on A&E's "Duck Dynasty," talking about his beliefs about gays and the bible, these men had the right to say what they said. And in response, people are allowed to counter those remarks if they find them offensive. All of this is guaranteed in our Constitution.
But what is NOT guaranteed, is how business connections will respond to your remarks and or actions. That is because you are bound by the terms of employment and may be contract to certain limitations. This applies to everyone, but becomes more pronounced when you are a figure in the public eye. An example of this is TLC and their reality show "All American Muslim". TLC didn't take kindly to the fight that broke out during a football game where some Muslim boys featured on the show picked a fight with a Lutheran school, so they cancelled the show. But since the show was not nearly as popular as "Duck Dynasty", it went almost unnoticed.
In the case of "Duck Dynasty", the comments were made to GQ, a very popular and well read magazine. And while Phil Robertson was free to express his religious views, those that oppose those views are also allowed to voice their opinions. But to A&E, the issue isn't religious rights versus gay rights, but what is in Phil Robertson's contract and how it affects their bottom line. This whole affair isn't about whose rights trumps who's, but it's about contract law and bottom line. That is why Phil Robertson has been put on suspension, and the show wasn't cancelled. A&E is meeting with their lawyers to discuss their best possible option, before they make a decision.
In our current culture wars, often issues that have nothing to do with our culture are made into a media feast. Phil Robertson's religious beliefs verse gays rights is a made up argument to forward people's agendas. It is emotionally charged topic for many and therefore so easy to manipulate. But in reality, this is about the terms of a contract. The real issue is nothing more than a man forgetting that being in the public eye has its downside when dealing with the contract that put him in the public eye in the first place. Culture wars be damned. This is a legal issue. People should stop being easily manipulated by our media and break away from the flock. If "Duck Dynasty" should teach anyone, anything, it's that if you follow the call, you might end up as dinner.
Tags
Who is online
89 visitors

A&E needs to realize that when you put trash on TV, that trash is going to behave like... Trash.
The man has a right to spew any hatred he wishes, but A&E must realize that in association, they are going to be painted with the same brush. So, A&E, DO something. i.e. Quit putting trash on TV.
A&E has gone down the road, (like many formerly more intellectually stimulating channels), of appealing to the lowest common denominator. You make thedecision, you reap theawards. If that means less viewership, maybe they shouldn't have tried to appeal to the lowest common denominator.
And yeah, that sounds like elitist BS, but it's also true.
I do NOT want to even hear about that Kentucky Wildman who has no teeth and, even if he is doing good for the community and nature, appears to be absolutely bat shit crazy. Nor do I want to hear about Guntucky. We have a bunch of morons in this state, and somehow, they all make it to TV in one way or another. It almost seems as if the TV networks are bound and determined to pick out the worst of us and put them on display on TV.
SIGH!
You are correct Perrie. Most everyonein theeyeof the public, many executives, senior managers of all types of business have a contract. Most have in that contract, actions that are not acceptable, and can result in termination if they are violated. These do not have to be work place incidents. They can be outside the work place, and on your own time.
I agree that A&E is discussing this with their lawyers.
Dowser,
I do feel sorry for you and your state. It does get some of the worst publicity I have ever seen. But TV thrives on the their self made circus and freaks are part of any circus. Par for the course.
Even regular folks have to keep in mind, that what they put out there, especially on the internet, can be used against you on the job and at school. There is no privacy to be expected.
Yup. They are making some big bucks in overtime billing. At least someone is the winner here.
Dowser, I have no idea how crazy, ''bat shit crazy'' is. But I suspect that it's at the upper end of the ''Crazy'' scale.
I disagree, John. He could have gone on reading his bible on the show, and no one would have known what was going on in his head. I think that GQ could feel this story happening, and I bet there were some leading questions that could get the old guy talking... and they would have all this free hoopla that they wanted in the first place... but on the back of Pat.
But there you have it. He spoke his piece and how it plays out, will probably be that the show will continue, just without him.
The whole GQ thing is getting A and E some good publicity. No conspiracy, just a guy with a big mouth not knowing how to behave in public and not believing that he will be held to his contract. Did he figure he could get by with it cause he's a "star" or was he just stupid? I don't really need an answer to that, I was just wondering. Also, do any of us think that A and E was worried that their HUGE gay viewership would run away from Duck Dynasty screaming and clutching their pearls? Probably not.
Why would I watch a show about stupid people? They're everywhere, they're everywhere. Eeeeeeeeeek and yikes !!!!
Yeah, its contract based. If I had a company and one of my employees was embarrassing the company, contract or no, I'd can him.
Ha ha ha, Dowser. I can't wait until they get hold of New Mexico. We really are a third world country.
Yep. Everyone forgets the Kentucky Derby which is when most normal people come out of the woodwork to see the horses. EGAD, we may have large and ridiculous hats, but it's all in good fun!
Yes, it is. Bat shit crazy is just what this guy is. He is a naturalist and he does good work, saving the lives of all kinds of wildlife, but GEEmonetti, he acts like a loony tunes. I'm sure at least some of that is for the cameras. I hope, anyway.
Most of the DNR people I know are nice, normal, people, who do their job the best they can.
I don't know, dear Grumpy Cat. I think that all of the TV networks are bound and determined to portray us as toothless wonders in overalls and no shirts. Drinking white lightnin' and shooting anything that moves. ICK!
Much of that telly show Cops was filmed here in Albuquerque. I was ashamed to even watch it. Good Lord.
What a putrid argument this is. Consider this,Comment removed for "skirting the CoC and inflammatory""MiG" - your doctrine not only claims homosexuality to be a sin, but it also says divorce is a sin. Fortunately for you, the Bible also says that divorce can be permissible, but clearly that is only in extreme situations. Therefore, the 'acceptable rate' of divorce should be expected to be, oh let's say somewhere between 0.1%, to something like 10% (on the extremely generous side.) Now consider that the actual divorce rate in the US continually hovers AROUND 50%! Now let's think about how much attention gets directed to this OBVIOUS FLOUTING OF BIBLICAL LAW, and the issue of homosexuality. Get the fucking picture yet, Comment removed for "skirting the CoC and inflammatory""MiG"
Oh Grump,
I loved "In Plain Sight" and that was inAlbuquerque. Mary is my hero!
It really is just that simple.
An interesting take BF. I didn't know this:
Which goes to show that we think it's reality TV, but it's really an illusion, like many things on TV. From my POV both Phil and the gays have the right to their comments. The only difference is that Pat had contractual obligations....
This is empty rhetoric .
It does ?
Seems to me there's something in there about stoning adulterers to death, which ought to put a large percentage of the population (including 'Christians') at high risk. Let's not forget 'thou shalt not suffer a witch to live', keeping all the Wiccans pretty nervous, y'think?
The good news is that the majority of Christians have the ability to quietly ignore and/or gloss over the most overtly crazy parts of the Bible... and of those who adhere to the most whacked-out elements, the majority don't have balls enough to act on them.
"God, deliver me from those who claim to follow you..."
I loved Mary, too!!! A strong, good woman.
Excellent, Bf!!
God obviously has a high tolerance for all kinds of crazy animals... only possible explanation for why there hasn't been another flood--yet.
Who's morals are correct? I figure the morals of the guy paying the bills is correct.
On Anderson Cooper tonight, a guest said he was not going to be part of filming for the show until next March. So neither he nor A&E are losing a thing with the "suspension." They're playing a waiting game and hoping the ado will be over before he's due to be on the show again.
I doubt it will work. Advocates for any group have long memories.
Hey, I'm a California Wild Woman who can act bat shit crazy....err...eccentric...maybe I can get a show of my own. I can be as offensive as anyone else.
Bruce,
This is about two different groups of people, deep in their own beliefs, speaking out. I feel that Phil has the right to believe what ever it is that he feels his faith is telling him. He feels that he feels homosexuality is a sin... fine. But when he, a public figure makes a comment like this:
Start with homosexual behavior and just morph out from there,Bestiality, sleeping around with this woman and that woman and that woman and those men.
Well he had to understand that he might be insulting some folks out there. And of course he did and then they had their turn at freedom of speech.
Since he is in the public eye, GLAAD would make a very public statement in return. GLAAD's statements are no more about their beliefs (not true, ture or otherwise about what Christianity is about) then that of Phil's. The only thing that I find amusing is that GLAAD is speaking for a whole lot of people, which to me, is just yadda, yadda, yadda. The Christian community can't be defined by GLAAD and I venture to say that no two denominations of Christians would have the same view on homosexuality.
Now that all being said, each had their say. Each had their shot at freedom of speech. As for morality, both Phil and GLAAD can say what ever they think, but that won't change people's minds who have different beliefs and morals even if they think they can set that in stone for others. And for that matter, it swings the other way, too.
As for correct morals... that is always in the eyes of the beholder. Earlier this week, we had a huge discussion about Rodger Waters' comments condemning Israel. Each side thought they had the moral high ground. The truth is, how we live our lives are our morals... and these things can't be judged. Not by Phil and not by GLAAD and not by Rodger or the ADL.
The only thing that does count is if the Constitution has been infringed upon and as far as I can see, the answer would be no. Back to the lawyers.
It's doubtful he's an employee of A&E. It's more likely he's an independent contractor or, if another company (perhaps one owned by the family) produces the show, he may be an employee of theirs.
Tax-wise, everyone would be better off if he is his own business entity or the entire family is a separate business entity. Since there were plenty of attorneys involved in drawing up the contracts, I doubt that was overlooked.
The Bible is a form of "law"-- religious law. Like civil law, in actual practice its not so much what the words say-- but rather how people interpret them.
For example, in the Constitution, "the right to bear arms"..."no restrictions on free speech"..etc. Many people will say "Oh, its obvious what those mean". But the "obvious meaning" is different for different people. How the "law" is interpreted is key.
Our Founding Fathers, in their wisdom (that's not sarcasm. I do believe an exceptional group came together at the same point in time) were wise enough to realize provision must be made for interpreting the law-- so they made provisions for a Supreme Ct.
The Catholic Church also has a "supreme judge" of what Catholic teachings mean (the Pope)- he is the authority as to the interpretations.
Many other religions don't have a single authority -- many Protestant denominations, Muslims, Jews, Hindus, etc. (In most (all?) Protestant denominations, if you don't like your minister's interpretations, you can just go to the church down the road).
I don't mean to imply that any particular system is "better" or "worse"-- but rather to point out that interpretation is very important!
This reminds me of the Chic-fil-A comment from Dan Cofey who said he believed in marriage between a man and a woman and the LGBT etc which spurred the highest profit day in the history of the company. I remember riding around that day and the parking lots were overfilled with customers. I guess the LGBT can be a positive force and an negative force. I think it will be a negative force this time around.
This was a well thought out process to make this happen by CQ. Look at Cyrus. She's in the spotlight and a real role model for the progressives.
I've never seen the show and probably will never see it. I just have more important things to deal with and this show like many of the reality shows just don't do it for me.
This is a business decision by A&E and nothing more in a perverted world.
Please don't expect me to celebrate your gay/lesbian lifestyle. You don't need me. I accept it for what it is. Leave the celebrating among yourselves.
As I understand it he was crude in his comments, but be tolerant of him and understand he isn't you and doesn't understand your nor will have to answer for anything you do, good or bad.
Just another distraction from the real important issues we face today. Obama must love it. I'm really surprised he hasn't commented on it.
Due to a family situation, I am going to close this article for comments. I apologize to those who wanted to make comments.