America's Polygamous Future -- A Utah court ruling on Mormons is likely to spread to Muslims and others -- Charlotte Allen WSJ 12/18/2013
When the Supreme Court paved the way for universal recognition of same-sex marriage last June, opponents predicted that polygamy would be next. They didn't realize how quickly this would happen.
Less than six months after the high court issued a pair of decisions expanding access to gay marriage and its benefits, a federal judge in Utah has ruled unconstitutional key parts of a Utah bigamy law that makes polygamous cohabitation a crime. The law had been challenged by 44-year-old Kody Brown and his four wives, who, together with their 17 children, star in the reality-TV show "Sister Wives." The Browns, who used to live in Lehi, Utah (they have since moved to Las Vegas), belong to one of several breakaway Mormon sects that practice plural marriage. (The mainstream Church of the Latter-day Saints formally abandoned polygamy in 1890, shortly before Utah became a state). An estimated 40,000 residents of Utah live in polygamous households.
To be sure, the court ruling, by U.S. District Judge Clark Waddoups, does not legalize polygamous marriage or even invalidate Utah's bigamy law in its entirety. All 50 states have antibigamy laws on their books. But Utah's law, apparently uniquely, forbids plural marriages entered into via multiple marriage licenses and also applies to a married person who "cohabits with another person."
The typical practice for breakaway Mormon men, including Kody Brown, is to enter into only one legally recognized marriage but to take on additional "sister wives" in "spiritual" unions sanctified by religious ceremonies. Such unions are technically adulterous, but since the state of Utah does not prosecute adultery, Judge Waddoups said there was no "rational basis" for Utah's criminal law to distinguish between plain old adulterous cohabitation and informal polygamy entered into for religious reasons.
His ruling thus affects only so-called "fundamentalist" Mormons. However, the decision becomes precedent elsewhere, then it may apply to an estimated 50,000 to 100,000 Muslims in the U.S. who are in similar polygamous arrangements that they believe are permitted by the Quran.
Still, since what can't be criminally prosecuted is de facto permissible, the plural-marriage toboggan is now positioned firmly downward on the slippery slope. Judge Waddoups's decision has already been hailed by polyamorists, libertarians and feminists. In an April article for Slate, Jill Keenan argued that legal polygamy "is the constitutional, feminist, and sex-positive choice" that would allow women to select among "diverse family arrangements" for the one that suits them best.
Cheerleaders for legalized polygamy should be careful what they wish for. For one thing, "polygamy" almost invariably means "polygyny"one man with multiple wives, not the other way around. "Polyandry"one woman with multiple husbandsis extremely rare. It seems to exist only among isolated Amazonian hunter-gatherer tribes and in parts of rural Tibet, where brothers sometimes marry the same woman in order to keep the property in the family in case one of the brothers dies. You can call that female empowermentor you can call it the same old patriarchy.
Polygamy invariably favors "alpha" males who can beat down the competition for available women and maintain a lock on the affections of the women themselves. The women also have to be willing to sacrifice being the only object of attention of their spouse or lover for the glory of being an object of his attention at all.
The evolutionary psychologist Geoffrey Miller, in his 2000 book "The Mating Mind," described polygyny as a kind of default setting for human societies, and indeed primate societies as well. "[M]ating in our species has always been moderately polygynous," Mr. Miller wrote. He pointed out that women crave powerful, charismatic, often sexually promiscuous menthe most successful hunters and herdsmen, conqueror-kings such as Charlemagne and Genghis Khan, politicians, rock stars, and even sociopaths such as Charles Manson because women instinctively reach out to men strong enough to protect them and the vulnerable offspring they bear.
Tune in to "Sister Wives" on TLC or watch a video clip, and you will see exactly this alpha dynamic at work. When Kody Brown sits down to preside benevolently over a family council with his four adoring wives, there is no doubt who is the head of this household. Upper-middle-class American men, used to constant arguments with their feminist spouses over "gender roles" and whether they're doing their "fair share" of the laundry and floor-mopping, must envy Mr. Brown.
But as with all things, there is a trade-off. Monogamous marriage, still the paradigm in the West, ensures that a wife is ontologically the equal of her husbandbecause there are only two of them and they are dependent on each other.
In the biblical story in Genesis, God creates Eve as "an help meet" for Adam, because she is the only creature who can fulfill that function. While it is obvious that "surplus" non-alpha men will be losers in any society where polygamy becomes widely acceptablewomen will also be losersharem members instead of helpmeets. This is something that feminists and their male enablers who blithely tout polygamy as another "diverse family arrangement" ought to think about.
Ms. Allen is the author of "The Human Christ: The Search for the Historical Jesus."
Tags
Who is online
89 visitors

Besides, for anyone that has ever been married or been in a long term committed, relationship......do you really want to deal with those relationship issues in multiples?
I got this far and said to myself, "oh, this is just more irrelevant hyperventilating from Len about how gay marriage is going to be the death of humanity ... no point reading any further."
Aeon,
Why shouldn't we allow all that?
Depends on where you get your news, for example;
In a manner of speaking, the judge gave credence to " polyamory " relationships, which are not polygamous by definition. None of this however, " is likely to spread to Muslims and others", and even if this does, so what?
Wow. Can the author cram anymore sexist stereotypes into the essay? Perhaps not. I don't think she missed a single one. She's very good at degrading and debasing her own sex. "...women crave powerful, charismatic, often sexually promiscuous men..."? Really? I haven't met even one woman who fits that description. It certainly isn't born out by the fact the majority of women are choosing to live outside of marriage in any form.
The author apparently hasn't heard the whine of the far right fundamentalists that us nasty feminists are ruining marriage completely and how marriage itself is being completely undermined, soon to disappear much to the detriment of our society. That's far more likely to happen than for women to rush into either polygamy or polyandry.
Here's the problem with both whines: both are premised on the idea that women are not rational, not able to make a valid decision and should expect to be treated like subhumans within some form of marriage defined by patriarchs.
When are those who have no respect for women going to stop trying to demoralize women? If we really are all they pretend we are, then they shouldn't have to whine about us using our power at all. If their whines were true, we wouldn't have any power, so their whines are proven false simply because they acknowledge our power every time they whine.
Women will control the shape of marriage in the future. We will control whether it exists at all and, if it does, what form it takes. We'll have that control because we can simply refuse to participate if we don't like the existing options and will go looking for other options. We can no longer be forced into marriages we don't want because we now have financial control over our own lives. Since marriage only existed to control women's sexual choices, any form of it will die if we don't choose to participate.
Actually , the question is will he introduce them to an STD infected partner or not . That's if they haven't already done that ...
Catherine Allen regularly writes diatribes against feminists and liberals. She relies upon her regular readers to nod their heads and agree, even when her statements are illogical.
From the article:
Here's a prime example. How could the ruling only apply to Mormons? That's irrational and ignorant. It does only apply to Utah residents because it is a Utah law. This ruling brings Utah law into compliance with the bigamy laws in all the other states. It changes nothing at all for any polygamous families who are defying the laws in their state.
Well, yes, one woman, one man are "ontologically equal" because they exist in equal numbers, but what does that have to do with equality in marriage? In "traditional" aka patriarchal marriage, the definition has always been "male dominate, female subjugated." That's the very same thing she says will happen if polygamy is legalized. Either way, they're both forms of patriarchal marriage, so her argument is based on a hypocritical, false premise. She admits this in another part of her essay, which contradicts her argument above:
She's so caught up in hating feminists she doesn't even see thehypocrisyor the stupidity of contradictingherself.
She claimed one feminist at Salon supported it and then extrapolated that into plural feminists without any supporting facts and implied because one supported it, then all of us must support it. More irrationality.
Blaming feminists for "supporting" this ruling is just bizarre. The only person who has any say in the ruling is the judge. If it is appealed, then the appeals court will have a say, so why blame feminists except we are her favorite target to blame for all things.