╌>

Federal Judge Deals Major Blow to PPACA

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  13 years ago  •  76 comments

Federal Judge Deals Major Blow to PPACA

On Monday, United States District CourtJudge Brian Cogan ruled that the Affordable Care Act cannot force religious nonprofit organizations to pay for birth control for their employees.However, the judge didnt stop there.

Cogan went on to completely blastObamacares contraception mandate and the Presidents unconstitutional way of enforcing it with these three very compelling points:

#1 First, he dismissed the Obama administrations argument that the contraception mandate must be uniformly enforced for it to work, reminding them of all of the exceptions theyve made for special interests such as unions and members of Congress:

Tens of millions of people are exempt from the Mandate, under exemptions for grandfathered health plans, small businesses, and religious employers like the Diocesan plaintiffs here. Millions of women thus will not receive contraceptive coverage without cost-sharing through the Mandate. Having granted so many exemptions already, the Government cannot show a compelling interest in denying one to these plaintiffs.

#2 Second, he rejected the claim that nonprofits should just agree to the law because they wont have to follow it anyway:

Here, the Government implicitly acknowledges that applying the Mandate to plaintiffs may in fact do nothing at all to expand contraceptive coverage, because plaintiffs TPAs arent actually required to do anything after receiving the self-certification. In other words, the Mandate forces plaintiffs to fill out a form which, though it violates their religious beliefs, may ultimately serve no purpose whatsoever. A law that is totally ineffective cannot serve a compelling interest.

#3 Finally and this is the best one he called out Obama for overreaching his executive powers to enact parts of the law that Congress didnt agree to:

The Government first argues that the alternatives above are infeasible because the defendants lack statutory authority to enact some of them. This argument makes no sense; in any challenge to the constitutionality of a federal law, the question is whether the federal government could adopt a less restrictive means, not any particular branch within it. It would set a dangerous precedent to hold that if the Executive Branch cannot act unilaterally, then there is no alternative solution. If defendants lack the required statutory authority, Congress may pass appropriate legislation.

Judge Cogan is one of the few federal judges to call out Obama for his administrations increasingly widening interpretationof what he can do without congressional approval.

http://www.ijreview.com/2013/12/102680-federal-judge-deals-major-blow-aca-obamas-executive-orders-one-fatal-swoop/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Seems likely that this will case will proceed to the Nine Wise Ones in Washington but the judge certainly was candid and open in expressing his view of the contraception mandate and in part the PPACA in the decision.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Very interesting development . I would like to see more elaboration about #3 particularly ...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Petey

You may be able to find the actual decision on line somewhere, I haven't looked for it but there might be more detail available if you find it

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Second time ina few days that the administration got their hands slapped.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Petey...

#3 Finally and this is the best one he called out Obama for overreaching his executive powers to enact parts of the law that Congress didnt agree to:

This is just one of the many things Obama is overreaching his executive powers and has been successful in doing so. Why should he think anyone is going to stop him here after so many other successes.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Here's the courts decision;

...

An interesting take here;

  • "The Obama administration has handed out so many exceptions to the law, it can no longer claim the law serves a compelling purpose. In the past, courts have allowed the government to infringe religious rights if the government demonstrates a compelling interest and narrow tailoring, for example, income tax laws or criminal laws related to marijuana and peyote. But in this case, the administration was not able to claim that the contraception mandate serves a compelling purpose because it has been falling all over itself (largely for political reasons) to offer exceptions to the law." -
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

You did mean the five blind ones included with the nine owl reference, eh? Roberts, Scalia, Alito, Thomas, and majority of times, Kennedy- if Barry wants it, it's gonna be his.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Sixpick

There are some who think he will resume circumvention of Congress through executive orders to move his agenda forward in 2014.

Time will tell

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

1stwarrior

Actually no, the SCOTUS (like the individuals or not) decide the important issues of the country and this one will be no exception.

I have agreed and disagree with decisions that went right and left in the past and will like disagree again as time goes on.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A P

Thanks for sharing the information and link

"The Obama administration has handed out so many exceptions to the law, it can no longer claim the law serves a compelling purpose.

Clear and concise

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Egilman

Predicting reversal may be a but premature.

It's a law that doesn't apply to everyone, by governmental fiat.

Interesting, sounds like you think an "equal protection" argument is in the offing

Interesting times and legal conversations to come in the future

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

IMO the economy is in most need of tax reform . Instead we get a law with so many exemptions that it becomes meaningless ...

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

yup, and if theres any question, just claim ________ is a tax.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

JoAnne

Relevance to the topic of the contraception mandate being struck down?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Petey

No argument from me that tax code reform (personal and corporate) is badly needed but not really directly relevant to the contraception mandate being struck down

Tax reform can be accomplished with or without the PPACA being in place in whole or in part s we know it today

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

Article 1 Section 8 of the United States Constitution ... The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes

trumps:

Amendment 1: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech , or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

JoAnne

I repeat my question

Any relevance to the topic at hand, your constitutional citation does not make your comment relevant

Though the 1st amendment is relevant to the decision by the court

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Tax reform can be accomplished with or without the PPACA being in place in whole or in part s we know it today

Maybe not . I would think that genuine tax reform would end up trashing much of PPACA too . Most tax reform would eliminate loopholes which provide special privileges . PPACA would be eliminated for being not exclusive enough . Is Obamacare a plan to water down the taxcode ?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Petey

I agree to an extent but would rephrase --- that likely tax code reforms would eliminate some loopholes that provide credits or exceptions to select groups of people.

Therefore, I believe that tax code reform can be accomplished whether the PPACA stands as written, is revised to some extent or is repealed and replaced with some other program.

Is Obamacare a plan to water down the taxcode ?

I would say No, that is simply an unexpected perk for those that promulgated the program.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

On Monday, United States District CourtJudge Brian Cogan ruled that the Affordable Care Act cannot force religious nonprofit organizations to pay for birth control for their employees.However, the judge didnt stop there.

Which means they can impose their religious beliefs on their employees while operating essentially tax free.

That's hardly a separation of church and state.

Why should my tax dollars subsidize the imposition of their dogmas?

How 'bout they pay their Jewish employees less than their Christian employees unless they convert and accept Jesus?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Well it is a perspective and I thank you for sharing

Really not interested in an argument on separation of church and state versus freedom to practice one's religion as they see fit

But would you consider this, the owners of these businesses do not care if their employees use contraceptives, they simply do no want to participate in that use by paying for the contraceptives.

Your example of payment of different wages is an absurd straw man and you know it

Thanks again for sharing your perspective which is always entertaining

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Really not interested in an argument on separation of church and state versus freedom to practice one's religion as they see fit

I believe that argument will be a part of any appeal going forward. The decision absolutely upholds the intercession of religion into mandated law --

But would you consider this, the owners of these businesses do not care if their employees use contraceptives, they simply do no want to participate in that use by paying for the contraceptives.

I'll consider it if the business in no way enjoys any form of tax-exempt status.

Your example of payment of different wages is an absurd straw man and you know it

Really? The example is analogous to selective implementation of a law based on religious belief. Rather than do the "and you know it" thing, just explain why my analogy does not apply. If you can't, then maybe your calling it "absurd" is what's actually absurd.

Thanks again for sharing your perspective which is always entertaining

My pleasure coming here to entertain.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

that they shouldn't be forced to pay for it by any law.

What if they decide they don't have to pay taxes because their religious beliefs are in opposition to the concept (and if they're tax exempt, they're having it both ways).

they are imposing a law that forces them to support something that they do not based upon their religious beliefs.

Some parents have been convicted of a crime for not allowing their seriously-ill children to be treated by physicians because of religious belief. Isn't that an irony religion opposing birth control and abortion but condoning "faith" healing? Religion should not interfere with law -- it's a potential mine field. I appreciate the dilemma but law is intended to be utilitarian and while it often falls short, dogma tends to be myopic and self-serving.

The government cannot chose an approved religion or religious practice, the reverse is also true, they cannot mandate that religious belief is irrelevant.

Neither can religious belief decide when a mandated law is irrelevant.

Religious Discrimination

Religious discrimination involves treating a person (an applicant or employee) unfavorably because of his or her religious beliefs. The law protects not only people who belong to traditional, organized religions, such as Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, and Judaism, but also others who have sincerely held religious, ethical or moral beliefs.

Religious discrimination can also involve treating someone differently because that person is married to (or associated with) an individual of a particular religion or because of his or her connection with a religious organization or group.

Religious Discrimination & Work Situations

The law forbids discrimination when it comes to any aspect of employment, including hiring, firing, pay, job assignments, promotions, layoff, training, fringe benefits, and any other term or condition of employment.

It doesn't, it is the tax dollars imposing the government chosen position on their religious belief.

Disagree; once an entity is tax exempt, ironically, the tax dollars of the citizenry makes up the resultant shortfall and subsidizes it. Can't have it both ways -- as you wrote

If it can't be done in one direction, it can't be done in the other direction either...

_____________________________________________

My friend, we do have some doozies and this is a good one!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago
How can it possibly be discrimination if every employee is treated the same? The employers position is the opposite of religious discrimination, all employees regardless of religion, are treated the exact same. They are all not being given a free benefit.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

They are all not being given a free benefit.

And consequently, those who are legally entitled to it and want it, are the victims of discrimination. Violating everyone's right to either accept or decline that to which they have a right under the law, is discriminatory.

The employer can't arbitrarily decide that if he denies EVERY EMPLOYEE A BENEFIT TO WHICH THEY'RE ENTITLED (whether they take it or leave it), he therefore hasn't discriminated against any of his employees.

By in effect, declining for ALL, the employer discriminates against ALL. The law does not mandate employees must USE the benefit, it mandates that it's their right to decide for themselves whether or not they do!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago
Violating everyone's right to either accept or decline that to which they have a right under the law, is discriminatory.

It's the exact opposite of discriminatory because everyone is treated the same. A discrimatory policy requires the employer to actually discriminate. If an employer failed to pay all employees legally mandated overtime, it's not discriminating against them. If the employer only pays black people for overtime, it's discriminating. Every violation of a law or regulation by an employer doesn't constitute discrimination.

Finally, I note the department of justice didn't even bother to raise this argument. Do you beleive the Obama DOJ would fail to raise the issue of discrimination if it had even the slightest chance of being succesful?
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

It is my view (and my view only) that

* people should have access to birth control options (if they so desire to have that access and to use birth control measures).
* a individual employer (or a business) should be able to choose to not pay for contraception (if the practice of birth control is against their religious beliefs)

Of all the many exceptions being granted to unions, businesses and individuals as regards the PPACA this one seems the most reasonable

Since all employees would be treated exactly the same, there is no employment discrimination of any kind. Employees would have the option of either fulfilling their birth control requirements, without the assistance of company supplied insurance, purchasing supplemental insurance through the PPACA exchanges or finding other employment.

I support the idea thatpeople should have access to the birth control method of their choice, but also support the choice of employers not to pay for it. Their other drugs, procedures and medical devices that not all insurance policy covers and this should be in that category.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Egilman argues,

But it's the government, by fiat, deciding what is discriminatory, isn't that discriminatory by and of itself?

Not so; it's the definition of "discriminatory" itself that sets the parameters.

discriminatory |diskrimntr|
adjective
making or showing an unfair or prejudicial distinction between different categories of people or things, esp. on the grounds of race, age, or sex : discriminatory employment practices.

Laws do not stop at the doors of churches or employers; the SCOTUS ruled that the PPACA/"Obamacare" is constitutional -- therefore, if/when any single entity/employer, etc. arbitrarily denies a citizen(s) access to the protections/benefits, etc. of any given law, particularly on the basis of, but not limited to "reasons" of religion, race, gender, etc., such a denial is therefore, by definition and by law, discriminatory.

but governments role isn't to decide what is fair either

Oh, indeed it is under particular circumstances.

The Equal Protection Clause is part of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution . The clause, which took effect in 1868, provides that no state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws .

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws .

IMO, by extension, "state" applies to any entity that deprives any citizen of "the equal protection of the laws".

Lets not go to the idea created that mandates the government is declaring what an employer must pay it's employees or offer in benefits.

We're not arguing about "what an employer must pay its employees," rather that it cannot legally pay them in discriminatory ways Christians get "x", non-Christians get x minus 25%, etc. . And that still isn't the issue herein. The issue is that the tenets of a Federal law cannot be abrogated by an, i.e. employer, in this case, not on religious grounds.

The employees in this case, being American citizens, as such, can't be separated out from other American citizens by their employer on the rationale that the employer is denying ALL OF ITS EMPLOYEES EQUALLY so therefor it's not discriminatory. This employer is discriminating not against his employees, but a group a American citizens he happens to employ.

Sean argues.

It's the exact opposite of discriminatory because everyone is treated the same. A discrimatory policy requires the employer to actually discriminate.

The flaw in that argument, in part, is in the word "everybody". In terms of the law, "everybody" includes everybody in a jurisdiction to whom the law applies, not "everybody" working under one particular employer.

Do you beleive the Obama DOJ would fail to raise the issue of discrimination if it had even the slightest chance of being succesful?

We'll see when the appeals come.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

* a individual employer (or a business) should be able to choose to not pay for contraception (if the practice of birth control is against their religious beliefs)

Imposing one's religious beliefs in order to abrogate a portion of a law is unconstitutional (IMHO).

If one wants to get technical, SO CALLED "BIRTH CONTROL" MEDICATIONS ARE NOT ALWAYS USED FOR THAT PURPOSE; MANY WOMEN TAKE THOSE MEDICATIONS TO PREVENT CANCER!

Endometrial cancer is a cancer that starts in the endometrium, the inner lining of the uterus (womb). The picture below shows where the uterus is located.

How about the drug Sudafed? It's a decongestant but can be used (misused) in ways that are objectionable to a given employer. Does that give an employer the legal right to deny employees access if the PPACA has a prescription component?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Obama and Democrats MANDATED free coverage.

Maybe you missed it.

Supreme Court Ruling Released: PPACA Deemed Constitutional

Thursday, June 28, 2012

On June 28, the United States Supreme Court released its ruling in the National Federation of Independent Business, et al. , v. Sebelius, Secretary of Health and Human Services, et al . finding the law to be constitutional.In the majority opinion, the constitutionality of the individual mandate section of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) the centerpiece of the case was upheld under the rationale that the constitutional power to levy taxes sufficiently extended to the law.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Maybe you missed it, but

On Monday, United States District CourtJudge Brian Cogan ruled that the Affordable Care Act cannot force religious nonprofit organizations to pay for birth control for their employees.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

A federal court has found that portion of the law to be unconstitutional (the topic of he thread in case you forgot)

You continue to obfuscate a narrow issue but you are enjoying yourself and others are engaging you so have at it

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

On Monday, United States District CourtJudge Brian Cogan ruled that the Affordable Care Act cannot force religious nonprofit organizations to pay for birth control for their employees.

We'll see if this stands as it most certainly will be appealed.

QUESTION TO RIO (et al):

WHAT IF AN APPELLATE CONTENTION IS "Women who are taking i.e.

Gonadotropin-releasing hormone (Gn-RH) agonists and antagonists. These drugs block the production of ovarian-stimulating hormones, lowering estrogen levels and preventing menstruation. This causes endometrial tissue to shrink. Gn-RH agonists and antagonists can force endometriosis into remission during the time of treatment and sometimes for months or years afterward. Because these drugs create an artificial menopause, taking a low dose of estrogen or progestin along with Gn-RH agonists and antagonists may decrease menopausal side effects, such as hot flashes, vaginal dryness and bone loss. Your periods and the ability to get pregnant return when the medication is stopped.

ARE NOT USING THEM AS "BIRTH CONTROL" MEDICATIONS RATHER, AS CANCER-INHIBITORS. BIRTH CONTROL IN THOSE INSTANCES ARE TANTAMOUNT TO "SIDE EFFECTS" AND CONSEQUENTLY, EMPLOYERS WHO DECIDE ON RELIGIOUS (et al personal) GROUNDS ARE ARBITRARILY DETERMINING A WOMAN'S "INTENT" AND DENYING ACCESS TO A CANCER-INHIBITING MEDICATION ON SPECULATION -- ON AN ASCRIBED INTENT PREDICATED UPON RELIGIOUS BELIEF/DOGMA."

What then?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

A federal court has found that portion of the law to be unconstitutional (the topic of he thread in case you forgot)

You continue to obfuscate a narrow issue but you are enjoying yourself and others are engaging you so have at it

I am discussing that ruling and giving my opinion as to why I believe it will be appealed and overturned.

It is the very opposite of obfuscation -- it is clarification based upon questioning from an opposing perspective. Those who brought the suit did exactly that when opposing the PPACA component, did they not?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

And you dismiss those who have the exact opposite opinion

But as I said go for it

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

They would still be able to get and take the medications, the business owners though would not b paying for them as 100% covered items in the company provided insurance

And they would not be paying for the medications for all of their employees and therefore would not be discriminating against anyone

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

And you dismiss those who have the exact opposite opinion

RIO,

I never (merely) dismiss anyone's position; I explain why I disagree with them and always give details as to why I do.

Unlike some others.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

They would still be able to get and take the medications, the business owners though would not b paying for them as 100% covered items in the company provided insurance

But that's the issue at hand; can the business owners unilaterally abrogate any/all parts of a law based on religious objection?

And they would not be paying for the medications for all of their employees and therefore would not be discriminating against anyone

Already explained why that distinction does not hold up.

The employees are not only employees of a company denying them certain benefits mandated by law, they are Americans covered under a law (upheld as Constitutional by the SCOTUS) and, in terms of Americans taken as a whole , as such, are being discriminated against by their employer.

The plaintiffs, a group of New York Roman Catholic organizations that were part of a national effort to fight the contraception coverage mandate, argued that Obamacare's provisions violated their freedom of speech and their religious beliefs, which preclude them from facilitating access to abortion-inducing products, contraception, sterilization, and related counseling, according to the decision last week.

Judge Brian Cogan's decision, issued on Dec. 13 but made available electronically on Monday, said the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services could not implement the regulations, which require the Catholic religious groups and their health plans to provide insurance coverage to employees and their covered dependents for Food and Drug Administration-approved contraceptive methods, sterilization procedures, and patient education and counseling, because they violate the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

http://www.businessinsurance.com/article/20131217/NEWS03/131219872?tags=|62|307|74|278|79#

When a tax-exempt entity wants to be also exempt from following certain law, it is biting the hand that feeds it, that of the American tax pay who indirectly subsidizes its very existence.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

No actually the court is going to decide that a law cannot force a citizen do something that is an abrogation of their right to freely practice their religion

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"Freely practicing one's religion" cannot trump the law.

Let's take "faith healing" as an example.

Wisconsin court upholds homicide conviction for faith-healer parents who let daughter die

The Wisconsin Supreme Court upheld homicide convictions on Wednesday for a mother and father who stood by and prayed as their daughter died of undiagnosed diabetes, believing that God would save her. According to the Associated Press , the court ruled that while parents in the state who seek faith cures over medical attention for their sick children have some protections under the law, the parents of 11-year-old Kara Neumann went too far.

In May of this year, a Philadelphia couple, Herbert and Catherine Schaible were jailed on third-degree murder charges after they let a second child die rather than take him to the doctor . The couple lost their 2-year-old son to pneumonia in 2009, then neglected to treat their 8-month-old this year and lost him under what prosecutors called eerily similar circumstances.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Freely practicing one's religion is the law, amendment numero uno!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion

Consequently, acceding to a religious dogma and modifying a law, thus is a dangerous step towards establishing an official religion -- which would be unconstitutional.

Bigamy/polygamy, although permissible in the Mormon religion, is illegal under the law.

Polygamy

The offense of willfully and knowingly having more than one wife or husband at the same time. The offense of willfully and knowingly entering into a second marriage while validly married to another individual is bigamy.

The Crime

The law in every state prohibits a man or a woman from being married to more than one living person at a time. The crime of having more than one current spouse is called either bigamy (having two spouses) is a subset of the crime of polygamy (having more than one spouse), and the law makes no practical distinction between the two.

Even in states that separately criminalize both polygamy and bigamy, either crime is committed when a married person first enters into an unlawful marriage with a second person.

Also

The no religious test clause of the U.S. constitution states that "no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States." Although it has become tradition for US presidents to end their Presidential Oath with "so help me God", this is not required by the Constitution

And

Pay And Benefits

It is illegal for an employer to discriminate against an employee in the payment of wages or employee benefits on the bases of race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy), national origin, age (40 or older), disability or genetic information.

Employee benefits include sick and vacation leave, insurance , access to overtime as well as overtime pay, and retirement programs. For example, an employer many not pay Hispanic workers less than African-American workers because of their national origin, and men and women in the same workplace must be given equal pay for equal work.

This cuts both ways an employer can not discriminate ON THE BASIS OF HIS RELIGIOUS BELIEFS OR THAT OF HIS EMPLOYEES.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

But being opposed to contraception is not against the law, so they government cannot pass a law that forces the citizens to do something that is contrary to the free exercise of their religious beliefs

It is going to a real kick in the teeth for the administration when this decision is upheld on appeal

The employer is not discriminating against any employee based on the employee's religious belief or anything else. All employees will be treated exactly the same ego no discrimination.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

If it is a business that is incorporated in any fashion, it should have no innate rights, imo. It is incorporated under the rules and mandates of the states and federal government, and as such, should comply with all rules and regulations regarding same. Whether or not exceptions are made for certain types of companies should not effect, in any way, the applicability of any law written.

Companies are not people. Companies have no innate rights. It is (or should be) that simple.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Broliver

Thanks for the feedback and perspective

It is (or should be) that simple.

Unfortunately it seldom is when it comes to laws, the constitution and the SCOTUS. It seems to me (and maybe to others who knows) that it is more compelling to grant this exception that it is to grant exceptions to unions or Congress or insurance companies etc etc

But I am not a constitutional scholar and I will wait to see what the nine wise ones have to say about the matter

Hope you have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But being opposed to contraception is not against the law, so they government cannot pass a law that forces the citizens to do something that is contrary to the free exercise of their religious beliefs

Being opposed is not the problem; denying people's legal rights because, in this case, the employer is opposed to contraception is the problem.

You have it exactly backwards, RIO.

An employer cannot disobey a law (passed by government) that in effect forces citizens (in this case the employees) to de facto be restricted to the employers beliefs and/or by the employer's beliefs.

Denying those citizen/employees their legal rights because the employer wants to negate them based on his religious beliefs, additionally denies the employee/citizens the free exercise of their religious beliefs (or the right to a lack thereof).

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

I have it exactly forwards A Mac, contrary to the fact that you think anyone that disagrees with you "has it backwards"

The employers do not care one way or the other if the employees use contraception, they issue is that the employers do not wish to pay for the contraception.

Big difference

The employees retain the "right" and ability to use contraception they simply have to pay for it in some way outside of their employer provided health insurance

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The employers do not care one way or the other if the employees use contraception, they issue is that the employers do not wish to pay for the contraception.

That's ENTIRELY because of their religious beliefs . Why don't these particular employers also challenge the requirement to pay for any/all of other medications?

Judge Brian Cogan issued a permanent injunction Monday exempting four organizations with ties to the Roman Catholic Church from complying with a rule to provide their employees with contraceptive health care coverage through a third party.

...

The employees retain the "right" and ability to use contraception they simply have to pay for it in some way outside of their employer provided health insurance

The law as written mandates the employer to pay for it. It's not about the employees' right or ability to use contraception; that has not been challenged.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

RiO said:

"I will wait to see what the nine wise ones have to say about the matter"

Are those nine supposedly wise ones not the same ones who definitively equated incorporation with person-hood?

I do not trust the SCotUS to deliver what I would feel to be an impartial judgement, because they can't even frame the questions properly.

Let's go hypothetical here: Suppose that a member or two of the family who owns the company in question disagrees with the decision not to provide birth control through an insurance plan on religious grounds. What would be the proper constitutional response in that instance? I mean, if the court goes with the corporation majority, you are infringing upon the individual's right to freedom of religion in favor of a corporation by the same argument that the corporation is using. So the individual gets trumped by the corporation, and the corporation gets to say' "We are not going to provide birth control because we it will violate our right to religious freedom." If the court goeswith the individuals, then the individuals get to say, "We are going to provide birth control because to not do so would violate our right to religious freedom."

How on earth can anyone justify such a thing?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Broliver

I do not always agree with the decisions of the SCOTUS over the past decades, but I do accept their decisions as the law of the land. As I recall there was much rejoicing when the same "nine wise ones" decided that the PPACA was constitutional a little while back.

Just as "we the people" must accept the decision that said the PPACA and individual mandate/penalty was constitutional, so will we have to accept the decision (whichever way it goes) on the contraception mandate.

Hypotheticals will be considered during the deliberations I am sure but the decision will turn on the view of how (if at all) the contraception mandate infringes on the owners opportunity to freely practice their religious beliefs without interference from legislation

Appreciate the feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Finally a good point

The law as written mandates the employer to pay for it.

That is the exact point and only point involved here - whether the SCOTUS ends up agreeing that the mandate for the employers to pay for contraception (which is contrary to their religious beliefs) is an infringement on their rights to freely practice the religion of their choice which the1st amendment says laws shall not do.

You are also right when you say

It's not about the employees' right or ability to use contraception; that has not been challenged.

The employers are not saying an employee cannot use contraception but rather that they (the employers) should not be required to pay for it). The employee would still be able to get contraception through means other than employer provided health insurance (perhaps a policy through the PPACA exchange.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

RIO,

All my comments are "good points".

These cases are discussed in law schools and forums of all kinds and they are picked apart, sometimes down to the relevance of a single word. If you're going to start discussions about legal decisions, you're going to have to accept that reality.

The employee would still be able to get contraception through means other than employer provided health insurance (perhaps a policy through the PPACA exchange.

That is irrelevant to the case; the issue is not whether the employee can otherwise do X, Y, or Z, it's whether or not an employer can refuse compliance with a law based on religious beliefs. The meaning of the phrase "separation of church and state" has been argued endlessly -- although the Constitution does not contain that language.

Generically speaking, the fact that, from an employee's perspective "there's more than one way to skin a cat," the PPACA as written and upheld by the SCOTUS, mandates the employer to pay for the particular "skinning" being discussed herein.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

No actually the question is whether the law in unconstitutional as regards the employers rights to freely practice their religion under the provisions of the 1st amendment ot the constitution.

That is the one and only question to be decided in this case.

Until the SCOTUS overturns this judges ruling, the mandate that employers must provide contraception drugs or devices to their employees is still an unsettled question.

The SCOTUS will decide and then the question will be settled and "we the people/ will abide by that decision as we are abiding by the first ruling that the individual mandate and the PPACA as a whole were constitutional. This question is not questioning that decision but asking for specific clarification on an aspect of the PPACA

And of course your points are good ones, no one would suggest otherwise, I used the phrase to emphasize that it was a point we agreed on

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

No actually the question is whether the law in unconstitutional as regards the employers rights to freely practice their religion under the provisions of the 1st amendment ot the constitution.

That is the narrower question -- a particular situation that poses the ultimate question.

"Are there limits to free speech, in this case, a religious preference constitutionally trumping the law-of-the-land"?

Whichever the answer, it sets precedent -- and either way, it will likely be challenged again and again.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

I agree the questions narrow but that is the question to be answered in this case

As always I appreciate the feedback and I learned some stuff along the way

Have a great Christmas

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

A great Christmas to you as well!

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Egilman

Very interesting and well presented position on the issue

I agree with the basis but do not think the slope is as slippery as you see it where the employer mandate might be determined to be unconstitutional.

I agree that such a decision would be devastating to the law as it exists today

Thanks for all the feedback and best wishes for a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you and yours

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"The law of the Land" Is that Congress can make no law abridging a persons right to whatever religion or religious practices they choose to follow. First amendment to the constitution. It is not a free speech issue.

Disagree; the "Faith Healing" convictions (as one example) in essence say, "a criminal act (as defined by law) can be neither "justified," nor, that law unilaterally abrogated with impunity, solely on the basis of one's religious beliefs." And I don't just limit "violations" to "criminal" acts, but any act in the name of religion that is contrary to law.

So, "Is making a law that abridges a guaranteed right legal" IS the real question. Or in the alternative, are we claiming that any law passed by congress is absolute? and takes precedence over the constitution itself?

Individuals are free to practice the tenets of their religion BUT NOT IF ANY OF THOSE TENETS ARE IN VIOLATION OF LAW.

If the government isn't bound by the constitution and it's plain meanings, why should the people be?

The people can not violate a law and claim Constitutional privilege. Read about a man name Bob Graham (a local guy) who filed a Fifth Amendment Tax return claiming that the 1040 violated his right to not self-incriminate.

I believe he served 5 years in prison.

The judge, Norma Shapiro came right out and said, "You can not use the Constitution as your defense."

the danger here and the real big gamble by the government is the court could easily rule that NO employer be required to pay for any medical insurance coverage

What if benefits are part of a collective bargaining agreement? And, in the absence of such an agreement, employees without private insurance could go to the state exchanges.

The government is counting on the employers to bring the young people into the network cause the young people, (except those under 27 still living with mommy and daddy) are rejecting this mandate by the millions...

As stories are reported regarding "healthy" uninsured 30 year-olds being hit by a truck, being diagnosed with cancer and other tragic circumstances, the light bulbs will begin to turn on and illuminate the sign that says, "Holy shit, that could have been me!"

__________________________________________

You do keep me on my toes Egilman!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Does anyone here know about "Tribute Money"?

The story takes its roots from the Gospel of Matthew in which Jesus and the disciples are confronted by a tax collector.

The traditional Jewish view point was to give everything to God as all belonged to God and not to the state.

So, what if an American citizen decides not to pay taxes because his religion believes that everything should be given to God and not to the state?

The argument comes down to not whether the Constitution guarantees the (absolute) freedom of religion, or, if there is a line that is drawn between where religion ends and the law begins if there is a conflict between those two entities.

Don't duck the question. Using the religious concept of "tribute money," were this to be the basis of a case brought by the IRS against a taxpayer declining to pay taxes because "that would violate his religious beliefs," what say you (any of you)?

And please do not tell me this is "off-topic" because the topic is about a conflict between religion and law.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Actually the topic is about the constitutionality of the contraception mandate in the PPACA.

That being said, I am neither a Biblical or constitutional scholar so I have only my view on the matter on a "red line" that cannot be crossed regarding religious practice and legislation and whether there is a line and if so where that line is what the SCOTUS will decide in this case.

For me (my opinion in other words), the contraception mandate infringes on the business owners free exercise of their religious beliefs, but the reality will be decided by the court and I will accept whether it goes my way or the other.

I do not see the correlatation between "tribute money" and this case but perhaps someone else will and will provide feedback.

Good question and thanks for the feedback

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Actually the topic is about the constitutionality of the contraception mandate in the PPACA.

Not so; that is the case that tests the issue which is broader -- that issue being "what if any religious exceptions to law are justified by the language of the Constitution?"

The topic of your article cannot be reasonably separated from the issue that led to the article.

But you are entitled to a response to

For me (my opinion in other words), the contraception mandate infringes on the business owners free exercise of their religious beliefs, but the reality will be decided by the court and I will accept whether it goes my way or the other.

I cited earlier, there is a flaw in the very contention that, in this case, "contraception" is the problem for the employer's religious beliefs.

Because "birth control pill," etc. is a generic ascription, and, "contraception" is as well, since many of these so-called "contraceptive" medications ARE NOT PRESCRIBED FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONTRACEPTION, RATHER AS TREATMENT FOR A CONDITION KNOWN AS ENDOMETRIOSIS, the employer, it can be argued, is making a judgement based on a medication side-effect and thus completely discounts its primary (and often its ONLY) use by women.

If the employer is asked during the appeal process:

"Which of your religious beliefs are violated when you (through employee benefits you provide) are asked to pay for a medication prescribed for the purpose of treating a condition resulting from the appearance of endometrial tissue outside the uterus and causing pelvic pain?"

What's his answer?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

What the pill is used for is tangential at best to the issue of the business owners religious practice precluding the use of contraception and their belief that the law unfairly and unconstitutionally infringes on the free practice of their religion

That is what the case is about and that alone.

The topic of the article and the appealed decision are about the constitutionality of the aspect of the PPACA that mandates the provision of free contraceptive coverage by employer provided health insurance

I think a possible ruling could be that the employer is exempted from the mandate to provide insurance if there is a valid 1st amendment conflict (such as contraception) in which case these business might eliminate employer health insurance (without penalty) and the employees would be able to get insurance through the exchanges, with contraception coverage.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But how does the employer answer the question if asked under oath?

That question challenges the employer's objection, not based on his Constitutional rights, but on the matter as to whether or not the medication in question is being expressly prescribed or used for the purpose of contraception. If it is not, on what basis then -- if not the conflict between the medication, his religious beliefs and the Constitution -- then what?

What if it all comes down to "the plaintiff has no issue regarding medications that are not 'contraceptive' per se"? In the vernacular, "No harm, no foul; ONLY MEDICATIONS PRESCRIBED SOLELY FOR CONTRACEPTIVE PURPOSES raise a possible Constitutional/First Amendment question."

Asked another way; "Can an employer justifiably/Constitutionally deny employees benefit coverage regarding medications that may be used for 'contraceptive' purposes but which are prescribed specifically for non-contraceptive, verifiable purposes?

Can said employer, by inference alone, decide how medications so prescribed, will be used, and his base alleged claim of "violation of his right to 'religious freedom' on such an inference?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Your clouding of the issue makes the option of exempting the employer from the mandate to provide employees insurance a more logical decision than taking the contraception out of the PPACA mandated care.

The article you posted may be about all of these tangential issues and questions, but this one is about whether the constitutional protection in the 1st amendment extends to the employers not providing contraception coverage in their employer provided health insurance if it is contrary to their religious beliefs.

I think we are at what one could call an impasse since we are on opposite sides of this table (issue) and not about the change seats

I thank you for all the back and forth and will see you on other articles I am sure

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

OK. Impasse it is.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

all hail king obama

his subjects aint seen nothin yet

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"Give unto Caesar's what is Caesar's and give unto God what is God's"

Then Long Live Caesar Obama!

So for Christians, it has always been a good measure of a christian to pay his taxes, as required by Caesar, with Caesar's own money.........

Since the SCOTUS upheld the Constitutionality of the PPACA on the basis of the government's right to tax, aren't you thus arguing that there is no religious rationale for failure to pay for the medications in question? Is it not then the Christian thing to do?

BTW, I have not taken a stand per se on religious exemptions based on the Constitution; my argument is that many so-called "birth control/contraceptive" medications are not used for that purpose, therefore, at least in the instances where women are being prescribed medications to treat endometriosis, the plaintiff has no argument.

It also destroys the religious tax exemption claims also, and is why Mr Graham went to jail... His defense was laughable right out of Jesus's mouth..... (Notwithstanding that you cannot posit a constitutional defense to specific acts, original constitutional arguments in defense are reserved for the appellate jurisdiction, not the trial court, which left Mr Graham with no defense, which the judge noted in her comments)

And my point in citing Graham's argument is that the Constitution, in fact, may not always be a defense for disobeying a law.

Both the arguments above are moot I'm sorry to say, but eloquently stated.

On many-a-day, I am nothing if not eloquent. Moot that's another matter altogether.

I pay "tribute" to you my good friend and most worthy adversary in that it seems you noted my "tribute money" posit could be refuted and/or seen as relevant to both sides of this argument. I had hoped to allude to the inherent dilemma without leading the witnesses so-to-speak.

The "Render Unto Caesar" gospel "gives rise to multiple possible interpretations about the circumstances under which it is desirable for the Christian to submit to earthly authority."

But I ask you (as others) to respond directly to this question as if you were the employer;

If the employer is asked during the appeal process:

"Which of your religious beliefs are violated when you (through employee benefits you provide) are asked to pay for a medication prescribed for the purpose of treating a condition resulting from the appearance of endometrial tissue outside the uterus and causing pelvic pain?"

_____________________________

This is one of our best go-rounds.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Then Long Live Caesar Obama!

Interesting

So you see Obama as an emperor rather than a president that explains a lot

Smile.gif

Sorry couldn't resist that one you made it so easy

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

RIO asked,

So you see Obama as an emperor rather than a president that explains a lot

You know I don't; it was a quip in response to Egilman's comment "Caesar" representing "government" -- under any President/Congress.

It is metaphorical.

Render unto "Caesar" meaning, give government its due and God, His due.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

I thought the smiling face would let you know that I was kidding, making a play on your words so to speak

As you can see form the comment directly above yours it is not metaphorical to everyone so I thought I would poke a little fun at you with your own words

It was a quip, as you say, in response your comment of Caesar Obama

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

RIO,

I know you were kidding I just gave the explanation for those who may have (by choice or by misunderstanding), taken my comment literally.

No problem -- I think of you as a friend with whom I can freely and openly disagree without harming the friendship.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Absolutely

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Why? because under the specific example posited, the drugs in question are not being used to end a life, which is the religious exception most take.

From an insurance perspective, this is easily handled by a rider on the policy.

But the employer has not made that distinction nor any other of which I'm aware and that is why I believe we'll be visiting that point in the appeals process.

Faith Healing, is a controversial issue, one the medical associations have been pushing against for many decades.

Not the point here; parents have been charged and convicted where they've allowed their children to do die on the premise that their religion both mandated "faith healing", and, cited that as being consistent with their rights under the First Amendment.

I'd cite those situations as case law (the law as established by the outcome of former cases). I'm not going into ex post facto -- the PPACA and any alleged religious conflicts are now.

Today it is in a state of flux, some states have seriously restricted and narrowed the exempted actions that can be excused under religious grounds... it still allows the jury To decide many though.

Juries must render their decisions based on the law as it stands at the time a dispute arises. Bad decisions notwithstanding, a judge has the obligation of explaining the attendant law to jurors.

And since our responsibility as citizens is to protect our citizens from harm, the needs of society outweigh the needs of a few individuals in general under this specific circumstance.

Laws exist for that alleged very purpose and again, it is not a juror's function to interpret the law or even to personally assess its reasonableness; a juror's function is to decide, based on the facts or lack thereof regarding a particular case, whether or not the "letter" of that law has been violated.

It is the government that makes law, if religion had to subjugate itself to all law making, then who controls the religion?

That is the very question at hand! Religion controls itself within its parameters; when those parameters overlap and violate a law in which that religion is practiced, it theoretically, potentially or actually can undermine the very society which enables it to exist.

In the vernacular: One shouldn't defecate where he eats.

In the scriptural" He who troubleth his own house shall inherit the wind.

I know it just isn't that important to many in today's world, but just try and make religion subject to all law, we would finally see just how much the non religious are in the minority.....

It's interesting; we see this in mirror-image! Just try to make law subject to religion!

___________________________________

Egilman,

Thank you for these thought-provoking dialogues. I respect you greatly.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mac, we are not in exact mirror image, I clearly said that children have the same rights as the fundamentalists would give a conjoined egg and sperm in the womb, thereby making any fundamentalist argument for faith healing against the law a supreme hypocrisy....

I'm not sure I understand what you're saying; as I see it, "faith healing" resulting in a child's death is an actionable offense (in 1974 after the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services enacted an important regulation on the subject. This regulation required that states receiving funds for child abuse prevention programs adopt exemptions for parents who practiced faith healing). But this federal regulation was rescinded in 1983.

I have not talking been about "the morning after" pill; nor have I been talking about "abortion" or anything related to abortion. My issue is with regard to medications that could be used for contraceptive purposes but are not solely for those purposes. My problem with this employer is that he considers ONLY that aspect of certain medications and on that narrow view objects ON RELIGIOUS/CONSTITUTIONAL grounds to providing it as an employee benefit.

Where I conflate "faith healing" and this employer's objections is ONLY WITH REGARD TO THE PREMISE THAT RELIGION CAN BYPASS THE LAW -- ANY LAW -- USING THE FIRST AMENDMENT FOR IMMUNITY AND IMPUNITY.

Be it "my religion allows me to jay walk on the Sabbath" or "allows me to let my child die if that is God's will because we don't believe in Medicine," -- the issue (IMO) is the same -- The First Amendment's reference to "prohibiting government from establishing a religion and protecting each person's right to practice (or not practice) any faith without government interference" is not the equivalent of carte blache to break laws.

Just as there are limits to free speech, there are limits to religious practices.

And even though juries are charged with following the law, it is the paramount right of a jury to decide in any manner they choose. And such decision being final as concerns that case....

That's one reason there are appeals.

The law is written that way to preserve the citizen input to the law as written into the constitution and interpreted by the nine wise men ever since....

Appellate jurisdictions are there to correct major discrepancies in the law with such cases, but rarely over turn jury verdicts unless some kind of misdeed concerning the jury is discovered.

The citizen/juror's duty is not to interpret the law. In a criminal trial, jurors are charged with the responsibility of deciding whether, on the facts of the case, a person is guilty or not guilty of the offence for which he/she has been charged. The jury must reach its verdict by considering only the evidence introduced in court and the directions of the judge. The jury does not interpret the law. It follows the directions of the judge as regards legal matters.

Mac, I don't often go into such conversations with people, usually online it becomes such a bore when the point is ignored in favor of a flame fest or a juvenile finger pointing session, thank you for the honest clear discussion of the actual issue, it is refreshing....

On this we are in total agreement. And thank you as well.

And, over here on the east coast, it's "good night".

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"The doctrine of jury nullification (is) the power of a jury to bring in a verdict in the teeth of both law and facts, a technical right, if it can be called so, to decide against the law and the facts.

" Jury nullification has a unique place in the law and has been the subject of spirited debate for hundreds of years in both English and American law....

Yet, when defendants have asked that jurors be instructed on their power of nullification, the requests have been denied. Thus, although acknowledging the existence of the jury's prerogative and its beneficial role in acting as a safety valve, the courts do not encourage exercise of the right. Fear of excess or intolerable caprice is cited as the reason."

And,

In 1988, the Sixth Circuit upheld a jury instruction: "There is no such thing as valid jury nullification."

In 1997, the Second Circuit ruled that jurors can be removed if there is evidence that they intend to nullify the law, under Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure 23(b). [ 35 ]

as officers of the court , attorneys have sworn an oath to uphold the law, and are ethically prohibited from directly advocating for jury nullification . [ 36 ]

Also,

Today, there are several issues raised by jury nullification, such as whether:

  1. juries can or should be instructed or informed of their power to nullify.
  2. a judge may remove jurors "for cause" when they refuse to apply the law as instructed.
  3. a judge may punish a juror for exercising the power of jury nullification.

Can we declare "IMPASSE" at this point?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Peace to you and your family, my friend.

We will converse again after Christmas.

 
 

Who is online





89 visitors