O ne consequence of the botched launch of Obamacare is that it has, judging from his plummeting numbers with Millennials, diminished Barack Obamas cool. Its not merely that the website isnt state-of-the-art but that the art its flailing to be state of is that of the mid-20th-century social program. The emperor has hipster garb, but underneath hes just another Commissar Squaresville. So, health care being an irredeemable downer for the foreseeable future, this week the president pivoted (as they say) to economic inequality, which will be, he assures us, his principal focus for the rest of his term. And whats his big idea for this new priority? Stand well back: He wants to increase the minimum wage!
Meanwhile, Jeff Bezos of Amazon (a non-government website) is musing about delivering his products to customers across the country (and the planet) within hours by using drones.
Drones! If theres one thing Obama can do, its drones. Hes renowned across Yemen and Waziristan as the Dominos of drones. If hed thought to have your health-insurance-cancellation notices dropped by drone, Obamacare might have been a viable business model. Yet, even in Obamas sole area of expertise and dominant market share, the private sector is already outpacing him.
Who has a greater grasp of the economic contours of the day after tomorrow Bezos or Obama? My colleague Jonah Goldberg notes that the day before the presidents speech on inequality, Applebees announced that it was introducing computer menu tablets to its restaurants. Automated supermarket checkout, 3D printing, driverless vehicles...what has the minimum wage to do with any of that? To get your minimum wage increased, you first have to have a minimum-wage job.
In my book (which I shall forbear to plug, but is available at Amazon, and with which Jeff Bezos will be happy to drone your aunt this holiday season), I write:
Once upon a time, millions of Americans worked on farms. Then, as agriculture declined, they moved into the factories. When manufacturing was outsourced, they settled into low-paying service jobs or better-paying cubicle jobs so-called professional services often deriving from the ever swelling accounting and legal administration that now attends almost any activity in America. What comes next?
Or, more to the point, what if there is no next?
What do millions of people do in a world in which, in Marxian terms, capital no longer needs labor? Americas liberal elite seem to enjoy having a domestic-servant class on hand, but, unlike the Downton Abbey crowd, are vaguely uncomfortable with having them drawn from the sturdy yokel stock of the village, and thus favor, to a degree only the Saudis can match, importing their maids and pool-boys from a permanent subordinate class of cheap foreign labor. Hence the fetishization of the undocumented, soon to be reflected in the multi-million bipartisan amnesty for those willing to do the jobs Americans wont do.
So what jobs will Americans get to do? We dignify the new age as the knowledge economy, although, to the casual observer, it doesnt seem to require a lot of knowledge. One of the advantages of Obamacare, according to Nancy Pelosi, is that it will liberate the citizenry: Think of an economy where people could be an artist or a photographer or a writer without worrying about keeping their day job in order to have health insurance. Its certainly true that employer-based health coverage distorts the job market, but whats more likely in a world without work? A new golden age of American sculpture and opera? Or millions more people who live vicariously through celebrity gossip and electronic diversions? One of the differences between government health care in America compared to, say, Sweden is the costs of obesity, heart disease, childhood diabetes, etc. In an ever more sedentary society where fewer and fewer have to get up to go to work in the morning, is it likely that those trends will diminish or increase?
Consider Vermont. Unlike my own state of New Hampshire, it has a bucolic image: Holsteins, dirt roads, the Vermont Teddy Bear Company, Ben & Jerrys, Howard Dean...And yet the Green Mountain State has appalling levels of heroin and meth addiction, and the social chaos that follows. Geoffrey Norman began a recent essay in The Weekly Standard with a vignette from a town I know very well St. Johnsbury, population 7,600, motto Very Vermont, the capital of the remote North-East Kingdom hard by the Quebec border and as far from urban pathologies as you can get. Or so youd think. But on a recent Saturday morning, Norman reports, there were more cars parked at the needle-exchange clinic than at the farmers market. In Vermont, theres no inner-city underclass, because there are no cities, inner or outer; theres no disadvantaged minorities, because theres only three blacks and seven Hispanics in the entire state; theres no nothing. Which is the real problem.
Large numbers of Vermonters have adopted the dysfunctions of the urban underclass for no reason more compelling than that theres not much else to do . Once upon a time, St. Johnsbury made Fairbanks scales, but now a still handsome town is, as Norman puts it, hollowed out by the loss of work and purpose. Their grandparents got up at four in the morning to work the farm and their great-great-great-whatever-parents slogged up the Connecticut River, cleared the land, and built homes and towns and a civilization in the wilderness. And now? A couple of months back, I sat in the caf in St. Johnsbury, and overheard a state official and a Chamber of Commerce official discuss enthusiastically how the town could access some federal funds to convert an abandoned building into welfare housing.
Work and purpose are intimately connected: Researchers at the University of Michigan, for example, found that welfare payments make one unhappier than a modest income honestly earned and used to provide for ones family. It drains too much of the life from life, said Charles Murray in a speech in 2009. And that statement applies as much to the lives of janitors even more to the lives of janitors as it does to the lives of CEOs. Self-reliance work is intimately connected to human dignity purpose.
So what does every initiative of the Obama era have in common? Obamacare, Obamaphones, Social Security disability expansion, 50 million people on food stamps... The assumption is that mass, multi-generational dependency is now a permanent feature of life. A coastal elite will devise ever smarter and slicker trinkets, and pretty much everyone else will be a member of either the dependency class or the vast bureaucracy that ministers to them. And, if youre wondering why every Big Government program assumes youre a feeble child, thats because a citizenry without work and purpose is ultimately incompatible with liberty . The elites think a smart society will be wealthy enough to relieve the masses from the need to work. In reality, it would be neo-feudal, but with fatter, sicker peasants. It wouldnt just be economic inequality, but a far more profound kind, and seething with resentments.
One wouldnt expect the governing class to be as far-sighted as visionaries like Bezos. But its hard to be visionary if youre pointing in the wrong direction. Which is why the signature achievement of Obamas hope and change combines 1940s British public-health theories with 1970s Soviet supermarket delivery systems. But dont worry: Maybe one day soon, your needle-exchange clinic will be able to deliver by drone. Look out below.
Mark Steyn , a National Review columnist, is the author of After America: Get Ready for Armageddon . 2013 Mark Steyn
Excerpt from "Don't Eat the Bread of Shame" by Rabbi Marc D. Angel
..More than just dignity, but it removes the opportunity and incentive to better oneself economically, but also, why go to college if it doesn't 'buy' a better future; if it was just about knowledge and learning past and proven concepts, we could go to the library and accomplish the same thing. It's about lowering the standards and competition from certain groups and individuals, and giving them away to another, the same goals as NATO and other failed concepts. Dumbing down the nation, so that emerging nations don't have to compete with a higher intelligence and standard.
Hi Chloe,
You have to explain your comparison of college, competition andNATO more. I got lost somewhere.
Having come from a poor family of immigrants, I went to college to do better than my waiter father by studying engineering. As you point out, a profession lessens the competition somewhat with respect to jobs that offer easy entry.
However college should be more than trade school. It is the difference between education and training.
Hi Len,
I'm not sure what more to say. Was my comment not on par with the 'point' of the article? i.e. this:
My comment was purporting the 'reasoning' behind that, as I see it...especially significant with the onset of Globalism and the proposed TPP, lowering the copyright standards, changing internet regulations among a few issues that address lowering individual rights, opportunities, IQ and standards that might be higher than someone else's...so that everyone else can take credit for and/or reduce the effects of the unique intelligence, innovation and creations of the individual.
Collect subsidies, I guess. Although, who's paying for them if very few are working---just keep printing it up and borrowing from other countries?
Marx's paradigm...capitalism--to socialism--to communism...and as Russia proved, it doesn't work, so it leads to revolution...and we start over again?
Errant nonsense, as usual from you, John.
You have not answered my question: How do you want to avoid income inequality?
Are you a Communist?
Obama-supporting industrialists, GE, GM, are shipping jobs out of the country.
Obama's Outsourcing Allies | Washington Free Beacon
Outsourcer-In-Chief: Obama Of General Motors - Forbes
Even The CEOs On Obama's Job Creation Panel Are Shipping Jobs ...
Obama, GM & Jeff Immelt all sent jobs overseas , why is this ...
How is it more meaningless than your question to which I responded, namely:
Is ":guaranteed income" the same as income equality?
Social security and Medicare are returns on investment during working lives.
No work, no investment. Where does the money come from? Are you prepared to pay $1000 for a quart of milk as in 1920s Germany, when the Treasury starts throwing money out of helicopters (like housing stamps, auto stamps, etc.)?
How come Russia and China, after long experience with Communism, are turning capitalist even as leftists here long for Communism???
This verbose article was written by Mark Steyn who is a Syndicated columnist and is a purely an opinion piece. It was published in the Orange County Register.
In the world of journalism, an opinion article is not governed by rules of proof and evidence, so its author can play loose with the facts, if they even exist in an opinion article. In the case of Mr Steyns essay, facts are not necessary as he is preaching to the choira choir that will docilely eat up and accept what he says without question.
Take for example the Bezos trope Steyn uses to tie his patchwork together; it was a publicity stunt. Any educated person familiar with science and logistics immediately saw through this Bezoss charade, yet it did capture the publics attention if only for a brief time. So already, you have an article based on a joke.
The fact is, Steyns article is one massive collection of tropes, clichs, metaphors and hyperbole, loosely bound together with conservative idealistic pabulum which appeals to the right. Devoid of meaningful content, he rambles on using cherry picked facts so blown out of proportion; it hurts the educated mind to read this slop.
Apparently the Orange County Register paid Steyn to publish this. Perhaps next time, they can just reprint something from the dreaded American Thinker and save a few bucks.
John, $15 an hour was voted in for our airport district, however, Alaska Air is saying the issue still needs to be taken to court. I don't know if they can fight it, but instead of pressuring the businesses, it appears the voters' measure can affect this issue.
Hey John, since the Unabomber is no longer with us and you are a supporter, perhaps you should consider continuing his program for improving the nation.