╌>

Without Merit - Cherokee Nation slams Capobiancos’ compensation claims

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  1stwarrior  •  13 years ago  •  29 comments

Without Merit - Cherokee Nation slams Capobiancos’ compensation claims

http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/enewsletters/ictweeklydecember42013-152519

The Cherokee Nation has delivered a trenchant 50-page dismissal of attempts by the adoptive parents in the Baby Veronica case to recover legal costs they incurred during their four-year custody battle.

The Cherokee presented their response on November 22 after Matt and Melanie Capobianco filed suit in county court in Nowata, Oklahoma seeking $1 million in compensation in the case of Adoptive Couple v. Baby Girl.

The couple had previously filed similar litigation in South Carolina, seeking roughly $500,000 in that state. The South Carolina suit was begun in September, immediately following the transfer of Veronica Brown to the Capobiancos custody. Her biological father, Dusten Brown relinquished her to the Capobiancos after losing the long-running case in the U.S. Supreme Court in June.

In its response to the Capobiancos, the tribe bluntly told District Judge Curtis DeLapp that it is not responsible for paying the couples fees and costs because its Eleventh Amendment sovereign offers immunity from suits without its express consent. In addition, the tribe said that the statute under which the couple is seeking compensation, the Uniform Child Custody and Jurisdiction Enforcement Act, is not applicable to the tribe.

In their filing, the tribe declared that its intervention into the case does not imply or denote any type of waiver of immunity or responsibility to the adoptive couple. The Indian Child Welfare Act, which was intended to set minimum federal standards and limit the authority of states, cannot arguably authorize suit against a tribe, the tribe wrote. The ICWA provisions put responsibilities on states. In fact, nothing in ICWA requires anything of the tribe and only provides rights to the tribe including the right to intervene in state court proceedings. Without express language by Congress that such intervention would authorize suit against the tribe or permit the award of attorneys fees, this court cannot award fees.

The response points out that in over 1,000 Indian Child Welfare cases...not one single court has ever held that intervention into a state proceeding pursuant to ICWA allows for the award of attorneys fees against the tribe.

An Oklahoma lawyer who declined to be identified because of the sensitivity of the case said that the Cherokee have the stronger argument.

First, the tribe is a sovereign nation and cannot be sued without its express consentand to my knowledge the Cherokee Nation is not in the habit of waiving their immunity, he said. Second, this is a domestic case, one in which both the Capobiancos and Dusten Brown were represented pro bono, which was widely understood by everyone on both sides.

To come after the fact asking for fees that the adoptive couple would not have had to pay had they lost, it then becomes a contingency case. Contingency fees are never awarded in domestic relations, so thats a null.

Finally, he concluded, you cannot sue in Oklahoma for work performed in other courts and jurisdictions, whether its another county, state or even the Supreme Court. That is just ludicrous and would open the door to chaos in parties going all over the United States seeking compensation and awards in multiple jurisdictions. They can only ask for fees relevant to the case that was before that specific court. The case in Nowata County only had two hearings and a few filings.

But what is concerning is that they are claiming some 2,000 hours and fees in both states totaling some $1 million, which will not fly with any judge.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Bottom Line: Mustering an array of arguments, the Cherokee Nation is arguing that the adoptive parents of Baby Veronica do not deserve to be compensated for four years worth of legal costs in the agonizing custody case.

You need to read the entire article. This case was nothing more than greed, self-aggrandizement, ego, money and power. The Capobianco's had no desire for Veronica - they just wanted to see their name in lights - and they got what they wished for.Frown.gif

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

The fact is they widely publicized the fact they were getting their legal representation pro bono. Now they want to be compensated for fees they never owed. Don't know the law on this, but it seems to be they're trying to punish the tribe for standing up for the rights of their tribe members.

These people broke the law and got away with it. I sure hope they aren't allowed to profit from their illegal snatching of a child.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

They are a political body - that's what they do - ICWA is a political law based on a political status.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

They were embarrassed in the first two court cases in SC and they are seeking revenge for the law going against them.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Don't think he needs to advise them - he needs to just show them.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

What scumbags these people are. They deserve nothing, less than nothing.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Second, this is a domestic case, one in which both the Capobiancos and Dusten Brown were represented pro bono, which was widely understood by everyone on both sides."

So, if it was so widely understood, why are they suing for what was free?

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    13 years ago

My take on the law suit:

Sure it was pro bono. The Capobianco lawyers knew all along, whether or not they won or lost the case, that they could take the Cherokee Nation (the deepest pockets) to court and attempt to make a few bucks seeking compensation. Doing so was no skin off the lawyers ass and might end up making them a few bucks. All they had to do was approach the Capobianco family and get them to go along with with the suit by promising them that they might pocket some money, too.

I don't think this lawsuit is any more complicated than that. It's the lawyers filing a few papers it took them an afternoon to type up here and there and they may hit the jackpot, maybe not. It's gambling, plain and simple.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Interesting Robert. Now read ICWA 101. The "parent" has the right to stop the proceedings ANYTIME prior to the final adoption. Dusten applied, well within the timeframe, for custodial rights as a "parent" and was awarded those rightsby the Family Court of SC and the Supreme Court of South Carolina.

Judge Alito said this case WAS NOT about ICWA and ruled according to what Justice Roberts wanted.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    13 years ago

It often does. Fathers are seen as the least favorable option in many cases. Very sad.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Wrong vision Robert - wrong decision per the law.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Per Justice Sotomayor, if the court had followed the law and Congress's intent, Veronica would still be with her father -

"Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote a dissent in which she argued that the majoritys opinion distorted the statute and led to a result that was both contrary to Congress intent and potentially devastating to Baby Girl. Additionally, she argued that the majority completely ignores Congress policy reasons for passing the ICWA and distorts the clear provisions in the act. Finally, Justice Sotomayor stated that the majoritys interpretation of the ICWA applies adversely to all noncustodial Indian parents, regardless of whether those parents actively participated in their childs upbringing. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Justice Elena Kagan joined in the dissent, and Justice Antonin Scalia joined in part. In his separate dissent, Justice Antonin Scalia argued that the majoritys definition of the phrase, continued custody, should have also included future custody. He also wrote that the majoritys decision needlessly demeans the right of parenthood by removing a fathers right to raise his child."

But, Justice's Roberts and Thomas, who are both adoptive parents, pushed for the adoptive parents - Kennedy, Beyer and Alito toed the line with the Chief Justice - as they usually do.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

If anything, the Nation should be suing the Capobianco's for theft, lying, abuse, misdirection and numerous other specifications.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Sorry Robert, but we've had this discussion before and you lost then. ICWA is a political, not a racial law. Hollyfield v. Choctaw Band of Indians of Mississippi, SCOTUS stated that ICWA was for the protection of the tribe - not the race.

"Is the ICWA a racist policy, or one established to protect Indian Culture?

To accurately answer the question, we first must understand the term "racism". Racism , by its simplest definition, is the belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race.

This is not a belief held by Indian Tribes, nor is it referenced to in the definition of ICWA . In fact, ICWA begins by clearly stating that the intent of the law is to ensure security and stability to Tribes and Children of the Tribes, as well as respecting the continued existence of cultural and social standards of the tribes. It is, therefore, a policy protecting the culture of Natives in America.

To summarize this short argument, before moving forward, it is necessary to reiterate the important fact that maintaining tribal integrity is NOT racist - it is a means of cultural survival ."

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Actually, again, no. SCOTUS is "required" to ensure that "This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made , or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land ;and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding."

ICWA was passed to ensure the perpetuity of Indian tribes, as guaranteed by treaties, statutes, laws, Executive Orders and Memorandum, is continued. The "Indian Self-Determination and Educational Assistance Act" guarantees tribal self-governance and their culture/traditions/heritage will be continued and protected by the U.S.

The decision made by SCOTUS was incorrect and did not follow nor adhere to ICWA (see Sotomayer's comments below) because of bias by the Chief Justice, an adoptive father.

And, yes, the LAW says ICWA is a political act, not a racial act. (BTW - Prebbiesterrians are not Political bodies - overweight, out-of-shape, frumpy bodies, but not political).Grin.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

WWWHHHOOOAAAAAA !!!!!!! "It is based on blood lines."?????

Nowhere, absolutely NOWHERE in the law are blood lines mentioned. Have you gotten into your stash early today?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

How're you doing Rescue?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

BF - SCOTUS ruled against the father on exactly those grounds - he wasn't there when Veronica was born, so he can't be the father. How friggin' stupid is that?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

Oh, and Robert - for your enhancement and enjoyment - "Indian tribes are "distinct, independent political communities, retaining their original natural rights" in matters of local self-government. Worcester v. Georgia, 6 Pet. 515, 559 (1832) ; see United States v. Mazurie, 419 U. S. 544, 557 (1975) ; F. Cohen, Handbook of Federal Indian Law 122-123 (1945). Although no longer "possessed of the full attributes of sovereignty," they remain a "separate people, with the power of regulating their internal and social relations." United States v. Kagama, 118 U. S. 375, 381-382 (1886) ."

Might be helpful for future discussions to read the above cases. Maybe you'll understand that Indian tribes are sovereign nations within the United States.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    13 years ago

What's your argument? The Capobianco's are attempting to sue the Cherokee Nation - can't due to sovereign immunity - for costs they didn't have - shit in one hand, wish in another - for activities that took place in another state that the Cherokee Nation was/is not located nor does their jurisidiction spread to South Carolina

 
 

Who is online



JohnRussell


101 visitors