Businesses Win in U.S. Court Ruling on Worker Arbitration Pacts
U.S. employers can use arbitration agreements to require employees to resolve disputes on an individual basis, a federal appeals court has ruled, marking a victory for companies and a setback for labor groups
In a 2-1 ruling on Tuesday, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a January 2012 National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) decision that had invalidated such an arbitration agreement used by homebuilder D.R. Horton Inc. ( DHI.N ).
The case had been closely watched by business groups, employment lawyers and labor unions.
"It's an important victory not just for D.R. Horton, but for employers across the country who have struggled with this issue and the decisions coming out of the NLRB," said Ron Chapman, an attorney at Ogletree Deakins who represented the homebuilder.
Chapman said U.S. employers have struggled as class-action and collective-action litigation over workplace disputes has "sky-rocketed" in recent years.
The ruling by the New Orleans-based court was the first time a federal appeals court ruled directly on a key NLRB finding. The board has maintained that the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) cannot be used to prevent workers covered by the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) from resolving disputes as a group.
An NLRB spokesman said the board is "reviewing the court's decision." The NLRB is a federal government board that polices labor disputes and oversees union elections.
To mitigate legal risks, many employers have begun using arbitration agreements that must be signed by workers as a condition of employment. The agreements contain class-action waivers that bar workers from pursuing arbitration as a group.
But the NLRA protects the rights of private-sector workers to organize and take collective action to improve working conditions. So, the board has said, arbitration agreements cannot bar workers from bringing collective claims.
The 5th Circuit said the NLRA generally does protect taking collective action, but does not specifically address arbitration. There is no evidence that Congress intended the NLRA to override the FAA, the panel wrote.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/12/03/us-usa-employment-horton-idUSBRE9B21B320131203

It seems likely that this case will end up with the 9 Wise Ones in Washington
D. R. Horton is the largest residential house builder[1] in the United States based on its 18,890 houses sold and posted a profit of $956 million in the 12 months that ended Sept. 30, 2012.
I guess US real estate is doing OK ... until the current investor bubble pops ?
Expecting a lawyer representing a firm to express accurate info for dissemination is likely overly optimistic .
Shitty employers ? D. R. Horton is likely to get hammered in the next real estate retraction so many of their workers will be subject to layoffs .
Petey
What do you see in that statement hat is inaccurate?
Barb - btco
Yes that s exactly the point of the article and what we should all take away from the court decision thanks for putting it so concisely
If an employee signs an arbitration agreement as a condition of employment shouldn't the employee be obligated to abide by that agreement just as employers abide by the provisions of employment agreements?
Petey
When is the next real estate retraction going to occur?
Please enlighten us
How many businesses will take the risk of operating in one of the most corrupt cities/states in the United States? Ill betthat linelooks like Macys on Black Friday [insert sarcasm here].
One M
I am tired today but I am not sure what you mean here
Businesses, like the population have fleed Detroit/Michigan.
The sarcasm is that I'll bet the line to sign up, to come back to Michigan, is NOT like Macy's on Black Friday. *wink, wink, say no more*
One M
I think you might be on the wrong article with the comment
This article is about a court ruling on binding arbitration versus class action suits
I would be surprised if a lawyer with a vested interest didn't exaggerate by using a term like "sky-rocket" .
Maybe I misunderstood the headline: "Businesses Win ..."
How do they win when the Michigan/Detroit economy sucks so bad half the population has left? Businesses have left en mass too,as it all fell apart. It also makes for a fertile business environment(again sarcasm),if you throw the corruption brick through the window too.
As to the court decision itself, the businesses that are concerned, only care about recouping losses form the bankruptcy, which hasn't been decided. And they will lose money, it a question of how much.
Neither is an optimistic business model.
I can't answer when . But from what I have been reading , the current surge in real estate prices is due to investors , not home owners . If that is accurate there is no practical floor on pricing when things turn around .
Petey
Your reasoning is correct but that same combination of investors and home buyers is part of the daily up and down of the real estate market it is nothing that unusual
Businesses won a court case that is relevant in every city in the country and is not directly tied to anything good or bad in Detroit.
And the court case has nothing whatsoever to do with bankruptcy in Detroit or anywhere else
Please read the article
It is all a matter of the ratio of home buyers to investors . If that ratio is very low it is unusual ... and dangerous .
Sorry about that, senior moment. You are correct.
One M
I have those moments myself
NO worries
Barb
You should be happy then because this decision will limit the number of class action suits
The decision is about the legality of employment agreements which contain binding individual arbitration clauses and this court says they are legal and binding
No doubt there are situations where the employee is treated badly or unfairly, but there are likewise untrue claims and nuisance suits as well. If the arbiter in the case, normally a magistrate or other outside, approaches his/her role ethically then he individual arbitration process works.
Petey
That would depend on what the investors do with the properties.
If they are improved and resold then they are adding value to the market
BadFish
After a career in HR I could not agree with you more that documentation of performance shortfalls and performance successes are the most important thing a manager and business owner can do in order to properly reward the good employees and discipline/terminate the poor performers without discrimination.