Illinois Legislature OKs Fix for $100B Pension Crisis
The Illinois Legislature approved a historic plan Tuesday to eliminate the state's $100 billion pension shortfall, a vote that proponents described as critical to repairing the state's deeply troubled finances but that faces the immediate threat of a legal challenge from labor unions.
The House voted 62-53 in favor of the plan, sending it to Gov. Pat Quinn, who has said he will sign it. The Senate approved the measure 30-24 just minutes earlier.
"There will be changes here, much-needed changes, but this bill is a well thought out, well-balanced bill that deserves the support of this body, the state Senate and the approval of Gov. Quinn," House Speaker Michael Madigan said at the start of the House debate. "Something's got to be done. We can't go on dedicating so much of our resources to this one sector of pensions."
Public employee unions, who oppose the bill, vowed to quickly take legal action. They say the legislation is unfair to workers and retirees who for years made faithful contributions to retirement systems but now will see benefits cut because of government mismanagement. They also argue parts of the measure are unconstitutional.
Illinois' unfunded pension problem is considered the worst in the nation, primarily because lawmakers failed for decades to make the state's full payments to the funds. The massive unfunded liability has led the major credit rating agencies to downgrade Illinois' rating to the lowest of any state in the nation. It's also siphoned money from education, roads and other areas.
Yet for years, lawmakers have been unable to agree on how to fix the problem.
The measure approved Tuesday emerged last week following negotiations by a bipartisan pension conference committee and then meetings of Illinois' legislative leaders. They say it will save the state $160 billion over 30 years and fully fund the systems by 2044.
It would push back the retirement age for workers ages 45 and younger, on a sliding scale. The annual 3 percent cost-of-living increases for retirees would be replaced with a system that only provides the increases on a portion of benefits, based on how many years a beneficiary was in their job. Some workers would have the option of freezing their pension and starting a 401(k)-style defined contribution plan.
Workers will contribute 1 percent less to their own retirement under the plan. Legislative leaders say they included that provision, as well as language that says the retirement systems may sue the state if it doesn't make its annual payments, in hopes of boosting the measure's odds of surviving the unions' anticipated court challenge.
Quinn and the legislative leaders reached out to a number of lawmakers over recent days, urging them to support the bill.
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory/ill-lawmakers-prepare-pension-vote-21075890

A solution to a budget crisis which could keep Chicago from following Detroit down the bankruptcy path
The legal challenges will come quickly and in bunches, in my view, but I think these changes will survive the scrutiny of the courts
BaFish
That is a lot of hyperbole and rhetoric in such a short comment
I am sure that many may disagree with your perspective but I thank you for sharing your views
BadFish
No
Nor do I think that this change in the pension funding process is austerity, but rather a necessary change for the continued solvency and viability of pension plans in Illinois
As is true in most complex problems, there is no single solution to fiscal problem in Illinois or anywhere else
I just became incorporated... One Miscreant, Inc.
This corporation is going to go out andenter into a contract to purchase a large ticket item or two, like a car,house, building, time share in theCaribbeanor maybe even a yacht, promising to pay my creditors lots of money every month.
Next, I'll piss away all my money in bad investments, parties, etc. and totally mismanage every red cent. I'll declare bankruptcy; chapterOM will do, and tell the bank they'll have to accept less in each monthly payment.
I wonder, if I'll get away with it?
After all, others do it all the time, establishing the precedent for corporate persons like me, am I right? The bank will not be "entitled to their monthly entitlements. They will just have to make due with a lesser amount. It sounds more than fair to me. It's for the good of the economy.
One M
The shift to the absurd clearly proves the point, just as you would have no money to pay your creditors if you followed your plan, the city of Detroit has no money to pay its creditors.
Ergo bankruptcy and a new beginning is the answer
Detroit did not as you put it "get away with it", the city and its people are paying the price for the malfeasance and ineptitude of the people they elected over the years
BadFish
Thanks for sharing the information
Good to know how it works (or does it)
But wait...
I'm in business to make money/supply services to my peeps. How does bankruptcy achieve that goal? My favorite fishmonger could have something here. Hide all my assets, then go belly up. Thanks BF, I need a CFO.
And yes mr Robert, Detroit did get away with it, for decades it was mismanaged and money intended for workers was taken. The workers are paying for the theft, not the thieves.
There's been a lot of discussion of the "problem of income inequality" in the U.S.
What a lot of people fail to realize is that taxpayer's funding generous pensions to one segment of the population (members of unions of workers in the public sector) actually increases the disparity been them and the unemployed (and those working at or near minimum wage).
Some workers would have the option of freezing their pension and starting a 401(k)-style defined contribution plan....Workers will contribute 1 percent less to their own retirement under the plan
OMG!, did all the dems in the legislature leave the state on NBC's dime for a while? did OWS wannabes deficate in the state capital building? is the DNC going to fund a recall of the gov? will maddow, schultzand Matthews spew personal attacks against Quinnad nauseum for weeks?
if not, could it be because unlike wisc, I don't believe this gives union workers the option of paying dues. you see, the liberal machine could care less about the worker, its all about power and money!
The flip sideall that "elite class" money goes to the local economy, that is until they move to Florida.
So, I guess that means anything you earn, you just let others take?
One M
You are correct that some workers will pay a price for the malfeasance and misconduct of others but that does not detract from the fact that the changes are in the best interest of the many (the state and cities) going forward
Krish
Support for or opposition to unionization is beside the point that the agreement made with the workers will be breached as part of the reorganization bankruptcy.
One M
Excellent point
Whether one is pro union or not, we tend to guard that which we see as ours
It seems so many of these localities hadn't realized what they were getting into when they first agreed to such generous use of taxpayer money. But that's an interesting point-- how can they get out of these agreements which are (or were) legally binding...?
JoAnne
You were almost there discussing the issue, then off you went to the MSNBC talking heads and Wisconsin etc
Egilman
"blindly" would be determined by who was looking at the holding on, the person the stuff belonged to and wanted it for his family or the person who wanted toredistribute it to others
But you are right taking care of ourselves also must entail taking care of the society and everyone should contribute to that end
It's not blind E, it's bargained in good faith. The faith is where the problem arises. The Funding was mismanaged and no one can dispute that issue. But because the city is bigger than the individual, the individual must suffer the consequences of intentional malfeasance. They must suffer the crimes against them as a whole, because the city is greater as a whole? No sir.
When an entire class of taxpaying citizens is wronged, they must not be made whole for the greater good? It's total Bullshit to think the pension they are owed is excessive or not relevant.
I find the very notion of this abhorrent, morally devoid of substance and a linchpin to class warfare. At a minimum, all that money paid-in by the workers is still theirs. It does not belong to Ali Babba and his forty thieves. Workers demand to be made whole and that should be part of the solution.
If what you wrote is true, then why is this settlement(Illini fix), before bankruptcy such a great thing? Why are other cities states trying to negotiate before it get's that far. Why? Because bankruptcy is not the only way. Nor making an entire class of workers move closer to the poverty line in their retirement.
One M
My opinion (and it is only an opinion) is that the situation in Illinois is not as severe (yet) as the one in Detroit and a systemic change is a logical solution since the issue facing Illinois is the under funded pension and other creditors are not yet an issue there
Krish
The contracts (agreements) made with all the creditors, bondholders and the workers are being breached and the fair approach is for all the creditors to share the burden rather than one group being treated differently from the other creditors.
So, because you are not at the limit of your credit card, thenthere isnot or will not be a problem in repayment? Likewise, since the Illini debt isn't some insane number, like Detroit, there isn't a problem? It's not the debt which is the problem in these issues, my friend. It's the behaviors which led to the debt that is the problem. If not addressed we are doomed to repeat them
So, the solution is that the city/state must still pay that which is owed, in a way that does not reward fiscal hokey pokey. That may mean that payments may be delayed or stretched out, but creditor, pensioners, et al, must be made whole. The city/state can still conduct business, although at a lesser scale than is needed, but in Detroits case it will most likely be a higher level than they have presently.
Egilman
Everyone, in other words all creditors, should be treated the same
One M
Illinois IMHO is taking a proactive step to avoid the state or its cities ending up in a fiscal bind as bad as Detroit's situation and I for one hoe it works.
Fair enough. But, if you had, like the unions do,the resources to fight "city hall", would you? I'll answer for you, "yes" and that would not be selfish, IMO. That is the sole purpose for organizations across the board, and that includes lobbyist et al, it combine resources for just such situations, to fight as one.
However, when you set a precedent in the fight, it does carry over to the non-union arena. Protection of workers rights benefits all workers.
One M
Good point about worker's rights
And now a question for you -
Do you think the other creditors or bondholders should ever be treated more harshly (by a state or city) in order to treat the public sector unions better?
No I do not. I think bankruptcy laws today reward mediocrity and criminal activity. They are not used as intended, protecting law breakers, when it has always been the creditors who decide how assets are liquidated. The debtors have no say or at least shouldn't.
In the case of public pensions, numerous cases besides this one, have shown that there are ways around bankruptcy. Gov Corbett (R-PA) has tried numerous times to pass legislation in this regard. He has been rebuffed, because the debtor doesn't carry the same weight of the creditor. Why? Contract law.
Hiding behind bankruptcy laws is a tool to escape the criminal prosecution. Because, if a new agreement is reached, it supercedes the previous contract(s).
One M
Thanks for the response and perspective
Remember as yet there is no bankruptcy in Illinois and hopefully these changes to the pension plans and retire benefit packages will mean that there never will be municipal bankruptcy in Illinois in the future