California GOP Launches Fake ACA Website in a Massive Disinformation Campaign
California GOP Launches Fake ACA Website in a Massive Disinformation Campaign
http://thedailybanter.com/2013/12/california-gop-launches-fake-aca-website-in-a-massive-disinformation-campaign/
The latest attempt by the Republican Party to sabotage the Affordable Care Act will absolutely piss you off.
California Republicans specifically, GOP members of the states general assembly sent out mailers to their constituents informing them about the state exchange website, known as Covered California. Only, instead of sending voters to the actual Covered California exchange website, CoveredCA.com, the mailers direct Californians to go to CoveringHealthCareCA.com, which is most definitely not the California exchange.
Writing for Crooks & Liars, Karoli reported :
On their version, there are links to negative articles and twisted messages intended to sour people on signing up for health insurance before they ever land at the official health exchange site.
The fake website, created by the Assembly Republican caucus , tells seniors: Seniors on Medicare may not see changes immediately to their benefits or coverage. Down the line, however, the erosion and accessibility of care may become a problem.
Death panels. You wont be able to get medical care, seniors, because of Obamacare.
Additionally, the site tells young people: Young adults will end up paying for much of federal health care reform by subsidizing the cost of sicker people, or by paying a tax penalty if they do not obtain health insurance under the provisions of the individual mandate, which requires all Californians to have coverage beginning in 2014.
Instead of providing an insurance premium calculator, as many exchanges do, the fake GOP astroturf website features an individual mandate penalty calculator .
And three of the top four questions in the FAQ are in the form of cleverly negative spin against the ACA. The first question involves informing the scary IRS about your health insurance; the second question discusses how the ACA hasnt prevented rising healthcare costs (even though it was only implemented on October 1); the fourth question claims that there have been 18 tax increases due to the ACA, including an excise tax on businesses. I think you get the idea.
In other words, disguised as the official California exchange, California Assembly Republicans (noted and linked at the bottom of every page on the site), using state money to send these mailers, are conducting a massive disinformation campaign preventing their own voters from buying health insurance.
I told you it would piss you off.

Bring on the equivocation!
If anyone were to say to a Tea Party member
"I hope your elderly parent goes to this website, believes its lies, consequently fails to obtain health insurance and dies " rightfully that person should be castigated and repudiated mercilessly.
And this, in essence, is exactly what those who generate and spread the lies about "Obamacare" are hoping, although the followers have made themselves believe the lies because they want to discredit the President.
Blind hatred has many dangers.
Providing misinformation and prioritizing everything but the pluses is more like it.
There are restrictions on the freedom of expression -- the First Amendment is not an absolute right to lie; if it were, the charge pf perjury, among other things, would be unconstitutional.
As I requested, the equivocation is upon us.
The Tea Party launched that one, Robert G.
And no one dares to address
Because the scenario of deceiving individuals into going without health insurance could indeed end in deaths as a result.
Well, there you have it, AMac--
No addressing the actual issue, not even 'equivocation'... you can have your choice of two responses thus far: outright denial of the validity of the entire repulsivescenario, or a one-line effort at diversion. Swamijim bets a sawbuck you won't hear anything except variations on those themes, until of course you get JAO and the typical "non-sequitur Obama bla-bla-bla"...
Check some of the comments in this thread and you'll see.
Please detail the false information provided on the website. What language, specifically, do you feel is not protected by the First Amendment? There is alot of hysteria and incendiary language being thrown about here and precious little in the way of rebuttals. I see one misstatement on the website, that there are three plans as opposed to three levels of plans. Hardly earth shattering. Everything else is true, if not convenient for supporters of the ACA. I don't think the First Amendment requires authors to spin facts in a DNC approved way.
I also see a falsehood in the linked blog, that the ACA only went into effect on October 1. Somehow I managed to refrain from calling the blogger a terrorist for his misstatement.
Its amazing that merely presenting facts on the internet is somehow beyond the pale to some people. Do you believe that the Republicans should only be allowed to publicize Obama approved facts? Or do you believe that the public at large is simply to stupid to process facts and arguments that you don't like? Is there a bureaucrat Republicans should apply to regarding what political speech is acceptable and what isn't?
The haters will relentless attack the web site problems and do so relentless in the hope of obfuscating the eventual good the ACA will bring about.
That's the right-wing hope I defined; you are clearly one of the "I hope he fails" crowd. Limbaugh trashes everything utilitarian including the pope for daring to sound Christ-like.
My hope is you won't go where you did before re: this reference; I won't plead your case if there's a next time.
Mike,
Instead of doing the straw man routine and attacking what hasn't been stated nor implied, address the fake website.
Sean,
It's in the article.
And just for you, Sean
There's a difference between a screw up with attempts to make corrections and AN INTENTIONAL PLAN TO DECEIVE AND DO SO FOR THE SPECIFIC PURPOSE OF PREVENTING PEOPLE FROM HAVING HEALTH INSURANCE -- THAT FOR POLITICAL REASONS WHICH INCLUDES THROWING THE HATERS A BONE.
The ACA site is for the purpose of assisting people obtain health care.
The fake site is to frighten them away from doing so; unconscionable!
How Will We Know If HealthCare.gov Is Fixed?
And yet, here we are.
Screw ups and bad information, no argument; and we will see in time which of those statements ultimately stand as such.
But to produce a website SPECIFICALLY MEANT TO MISLEAD is a different situation and the equivocating on that is as I predicted.
So what do you say Mike? Is the California site dishonest and meant to cause ACA to fail, not of its own accord, but with the help of an orchestrated pack of lies?
Attempts to fix a screw up and bad information is a long way away from trying to destroy by deception.
Down the road, if the ACA succeeds, the screw ups will, in perspective, be left behind. BUT THE RIGHT-WING LIES AND ATTEMPTS TO SABOTAGE WILL BE KEPT IN THE FOREFRONT.
One of the two parties is holding a losing hand and only time will tell. But intentional deception regardless, is not going to be sold to any but the Obama-haters.
Pelosi made a clumsy statement of course people had to see the law to know what was in it. Dumb, rhetorical, poorly expressed. BUT ARE YOU GOING TO COMPARE THAT TO THIS FRAUD BY INTENT IN CALIFORNIA.
Is the site a scam or not Mike?
Tell me tomorrow I'm going to sleep.
There is a world of difference between factually supported arguments and unsubstantiated conclusions. I was hoping for the former and you provided the latter. Unsupported, conclusory statements from a liberal propaganda factory like think progress are simply worthless.
I also note that you and the liberal blogger you approvingly cite are up in arms and make quite a production about "negative spin" and how apparently evil it is. Yet, you cut and paste the liberal bloggers "negative spin" about death panels without so much as a by your leave. The California site makes no mention of death panels, yet you have no problem "spinning" that it does.
Your blogger makes a number of unsupported conclusions about the supposed misinformation contained on the California Republicans site. I'm sure you and other readers capable of critical thought have already noticed that he doesn't bother to actually refute anything on the Republicans' site though. For my own edification, can you confirm you believe that the following statements are true. I assume they must true because they would rebut the only specific statements contained on the Republicans site that the blogger references. I'd also appreciate any authority you can provided to support them. By authority, I mean something other a conclusion by think progress that is devoid of any supporting facts.
1. That it is absolutely impossible that access and/or care may be diminished if doctor reimbursement rates are cut.
2. The ACA doesn't force young healthy taxpayers to pay a higher rate than their health dictates in order to subsidize the care of older insureds.
3. The individual mandate doesn't exist and/or taxpayers should not be allowed to know what their penalty would be for not purchasing insurance.
4, The IRS will not ask for proof of insurance
5. The ACA wasn't implemented before October 1, 2013.
6. The ACA doesn't contain at least 18 tax increases.
If you are correct and this terrorist act of a website is nothing but lies, these positions must all be true. I look forward to seeing how you support these claims.
ENTIONAL PLAN TO DECEIVE AND DO SO FOR THE SPECIFIC PURPOSE OF PREVENTING PEOPLE FROM HAVING HEALTH INSURANC
What an Orwellian world we have entered. Apprantly providing consumers with verifiable, true information about the ACA and publishing a website that links consumers directly to coveredca prevents them from having health insurance.
If an intentional plan to deceive is going on, its not being done by the Califonria Republicans. To see how silly these complaints about the site are, I would advise anyone with an open mind to go to the actual website. From the main page click on the huge link in the center "I don't have health Insurance." The consumer is then greeted with this:
"Under the Affordable Care Act, there are three ways for uninsured people without the option of employer-based coverage to get health insurance, based on income:
1) You can purchase insurance independently (through a licensed insurance broker or directly from a health insurance company).
2) You can buy a plan at the state's new health insurance marketplace called Covered California ."
3) You may also be covered by an expansion of Medi-Cal, the state government's health insurance program for low-income individuals and families.
How diabolical is that! Directly taking browsers to a link to the california exchange! How evil! Seriously, the website couldn't be more helpful and user friendly in directing the uninsured to covered ca
I meant to include this:
Once you click on the site you see how silly this whole tempest in a teapot is. The website couldn't be more straightforward. The site is clearly labeled as a resource guide, making claims about it being a "Fake" site ridiculous. Its a contains a link to coveredca right on the landing page!
The burden of proof is incumbent upon the entity bringing the allegations -- THE FAKE WEB SITE IS THAT ENTITY and the blogger has called them on their allegations.
The ACA, stumbling and fumbling as it has been, nevertheless puts its intentions on-the-record and has the responsibility to substantiate all of its claims and make them the realities; should it ultimately fail to do so, it will be to their detriment and demise.
An orchestrated pack of liars, whose intention is to deceive via a COUNTERFEIT website, does not have to deliver the goods BECAUSE IT OFFERS NO GOODS. Any schmuck or pack thereof can sit on the sidelines and take potshots.
The Tea Party would be that schmuck-pack were it an innocuous pile of shit; but far from innocuous, it is a hate-predicated, self-serving destruction machine that foists the "less government" bullshit on us while actually meaning "less government for everyone but the criminal rich who own our sorry asses and, more control of government for angry white men who once controlled our government and country but do not any longer."
Some people will literally die if they do not obtain health insurance; they will be diagnosed too late or not at all.
Fuck the evil, self-serving pieces of shit who have no concerns over that phenomenon.
The ACA websites ultimately have to be accountable in that they state what they offer and, should they ultimately fail to deliver, will suffer the consequences.
Unlike the ACA's on-the-record, put-up-or-shut-up status, the Republicans' lies offer nothing, not even viable alternatives to what they claim is wrong with the ACA. And from conception to implementation, the Tea Party/Republicans have been in sabotage/thwart mode.
Any a-hole can be a critic; as long as he offers no viable alternative to that which he criticizes, he lays nothing on the line THAT HE BELIEVES HE CAN'T SUBSEQUENTLY DENY OR WALK AWAY FROM.
But Mike, this isn't chess, it's LIFE and possibly DEATH!
Many significant endeavors have missed perfection by a long shot -- that doesn't negate whatever good eventually emerges.
If an insurer can no longer cancel a policy when a cancer-victim makes a claim, or, can no longer require a deductible so large that a claimant becomes bankrupt before seeing one penny from that insurer, these things, to a potentially, otherwise dead human being, have far greater importance than a fucked-up roll out of a program which hopefully becomes, literally, a LIFE-SAVER!
I repeat;
EG,
Under what circumstances did you lose your health insurance? Please, I'm asking.
Insurance policies charge deductibles and they vary; there will be a number of policy options, but, even with deductibles, would you argue that being denied coverage altogether is the alternative to paying a deductible?
The deductibles I refer to are the "junk policy" variety which in essence, cover virtually nothing and re virtually ALL PREMIUM AN DEDUCTIBLE.
Same answer; tell the guy with a spot on his lungs that he has to pay entirely out-of-pocket because he's been denied any coverage whatsoever. It's an imperfect world and an imperfect ACA, BUT IT'S MOVING US IN A BETTER DIRECTION THAN THE ONE WE'RE HOPING TO LEAVE BEHIND.
For the record, my gripe with President Obama is that he never advocated Single Payer and that we cut the balls off of the for-profit health insurance industry that takes thirty one cents of every premium dollar, and gives it to a CEO, wastes it and, heretofore, runs a claims-denial section!
And if the Republicans weren't the pimps for the health insurers et al, THEY'D SAY TO THE PRESIDENT, "Let's dump 'Obamacare' and go to Single Payer, that in the best interests of most Americans."
But they won't offer anything of the sort because they are simultaneously pimps AND prostitutes for Organized Wealth.
At lease from Democrats, the middle class and poor get the crumbs from the table, while Republicans try to stuff the whole cake in their mouths and ask the rest of us to pay for it.
They should go to PRISON!!!!!
Many will face extenuating and adverse circumstances but the ultimate blame, IMO, is on the Health Insurance Industry's profiteer model and the failure of both parties to have the political balls to allow a "public option" be it Medicare-for-all or some variation.
Heard from what source? I have no doubt you heard this; but these kinds of stories have been making the rounds and that's why I ask for source, chapter and verse.
Mike, I'm not bashing any source until
1) A story from that source is verified to indeed have come from that source,
2) The story can be debunked, particularly if that source has a history of "reporting" stories that are regularly debunked WITH SPECIFIC COUNTER POINTS
Check my history on going after sources; invariably I will first post information about that source's history, individuals and (paid for) agendas, and then counter the information I question.
From the linked article
AVIK ROY!
Until the story is verified, your indignation is valid but generic.
And all those who run with this and other unsubstantiated stories that cause outrage, should there be no validation, I'll look forward to their
Which will never come.
And we all know
Where is the link?
Your damned right it is! If someone raises an issue and does so as if it's gospel, if they can't validate/verify their contention but defend it nevertheless, it's
Zeal-without-knowledge
Discussion is just fine but insisting/insulting/mocking in the absence of verification, that's not discussion.
Shall I list some of the words and images used to describe Democrats and Obama. We can rightfully ascribe the double standard to both sides -- no argument. But issue-for-issue, when any faction waxes in absolutes without proof, it needs to be assailed.
Some discussions begin as debatable and remain that way because neither side of the debate has enough (or any) empirical information to make a final, definitive case; BUT, some arguments are more plausible than others and have more verifiable information on their side than others.
At some point, when all has been said and nothing more of value can be added or considered, I like to call an "IMPASSE".
In the case of this California Republican website, I personally view it as "fraud" in the same way I'd deem a counterfeit $20 bill a fraud. The name of the fake web site is more than coincidentally close to the web site it tries to imitate and discredit. An honest such site would identify itself clearly and let it be known UP FRONT that it existed to countermand the tenets of another, NOT BE A WOLF IN SHEEP'S CLOTHING.
Nothing biased in that assessment
Other than the assessment itself.
No, it would not.
One is the manifestation of bad planning and incompetence; the other is a bait and switch operation.
A potentially good product or service can suffer and/or be delayed by bad/incompetent planning that compromises distribution not the quality of the product once the marketing is right.
But a product knowingly disguised as another product is pure dishonesty. If someone wishes to discredit a product, by pretending to be that product in order to do so -- makes that someone A LIAR FROM THE GETGO!
If the truth is on one's side, there's no honorable reason to first lie in order to tell it!
From the link:
Correct me if the following questions have no analogous value.
When individuals file their taxes (Federal, State, Local, etc.), are their returns not scrutinized by the taxing entities, done so after the filing, and, where errors in calculations and/or fraud is suspected, actions and adjustments made?
When entrepreneurs/businesses/utilities, etc. are paid with credit accounts, are not billing errors, late payments, over/under payments not part of the real world of commerce?
Are such phenomena ideal -- or are they transacted as such for pragmatic reasons?
How viable in this economic world, are "cash only" at POP arrangements; can anyone name one we all would recognize?
I'm asking, not declaring and I'd like to know what people here think.
Yeah. Don't you see the irony. Calling out an alleged liar by starting with a lie?
I see a series of fuck ups being called out by a self-acclaimed "truth teller" who summoned those it deemed entitled to the truth, by starting with a lie.
California GOP Launches Fake ACA Website in a Massive Disinformation Campaign
I'm shocked I tell ya I'm SHOCKED!
In a sense, virtually all tax returns are filed with "estimated" bottom lines. It is the taxing body that evaluates each return to determine if the tax payer has "estimated" correctly that which is owed or that which is to be refunded.
Many contracts have PROVISOS -- I've negotiated a number of them. These fundamentally are in place often in the recognition that the unforeseen is part of the real world.
Virtually the case; thus business is done on an almost universal "promise" to deliver and "promise" to pay basis. My point exactly. Is it possible we might actually agree?
Logistically not a far distance from cry from an individual's tax return; "This is how much I dished out for charitable donations, this is what I dished out for medications, this is etc., etc. ." And if the government says "show me the receipts, the proof," and it's not forthcoming or plausible, the individual has a potential a problem.
If an insurer says "We paid x in subsidies" and the government is suspicious, or, simply wants to set an example, it will audit that insurer, make it produce proof of every penny it claims to have paid out, and if it can't, the story and the punishment will be on the evening news for all to see.
And if we want to truly address the phenomenon at-hand, let's get real and nail the corporate lobbyists who buy the legislators so that Organized Wealth can write the loopholes into the tax code.
As for "smelly,"
"A FISH SMELLS FROM THE HEAD DOWN!"
Good back-and-forth my friend!
why should the left hold a monopoly on fraud?
why should the left hold a monopoly on fraud? Well reasoned; Bush stole two elections
Well reasoned; Bush stole two elections, started a bullshit war, looked the other way when Wall Street nearly crashed the Global Economy but wait, there's more!
JoAnne, good call!
And, Good afternoon (or morning out your way).
did this site take 3 years and half a bill of hard earned tax money to produce?
Absolutely!
Damn Republican obstruction makes everything potentially worthwhile near impossible to impossible and thus more expensive because of logistical roadblocks intended to deny Obama, the American Middle Class and poor, their due.
JoAnne, you're on a roll today and it's still early.
Please share more of your insights (not to mention, incites).
And yet, you're still among my NT favorites. Really.
good day to you Amac sir!
fox at the presser yesterday asked carney if he believed 80, or 90%, (aka a 20 or 10% failure rate) was good enough. carney responded with a backflip ending in tossing a handful of sand on stage left, where Obama, donning a bowler and a cane, did the obamacare softshoe, resulting in a standing o, from all "reporters" but fox.
speaking of obamalies, how many low info voters know he recently asked insurers to guestimate the premium subsidy needed, and that treasury will just cut them a check now, and "true it up" later?
nice, huh?