Nuclear Filibuster Fallout Will Depend On Future Wind Direction
Harry Reid and his fellow Senate Democrats exercised a very dangerous risk when they detonated the nuclear option to kill time-honored filibuster rights afforded to protect minority representation from total dominant-party rule. The 52-48 vote which overturned a 235-year-long tradition requiring a 60-vote majority for most presidential nominees will have profound short and long- term consequences that cut both ways across the Senate aisle.
A few notable political figures in Washington offer perspective on the action
Jim Manley who served as a former aide to Reid and also to the late Senator Edward Kennedy commented that Actions have consequences. There will be changes out of this. Manley noted the vote opens a Pandoras box to further changes in the rules on a range of issues.
Michigans veteran Senator Carl Levin , one of three Democrats to oppose the rules change, warns that the precedent will enable future majorities Democrat or Republican to run roughshod over minority adversaries. Following the vote he said: If a Senate majority demonstrates it can make such a change once, there are no rules that bind a majority, and all future majorities will feel free to exercise the same power, not just on judges and executive appointments, but on legislation.
It wasnt so very long ago that Senate Majority Leader Reid strongly objected to any such action. That was back in 2005 when Republicans who controlled the White House and both houses of Congress threatened to change the rules to allow President George W. Bush to confirm some judicial appointments democrats regarded to be too conservative. Democrats loudly cried foul.
Then-Senator Barack Obama joined the opposition chorus. He argued that neither party should change the rules in the middle of the game so that they can make all the decisions while the other party is told to sit down and keep quiet. Under such a change, he warned that, the bitterness and the gridlock will only get worse.
Joe Biden , also a senator back in those days, agreed. He said that removing a filibuster privilege abandons Americas sense of fair play. Its the one thing this country stands for: not tilting the playing field on the side of those who control and own the field.
Even Ted Kennedy, ultra-liberal lion of the Senate proclaimed that Neither the Constitution, nor Senate rules, nor Senate precedents, nor American history provide any justification, for selectively nullifying the use of the filibuster.
Then after Reid publicly stated in 2008 that invoking the nuclear option would usher in a black chapter in the history of the Senate, who would have guessed that the usher would turn out to be none other than his very self?
Up until now the Democrat-controlled Senate has had the wind at its back. Between 2009 and 2011 alone they rammed through such hard-left agendas as ObamaCare and Dodd-Frank. Reid circumvented the filibuster possibility to pass ObamaCare using a creative reconciliation ploy which required only 51 Senate votes rather than 60. Next we can expect a big push to jam through lots of other agendas which have heretofore been blocked, ranging from immigration legislation to gun control.
So first of all, lets imagine what might happen if the Republicans hold the House and also score a big 2014 Senate win. While they cant overcome the presidents veto on new legislation, they can at least end existing carte blanche passage of White House bills and treaties. This will extend leverage past 2016 in negotiating concessions on such matters as tax reform, border security, military priorities, and curbs on taxes and federal spending limits.
Theres also a very good possibility that a Republican Senate might revisit that filibuster elimination rule, and not necessarily in order to reverse it at all. If they ultimately take the White House, they might just as readily expand it to avoid the need for a super-majority confirmation vote for high court nominees. And incidentally, if Republicans do retake both the Senate and White House its a safe bet to say goodbye and good riddance to ObamaCare.
On the other hand, after having broken through that two-century-long Senate tradition, also expect the Dems to apply the same filibuster-killing rules if they gain the House in 2014. If so, forget about stopping the union card-check plan that has been blocked for two yearsamong many other agendas. Under that proposed Employee Free Choice Act, unions will be able to organize workers and collect dues after receiving publicly signed or mailed in cards from 50 percent of a companys workforce. The process also identifies the respondents names to the union and fellow employees, depriving them of privacy in their decisions.
New Rules, New Radicals?
Only a few years ago, Republicans like John McCain, Lindsey Graham and Orin Hatch worried that eliminating the filibuster option would constitute a breach of sportsmanship. Now Republicans are belatedly wising up to the new Saul Alinsky game rules. As McCain told reporters after the change , It puts a chill on the entire United States Senate. It puts a chill on everything that requires bipartisanship.
Yes, welcome to Congresss new rule of governance, one that Alexis de Tocqueville referred to as tyranny of the majority, and that James Madison warned of as the superior force of an interested and overbearing majority.
Actually, its really not new at all. FDR attempted to apply it in 1937 when he sought to pack the Supreme Court with additional nominations in order to overcome judicial resistance to his proposed New Deal legislation. Roundly denounced by sitting judges and lawmakers, his plan died in Congress.
That wise rebuke was founded upon a respect for long-standing parliamentary barriers to opportunistic rule-changing power grabs. While such exploitive temptations are not unique to either party, abandonment of those time-tested traditions portends a watershed of serious consequences for everyone.
Its not just limited to the fact that eliminating filibusters can empower Democrats to pick more liberal judges and legislative appointees, or Republicans to score more conservative ones. Even more consequential, as liberal Washington Post columnist Ruth Marcus observes in an Investors Business Daily commentary, the filibuster rule change marks a fundamental and unappreciated shift of power from the Senate to the executive branch.
Questioning whether senators have fully thought all of this through, Marcus notes that
The filibuster should be a break-in-case-of-emergency tool for judicial nominees. Democrats liked having it on tap when George W. Bush was president. They may well miss it one day.
Yes, we all may have good reason to miss it.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/larrybell/2013/12/01/casualties-from-dems-nuclear-filibuster-fallout-will-depend-on-future-wind-direction/

It is safe to assume that the rule will be missed in the coming months by one side of the aisle and if control of the Senate and White House changesit will be missed even more so by those that made the chane
I doubt the Democrats will gut the filibuster any further, at least not before the next Congress is elected. As it stands right now, the Senate and the filibuster isn't really holding up any Obama favored legislation. The House is "the block" on gun control etc... If the Democrats take the house in 2014, I expect all remaining vestiges of the filibuster will be promptly removed.
If anything, I think the nuclear option signals Democratic worry over holding the Senate in 2014. While predicting elections a year in advance is a fools errand, the state of polling right now makes it very unlikely the Democrats can retake the house and the Senate is in play. Obama doesn't seem to care about letting Congress pass laws and instead is focused on implementing his agenda by executive mandate. Given the Supreme Court's low caseload, a significant number of the inevitable challenges to his dubious expansion of executive power will be ultimately decided by the DC Court of Appeals . Thus its incredibly important for Obama to have as many rubber stamp liberals on the DC Court as possible. If the Democrats are worried about losing their Senate majority, now may be is the only chance Obama will have for his legal rubber stamps to receive a majority Senate vote. In order to protect his legacy and ensure he can ignore Congress to enact laws, Obama felt it was worth destroying the historical protections of the minority party.
I continue to be fascinated by how few seem to grasp the ramifications of this precedent. in an effort to stack the dc circuit, and thwart any constitutional challenges to obamacare, the progressives have opened a Pandora's box which I fear does not include hope at its bottom.
Sean
Thanks for sharing your perspective
I tend to agree and I would also opine that if the Republicans take control of the Senate in 2014 and retain control of the House that they will do the same
JoAnne
I agree that "Pandora's box" is an apt analogy for the future ramifications of this rules change
Sean
You could be right but time will tell
This is the reason, I foresee the Democrats expanding the rules change, so we can likely expect another nuclear detonation in the Senate chamber before very long
dennis
Time ill tell but I fear that you are correct