╌>

The Great Destroyer -- ObamaCare wreaks havoc on health care, the economy, American freedom and Obama's presidency -- Pete Du Pont -- WSJ.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  22 comments

The Great Destroyer -- ObamaCare wreaks havoc on health care, the economy, American freedom and Obama's presidency -- Pete Du Pont -- WSJ.
11/25/2013
Polls show an increasing majority of Americans dislike President Obama's health-care law and disapprove of the job the president is doing. Perhaps more disconcerting for Mr. Obama is a recent Quinnipiac University poll that finds, for the first time in his presidency, a majority (54%) of registered voters feel he is not honest and trustworthy.

In response, the administration rolls out ObamaCare delays or stopgap fixes just a month after Republicans were labeled extremists for proposing delays and fixes. The White House tries shifting blame for the embarrassing rollout to othersinformation technology contractors, insurance companies and of course, Republicans. The administration is even working to discourage use of the word "ObamaCare," which the president had proudly embraced before the law encountered reality.

Most interestingly, the administration and congressional Democrats seem genuinely surprised that their prized legislation, which was to be the crown jewel of the president's legacy and the culmination of decades of liberal ambition, simply doesn't work. Did these folks ever study history, economics or sociology? If they had, they would have known there was little chance of success for their attempt to snatch one-sixth of our economy and thrust it under a complex set of bureaucratic regulations, market disincentives, higher costs and new taxes.

Large government interventions in the market almost always fall short of their backers' dreams (although not usually this rapidly). Such programs suffer from a common set of flaws, all of which are found in ObamaCare . First, and perhaps foremost, is the hubris inherent in the assumption that bureaucrats in Washington (or Moscow, Beijing or Pyongyang) know better than families, individuals and businesses do what is best for them.

We also often find a certain "looseness" with the facts. There is overpromising at the beginning. Mr. Obama actually promised to provide better health care to more people while spending less money. While some of us saw that was obviously absurd, many are just now coming to this realization. We were told we could keep our existing plan if we liked it, "period." But it turns out that means "only as long as the government, in its wisdom, decides it's right for you." The posturing and spinning continues as the administration tries to inflate the pathetically low enrollment figures. The left's mindset is that such obfuscation (to be generous) is fine as long as it is deployed in the furtherance of the greater good, which they see as coming only from their policies.

ObamaCare embodies the usual hypocrisy of large liberal programs, as the administration bestows benefits and exemptions on favored constituencies and the politically connected. We see waivers for big labor, relief from inconvenient mandates for congressional staff, and decisions timed to minimize harm to Democrats in the next election. Conversely, those who don't have politically correct views are ignored or mocked. We see lip service given to conscientious objections to abortion and birth control, but ObamaCare policies that run roughshod over these objections.

Perhaps most disappointing, we can observe in the administration's handling of ObamaCare a now all too familiar subversion of the rule of law, a fundamental precept of our nation's founding and of democracies everywhere. George Will notes that the administration has apparently decided it can adopt legislation by press conference as Mr. Obama simply announces changes to the law or that he will not enforce certain provisions. His administration then proceeds to strong-arm businesses and demonize critics.

There is the usual governmental failure to anticipate how people respond to economic incentives. Why would the administration expect the required large numbers of healthy, young people to enroll in ObamaCare in response to higher premiums? Why would the administration expect businesses to refrain from adjusting their staffing decisions based on the additional cost of ObamaCare?

Finally, we see the familiar curse of unintended consequences as the fantasy of better, more affordable insurance with more options runs into the reality of higher costs and fewer options. The failed exchange and the cancelled plans were just the beginning, followed by sticker shock at the cost of the government-mandated coverage and doctors being dropped from networks or opting out.

We don't yet know every way in which ObamaCare will damage our health-care system, our economy and our freedom, but we can be sure more pain is coming.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

As per an article the other day when it said 70% of the people covered would be subsidized I can't see where anyone with a 5th grade education can't read the writing on the wall.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

ObamaCare embodies the usual hypocrisy of large liberal programs, as the administration bestows benefits and exemptions on favored constituencies and the politically connected.

And, are we to believe Republicans do not give out favors to their politically connected?? I just love how people enjoying Govt. healthcare, criticize people enjoying Govt. healthcare..

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

And, are we to believe Republicans do not give out favors to their politically connected?? I just love how people enjoying Govt. healthcare, criticize people enjoying Govt. healthcare..

Like?

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

Look up the history of Republicans giving to their supporters and you will find your answers, hypocritically criticizing one administration, when the previous administration did the same thing, it may not have been similar programs but they have done the same for their supporters, it is well know that Democrats try to help the people who are poor but, Republicans do favors for the wealthy and screw people in need...

I just love how people enjoying Govt. healthcare, criticize people enjoying Govt. healthcare..

Like?

Like, people receiving Medicare, criticizing a health care program set up for working people who are uninsured, those working people "OI just love how people enjoying Govt. healthcare, criticize people enjoying Govt. healthcare..

Like? people currently enjoying Medicare, criticizing a healthcare program set up to help the people who are working and yet have not health coverage, those working people, pay taxes, they contribute to social security and medicare in payroll, those working people are keeping the social security, medicare working, YET, the ones enjoying the benefits of social security and medicare do not want the ones who are keeping their benefits coming to have any health coverage, that is the most blatantly, devious of a mentality that I can fathom

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Let me give you an example. Now here we are at the edge of the cliff on this Obamacare and it should be a breeze to figure just about what your premium in this age of technology. Well, there is a calculator put out by The Henry Kaiser Family Foundation. Well you would think since I first looked at this tool a little over a month ago and being Kaiser it should be correct in calculating an accurate premium, so lets see how we come out with an example.

Lets say we have a 63 year old non smoker making $35k a year single person living in Los Angeles, CA.

Now these are yearly premiums.

Total premium : $7251

Subsidy : $3926

Actual Premium : $3325

And another person same situation with a one thing different. Instead of making $35k, let's say this person gets a paid $46k a year.

OK

63 year old non smoker making $45k a year single person living in Los Angeles, CA

Total premium : $7251

Subsidy : $0

Actual Premium : $7251

Now let's look at the difference the person making $46k compared to the person making $35k is.

$46k premium: $7251

$35k premium: $3325

Difference : $3926

Wow!!!! It is the same amount as the subsidy for the person making $35k. Isn't that interesting?

Now what are the Federal taxes on a single person having a net income of $46k? Well it's $7536.

Now what are the Federal taxes on a single person having a net income of $35k? Well it's $4819.

So

$7536

$4819

$2717 difference. In other words.....

The person who has an income $11k more than $35k to $46k has to pay $3926 more in premium, the same amount the person making $35k is saving and the person making $46k has to pay an additional amount of $2717 in Federal taxes, not even considering the state taxes that comes to $6643 more money the person making $46k has to pay out for Obamacare with the extra Federal taxes. Maybe he is just lucky or it could also be that 3rd job just to make ends meet. Who knows? Anyway it sure takes away the motivation when you make $35k and think it's a good idea to improve yourself by working overtime.

Anyway, for making that extra $11k the person gets to keep all of it except the $3926 in extra premium and the extra Federal tax of $2717. So what does that leave them with?

$11000

$ 3926

$ 7074

$ 2717

$ 4357

Now since Obama and Company kept telling every one it wasn't a tax the entire time he was trying to sell it to the American people and some of us really knew it was without looking in the dictionary and once it got to the Supreme Court his lawyers argued that it was a tax, the $45k person could just take his chances and pay the tax, well you get the picture. Would you buy a vacuum cleaner from this con artist?

So the extra premium and Federal tax on that $11000 is $11000 minus $4357 which is: $6643

So $6643 divided by $11000 is: 60.39% tax on that $11000. Isn't that nice and the fellow gets to experience the pleasure of knowing between the two of them they are paying the same thing, except he feels like something is wrong with this picture?

Now the writing on the wall says that 70% of the people with Obamacare will be subsidized. Well in this one incident with only an $11k difference in income this one person is paying the subsidy of another person. That kind of makes it for every two people like this one is paying the subsidy for the other.

What is it was a 21 year old just out of school good non smoker first job starting out with a small company of less than 50 employees starting out at $20 a year, how would it look?

Well the Kaiser calculator in the same location would have these figures.

Total premium : $2456

Subsidy : $1435

Actual Premium : $1021

What about a 30 year old like many of those low paying jobs making $25k a year?

Total premium : $2788

Subsidy : $1059

Actual Premium : $1729

Ok, let's see this 30 year old went to college and is now making $46k on his job.

Total premium : $2788

Subsidy : $0

Actual Premium : $2788

In all the years I sold insurance over a dozen I never wrote a policy like the Silver Plan which covers 70% of the first $21166.67.

The most common policy I ever wrote usually had a deductible of $100 or sometimes $250 and then 80% of the next $5000, then 100% after that. I know things and prices obviously have changed since then. Back in the late 70's the government wasn't into the insurance business as they are now covering even the air you breathe and believe it or not the premium was less than $100 per month for a whole family of four.

This plan we are up against today will do nothing to reduce the cost of service. That's where the problem is. The insurance companies are now limited to only making a 20% profit on their policies and have to return anything over that back to the insured. I see people claiming to receive money back from their insurance companies that were over charged. So they were. If there had been an epidemic or something they are putting themselves at risk and contrary to popular belief this insurance for profit is not going to stop. The White House just announced just last week they were going to spend $7 billion on finding ways to reduce the cost of Obamacare. Now wonder who is getting that contract. Halliburton? CGI? Sounds like an easy $7 billion to me. I can tell you how to reduce the cost by $7 billion right now.

Anyway wow!

Anyway if these premiums are wrong, don't blame me, blame Bush!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

People "enjoying Medicare" were not subsidized. They were working too; andpaid premiums all their working lives.

Now what they paid is going to subsidize those who did not work or, earning low salaries, paid virtually no FICA or taxes. Many even received tax credits.

But all will receive the same benefits.

Any more examples?

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Len said: "But all will receive the same benefits."

IMO, as it should be. Everyone. Regardless of whether they make $0 or $1 billion dollars.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Yeah, and the world is going to end tomorrow

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

People currently receiving medicare were also paying into the program but not at the rate % as the people who are currently paying in, that in essence is been subsidized by working people to date.

Now what they paid is going to subsidize those who did not work or, earning low salaries, paid virtually no FICA or taxes. Many even received tax credits.

But all will receive the same benefits.

Any more examples?

YOU ARE INCORRECT

People who are currently working no matter the wage "MUST PAY" FICA PAYROLL TAXES which is 7.65% of the gross income which covers Social Security and Medicare payments. If a person has not worked, they are and has been receiving MEDICAID, Medicaid has been LAW before OBAMACARE became Law.. Now, Obamacare covers Uninsured working people, People working up to 133% of the Poverty rate will be covered under the Medicaid expansion if the States they lives expanded medicaid, others will be subsidized, depending on their income..

Provisions of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

The ACA includes numerous provisions that take effect between 2010 and 2020. Policies issued before 2010 are exempted by a grandfather clause from many of the changes to insurance standards, but they are affected by other provisions. [ 15 ] [ 16 ] Significant reforms, most of which take effect by January 1, 2014, include:

  • Low-income individuals and families whose incomes are between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty level will receive federal subsidies on a sliding scale if they purchase insurance via an exchange. [ 37 ] Those from 133% to 150% of the poverty level will be subsidized such that their premium costs will be 3% to 4% of income. [ 38 ] In 2013, the subsidy would apply for incomes up to $45,960 for an individual or $94,200 for a family of four; consumers can choose to receive their tax credits in advance, and the exchange will send the money directly to the insurer every month. [ 39 ] Small businesses will be be eligible for subsidies. [ 40 ]
  • Medicaid eligibility expanded to include individuals and families with incomes up to 133% of the federal poverty level , including adults without disabilities and without dependent children. [ 41 ] The law also provides for a 5% "income disregard", making the effective income eligibility limit for Medicaid 138% of the poverty level. [ 42 ] Furthermore, the State Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) enrollment process is simplified. [ 41 ] However, in National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius , the Supreme Court ruled that states may opt out of the Medicaid expansion, and several have done so .
  • Reforms to the Medicare payment system are meant to promote greater efficiency in the healthcare delivery system by restructuring Medicare reimbursements from fee-for-service to bundled payments . [ 43 ] [ 44 ] Under the new payment system, a single payment is paid to a hospital and a physician group for a defined episode of care (such as a hip replacement) rather than individual payments to individual service providers. In addition, it has been asserted that the Medicare Part D coverage gap (commonly called the " donut hole ") will shrink incrementally, closing completely by January 1, 2020. [ 45 ]

Notice: The article uses the word INCOMES which means someone who is working and collecting a paycheck...

...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Nothing in your paste contradicts what I wrote, contrary to your spin.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

I suppose it depends on how much you are able to comprehend, can't get blood from a turnip can I???

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

It doesn't matter if you agree or not, the important thing is that the people who have been misinformed receives the right information..

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Karl Marx would agree.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

A man who worked in a small business had his insurance cancelled... all policies were cancelled and the people told himto sign up on ObamaCare. He and three of his daughters were covered by the policy he had to choose, and the premium was higher. We've all heard stories like this but this one had a twist.

His youngest daughter was not eligible to be covered due to her age and he would have to wait another nine months before including her on the policy. To get her covered he had to buy a single policy just for her.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Either side could say this. You need to be more specific.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

Len you prefer the Wal-Mart's of the world who like the Fast food restaurants have their employees apply for food stamps and Medicaid. Or maybe you prefer those who go to the Hospital and stiff the doctors and nurses. Political troll's like you have convinced me the GOP and Conservative citizenslike youare corporate junkies waiting for the trickle down to happen. Talking heads are your only source of thought or lack there of. Surely you never belonged to a Union or other related group looking out for the working man or woman. My wife and I get a big laughfrom your racist anti working class view points.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

Hey MIMI guess your saying the baby has to be of what age before it is covered by the family policy.??? Where did you get that glob of nonsense?

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

but, after 3 years, and over a half billion, the website is being fixed with "private sector-like" velocity!

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

odd, the day after Obama's mission accomplished (well, 90% anyway) website that is the very face of what one of the originators of the law called a train wreck....there actually is a train wreck

 
 

Who is online


CB


121 visitors