╌>

America Is the Lemonade Stand

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  13 years ago  •  14 comments

America Is the Lemonade Stand

I ran across this article on LinkedIn and found it quite interesting and wanted to share it.

Julie Meyer Founder at EntrepreneurCountry

"For America, Is The Best Yet To Come?"

America had a spectacular 20 Century. If it is to have an equally spectacular if different - 21 Century, it must be wise, and it will come down to the choices that it makes.

  • Does it want to be the picture or the frame?
  • Do we want to win by our rules or do we want to set the rules of engagement for the world?
  • Said another way, is it all about us, or all about the world?

Whether superpower status was pursued and achieved or thrust upon America, it is a different thing to be one of many, an enabler of the worlds freedom and a people power enabler - the frame rather than the picture.

People come to America for start-ups, for Wall Street, for university but they then seek to go back to their corner of the universe , thinking that the operating model of America, the tools, the networks, and yes, the spirit of America will help them be the best that they can be.

What is the cause at the heart of the spirit? Because you cant have energy without an energy source.

What is the Spirit of America? Is it going viral or being snuffed out?

Americans believe they are more free . WE believe we are free in the brain, free in our minds, free to be. We are uncluttered with history, untethered by top down structures. We believe that we can make our future, and that it comes down to us. Its not that we were given more. We create more. Its not a good picture but a good frame for making pictures, a good operating model for business.

In the world that I see that I described in my book WELCOME TO ENTREPRENEUR COUNTRY I see a world moving from collective exchange (set up after WWII) to peer to peer exchange primarily because of the power of the web. I dont think that if the 25 year olds were running Washington today (and they will in 15 years time) that they would create a government that looked anything like what it does today. The macro trends are yes towards connections, but not an intermediary like government doing the connecting.

All smart strategists have to step back from a situation at a certain point, and say, How should this THING called our business, or government, or America work?

For the business of America is business!! Its not government. It is the lemon stand. It is the Monopoly Board game. It is the Harvard drop out that makes it big founding Microsoft and then Facebook. Its the small time farmer who lives his entire life under the official poverty line, putting his 4 children through education, and they all become doctors or PhD's, one of them my father, and the government tells him he's poor. But he's never felt poor a day in his life. He runs his own business, his own life, and is close to the land, and is in control of his destiny and therefore his dignity. We dont scratch our heads about what American business looks like. We know.

But we do wonder what American government looks like because only a hundred years ago it was infinitely smaller than it is today, and we can see that there are different views of what it is moving forward - - which the last election drew in sharp relief.

We can create great politicians like Hillary Clinton in her role as Secretary of State. And Obama what a handsome guy - won because he got the Mood Music right for his election.

But I would prefer that we create great philanthropists like Bill Gates, and the rest of them who give of their wealth to create social change bottom up around the world. Bill Gates put 1 million into Egypt. I love the fact that it is Bill Gates money, and that the US is known for its individuals generosity as much as for the states.

Business not government. Economics trumping politics. Economics economic strength and growth borne out of talent and freedom drives social change. Politics doesnt do that.

  • If America continues to choose strong economics and the conditions for strong economics, its future will be bright.
  • If it believes that it should create strong politics in order to try to make life fair, then it will not create a fair society because life is not fair - but it will create a country which will move towards a reality of the richest poor people ultimately, and its power will diminish accordingly.

In a world of 7 billion people, which is now driven by networks, with huge challenges The question is not whether America going up or going down, but does the American matter, does the individual still matter, or must we aggregate individuals in order to be strong aggregate the into nations in order to count, in governments in order to defend?

And here I am certain that the individual is the only thing which matters . Because you cannot be interdependent until you are independent. Freedom drives productivity, empathy, wealth creation. Only with these things at the core of society, can you create a society which matters - rather than a collection of people.

  • A future America which moves to centralize and to socialize is moving away from the great macro trends in play.
  • A future America which empowers the citizen not through government programs, but by allowing the individual to keep their money in order to dictate their future, which is active locally, empowers people with productivity tools moves with history.
  • A future America whose citizens create massive wealth will continue to have a large portion of them funding growth around the world.

And that is a good thing.

For those on linked in the article is available at

http://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20131118215239-12560-america-is-the-lemonade-stand


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

I thought this article captured the two points of view on the future of the U.S. economy and society quite clearly and thought it would be interesting to those who agree and those who disagree with the premise of the author of the article.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

The crux of the argument perhaps is shown here

Business not government. Economics trumping politics. Economics economic strength and growth borne out of talent and freedom drives social change. Politics doesnt do that.

  • If America continues to choose strong economics and the conditions for strong economics, its future will be bright.
  • If it believes that it should create strong politics in order to try to make life fair, then it will not create a fair society because life is not fair - but it will create a country which will move towards a reality of the richest poor people ultimately, and its power will diminish accordingly.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That was a particularly fine article from Julie Meyer . There is quite a lot of food for thought there .

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Petey

I see her columns on LinkedIn and agree that this is one of the better one with some interesting points of debate to be considered

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

It is hard to select a few good points for discussion when there are so many . This section drew my attention :

In a world of 7 billion people, which is now driven by networks, with huge challenges The question is not whether America going up or going down, but does the American matter, does the individual still matter, or must we aggregate individuals in order to be strong aggregate the into nations in order to count, in governments in order to defend?

And here I am certain that the individual is the only thing which matters. Because you cannot be interdependent until you are independent. Freedom drives productivity, empathy, wealth creation. Only with these things at the core of society, can you create a society which matters - rather than a collection of people.

The exceptional individual is going to continue to be a major contributor ...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Petey

Personal responsibility, personal initiative, personal achievement

Valued things in our past successes, somewhat lacking in the plans and policies of some but sorely needed for our recovery and future greatness as a nation

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Hi Robert,

In a world of 7 billion people, which is now driven by networks, with huge challenges

Huge challenges indeed! The size and nature of those challenges is largely determined by how many of "us" there are (7 billion)... and what we are "driven" to do.

And here I am certain thatthe individual is the only thing which matters. Because you cannot be interdependent until you are independent. Freedom drives productivity, empathy, wealth creation.Only with these things at the core of society, can you create a society which matters - rather than a collection of people.

That is classic "Ayn Rand" speak... This article is clearly and interpretation of Ayn Rand's ideas that avoids any specific references to her.

Manevery manis an end in himself, not a means to the ends of others; he must live for his own sake, neither sacrificing himself to others nor sacrificing others to himself; he must work for his rational self-interest, with the achievement of his own happiness as the highest moral purpose of his life.
~ Any Rand

I guess this is a somewhat different twist on Randism because the author applauds altruistic "individuals", but Randismabhors all altruism. Here is another one of Ayn Rand's gems of wisdom...

Weakness does not deserve love.
~ Any Rand

The author bundles"empathy" together with "productivity" and "wealth creation"... odd and rarely copacetic bedfellows in my view. She tries to make the case that empathy, and any subsequent altruism that might flow out of that empathy, should be strictly an "individual" choice,but coyly suggests there is something wrong with collective altruism administered by thegovernment.

We ARE"driven" to be "productive" and "wealthy." In my view, our quest for productivity and wealth (for which "the Monopoly Board game" is an excellent metaphor) is part of what has brought "us" the "huge challenges" we face.

The story about the farmer happily living close to the land is used to denigrate the government who deigns to tell him he is poor. That is a classic Libertarian mischaracterization of the government intentions and purpose. The government is simply saying that most people whose income is less than some figure will have a lifestyle that would commonly be seen as "poor", especially for people choosing to live in and urban society that is not at all "close to the land"... which is the case for the majority of people living in America today. If that farmer doesn't feel poor with the sort of income he has, good for him! I have seen people in other countries living with MUCH less than that farmer probably has, and they also seem to be happier than most of us who strive to live above that government established "poverty line."Too bad more people can't find the happiness he has managed to find living a simple life "close to the land." But our society "drives" "us" to be "productive" and "create wealth."

I'm sure by now, Robert, you have noticed that I have quoted certain words and phrases from the article over and over. I am doing that in part because I see a real conflict between the problems identified by the author and the solutions the author proposes. I am also doing that because I am pretty sure the author's intended meaning for some of those words is quite different than the meaning those words have for me. Allow me to explain...

...is it all about us, or all about the world?

The author seems to be a proponent of individualism, so the "us" of which the author speaks is probably meant to be American citizens, or even more likely to be each of "us" as individuals. When I hear the word "us" I think of every creature on the planet... and when I hear the word "world" Ithink of the planet itself and its finite resources on which which all of "us" depend (my "us" not the author's "us"). I think the author's notion of "us" is very self-centered... which Ayn Rand would say is very good because she believes "self-interest" is our "highest moral purpose." I find that notion of "us" very unappealing!!!

In summary, it looks to me like most people who are drawn to Ayn Rand's ideas are are attracted by two central themes...

  • "Keep your hands off my stuff!"
  • "Don't tell me what I can and can't do!"

Ayn Rand provides "moral" justification for those themes. This author attempts to do the same thing.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That is classic "Ayn Rand" speak... This article is clearly and interpretation of Ayn Rand's ideas that avoids any specific references to her.

I don't agree . I think she is speaking developmentally . A person needs to develop their own skill set before they can become a contributing part of society . Without that stage of development taking place a person is merely a speck to be tossed about by whatever prevailing winds happen along . But with that development under their belts they can go on to join a group and contribute there .

When I hear the word "us" I think of every creature on the planet

That's nice ... Say hello to the fleas for me .Tongue.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

MalamueMan

Interesting perspective you have there thanks for sharing

I did not go directly to Ayn Rand when I read the article but rather thought the author was saying that the U.S. has a responsibility to the world as well as to our own citizens and that we play a role in the socio-economic reality of our citizens, our country and the world

I figured the article would mean different things to different people which is why I decided to seed the article

Thanks for the perspective and feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

I did not see a single reference to deregulation or tax breaks but thanks for sharing your perspective

I agree in providing thatequal opportunities to everyone is a requirement but do not go as far as providing equal outcomes to everyone as individual effort and initiative should play some role in our individual successes and failures.

I got from the article that political policy to affect absolute fairness and equality in all things is the wrong approach, again the opportunity versus outcome outlook

Thanks again for stopping by and for the feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

Really I seem to remember something about the big banks being to blame

On one point, you are wrong

The dilemma and challenges of the socio-economic miasma we re currently in is a very complicated matter which will require multi-faceted and complex solutions.

Thanks for sharing your perspective

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Egilman

I thought the article might spark some interesting perspectives and points and I was right

Thanks for sharing your perspective and a set if interesting questions to which I am sure there will be varied answers and opinions from others

I agree with you that foreign aid should come after all domestic requirements are satisfied and I think that citizens should expect equal opportunities to succeed and better themselves but that the actual success or failure is up to the individual's efforts once the opportunity is given

If someone is truly in need, transitory assistance is certainly warranted

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Say hello to the fleas for me .

While fleas,mosquitoes, bacteria, and pretty much any creature who might be likely to prey on me in some way are creatures I try to steer clear of, I feel they have as much right to the life sustaining resources of this planet as I do. Just because I have been born as a creature with a combination of characteristics that make it possible to exploit the planetary resources for my benefit and potentially to such an extent that it is to the great detriment of other creatures does not mean it is morally justifiable to do so. I DO NOT believe self-interest is my highest moral purpose. In fact, I am not completely clear what my highest moral purpose may be, but I do believe it includes respecting all living things. :-)

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

to the great detriment of other creatures
....
but I do believe it includes respecting all living things.

That has an extreme Buddhist slant to it . Personally there are quite a few bacteria I kill on a regular basis ... and so do you .

 
 

Who is online

CB
JohnRussell


126 visitors