╌>

The Other side of History - The Real Story of Thanksgiving

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  ambivalent  •  13 years ago  •  67 comments

The Other side of History - The Real Story of Thanksgiving

Here is a primer for teachers and a very different Thanksgiving history lesson for all.

I was raised in Stamford Connecticut, went to school there, but this history was never taught to me.

manataka


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

The Other side of History - The Real Story of Thanksgiving

....It would be very good to say that this friendship lasted a long time; but, unfortunately, that was not to be. More English people came to America, and they were not in need of help from the Indians as were the original Pilgrims. Many of the newcomers forgot the help the Indians had given them. Mistrust started to grow and the friendship weakened. The Pilgrims started telling their Indian neighbors that their Indian religion and Indian customs were wrong. The Pilgrims displayed an intolerance toward the Indian religion similar to the intolerance displayed toward the less popular religions in Europe. The relationship deteriorated and within a few years the children of the people who ate together at the first Thanksgiving were killing one another in what came to be called King Phillip's War.

They brought:

... disease arrogance, intolerance, enslavement,murder .....etc ...where wasthe Christian charity?

At least for those who helped them in their time of dire need.

Thanks Giving History from the perspective of the savage European is a propaganda lie, to cover their crimes against humanity.

I can see from this article who the real savages were.

"he who controls the past, controls the future,

he who controls the future, controls the past"

~RATM~

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

So perhaps we should be sitting at theThanksgiving table and "confessing" the sins of our Europeanforefathers,

Confession is good for the soul.

...and my NA friends should be at their tables "forgiving" them.

Maybe NA or some of them, are big enough to forgive, personally I'm not big enough to forgive and maybe it is not my place to forgive or not forgive because I'm not NA, but I am a human-being and injustice of the innocent suffering at the hands of the bullies piss's me off.

It doesn't matter to me I hate murdering bullies, what they did was no different from what the Nazi's did,no matter who the victims are, for me such crimes are unforgivable.

So I guess that is my failing, I'm not big enough to forgive the big things.

The little things yeah.Smile.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Mike - I think this is one of the areas that many people misunderstand. "Most" of the Indians I know are more interested in attempting to "Educate" the majority of folks about the happenings of the past WITH THE HOPE that those events won't occur again - at least not during our life times.

All cultures, at one time or another, had pasts that are not the bestfor remembering. Some of the things our tribes did, according to our culture and traditions, were not in the best interest of others. Same with other ethnicities. No one can claim to have a clean slate of violence against another.

The vast majority of people I know, as John so eloquently stated above, gather the family together to be thankful for being a family - and the large quantities of wine and beer and football - and don't forget the napsGrin.gif

This is great history ambi - a history we HAVE to learn from and, as Bright said above, not repeat it.

Thanks.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I read the entire article and agree with it. However, I do have two minor points;

a) Disease - At that time, people were not only ignorant of most diseases but how they spread or why they were immune. It is not as if the Europeans deliberately spread any disease here.

b) It's fair to point out that the author deliberately narrowed down the culprits here to the "Puritans" (a forerunner of the Calvinists) who were hardly pure and the monied English aristocracy.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

How close-minded of you.

1) True enough, to wit; "Puritans adopted a Reformed theology and, in that sense, were Calvinists (as were many of their earlier opponents), but they also took note of radical views critical of Zwingli in Zurich and Calvin in Geneva" ( source ), nonetheless, their evil still exists today in the form of the Tea party and many evangelical so-called christians.

2) As I never mentioned "zealotry", (your word) perhaps you should read the links here. I commented on what was linked to. There is room enough to lay blame for the Europeans and the barbarity that followed the Puritans, but still, they set the stage for what occurred afterwards.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I'm not saying the diseases were not a factor. I'm saying the spread of those diseases were not a deliberate action. The colonists in general had no idea what they were carrying...None, zippo, nada, goose-eggs. The science behind diseases and their control was still being formed at the time. Cook did the same thing in Hawaii.

The culprit here was ignorance not nationality or culturalism.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

everyone knows the original settlers were a bunch of bumbling idiots, that would have starved to death if not for the indians (who they stole land from later on). thanksgiving was to celebrate the indians saving their lives, and thanking them

~punch line: after destroying our education system, now liberals think the young invincibles will be able to support an ever growing dependant class!

silly liberals.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

no, like liberal politicians' children, i was lucky enough to go to private school

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Good spin. I'll give you a C+ for it.

  • Your politics is showing

Did you just notice that?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Robert,

Ever hear the phrase; "horseshoes and hand grenade throwing?"

Allusions are a legitimate form of argumentation. Deal with it.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    13 years ago

At that time, people were not only ignorant of most diseases but how they spread or why they were immune

I respectfully disagree. Refer to Lord Amherst and the smallpox-tainted blankets he sent to Indians

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Naw, "horseshoes and hand grenade throwing" is an idiomatic phrase meaning "close enough". In making a point, one does not need to be exact on every detail, but just close enough for the reader to understand the point.

To explain, in the game of horseshoes, the closest wins and in hand grenade throwing (providing you don't drop it where you are at) lobbing it in the general direction you want usually is close enough to do the job.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Ya forgot the third one - nuclear bombs. If you're 2,000 miles away and can say "What was that" - you're too close.Grin.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Robert - in most cases, opinions are like noses - everyone has one.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    13 years ago

sorry ambi, thought you're talking in general.

Hunger plus the it-is-almost-Friday syndrome are to blameSmile.gif

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

You realize that the Thanksgiving myth was originally staged in 1621. The Amherst incident happened a full century later, in 1763. By then, 18th century science knew about contagions and their spread. Amhurst's actions were diabolic.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    13 years ago

If you look the post above yours you'll notice I corrected myself

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Unfortunately, your comment came while I was typing my reply. Please note the timing.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    13 years ago

that's OK, no bad feelingsSmile.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Odd . I have never seen any history detailing the use of Indians as slaves . Why is that ... Black slaves were so plentiful there would be no need for Indians as slaves .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That does NOT indicate anything about the use of Indians as slaves ... and not even about black slaves . What is your point ?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Indians were used as slaves by the Europeans.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    13 years ago

I can't recall the exact dates but they discovered that by scratching the skin of a non-infected person and applying the secretion from the pustule's material from an infected one would lead to developing immunity in the non-infected one,

Washington used this technique on his soldiers here in Valley Forge

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    13 years ago

I read somewhere that the first kidnapping in America was that of an Indian girl who was taken to France I think as a slave.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

From the very beginning of the European discovery of the American continents

That does NOT restrict itself to the US . It covers all of South & Central America .

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Coo 6.gif

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Read the article and it points out where and when Indians were slaves.

So, it's better that all of the Americans were slave markets, rather than just US.

How frickin wonderful is that.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

You must be having a bad day for confusing me with others.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Grandmother? I'm 31 and while my oldest is a freshman college, I warned her that if at all possible, not to make me a grandmother.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Actually, there are both - the histories of the Pilgrims and Indians would be both history stories - or the history of the Pilgrims and Indians as told by either a Pilgrim or an Indian.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I think you lost them John . Well done !

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Yeah - friggin' wonderful Grin.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

So, it's better that all of the Americans were slave markets, rather than just US.

From your link :

Not all Europeans supported the idea of slavery in general nor of American Indians in particular.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Kinda curious as to what your point is Petey.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

This article is about the US holiday . It is not about South nor Central America .

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Petey, that was a typo on my part. It should read all of the Americas not Americans.

The point being slavery was a part of the European conquest of North, Central and South America.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

Do you have facts to go with that eye roll? If so, please present your evidence that the author is wrong. It is an established fact Washington meant to wipe out Indians, and he did proclaim a federal Thanksgiving holiday.

George Washington...
In 1779, George Washington instructed Major General John Sullivan to attack Iroquois people. Washington stated, "lay waste all the settlements around...that the country may not be merely overrun, but destroyed". In the course of the carnage and annihilation of Indian people, Washington also instructed his general not "listen to any overture of peace before the total ruin of their settlements is effected". (Stannard, David E. AMERICAN HOLOCAUST. New York: Oxford University Press, 1992. pp. 118-121.)

In 1783, Washington's anti-Indian sentiments were apparent in his comparisons of Indians with wolves: "Both being beast of prey, tho' they differ in shape", he said. George Washington's policies of extermination were realized in his troops behaviors following a defeat. Troops would skin the bodies of Iroquois "from the hips downward to make boot tops or leggings". Indians who survived the attacks later re-named the nation's first president as "Town Destroyer". Approximately 28 of 30 Seneca towns had been destroyed within a five year period. (Ibid)

The First Thanksgiving Observance

A Proclamation Signed in Script Type by George Washington
Appearing in The Massachusetts Centinel of October 14, 1789

Abstract

This historic proclamation was issued by George Washington during his first year as President. It sets aside Thursday, November 26 as "A Day of Publick Thanksgiving and Prayer."


While there were Thanksgiving observances in America both before and after Washington's proclamation, this represents the first to be so designated by the new national government.
Signed by Washington on October 3, 1789 and entitled "General Thanksgiving," the decree appointed the day "to be observed by acknowledging with grateful hearts the many and signal favors of Almighty God."

The first recorded Thanksgiving observance was held on June 29, 1671 at Charlestown, Massachusetts by proclamation of the town's governing council.

During the 1700s, it was common practice for individual colonies to observe days of thanksgiving throughout each year. A Thanksgiving Day two hundred years ago was a day set aside for prayer and fasting, not a day marked by plentiful food and drink as is today's custom. Later in the 18th century each of the states periodically would designate a day of thanksgiving in honor of a military victory , an adoption of a state constitution or an exceptionally bountiful crop.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

everyone knows....

And that's the problem. Everyone has been fed lies, propaganda and myths as if it were actual history.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

Columbus enslaved Indians on his very first voyage. He took Indian slaves back to Europe with him. While he technically did not set foot on the land that became the US, he set the standard for what went on for centuries. The Catholic Church enslaved Indians when they arrived too. Indians were enslaved in California, even though California was not a slavery state.

Whites were also enslaved. Ambi posted about indentured servants, but there were also white slaves imported from England.

History of White Slavery - Save Your Heritage

The Irish slave trade began when James II sold 30,000 Irish prisoners as slaves to the New World . His Proclamation of 1625 required Irish political prisoners be sent overseas and sold to English settlers in the West Indies.

By the mid 1600s , the Irish were the main slaves sold to Antigua and Montserrat (70% of the total population of Montserrat were Irish slaves at this time).

From 1641 to 1652 , over 500,000 Irish were killed by the English and over 300,000 were sold as slaves .

Ireland's population fell from about 1,500,000 to 600,000 in one single decade.

During the 1650s , over 100,000 Irish children between the ages of 10 and 14 were forcibly taken from their parents and sold as slaves in the West Indies, Virginia and New England. Another 52,000 Irish (mostly women and children) were sold to Barbados and Virginia while 30,000 Irish men were sold to the highest bidder.

In 1656 , Oliver Cromwell ordered that 2000 Irish children be taken to Jamaica and sold as slaves to English settlers.

African slaves were very expensive (50 Sterling), had to be transported long distances and paid for not only in Africa but in the New World. Irish slaves were cheap (no more than 5 Sterling) and most often were either kidnapped from Ireland, prisoners or forcibly removed. They could be worked to death, whipped or branded without it being a crime. Many, many times they were beat to death and while the death of an Irish slave was a monetary setback, it was far cheaper than the death of an expensive African. Therefore, African slaves were treated much better in Colonial America.

The importation of Irish slaves continued well into the eighteenth century, long after the importation of African slaves became the norm. Records state that after the 1798 Irish Rebellion , thousands of Irish slaves were sold to both America and Australia.

Irish slavery didn't end until Britain decided to end slavery in 1839 and stopped transporting slaves.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

And, read the two links provided that show the "America's" as the initial slave population for the Euros.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

You don't cite any proof of the article is wrong. Please do so. Just calling the author "insane" is not proof.

Do you doubt the whites celebrated when they killed Indians? Do you doubt they killed Indians several times a year? Do you doubt they gave thanks when they were victorious?

There is no doubt that the various colonies celebrated "thanksgiving" several times a year, quite often because of military victories. Who were their enemies?

There is also no doubt Washington declared one day a year as Thanksgiving.

Unless you have proof of your stance, then you're just making noise to make noise.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago
Do you think maybe you could be obsessed and singularly focused on self?

So you can't disprove the author of the article, instead using only the absurd claim that the author is "insane," and now you have to use insults against me too because you can't produce proof of your stance.

Insults are a failed strategy of those who have no facts.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

The holiday itself evolved out of a routine Puritan religious observation, irregularly declared and celebrated in response to God's favorable Providence,

Although the Pilgrims' 1621 harvest celebration had been identified as the first American Thanksgiving as early as 1841 by Alexander Young, the common Thanksgiving symbolic associations in the 19th century centered on turkeys, Yankee dinners and an annual family reunion, not Pilgrims. Mention of the Pilgrims brought the Landings or Myles, Priscilla, and John to mind, not Thanksgiving.

Moreover, whenever a Pilgrim, or more accurately, a generic 17th-century puritan image appeared in popular art in connection with Thanksgiving during the nineteenth century, it was not the now familiar scene of English and Indians sitting down to an outdoor feast. On the contrary, the image almost always portrayed a violent confrontation between colonist and Native American. It was only after the turn of the century, when the western Indian wars were over and the "vanishing red man" was vanishing satisfactorily, that the romantic (and historically correct) idyllic image of the two cultures sitting down to an autumn feast became popular. By the First World War, popular art (especially postcards), schoolbooks and literature had linked the Pilgrims and the First Thanksgiving indivisibly together, so much so that the image of the Pilgrim and the familiar fall feast almost ousted the Landing and older patriotic images from the popular consciousness. This alliance also deflated Forefathers' Day, which sank in to insignificance even in Plymouth itself.

During the second half of the nineteenth century, Thanksgiving was more commonly symbolized by its New England origins and its chief dinner constituent, the turkey, than by the Pilgrims' 1621 harvest celebration. In addition to the rural New England theme, there were a diversity of contemporary and historical illustrations and stories, including Thanksgivings on the battlefield, down south with African-Americans and in the urban slums, as well as a few generic colonial New England (and Old England) Puritan images. It is surprising to note that when the colonists are represented, they are less likely to be sharing their feast with their Native American neighbors, than illustrating European and Native American conflict, indicated by a hail of arrows! Apparently the very real dangers of the Indian Wars in the West produced a sense of fear and guilt which was expressed in this fashion, in graphic contrast with the familiar peaceful autumn pastorals that we associate with the holiday today. It was only after the wars were over that a sentimental regard for the satisfactorily "vanishing Red Man" provoked a national change of heart in which Jennie Brownscombe could create her idyllic "First Thanksgiving" (1914). Even then the image of the Thanksgiving "Pilgrim-puritan" fleeing a shower of arrows retained a popular appeal.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Loretta - you do know that Robert will need a Pilgrim and an Indian from 1621 to stand in front of him and tell him what originally happened. But, then again, he will tell them that they can't prove it because he was not there to verify that they were there as proof of their story.

We can only beat a wall for so long.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Actually, no, I lost John - thank you.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

1st, that's okay. He's giving me an excellent opportunity to post good links for those who want to learn more. There are so many to choose from. There's one in the Boston Globe about how what we celebrate is opposite what the Pilgrims would have celebrated. I might do that one next. It's a good article.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

"The Other side of History - The Real Story of Thanksgiving"

- show me where "we were talking about credibility" has anything to do with this title.

Then show me where Pilgrims and Indians have anything to do with this title.

Everyone views what they read based on their perceptions and real life's experiences (we've had this discussion before Robert).

Show me YOUR credible evidence supporting that what was stated, and you highlighted, is NOT correct.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

What one learns from history is based on the information presented by the author. We can't all be there to editorialize/critique/correct the author's writings as we weren't involved in their research - or lack thereof.

The folks that wrote the articles being quoted did so from their point-of-view based on the information they obtained when they conducted their research. I, for one, will never critique anything written by Bacon as I'm not a physicist nor a philosopher. But, I will think and comment based on my own experiences and knowledge of those two fields.

As you and I have discussed before - history is exactly that - "his" "story" - based on the information the writer obtained, digested and published. The writers of the above dicta wrote about events occurring 300 years ago - when they weren't present, and used resources that were available to them when writing their "findings". It is not up to us to have to defend what they wrote. It is up to us to determine if we "believe" or "appreciate" the information presented.

Don't ask me or others to psycoanalyze/critique what another author wrote - because you can't either. I, and most others, will comment based on our concept of what has been written compared against our known experiences.

The title of the thread and the comments made "should have" been regarding the Pilgrim's interactions with the Indians and vice versus. It should not be about having to defend the use of the word "the" or "of" or whatever to determine/explain whether or not we believe the information is to be considered "credible".

If you disagree with the author's writings/musings, explain why and quit attempting to place other's on the spot of having to explain why you don't believe something - that's not our job - that is yours.

Show me your "credible" evidence.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

We were talking about....

We? You have a frog in your pocket?

I don't remember ceding to you my right to post what I wish or define what can be talked about.

I'm talking about the fact our children are taught mythology concerning Thanksgiving, mythology made up a mere 100 years ago and having nothing at all to do with what really happened between Indians and colonists. Why should our children be taught myth in their history class, a myth made up specifically to hide the truth?

Every schoolchild in America knows the story of the original Thanksgiving. In 1621 in Plymouth, migr English Calvinists struggled to make their way in the harsh climate of this New World. Wampanoag Indians helped them, teaching them to grow corn. In gratitude the Pilgrims invited the Native Americans to join in their harvest feast. On this secular holiday, with our extended families around us at the Thanksgiving table, we may be moved to give thanks not only for the feast but also for our families, our country, and our many other gifts.

But this modern version of Thanksgiving would horrify the devout Pilgrims and Puritans who sailed to America in the 17th century.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    13 years ago

a possible issue of credibility....

Robert, in order to dispute the credibility of someone else, you have to have some of your own. Despite repeated requests to substantiate your stance, you have not been able to.

Claiming that you'd be trying to prove a negative doesn't get it. There is no doubt Washington issued a holiday proclamation concerning Thanksgiving. You should be able to find accurate information as to why he did that.

There is also no doubt the colonists held several thanksgiving days on irregular occasions. You should be able to find the reason why.

There is no doubt the myth currently taught in our schools was invented a mere hundred years ago and has no validity as history. Prior to that, Thanksgiving images and tales acknowledged the holiday was about the wars between whites and Indians. You should be able to find the reason why.

You asked if I wasn't bothered that this one line, written by someone who doesn't teach in our schools, about Washington being taught to our children.

I'm far more bothered by the entire, elaborate fraud being taught to our children as supposed fact when it is a deliberately invented myth designed to hide white discomfort over the slaughter of Indians.

Our children should be taught the truth in their history books. If someone wants to teach their child myth, that should be done at home.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Concur - time to do the back-turn bit.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

In six more days, most of us will sit down to dinner with our families to give thanks for all that Creator/Higher Being has given us this year. Say it with meaning - say it from your heart.

Happy Thanksgiving.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Excellent article ambiv.

It is a time to give thanks for having family and friends, and to help the less fortunate.

 
 

Who is online




105 visitors