╌>

Birthright citizenship was one of the Republican Party’s greatest accomplishments. Now some Republicans want to end it.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy2  •  11 years ago  •  32 comments

Birthright citizenship was one of the Republican Party’s greatest accomplishments. Now some Republicans want to end it.

551_discussions.jpg?width=750

August 18 at 3:05 PM

Donald Trumps call for doing away with birthright citizenship for the children of illegal immigrants has once again focused media attention on the idea and led some of his GOP rivals to signal openness to it. The Huffington Post looked at the positions of the 2016 GOP candidates and concluded that a good chunk of the GOP field wants to revisit birthright citizenship.

As conservative writer Ben Domenech notes , many other GOP lawmakers have supported the idea in recent years, as do Republican voters, even though birthright citizenship is one of the things that is relatively unique to the American experiment, and requires rebelling against the Constitutional mandate placed within the Fourteenth Amendment in the wake of the Civil War.

But theres another historical irony here that was pointed out by renowned American historian Eric Foner: The 14th amendment and birthright citizenship rank among the great and defining accomplishments of the Republican Party , back when it was the Party of Lincoln.

This was one of the historic achievements of the Republican Party, Foner, who has written extensively on Reconstruction and the meaning of American freedom , tells me. Theres plenty of irony here.

Foner thinks that ending birthright citizenship would require changing the 14th amendment, which was passed and ratified after the Civil War to secure the citizenship of former slaves. Recall that the 14th amendment came after the Civil Rights Act of 1866, which was passed by Republicans in Congress and (among other things) defined all people born in the United States (except Native Americans who didnt pay taxes) as citizens. That Act was passed over the veto of Democratic president Andrew Johnson, and the 14th amendment was then secured by Congressional Republicans and ratified by the states to make African American citizenship irreversible.

In the current context, of course, the debate over birthright citizenship concerns the proper status not of former slaves, but of the children of undocumented immigrants. But Foner notes that at the time, the Republican Partys achievement of the 14th amendment showcased the partys adherence to broad principles that do seem applicable to the current debate.

The Civil War and the emancipation of the slaves shaped the Republican Party and pushed it in the direction of nationalism, inclusiveness, and openness, Foner says. The idea was that citizenship should be extended to people regardless of accidental characteristics, such as race, national origin, or the status of their parents. This established a national standard for citizenship. The principle was one of opportunity and inclusiveness. Thats what the Republican Party stood for. The 14th amendment became one of the defining principles of the Republican Party.

At the time, the 14th amendment did also have an impact on immigration status, Foner adds. The equivalent back then would have been the Chinese in the U.S., Foner says. They could not become naturalized citizens. Nonetheless, their children born here were citizens under the 14th amendment. The point is, this isnt just about black people. Its a statement about what America is. Its a place where anybody can become a citizen regardless of their parents, religion, or race.

Even some Republicans have fretted aloud that the party has moved away from some of the principles of the Party of Lincoln in its current treatment of minorities in a broader sense. Rick Perry recently opined that the GOP has been less-than-committed to another key element of the 14th amendment the federal governments role in enforcing Civil Rights: when we gave up trying to win the support of African-Americans, we lost our moral legitimacy as the party of Lincoln.

Democrats, too, have been wrestling with their racial heritage. Some state parties have changed the name of their Jefferson-Jackson Dinners, because Thomas Jefferson and Andrew Jackson were slave-owners.

Foner locates another historical irony in the current push among some Republicans to do away with birthright citizenship one involving American exceptionalism, which is often invoked by Republicans, some of whom like to claim that the current president is not a sincere believer in it.

This is one of the real examples of American exceptionalism, Foner says. There are very few countries that have birthright citizenship today. This does make us different.

Merlin_18495999.jpg&w=180&h=180

Greg Sargent writes The Plum Line blog, a reported opinion blog with a liberal slant -- what you might call opinionated reporting from the left.
Source Link

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

An interesting commentary (I think so anyway) both on how the major parties seem to have both turned 180 degrees from where they used to be and American birthright citizenship, which is a big part of the current Presidential race's immigration debate. It also addresses American exceptionalism. A good read.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Now you can understand why I no longer belong to either party or any party for that matter.

All the parties want to do it seems like is tear down what made this a great nation.

And I can't harken to that...

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
If someone steals a car and gives it to their kid, should the kid get to keep it?
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

I know there are many people, including several on here, who feel the same way about both parties. Still, as a hardcore old time liberal, I stick with the Democratic Party. Not because I agree with everything they do or stand for (I don't), but because I agree with the bulk of what are at least their stated goals and policies and hope to make changes from within. Hope springs eternal.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

you aware of what the founders opinions on citizenship and how to acquire it were?

Obviously not....

You cannot steal something that is yours by birth.

Put it another way, are you so superior to anyone else that you are entitled to a citizenship birthright and the rest born here afterwards aren't?

Are you really that far out there?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Yes. The founders, like me, did not give out citizenship unrestrained. Rewarding criminal activity encourages further criminality.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Yes. The founders, like me, did not give out citizenship unrestrained.

But the 14th Amendment to the Constitution does grant birthright citizenship. It was voted through both Houses of Congress and ratified by enough states. If you want you are always free to petition your Representative or Senator to pass an amendment to the Constitution eliminating that part of the 14th and we'll see if it clears both Houses and is ratified by enough states. That's how it (birthright citizenship, along with all of the other amendments) got there in the first place. American Civics 101.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

The 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution reads in part:

"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and the State wherein they reside."

Babies born to illegal alien mothers within U.S. borders are called anchor babies because under the 1965 immigration Act, they act as an anchor that pulls the illegal alien mother and eventually a host of other relatives into permanent U.S. residency. ( Jackpot babies is another term).

The United States did not limit immigration in 1868 when the Fourteenth Amendment was ratified. Thus there were, by definition, no illegal immigrants and the issue of citizenship for children of those here in violation of the law was nonexistent. Granting of automatic citizenship to children of illegal alien mothers is a recent and totally inadvertent and unforeseen result of the amendment and the Reconstructionist period in which it was ratified.

In 1866, Senator Jacob Howard clearly spelled out the intent of the 14 th Amendment by stating:

"Every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country."

This understanding was reaffirmed by Senator Edward Cowan, who stated:

"[A foreigner in the United States] has a right to the protection of the laws; but he is not a citizen in the ordinary acceptance of the word..."

The phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" was intended to exclude American-born persons from automatic citizenship whose allegiance to the United States was not complete. With illegal aliens who are unlawfully in the United States, their native country has a claim of allegiance on the child. Thus, the completeness of their allegiance to the United States is impaired, which therefore precludes automatic citizenship.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Well said, 1st. Thus should be common sense not controversial.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

As of now (and since 1898) the SCOTUS interprets it to mean anyone born in the US. Any attempt to change that by merely trying to pass a new law through Congress (and that's been tried several times in recent years, but never got enough votes) will be immediately challenged and I am certain will be declared unConstitutional by even the most conservative Supreme Court, because it would be.

Like I said, call up your Representative and/or Senator and see if they'll introduce a Constitutional amendment to change that part of the 14th Amendment. That's one of the greatest things about America. People of good will (and more often of bad) can work to change the things they don't like. The method for changing or amending the Constitution is very clearly laid out. Go for it.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Someone who is born in the United States is an American citizen, unless they don't want to be. Any such individual can always renounce their citizenship when the time comes.

Why does the U.S. government have the right to tax you? They have that right because of an implied consent that exists by virtue of you being an American citizen. Why are you an American citizen, because you were born here or born to American parents.

The implied consent given on your behalf by your parents when you were born is no more compelling than the implied consent given when any baby is born on American soil. It is the law via the 14th amendment.

I don't think we should bother trying to remove a single otherwise law abiding illegal immigrant. Accept all of them, but immediately create the means to diminish illegal immigrant entry into the U.S. by ending the ability of illegals to find work in the US. With the political will it could for the most part be done.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

It's purpose is to ensure that every child born in America is an American citizen, except if they are born to a foreign diplomat or a hostile foreign force at war in and against America. That's it's purpose. That's how the SCOTUS sees it's purpose or at least it's effect. It really doesn't need any other reason to be.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Actually, it should. Rewarding criminal invasion with citizenship was not the intent of the 14th.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

If the 14th Amendment guaranteed American citizenship to anyone born in America, why did Congress have to pass the Sndyer Act to grant automatic citizenship to Indians 50 years later?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Well, talk to your Representative or Senator. The SCOTUS thinks that's what the 14th means and it's good enough for them.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Because, until The Snyder Act (otherwise known as The Indian Citizenship Act of 1924) Congress did not consider Indian territories or reservations to be a part of the United States of America, therefore they had no birthright to citizenship. They thought that way for the same reason they passed The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 making it illegal for any Chinese, born here or not, to be or become citizens, which is what led directly to the Supreme Court ruling in US v Wong Kim Ark in 1898 that anyone born in America (and it's territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam, on foreign military bases and consulates, etc.) are Americans by right of birth under the 14th Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America (a ruling that still stands today). The reason was racism. Just plain old racism.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Uh - no, SCOTUS hasn't ruled in that manner.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Deport the mess of them. The biggest expense would be the airfare/busfare/trainfare.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

No - Ark's parent were in the U. S. legally - illegal aliens are in the U. S. illegally - huge difference - hence, Ark was granted U. S. citizenship.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

No, in the decision Wong's citizenship was affirmed by right of birth in the US (San Francisco) under the 14th Amendment when he was denied re-entry into the United States because of The Chinese Exclusion Act. The legality of his parents was not in question of decided upon. Only his citizenship was ruled on and it was by reason of being born in the United States. His parents legal or illegal status here was irrelevant. Just that Wong was born to them in the United States while they were here is the only reason. In fact Wong's parents were still Chinese subjects when he was born.

(better then expedia?Smile.gif )

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

False...

The 14th Amendment didn't grant automatic citizenship because of the restricting language"subject to the jurisdiction thereof." It's not about where an Indian was born, its about his or allegiance to and citizenship in a tribe. AnIndian,regardless of where he was born, was notan American citizen if he or she was a member of a tribe.

The reason was racism. Just plain old racism.

Who cares?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

The Indian Citizenship Act of 1924, also known as the Snyder Act , was proposed by Representative Homer P. Snyder (R) of New York and granted full U.S. citizenship to America's indigenous peoples, called "Indians" in this Act. (The Fourteenth Amendment already defined as citizens any person born in the U.S., but only if "subject to the jurisdiction thereof"; this latter clause excluded anyone who already had citizenship in a foreign power such as a tribal nation. ) The act was signed into law by President Calvin Coolidge on June 2, 1924. [1] [2] [3] It was enacted partially in recognition of the thousands of Indians who served in the armed forces during World War I .

However some full blood Native women were granted citizenship by marrying white men.

...

And citizenship was given to some Native men in the United States (not on reservations or in the territories) if they were less then half-blood Indians.

The Indian Citizenship Act of 1924 stopped all confusion over which NA's were or were not citizens.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Yes, that confusion would not have occurred if the fourteenth amendment was interpreted like you claim it was in the aftermath of its passage.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

It was interpreted by the SCOTUS in the way I stated it was in 1898. As I have said, I suspect it didn't include NA's for the same reason Congress tried to exclude Chinese. Racism and bigotry.

Complain to them. I didn't write the ruling. Though, with the exception of excluding anyone based on race, I do agree with it. I see the 14th Amendment as meaning that anyone born here is an American citizen. Until the Supreme Court rules otherwise or the Constitution is amended. I didn't write the 14th Amendment either, but it says what it says, no matter why it was passed.

From the above article:

At the time, the 14th amendment did also have an impact on immigration status, Foner adds. The equivalent back then would have been the Chinese in the U.S., Foner says. They could not become naturalized citizens. Nonetheless, their children born here were citizens under the 14th amendment. The point is, this isnt just about black people. Its a statement about what America is. Its a place where anybody can become a citizen regardless of their parents, religion, or race.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

The reason was racism. Just plain old racism.

Who cares?

I do. Everyone should.

Yes, that confusion would not have occurred if the fourteenth amendment was interpreted like you claim it was in the aftermath of its passage.

Don't believe me? Read the decision yourself.

Since then it has never been overturned (or even addressed) by any Supreme Court and no law (which would be unConstitutional anyway) trying to change it has ever made it out of Congress.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

You know Randy, I don't think I would like living in a United States if there were autocratic fascist hate mongers in charge like some of the people on this board.

That would make me give up my citizenship...

I never thought that there could be so many hateful thoughtless selfish Americans.

And they call themselves patriots.

Vermin to me.

They haven't a fucking clue what it means to be an American.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

On all you said I agree completely.

I never thought that there could be so many hateful thoughtless selfish Americans.

They're scared of the future, which is the inevitable browning of America. Scared of the unknown, but unstoppable. So they lash out at what is scaring them and dehumanize the people they blame. The Hispanics who are here illegally are not going to ever be rounded up and deported. It would cost hundreds of billions of dollars that the Congress would rather spend on war.

Also, despite what that moron Trump said, it would tear families apart because he can not deport the children and grand-children who have been born here and are therefore American citizens. He can't kick them out of their own country. The one they were born in. They have every bit as much of a right to be here as any other American.

Besides it's not going to happen and Trump is never going to be President anyway.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Yeah everyone just wants to IMPOSE their view on everything.

Not just the righties it's the lefties also.

What gives them the right?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

I'm not so sure that I personally am trying to impose my views on anyone, though I am from the left. So far the main thing I have done is to point out and educate some people on the laws and Supreme Court cases that apply to this issue, including the fact that I do agree with their ruling that the proper reading of the 14th Amendment means that anyone born in the US is an American citizen by birthright. People can debate if they think that is good or bad, but as I have said before it is what it is and it says what it says.

If people disagree with what it says, then the procedures for passing a Constitutional amendment to change that part of the 14th amendment that they don't like are not hard to follow, though they are, intentionally, difficult to achieve. And rightfully so. It is and should be difficult to amend our Constitution.

 
 

Who is online

CB
shona1


89 visitors